Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

How much of the planet do you use?

By CosmicConservative
Here is an interesting quiz you can take that supposedly calculates how much of the earth's surface your existence uses up for things like agriculture to feed you, living space, roads you drive on, etc. I am quite sure it has some logical fallacies built into it (probably does not consider road usage to be community usage, for example), but it is interesting nonetheless. Try it out at ecofoot.org.

Comments (5)

Cullen
25 acres! Mwahahaha! It would take 5.7 planets if everyone lived like me! Mwahahaha! I am holding the planet hostage.
CosmicConservative
I came in at 6.4 planets needed. And I don't have air conditioning, live in a rural area with well water and a septic system, and generally live a pretty quiet and simple life...
Aaron
3.4. But this is ridiculous. They're obsessed with transportation, which hardly takes any room at all. Maybe the footprint of 1/10,000,000 of an oil rig + the footprint of your car + 1/1000 of a gas station. Agriculture takes up perhaps the most space, along with water collection/reformation. Your house takes up the space that your house takes up, period. I just don't get it. The population of the entire world could be comfortably housed in a typical suburb the size of texas. (Presumably their buisiness would be elsewhere, maybe in a city half the same size). Furthermore, the agriculture to support them could all come from the arable land in the US and Canada alone (if they really liked corn and wheat bread).
Aaron
PS, this just goes back to my general rant against the green socialists: Whenever you hear them talk about "energy independence", they're not talking about actually providing any energy whatsoever. They're talking about getting us to live without it. They never attempt to sell us a good (actual power plants, actual transportation strategies, actual energy sources, actual processes that are more efficient). Instead, it's all a big evasive smokescreen for what they're actually trying to sell us: a confined, restricted, and rationed "lifestyle". (Note their continued deification of horrendously poor, oppressed, unproductive peasants in communist dictatorships: They're playing their role in the "grand scheme") If free governments and the market were allowed to operate, even assuming today's technology, I'd bet about 2x the population of the earth could live like I do. /rant.
CosmicConservative
Aaron: I went through their FAQ and I think I have a good understanding of their process. Basically they put you in categories based on income, nationality, house size, etc. Then they attempt to assign you a value based on the average of those attributes, particularly nationality. So if you are a US citizen, you get clobbered because of their existing idea of how much of the earth's surface the U S itself consumes. This is why I supposedly used more of the earth's surface as an American than as a Canadian when I entered exactly the same values (well, as close as possible, their Canadian form was in metric units) that I did when I used their US Citizen form. But back to your comments about the entire population of earth living in Texas. I've seen a lot of futurists ponder the maximum population that the earth could sustain in a modern technologically advanced lifestyle. I've seen that number predicted to be from 6 billion to 30 billion, but the most realistic figures I've seen put that number at roughly 10 - 12 billion people. If that is true then Texas, as big as it is, could not support the current population of the earth in a sustainable fashion according to modern ideas of a reasonable lifestyle. Throw in some lifestyle changes, primarily a change from a meat-based to a vegetable-based diet, and you can decrease the impact of humans considerably, but you still reach a limit. Like you I believe that the major "footprint" of a human being is related to their need for food and water, not transportation or manufacturing of goods and services. Since the website I linked assigns almost half of my "footprint" to my usage of "goods and services" I pretty much discount the results as being politically and ideologically motivated, not scientific.