Or don't knock at all.
The SCOTUS (Supreme Court Of The United States) has ruled in a 5-4 decision that police evidence obtained in a search of a house cannot be thrown out if the police failed to knock and wait 15 seconds before entering the house. The case in question involved a raid where police shouted "Police! Search Warrant" and waited no more than 5 seconds before breaking down the door and finding the suspect in the house with crack cocaine and an illegal hand gun in his possession.
There was no mention of bribe money wrapped in tinfoil in the freezer.
The interesting thing about this story is that this is the first CNN story I've seen where they are aggressively putting their ideological stamp on the Roberts court. Here's the first example:
President Bush's nominees to the high court, Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Samuel Alito, notably sided with the government.
Then there was this:
He was joined by Roberts and his fellow conservatives Anthony Kennedy, Clarence Thomas and Alito.
Oh, so now Kennedy is a "fellow conservative?" Wow, just a few months ago I thought he was the new "conscience of the SCOTUS" with O'Connor's retirement. How quickly they forget...
And in case you didn't get the message, there's this:
The justices sparred in an appeal they are hearing for a second time, and reflected the deep divisions that remain on a court divided along ideological lines.
And this:
The majority-conservative court has been generally supportive of police discretion since the 9/11 attacks, including disputes over home and car searches, suspect interrogations, and sobriety and border checkpoints. Several of the more liberal justices have disagreed sharply in many of those cases.
And in case you still are not clear about the destructive impact Bush's appointments have had on the court, there's this final dig:
Alito turned out to be the deciding vote in the Hudson case. He was not yet on the bench when the case was first argued in January. His predecessor, Sandra Day O'Connor, heard the case and appeared to support the defendant.
But she retired before a decision was issued and, under court rules, her vote did not count. That left a 4-4 tie, prompting the court to rehear the arguments.
So there you have it. The SCOTUS is now officially a "conservative court". Somehow it's been a "conservative court" since 9/11/2001 even though in four of those five years "before she retired" Sandra Day O'Connor was still the "conscience of the Court." I guess if it's been conservative all that time, it must be a neocon court by now.
I have said it before, and I'll repeat it here. If you think the political partisanship and rancor is bad now, you just wait and see what happens if Breyer or Ginsberg retire while Bush is in office. I don't think this country is prepared for the bedlam such a situation would produce.
But prepared or not, I am still hoping for it.
Comments (0)
No comments on this post.