Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Comments (14)

mtnlurker
I love R.E.M.! And yes, it is. 1. Higher taxes. 2. Higher insurance costs. 3. Businesses failing due to insurance costs. etc.
CosmicConservative
mtn: It's far worse than that. Obamacare will take our secret unfunded future debt from its current unpublished amount of roughly $60 trillion and bring it up to roughly $100 trillion. That's not even counting the acknowledged public debt of roughly $15 trillion plus whatever else Obama adds to it in the next three years. To put this into perspective, for us to pay out the estimated costs of social security, medicare, medicaid, prescription drugs, aid to families with dependent children, food stamps and now Obamacare, we would have to devote our entire gross national product to that effort for the next 60-75 years. That means EVERY PENNY of income made in this country from every source committed WHOLLY to paying off our unfunded liabilities. Before Obamacare it was already probably well past any tipping point, but with Obamacare it has increased by roughly 50%. And that's just with the acknowledged estimates of the costs. If those costs go up, or if our GDP goes down, then it's even worse. Even if you assume a truly unsustainable growth in GDP of 7% or so, you are still looking at investing our entire GDP for 50 - 60 years to pay those costs. Now, obviously that's not possible. But to even have any hope whatsoever of keeping the debt from growing to the point that the interest on the debt remains below $500 BILLION per year, there will have to be massive tax increases. I'm talking tax increases of historic levels. If we don't raise taxes, and continue to borrow money to pay for these boondoggles, then our entire federal budget will be consumed by paying the interest on the debt in as little as ten years, depending on what figures you use. Obamacare has just made it impossible to avoid raising your taxes more than you can possibly imagine.
Old Goat
This is and always has been about engineering things to redistribute wealth. I am not convinced that this nation will keep standing under the weight of all this. The political divide has gotten so much worse. There isn't going to be some Kum By Yah moment coming. The country is broke now, and this is going to push it over the cliff.
Andy
Cosmic, the figures you lay out really just put a spotlight on the fact that no one really ever expects these "debts" to be paid off. It is impossible. This is not like a guy making 100 grand, with a $20,000 credit card balance. He CAN pay it off eventually. This is like that same guy owing fifty bazillion, with interest piling on every month. It's not going to be an issue. It can't be paid. It will not be paid (with money... FRNs...funny money...etc.). It will be paid with US yielding ourselves, and our sovereignty to others.
CosmicConservative
Andy, I've been in a day long debate over the national debt and there are some really knowledgeable economists and statisticians that I've been talking to. My figures up there were "off the top of my head" figures. One of those brilliant dudes put together a long-term analysis of our current debt and plotted that against an estimated growth of our GDP and against a couple of interest rates. Basically it boils down to this. If we have 5% growth of our Gross Domestic Product and if we commit 10% of that gross domestic product JUST to paying down the debt (meaning spending 1.4 TRILLION dollars EVERY YEAR plus an additional 5% each year added to that) then the first 40 or 50 years we actually have the debt grow since the 10% of our GDP isn't enough to pay the interest on it. But eventually the growth of the GDP will end up paying more than the interest and the balance will finally start to come down. As it works out, if we were to start on Jan 1, 2011, and devoted TEN PERCENT of our GDP (Not 10% of our current federal revenues, 10% of EVERY DOLLAR MADE IN THIS NATION) then we would just barely pay off the debt by the year 2100. But that assumes no growth of that debt, and as we all know all of these entitlements grow at a rate indexed to inflation, and our idiot government will not be able to stop adding new entitlements to the existing ones (as was proved yesterday), and so the reality is that it is not remotely possible that this debt can ever be repaid. The MOST we can hope for is to pay enough of the interest on the debt that the balance doesn't grow faster than the GDP itself grows. But in reality, there is no way out of this, except staggeringly onerous taxes, or eventual default on the debt, which would spark a worldwide depression that would make the Great Depression look like a picnic. My only hope for the future is that something like the Singularity occurs which simply transforms this planet into something that we can't even recognize today. That's the only thing that will allow us to solve this problem.
CosmicConservative
One more point, which makes this a little better. A big chunk of the existing debt is money owed to ourselves in the social security system. Basically the federal government has been raiding the social security surplus for decades. Well as of this year social security is no longer running a surplus, it is running a deficit and that deficit will grow. But at least the money we've stolen from social security is not money that we borrowed from China, so we don't necessarily have to pay the interest that was promised, although all that does is run new deficits on social security in the future. But because of how the financial books work out, that actually does reduce what we have to pay back somewhat, but that calculation was beyond what our statistician had time to include, and frankly he was too depressed after running this first order approximation and just doesn't want to look at it again.
Andy
Rosy picture, huh Cosmic? Those figures are staggering. And, they are "telling." There is no intention to pay this debt. At least not with a negotiable instrument. We've known this for a long time. I guess it was about 20 years ago when I started hearing "right-wing-militia-type loonies" spouting these kind of figures. Of course, they were much more modest then...only something like 30 trillion in REAL indebtedness/liabilities. People scoffed! And the snowball kept growing. Folks have been ringing this bell for a long time. I guess there is none so blind as he who will not hear (or something like that).
CosmicConservative
Andy, the model we are currently working on assumes some level of "acceptable" debt, expressed as a percentage of GDP. There will no doubt be tremendous debate over that value, but I can't imagine anyone arguing that we should carry more than 100% of our GDP as debt, either in the form of actual treasury notes we have to pay, or in the form of unfunded liabilities that we have promised to pay in the future (which is what Medicare, Medicaid, social security and obamacare are). When you total up all of our debt and unfunded liabilities, the value is just about 700% of our GDP. I think most reasonable people would say that owing 7 times what you make in a year is an unsustainable debt load. My debt load, including my house, is slightly less than twice my annual income, and I find that pretty crushing. And remember, GDP is the total domestic product, not what the government rakes in in revenue. So an analogy to a person's finances would be that government revenues are about 30% of GDP, so that means our current debt is more like 21 times what the government actually takes in for a year. For a person making $100K per year, that would be the equivalent of having $2.1 million in debt.
Drax
The "hope" is to inflate our way out of debt. Yea. I'm all giddy.
CosmicConservative
Drax, we have discussed that too. One of the things liberals hated about Reagan is that he put a stop to inflation and that stopped the "bracket creep" that was generating revenue for the federal government by moving people into higher tax brackets when they saw no actual improvement in their standard of living. I am guessing that our next huge argument on this thing is going to be about inflation and how that will "fix things." Right now Dean is arguing that the government will somehow magically "create wealth" to the tune of the 100 trillion dollars we are currently in the hole. I've laughed at him and he has attacked me personally for it. Nothing new. Still, this model we're putting together is pretty interesting. Once we have it up and running, it might just show that there could be a glimmer of light at the end of the tunnel. I have to hope anyway.
Drax
Bottom line: There is no hope without restraint. If we don't get representatives into office who will restrain spending, we're S.O.L.
CosmicConservative
I agree Drax, what I'm wanting to see from this model is if it's already too late even for restraint. My immediate reaction to Obamacare was that it had to have pushed us far over the tipping point for economic sustainability. That's what my gut said. But it is just barely conceivable that I may have overreacted. I've learned a lot about the debt in the past two days. I'm sort of embarrassed by how much more some of those dudes on Dean's World know than I do. Not Dean though. :)
Drax
There is almost no amount of debt which couldn't be inflated out of if combined with spending restraint. The trick is to keep inflation under control so that hyper-inflation doesn't set in. Sigh. If we knew how to do that, we wouldn't be in this trouble to begin with. There isn't ANYONE (or any collection of "anyones") who knows exactly how this animal we call "the economy" actually functions or how to control it. It's best guess and cross the fingers...