Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

So much for "Scott Brown for President"

By CosmicConservative
I'm pretty sure this will take a whole lot of wind out of the Good Ship "Scott Brown: Conservative Hero" sails...
WASHINGTON, Feb 22 (Reuters) - A modest job-creation bill advanced in the U.S. Senate on Monday as the chamber's newest Republican bucked his party and sided with Democrats on a $15 billion package of tax cuts and highway spending. Republican Scott Brown joined four other Republicans, 55 Democrats and two independents to overcome a procedural hurdle that sets up a final vote later this week. via UPDATE 1-New U.S. senator helps Democrats advance jobs bill | Reuters.

Comments (13)

Drax
I got the biggest kick out of all the "conservative" bloggers who have been decrying all the "RINO's" over the years who not only held their nose for Brown, but actively supported him and begged others to contribute through the "money bomb." They'll be tired of him in 6 years and wanting a "real conservative" in the job... Too dam funny...
Old Goat
I'm not so sure this is something that will hurt Brown much. He is looking to show he isn't going to be marching in lock step with the party, but rather looking to see what HE feels he should go along with. It also takes away the talk that he is just in lockstep with his "masters". He wasn't the only one as 4 other Republicans voted for this, and in the grand scheme of things 15 Billion just doesn't seem like much. The bill won't produce jobs, but he will learn from this.
CosmicConservative
I can't help but think Harry Reid snookered him on this one, telling him how this will enhance his "independent thinker" and "bipartisan" cred. Drax, I think you are exhibiting some remnant of the Arlen Specter battle. I said at that time that if we ended up with an actual conservative or at least an actual REPUBLICAN when Specter ran for re-election I'd consider that a good deal. I'm still thinking that's a very possible outcome, so I'm not giving up on the "kick Arlen's ass out of the party" movement. I was fully behind that and remain fully behind that. But that was in part because I absolutely despise Specter since he pretty much epitomizes to me the worst kind of politician, the kind that can't even stay bought. But Massachusetts is not Pennsylvania. It is highly unlikely that any electable Massachusetts politician (including Mitt Romney, by the way) could be a truly principled conservative. That state just doesn't float that way. So I'm inclined to give Brown more leeway on this than usual, he didn't promise to stop every bill Reid proposed, he promised to fight the health care, cap and trade and boondoggle spending in Washington. And in actual fact, since Reid's 15 billion "jobs bill" was a replacement for a bill TEN TIMES LARGER, Brown can actually claim that he was fighting for a smaller bill. I wasn't on the Brown bandwagon to begin with, but insofar as I was pleased with his election, this is a fairly minor thing to worry about imho.
Old Goat
While I would love to see nothing but true conservatives in the Republican party, it will never happen. You have to have more middle of the road members from the States that lean left to help with the important legislation. This just doesn't even send up a red flag on him with me. I don't believe the "for President" hype about him, as I don't see anyone being elected again for a long time that is this inexperienced. The people will have learned from Obummer that having no resume is not what you want running the country.
Drax
Well... such attitudes are ... refreshing... So, no more "kick the RINO's out!" "I'd rather vote for Hillary than McCain!" ??? LOL. Not likely. It's the same old story on the blogs. "KILL THE RINOS!" "McCain must go! (And, Palin has proven herself to be party over principle by supporting him!") Brown gets a pass. For a while. Because too many of those who WOULD be calling for his head (and WILL be calling for his head) understand that, while short, our memories of their recent writings ain't THAT short... Beck's too libertarian -- HANG HIM! McCain's worse than a liberal -- retire old man! Etc. Etc. Etc. Circular firing squad assemble!
Drax
Oh... "But Massachusetts is not Pennsylvania." And Maine IS?
Old Goat
McCain needs to go for the various actions he took. You don't judge a politician from one single vote, you look at the wealth of their work. McLame should never have been nominated. Calling someone a RINO simply because of one single vote is absurdity. Calling them a RINO because they frequently went out of their way to be the maverick over the party AND the wishes of the base is another matter all together. I never liked McLame. I also felt that despite the left leanings of Hillary, she would have been more conservative than him, and that is a very sad thing to think. I also firmly believe that states where you have primaries that people in the other party or independents can vote, McLame won simply because he was beatable. His only highlight in the campaign was because of him choosing Palin, and that just shows how poor a choice he was. If Brown is conservative enough on the fiscal matters then right now that is fine. I don't like the vote for the jobs bill, but am sure that it will end up being something he regrets. If Brown is another McLame then I would say he would fine leaving. There is a reason why few Presidents are elected from the Senate. Its because they lack the backbone to truly lead, they are far too used to compromise, even if it compromises their supposed principles. McLame had no problem throwing aside the constitution for his campaign reform bill. He became an obstructionist and an appeaser, all for being able to say he was a maverick. He loved that title, as if it defined him.
CosmicConservative
Drax, I think you are over-simplifying several things simultaneously. I did not want to kick Specter out of the party just because he was a RINO. I wanted to kick Specter out of the party because he was a hack who sold his vote for a song, repeatedly and predictably. He was (and still is, that's why his biggest problem now is a challenge in the Dem PRIMARY) a hack who showed no sense whatsoever of loyalty or principle. As I said, he is the worst sort of politician and I didn't want an "R" by his name because of that. In the case of Olympia Snowe and other "RINOS" I don't think you've ever heard me call for their ouster, in spite of their votes. That's because I think they are mostly principled individuals who are simply on the far left fringe of the Republican Party. Right now I'd say that Scott Brown is probably on the left edge, but not the left fringe of the Republican Party, but his actual position remains to be seen. When you see me calling for Olympia Snowe's head on a platter, you can say I'm just trying to enforce party purity. Now, on John McCain.... I don't think John McCain is as unprincipled and corrupt as Arlen Specter, but there are other reasons I don't like (and have never liked) John McCain. You can put the Keating Five mess in there, along with his repeated assaults on the Constitution with things like McCain Feingold and other notable demonstrations of his complete contempt for our nation's founding principles. I don't like John McCain because I don't think his interpretation of "liberty" and "freedom" remotely matches my own. In too many cases his interpretation matches that of the core liberal position. But beyond that. My opinion of John McCain is that he is a self-aggrandizing camera hound who is more concerned with getting good press than he is with making good legislation. I respect his service and honor the suffering he took in the name of his country, but that does not, in my opinion, excuse his decades-long assault on this nation's core founding principles. But, in spite of all that, I don't think you've ever heard me call for his ouster from the party either. In fact, in my entire life, I think the only person you've ever heard me say I want to get kicked out of the Republican Party is Arlen Specter. I really, really despise that man.
Drax
Maybe you haven't called for the ouster of Snowe and McCain, but, if not, it was only because the alternative was even more odious. I have an entirely different opinion of McCain, as you likely know. The notion that a politician who has, as his job, the advancement of his agenda is a "camera hound" is beyond ridiculous. He should sit in the back of the room, saying nothing, hiding from the cameras? And, FYI -- McCain-Feingold was deemed (partially) unconstitutional by one vote. Next year or thereabouts, the answer would likely be different. How comfortable are you in determining that something is unconstitutional by a vote of SCOTUS? (I know that's the only way ... but, since their votes clearly have little to do with the actual words in the document, their rulings for the most part are meaningless to me other than the fact that, you know, they're the law of the land and whatnot...) I can make a strong case for McCain-Feingold with a single sentence. Corporations are not "persons" within the meaning of the Constitution as envisioned by our founders and are, therefore, subject to restrictions on their free speech which "persons" are not. Beyond that, McCain-Feingold attempted to address a significant issue -- the use of union and corporate funds to affect elections -- funds which are extracted from its members -- expended without its members consent -- for purposes which its members may not agree -- at a time where the "uninformed masses" (see, e.g. the studies you cite setting forth the abject poverty of information the masses possess relative to the political situation in this country) are just beginning to pay attention (mostly through advertisements since they don't -- you know -- read anything, listen to anything, watch anything which might accidently inform them...) and could have their votes informed by the massive amounts of money these "people" can throw at an election. At least McCain attempted to DO something about this. (I think it was a wrong-headed and unconstitutional (once you get past the "person" fiction) way of attempting to address what is, without question, a SERIOUS problem in the effect that large institutions, using other people's money, have on elections. KEATING FIVE? You gotta be kidding me. The PROSECUTOR not only cleared McCain of any taint, but declared him one of the most honorable men he has ever met! I could make a good argument for the the "Gang of Fourteen." With the "nuclear option" in the news today, it is apt that this is the very thing that McCain was attempting to forestall the REPUBLICANS from implementing as it related to the filibuster the Democrats were employing to prevent the confirmation of conservative judges. The REPUBLICANS, stymied by the filibusters, threatened to employ the "nuclear option" to push them through. The "Gang of Fourteen" STOPPED this, what the Republicans NOW call "unconstitutional abuse of power." Ox -- gore... I can make a rational and logical and, in many cases, COMPELLING reason for each of McCain's "unconservative" votes. I CAN'T make one for him doing it for SELFISH and self-aggrandizing reasons.
CosmicConservative
... oh, and as far as the comparison between corporations and private citizens, the SCOTUS has repeatedly ruled that as a COLLECTION of private citizens, corporations should have free speech rights. Now, you are correct, that may change with a shift in the vote. My own personal interpretation of the constitution probably won't change just because someone got appointed by Obama.
Drax
And, where in the Constitution, is a "collection of" persons addressed (e.g., a legally recognized fictitious "collection")? Further, where is the right of the leaders of that "collection" to speak FOR each of the individual members enumerated -- using their money -- saying things(in many cases) which the individual member is in complete opposition to? I give almost NO credence to anything SCOTUS has to say on almost any given subject as it regards its interpretation of the Constitution. Words have meaning. More importantly, when the word is law, that meaning must be IMMUTABLE. If it's not, then it can mean just about anything. Since it isn't, it does.
yoski
scott brown has never been a conservative or tradtionalist. he is pro abortion. period. i dont know why people supported this man with degenerate policies. its ridiculous. im actually glad he sided with the dems here, so moron conservatives will get some kind of a clue.