Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Obama adopts Cosmic's Space plan

By CosmicConservative
WASHINGTON (Reuters) – President Barack Obama made his case to NASA workers in Florida on Thursday for abandoning plans to return to the moon and instead aim for asteroids, Mars and more robotic missions. Visiting a nearby asteroid would be a small step with a big impact. Not only can asteroids tell scientists how planets formed, but they may contain some more primordial elements from the early solar system. via Why go to an asteroid? - Yahoo! News.
I am very, very, very pleased with this. If Obama actually follows through with this.... well, this is big.

Comments (8)

Drax
I'm split. While, from a practical perspective, this plan has much to say for it, it has NO "awe" factor. When money is short, to get the public behind space exploration, you need "awesomeness."
CosmicConservative
Well, for me "explore asteroids" using "robotic ships" is the first step towards "mine asteroids" and "build new ships in space." Once people with resources realize what they can do with asteroids, the next big expansion of the human species will begin, and we will no longer be a solely earth-based species.
Drax
Agreed. The next logical step is for this to go commercial. Don't have to have any bells and whistles -- just the smell of green.
Old Goat
Or they can use space exploration to figure out what this was. http://www.cnn.com/2010/TECH/04/15/midwest.fireball/index.html?section=cnn_latest I don't see Obummer following through with this. Unless he doesn't raise taxes on everyone, then I might think this "promise" will have a slight glimmer of hopey changey. I can see there being some worth to this, but we haven't done much with the moon either, and its been a while since we were there. Why wouldn't there be great potential to returning and the moon being a made into a way station or base for further travel? I would think that there could be potential for mining on the moon as well. Going to Mars via an un-manned vehicle isn't going to grab people. Neither is asteroid visitations by robots. Its the human element being involved and at risk that gets support.
CosmicConservative
The key to exploiting the asteroid belt is to start exploiting near-earth asteroids and using the metal from them to build more ships. The moon is a better place to launch ships from than the earth, but it's still got a significant gravity well to overcome. The great thing about asteroids is that once you build a ship, it's already in space. You don't need to spend a ton of energy throwing it out of a deep gravity well. The technology to create self-replicating robot ships is becoming more feasible every year. Once people realize the payback from that, it won't be long before that becomes the main focus of the space program. Seriously, I've been talking and writing about this for 30 years. The asteroid belt is the key to humans becoming a truly space-faring civilization. Sure we'll have moon bases too, but that won't be what transforms our civilization. The asteroids will.
Foobarista
I agree, and the irony is that his NASA approach is the exact opposite of how he wants to do medical. NASA: get the government out of the management and service biz and make it have a strategic and goal-setting role with lots of R&D, with management & service done by the private sector. And asteroids are very good things to study - arguably at least as important as the Moon or Mars. The Moon or Mars won't kill us, but asteroids eventually will unless we figure out ways to deflect them. Also, I always wanted to see someone build the "Orion bulldozer" for moving asteroids around. Basically, you take two huge plates, one facing the asteroid and another facing away, and you blow up a nuke behind the outer plate in a fashion similar to Project Orion. Since you can blow up multiple nukes, it's far more effective at moving them than one big nuke, etc. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Orion_%28nuclear_propulsion%29
CosmicConservative
There are lots of ways to move asteroids around. In general the most effective and efficient ways just take a long time to move them. Freeman Dyson (I think) proposed a method of solar sails to move small asteroids. Others have pointed out that you can move them pretty effectively simply by stopping their rotation and painting one side black and the other side silver. Sunlight will then push them slowly but steadily where you want to go. The most intriguing study I've seen was one which proposed either a nuclear or a solar power station on a mountain sized asteroid, using the power to run a local smelter and refinery, and chucking the residue into space as reaction mass to move the asteroid where you want it to go. By the time it gets into earth orbit, it might be almost pure iron/nickel with quite a bit of gold, platinum, iridium, etc. as a bonus. I think that's what we'll eventually see happen. I'd be leery of the nuclear bomb approach. Very few asteroids are large solid rocks. Most are jumbled up collections of pebbles, and regolith. Those might just come apart and become navigational threats.
davera
Just remember, all of Obama's promises come with an expiration date. All of them.