Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Obama administration executive order may restrict public fishing

By CosmicConservative
The Obama administration has closed all input on a new Executive Order that is being crafted to address the right of US Citizens to fish in public waters, including much of the ocean coastline and the Great Lakes. (Hat tip to Old Goat for the link.)

The Obama administration will accept no more public input for a federal strategy that could prohibit U.S. citizens from fishing the nation's oceans, coastal areas, Great Lakes, and even inland waters.

This announcement comes at the time when the situation supposedly still is "fluid" and the Interagency Ocean Policy Task Force still hasn't issued its final report on zoning uses of these waters.

That's a disappointment, but not really a surprise for fishing industry insiders who have negotiated for months with officials at the Council on Environmental Quality and bureaucrats on the task force. These angling advocates have come to suspect that public input into the process was a charade from the beginning.

Emphasis mine, by the way. So, basically the Obama administration is crafting this new policy with input only from "environmental groups" and they appear to be following an anti-use script that is modeled on anti-hunting legislation passed in Canada.

As ESPN previously reported, WWF, Greenpeace, Defenders of Wildlife, Pew Environment Group and others produced a document entitled "Transition Green" shortly after Obama was elected in 2008. What has happened since suggests that the task force has been in lockstep with that position paper.

Although the thrust of the ESPN story is about fishing jobs that would be lost if Obama shuts down recreational fishing, my own opinion is that the impact of such a decision will be far more profound than just the job losses. I suspect that Obama and his inner circle have no idea what political napalm they are dealing with here. I doubt there are three people in the White House who actually enjoy heading out to the local reservoir with a fish pole and a bucket of bait. My guess is that Obama's inner circle views the average outdoor hunting/fishing enthusiast as a toothless hillbilly with a bloodthirsty streak. He probably truly has no idea that fishing is one of America's most popular pasttimes, and that most fishermen are not poor backwoods banjo players, but include most of middle class America. If Obama shuts down access to popular fishing locations, forcing people to crowd into a few "approved" water holes, the political backlash will be thundering. What surprises me is that he's going after fishing first instead of hunting. But again, I doubt Obama has any idea of the sheer number of Americans who enjoy heading out to the local lakes and rivers each weekend to relax and bring home a few fish for dinner.

Comments (36)

Old Goat
I think there are a lot of things that will come about from this. I think the recreational fishermen (or should that be fisherpeople in this PC world we live in?) will become astounded by the depth of this action. There are some who have sounded off about this being just about controlling (there's that theme again we seem to keep seeing with this administration) the industrial or commercial fishing operations, but its not. The environmental groups are going off the deep end, as most groups will eventually when they become more impassioned about their cause. Take PETA, they don't want anyone to have pets. They view it as slavery. Think that these groups advising Obama feel its OK to catch and release the poor little fishies? I bet they view it as worse than murder for fish to be caught and eaten! Heck, there was an article I just skimmed that had sea lions being killed because they eat fish. Imagine that, those ungrateful lumps. They should know they should be eating at McDonald's I guess. I also see this as another tax generating device. The tax is the license fees and fines for fishing in general, which will mean that the cost of fish to eat will be going up dramatically. I wonder if they will also affect the various fish hatcheries around the US, they are generally run on state funding and they supply lakes with fish that might soon not have anyone culling the supply. I agree that there are a lot of people who enjoy fishing. Heck, even my daughters and son love to go out with me and cast the lines. Maybe Obama didn't go after the hunting just yet because those peoples has guns! Fishin' poles ain't gonna hurts ya bad as dem guns do. This man is sick. He is not a true American. How could he be (not talking about the birther stuff here) when all he wants to do is remove freedoms from people while gaining massive control and power over so many aspects of our lives? That isn't an American thing. Americans fight for freedom and at least used to have that ingrained in their makeup during the formative years. This may seem a small story, but its indicative of the systemic dismantling of our freedoms by the narcissist in chief.
Drax
He's a socialist/Marxist, possibly Facist, depending on how one defines that. He, by any measure, is a "true believer," who thinks that power should be in the hands of a central government run by a select group of people who know best how we should live our lives. This is but another example of this thinking.
CosmicConservative
I try not to get too far into the "Obama is the scion of Karl Marx" meme, but it's getting harder and harder to avoid it. I believe that Obama is a true believer, but not necessarily a Marxist or Socialist. I think those labels are somewhat outdated for the modern political landscape. Obama is a modern Leftist, and in many ways he is an iconic example of a modern Leftist. That's not the same thing as being a hardcore socialist. I don't believe that Obama believes in his own mind that all property belongs to the state, and that individuals are in all ways subserviant to the whims of the state. But, he also is not intellectually honest enough to follow the logical progression of his beliefs to their inevitable and inexorable conclusion, which is, in effect, socialism. This sort of intellectual cognitive dissonance is perhaps the most fundamental trait of the modern Leftist. Here is how their mind works. "Socialism is tyranny. I oppose tyranny. Therefore I am not a socialist. What I support is in the best interest of mankind. Therefore those who oppose me are evil and must be defeated. What I support must be implemented because I would not supporty tyranny. Therefore when I impose my beliefs on other people, it is by definition not tyranny. This is how you get Obama saying that those who oppose him just need to shut up, and how Michelle Obama feels totally comfortable saying "Obama will make you change." Because it's all for your own good, and therefore is not tyranny. It's not their fault that those clingy, bitter, ignorant hillbillies don't know what's good for them. Read the book "What's Wrong With Kansas." That's about as straightforward description of how the modern Lefty mind works as anything. So, when it comes to fishing, Obama has no problem telling the American people when, where, how and why they can fish. Because Obama clearly has the best interest of man and more importantly, fish, in mind, as opposed to us ignorant, selfish, bitter and clingy fisherfolk who just want to satisfy our base primal urges. It never would occur to Obama to consider that hunters and fishermen provide the huge bulk of funds in this country for preserving wetlands, protecting fish, providing salaries for forest rangers and fish and game wardens, etc. This is such an intellectual contradiction that he quite literally cannot comprehend it. In his mind the only people with any credibility about fish and game are environmentalists because they are fellow leftists. This is why he can exclude hunting and fishing interestes from the creation of a policy about hunting and fishing. In his mind hunters and fishers are philosophically incapable of providing any input except the input of a bitter, clingy, ignorant anti-environmentalist. Obama and his peers believe that hunters and fishers are the enemy of fish and game. That is as deeply ingrained in their philosophical DNA as the idea that Christian fundamentalists are the moral equivalent of Osama Bin Laden. It would never remotely occur to them to reevaluate their mindset on this (or pretty much anything else). Why should they? They already know they are right. Again, it's not their fault that you are a bitter, clingy, ignorant (no doubt white) redneck rube. After all, their policies are best for you too, you just are either too ignorant to know it, or too perverse to admit it.
pace
Dear Fishermen, Welcome to our world. -The OHV'ers
CosmicConservative
pace, I was thinking about that. This isn't really about fishing, at root it's about access. The True Leftist knows who should be allowed to walk on the sacred flesh of Gaia. And the answer is "them" and only them.
Cullen
or should that be fisherpeople in this PC world we live in? I think that would be "Slaughterer of our natural resources" in PC-speak, OG.
CosmicConservative
It still never fails to amaze me that the very same people who yell "fish feel pain!" at enviro-rallies will in the same breath say that "fetuses are just tissue!" at the abortion rally. There is a level of active cognitive dissonance in the modern Left that is truly frightening. To them fishing is murder while abortion is just removal of a parasitic mass of tissue.
pace
Yeah, it's about access. Whether that is public land access or waterway access is largely moot to the self-proclaimed environmentalist I think. They know what is best for the earth, and it most certainly doesn't involve non-enlightned humans roaming wherever they might please. Unfortunately the enviro groups have massive sums of money at their disposal to lobby. Conversely the folks who are most impacted by the legislation they drive, are typically represented by many small, underfunded special interest groups which have not worked together in any kind of coordinated effort. Fishermen, hunters, equestrians, mountain bikers, offroaders, etc. just don't have a good history of working together to fight their common 'enemy'.
CosmicConservative
True pace, but I think the Tea Party movement shows just how fast a coalition can form and can effect change in the internet age. If this truly does end up forcing people to give up on long treasured fishing holes, I expect a major backlash to happen. (Heh, get it? backlash? It's a fishing joke. Seriously. It's FUNNY DAMMIT!!!)
Old Goat
Think about this issue, then think about the little tidbit in the health care bill that will have "voluntary" home visits for families have have children where someone (it doesn't specify what relationship nor that they are actually living in the house) smokes. It also covers a lot of other items including checking that the children aren't being abused. Control is the name of the game. They fail to see or believe that any other person is smart enough to live their lives without the government having control. While they can kid themselves that this isn't tyranny, even though that is exactly what it is, and that it isn't socialism or marxist, the totality of it follows right along with those play books. Its why global climate change has been pushed so hard. Its why health care in this version is being pushed so hard. Its why the environmental cap and trade is being pushed so hard. It is about gaining control of the poor dumb masses to be run by them. Never mind that they are just as flawed, or maybe more so, than everyone else. Obama doesn't believe that all men are created equal. He is the "one" after all. The Messiah. How can you say no to a god. Or at least a demi-god. I see the moves this moron in chief is making and I am becoming more and more convinced that he is using Cloward Pivens strategy to reform the US into his image. This issue about the fishing is one that many won't even know about. Its by executive order, not even legislated! This guy thinks he was elected King.
CosmicConservative
It's not just Obama, Goat. The prevailing opinion on the hard Left when Obama got elected was that it had nothing to do with Obama's personality and was totally about the American people finally welcoming the full progressive agenda. That's why they are in such total denial now about the Tea Party movement and about the precipitous drop in Obama's poll numbers and the repeated electoral losses they are experiencing. They thought they had "won." They thought it was all over. That's why they so badly overplayed their hand.
Drax
CC: Socialist is as socialist does. I don't care what you cal him, but his policies are socialist. Even Newt is finally saying the "S word." All the time now. Many more pundits, loathe to use such inflammatory language, are beginning to use it with seeming abandon. He was mentored by Marxist, Frank Davis. When he went to college, Obama tells us (in his first book) that he intentionally surrounded himself by radicals and Marxists. He then began community organizing -- rubbing elbows with Brother Louis and Reverend Wright. Then, after law school, he kicks off his political life at the home of a Weatherman. He tells us (in captured video) that he has been hand in hand with ACORN "every step of the way" throughout his political career. Once in office, he surrounded himself with radicals, including self-described Communists. His policies and his actions can be explained simply if one believes him to be a Marxist/Socialist. (If you equate "modern liberal" with "Marxist/Socialist" then okay...that's pretty accurate...) Any other explanation for his policies and actions is simply not credible if you believe him capable of constructing a complex sentence. I've been saying this for over a year. Finally, there are a few of the more influential conservatives who are willing to risk the scorn of the MSM and call a spade a spade.
Drax
Oh... and Lenin thought that his policies were for the good of the common man as well. I'm sure that Castro began that way, as well. The road to hell, and all that.
Old Goat
Drax, I think that Castro still feels that his way was the best for all the people of Cuba. I don't think they are capable of critical self evaluation. I really believe that Obama cannot look at what he wants to do and see it as anything but the best thing to happen, not only for the US, but for the world. It doesn't matter that it is delusional, its what he and Pelosi and Reid all believe.
Drax
There's much to be said for rule by the elites. Aristotle considered democracy to be a relatively base form of government with the numerous poor ruling in their interests. (Who can argue THAT?) He considered an enlightened monarchy best, then rule by the few aristocrats. And, of course we're all familiar with Plato's maxim: "... until political power and philosophy entirely coincide, ..., cities will have no rest from evils,... nor, I think, will the human race." And, in truth, there's much to be said for the enlightened rule of a relatively small group of people who have the interests of the people in mind. Certainly, we can agree that approximately 50% of the adults in the U.S. aren't deserving of self-rule as they can't even be bothered to vote as to who has almost complete power over them. Of the remaining 50%, only a very tiny fraction have any clue as to what is going on, or, frankly, even care except when it directly and (in their limited and generally supplied reasoning) adversely affects them. Of the remainder, who of them has the time to study the issues so that they can become experts such that their opinions have any weight? Or the intelligence to reason out the meaning behind the multitudes of happenings so to determine the proper course of action. Thus, rule by an enlightened elite who have the ability to understand the great issues of the day and the intelligence to determine the proper course of action which favors the interests of the people of a nation would certainly seem to be a political model to be sought. If...if only such existed. But they don't. They never have. They never will. What exists are flawed people driven by self-interest even when they think that they are not. The problem we currently have is that too many of our representatives and our dear leader think that they actually are Plato's "philosopher kings," when, in fact, I could throw a dart at a phone book and have a better than even chance of pinning a better candidate for office than 99% of those currently holding office, and could find in my home town several thousand people more qualified to be President than that which we currently have.
Dadman
Jonah Goldberg is his book, Liberal Fascism, makes a pretty compelling case that progressivism, modern liberalism, and fascism are ideological soulmates. I tend to agree. Of course, it's important to clearly define what fascism is, which is frankly a point historians continue to debate even today. What it isn't is genocide. That was a peculiar and awful manifestation of Hitler's madness. Fascism, according to Goldberg (and many other historians), is: “...a religion of the state. It assumes the organic unity of the body politic and longs for a national leader attuned to the will of the people. It is totalitarian in that it views everything as political and holds that any action by the state is justified to achieve the common good. It takes responsibility for all aspects of life, including our health and well-being, and seeks to impose uniformity of thought and action, whether by force or through regulation and social pressure. Everything, including the economy and religion, must be aligned with its objectives. Any rival identity is part of the ‘problem’ and therefore defined as the enemy." Does that seem familiar?
CosmicConservative
Yes it seems familiar but I don't think it's a historically accurate description of fascism. What that sounds like to me is collectivism raised to a tyranny, which is how I would characterize Obama and much of the leadership of the Democrat party today. Fascism has always been associated with a strong nationalist urge, and that is precisely what is missing in the totalitarian collectivist state that the new Left is trying to set up. You can't really say that the new "globalism" replaces the "nationalism" of fascism because the nationalism of fascism is specifically geared as a means to unite the nation against manufactured external enemies. When the global collectivist state is achieved, there will be nothing to rally the people against. Fascism is also historically associated with a single approved cultural identity, which is one reason modern Leftists find comparisons of their collectivism to fascism so abhorrent. They seek ideological unity, but not cultural unity. I haven't read Jonah's book, and I should, I'm sure I would agree with 90% of what is in it, but I believe that he is stretching the definition of fascism too far, and I suspect he is doing it deliberately and somewhat disingenuously precisely because he knows how much it rankles the Left to be called Fascist.
Dadman
I typically don't read partisan political books, but the smiley face with the Hitler 'stache cover was too good to pass up. It's essentially a history book that establishes a very strong nexus between the American Progressives of the early 20th century (e.g. Wilson, FDR) and the emerging tide of European fascism. He does stretch the argument, no doubt, but I was impressed with his research and surprised to learn modern liberalism and pure fascism have much more in common than one might think. Differences too, yes, but a scary level of ideological agreement. If you're inclined, I'd check the book out. It's one of the best political books I've read in a long time...and I think Paul saw it on my bookshelf when he was here visiting a few months ago... :)
Dadman
I should say that Goldberg does a pretty good job of supporting his thesis, and his defintion of fascism, in his lengthy tome...
CosmicConservative
Heh... it's easy to support a thesis when nobody can ask "uh, yeah, but what about the nationalism aspect?..." :) But I'm a fan of Jonah Goldberg, and it has been on my list for a while. I may pick it up while I'm in Atlanta on business...
Drax
I frankly don't see any difficulty in substituting the "nationalism" element with a "globalism" element -- nor do I have any difficulty with substituting a cultural relativism with a singular culture -- in any definition of "fascism." These, after all, are the food for the masses -- the driving force for the leaders' support -- while the consolidation of power in the hands of the political/corporate elites remains the same.
CosmicConservative
Drax, the "nationalism" aspect of fascism is a militant aspect which has as its goal the unification of the fascist state against a common enemy. Unless we find aliens on Mars to identify as that common enemy, there won't be any common external enemy for the global "fascist" state to rally against. In my understanding of fascism, this militaristic bonding of the individuals of the state is not some minor aspect of fascism, it is at the very core of the concept. Without it you have some form of collectivism which doesn't entirely nationalize production and the economy, but it's not fascism as I understand fascism. But as Dadman notes, fascism is so thoroughly misunderstood that not even the major historical figures of the past 60 years can agree on where it exists in the ideological taxonomy. That is in part because ideologues on both sides have used the definition as a rhetorical club to beat on their ideological opponents. "I'm on the Left so fascism must be on the right!" is how the "debate" usually goes.
Cullen
One of the best political models I ever saw was a cirle with facism being the result of extremism on either side. I can totally see that.
CosmicConservative
Hmmm... I thought the proper spelling was "fascism". I could be wrong.
Drax
CC: The "nationalist" element in the rise of Mussolini and Hitler was not the citizenry rising up against a foreign enemy -- it was a reaction to INTERNAL enemies, i.e., the Communists. It was AFTER Mussolini and Hitler attained power (and eliminated the Communist "threat") that another enemy (in Germany -- the Jews) again internal. There was never any end of threats for the populace to overcome (communists, dissidents, anarchists, socialists, capitalists, the list is endless...and added to at need.) The "fatherland" propaganda which both Hitler and Mussolini used to indoctrinate the youth and motivate and/or placate the masses is, again, an INTERNAL type of message, i.e., "we're number 1!" But, this message wasn't one of domination of the German or Italian over others (this came later) but one of creating a self-image of value and worth for those who labored for Hitler's and Mussolini's vision so that they would voluntarily do that which they had no choice in doing. For the young (and both knew the value in indoctrinating the young) it was the driving force for their acceptance of the total control the Nazis and Fascists had over their lives. Again, there's not a single element of this "nationalism" which cannot be substituted with a likewise vision of "globalism." The "enemies" (i.e., the communists, jews, socialists, anarchists, capitalists, whatever) of this "globalism" substitute for the "enemies" of Germany/Italy. Global Warming, Environmentalism, eradication of class, race, gender distinctions -- whatever -- provide the self-worth needed for the populace to follow their new leaders' policies. What we are seeing today is the death throes of nationalism, to be replaced by regionalism -- perhaps globalism entire. Nations, frankly, cannot survive technology. The question is what form the new globalism will take, not whether it will ultimately triumph.
CosmicConservative
Drax, I agree with everything you have said about the political landscape. I just don't agree that "fascism" is being used properly in this context. But that's just a rhetorical debate, and isn't worth the effort really. The real danger is the supremacy of the collectivist ideology of Obama and his globalist cohorts, coupled with their disdain of individual liberty and their hatred of capitalism.
Cullen
I misspelled. It was my humorous way of saying whoops. No one gets my sense of humor :|
Dadman
Goldberg makes a pretty strong case that fascism is, indeed, a strongly collectivist ideology. And when the fascists came to power in both Italy and Germany, they replaced factions of the Left (e.g. communists) not those on the right. Also, initially, there seemed to be a great deal of expressed mutual admiration between U.S. Progressives and European fascists, particularly between Roosevelt and Mussolini. This, of course, changed as the winds of war strengthened in Europe, but the ideological similarities of progressivism and fascism were clearly noted on both sides of the pond. His book is a very interesting read. You should move it to the top of your must-read list...
Beefbern
BAN FISHING IN THE USA ? This is one of those things that would be hard to believe without seeing it first. All of us "Immoral fishermen" need to go out and get one of those new Fishouflage shirts to show our support and how many of us there are.
Old Goat
Beefbern, I remember the days when you didn't need to have a fishing license to dangle a hook in the water. Of course there were some restrictions even back then, but government likes only one thing better than regulation and that is a tax. I guess I have to go out and get me one of those fishouflage shirts!:D
Old Goat
I think I'll go with the crappieflag just cause I like the name and sentiment.
CosmicConservative
I miss crappie fishing. By the time I get back down to my favorite old crappie fishing holes, I may not be allowed to fish. I'm having severe Robin Hood fantasies here... Wasn't the initial reason Robin Hood became an outlaw due to poaching the king's deer?
Tdog
CC it was a fluke that the tides brought me to your honey hole and writings. I've enjoyed the sight fishing, and while the hook is not firmly set, I plan to see what else may be learned amidst the conservative schools here. Look forward to returning to your fishin hole. On the east coast of Florida we've already seen what owebama does to grouper and snapper fishing (it's not good). Enjoyed your posts
Old Goat
CC, the modern day Robin Hood! I don't know about missing crappy fishing. I like good fishing. ;) Just couldn't pass that lame joke by.