Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Debt analysis...

By CosmicConservative
I had posted a completely different post but had to redo it because I was reading some data wrong or the model still has a problem. So I'm looking at it again. To set up what the model may reveal, let's take a look at where we are today. Once you strip away all the social security funny money accounting and look just at total government revenue and government spending, including current debt, here is what we have. Current debt is roughly 14.6 trillion dollars. US debt first hit a trillion dollars back in the mid-80s, so we've basically increased our debt fourteen-fold in less than 30 years. But due to inflation and growth in the US economy, that's not really a very good way to look at things. It is probably more accurate to look at debt as a percentage of GDP. When our debt hit $1 trillion, it was roughly 40% of GDP, where now at roughly $14 trillion, it's roughly 90% of GDP. Our debt has been higher as a percentage of GDP in the past. During the height of World War II, just coming out of the Great Depression, our debt topped out at about 120% of GDP. So it is fair to say that our current debt is not "unprecedented". Here is a graph showing US debt as a percentage of GDP: However, things are not trending well. growth in our debt has been accelerating dramatically in the past ten years (thanks Bush), and has redoubled in the last year alone as you can see. Debt reaching 100% of GDP is a reasonable point to start ringing the alarm bell, as if 90% isn't enough already. Debt reaching 200% of GDP is probably getting to the point of being an existential threat to the nation. Next time I'll post what the model is predicting for our debt. UPDATE: I played around a bit with the model and managed to get it to reflect the numbers I pulled from the feds public page on debt and the budget. Using those values, our debt to GDP ratio will surpass our WWII debt ratio (reaching 125% of GDP) in 2020. So in ten years our debt will truly be at an unprecedented level, surpassing even the debt that this country took on to fight a world war and recover from the greatest depression in modern history. But the difference between 2020 and 1945 is more than just that in 1945 the war and the depression had ended, and that allowed us to pay the debt back down to manageable levels while growing GDP so that the ratio returned to levels of 40 to 50% where it mostly stayed until the 1980s (yes, Reagan ran up the debt). But now there is nothing to end and the trend remains in the other direction with the debt to GDP ratio climbing forever higher as far as the model can see. But in all honesty, looking at it this way, it's not actually as bad as I had feared. I wish I had done this exercise six months ago, I would have taken a different tone on some of these arguments where I've invoked end of the world scenarios on our debt. It's bad. It's not yet unprecedented. We've got ten years or so before we set a new record. And there are things we can do to deal with this. The question is whether we have the political will to do them. More to come on what the model suggests that we have to do...

Comments (2)

esox67
Yep, things are looking good for my kids. Bring back the greatest generation, because the entitlement generation has brought this country to its knees with debt they just keep passing on.
CosmicConservative
esox, to be fair, it is the "greatest generation" that is currently drawing the largest fraction of those entitlements you are talking about. That will change over the next decade as the baby boomers dominate social security and medicare, but right now, those folks from the generation that fought WWII are the ones that are getting paid the bulk of the benefits, and have been for the last couple of decades while this ballooning debt has become a national crisis.