Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Aging secret unlocked?

By CosmicConservative
Update, heh, I've been using the English spelling, Americans spell it "Aging." Oops. Hmmm... still doesn't look right.... Oh well. This is interesting news, not sure it rises to the level of "promising" or "exciting."
One of the biggest puzzles in biology – how and why living cells age – has been solved by an international team based at Newcastle University, in north-east England. The answer is complex, and will not produce an elixir of eternal life in the foreseeable future. via FT.com / UK - Scientists discover the secret of ageing.
Basically they say that aging is related to the body's natural defense against cancer. Which sort of makes sense if you think about it. One of the most obvious medical results of cutting down disease and accident to allow humans to live into their old age has been a marked increase in cancer as a cause of death. Projecting outwards using the rise in cancer as the population has aged suggests that if everything else could be solved, cancer would finally get everyone. So for aging to be an actual defense against cancer sort of makes sense.

Comments (49)

mtnlurker
But if people did not live long enough to get cancer regularly due to short lifespan why would there be any evolutionary pressure to evolve this defense?
CosmicConservative
There is no such thing as "evolutionary pressure." That's a form of Lamarkism that grates on me every time I see it in a biology paper or "science" news article. It evolved. Organisms with the defense succumbed less to cancer and so had higher survival rates. Since not much lived to an advanced old age, the consequence of eventually dying of old age wasn't a significant issue. It does imply that if humans live long enough, a different cancer defense might evolve and we could live forever. Or more likely, humans might bio-engineer themselves a different cancer defense and we could live forever.
mtnlurker
So, you are saying that changes in environment do not cause changes in creatures living in that environment? This is what I mean by evolutionary pressure. Change or die.
CosmicConservative
mtn, basically yes, this is the same discussion I had about a year ago with Drax. DNA just changes randomly, it doesn't change based on the environment (except insofar as the environment drives more random changes due to, say, radiation or cosmic rays). But the SPECIFIC change in the DNA is totally random, it's not based on any external conditions. The environment is only a filter which separates the useful from the non-useful mutations.
CosmicConservative
Drax... Well, just so you know, the overwhelming scientific consensus of biologists is absolutely in agreement with me. So there.
Dadman
Per the theory, Cosmic is correct. But I don't buy it 100% either...
CosmicConservative
Dadman, I suppose it's fair to say that I don't buy it "100%" myself, but my problem is that outside of divine interference, I have never yet seen a plausible agent of change that can influence the DNA changes. I'm more than willing to entertain them, but I simply haven't seen anything that would explain how the environment could "drive" certain changes. Lacking a change agent, I have to go with the random (or divine, I concede that there might well be divine intervention).
Drax
"Life will find a way." Sorry. But, I'm convinced that environment is the driving factor. "Random" means "random." That means that any evolutionary change is "random" and only "randomly" BECOMES beneficial hundreds or thousands of years later. Serendipity as the driving force for evolutionary change isn't something I can get behind.
Drax
This: http://www.cosmicconservative.com/weblog/?p=6661 seems promising...
CosmicConservative
Drax, I agree that is a promising thing. And I've referenced the quantum foam as a potentially information-driven matrix for years. It is possible that there might be some matrix where evolutionary change is driven out of the quantum foam through a decision matrix.... But nobody has proposed any agent that actually does it. So it's not "plausible" yet, only "possible."
CosmicConservative
... by the way, that quantum foam holographic information matrix is where some people think God lives...
Dadman
The vast majority of random change has a deleterious impact on the effected organism too. Just something to think about...
CosmicConservative
Drax... that's the fundamental belief of pure Hinduism.
Drax
I haven't a clue as to how humankind evolved over the centuries. I just find it to be a simpler and more rational explanation that life reacts to the environment, rather than, through "happenstance" -- somehow -- the very things needed to survive in the presented environment -- and little else. Further, when we see different life forms which have scantly evolved over millions of years -- one has to ask how these species have been essentially spared the "random" evolutionary changes which apparently were running rampant all around them.
CosmicConservative
Drax, in general what people have a problem with is the sheer magnitude of the phenomenon of random mutations. Your body has trillions of cells and there are millions and billions of individual organisms. Random mutations are occurring all the time at a prodigious rate, millions per day. The vast, vast majority are simply not significant enough to matter (most of your DNA controls things like how an enzyme molecule is shaped). Of those that do matter, most are harmful. But they never stop. Every day there are millions and millions more. When one happens to have an effect that is suitable for improving a creature's survival in their environment, it sticks. Most people think mutations are rare, they are not. Think of mutations in DNA as a boiling sea of potential change that is always seething and pushing in every possible direction. Like air, for example. Air doesn't enter a vacuum because it knows there is a vacuum, air is constantly pushing in all directions so when there is a vacuum, it floods into it. Mutations and natural selection work in a similar way. Mutations are always happening that cause changes to the genome, and whenever one happens to fit the environment, it has a strong likelihood of reproducing itself. That's how it works. That's also why cancer is so common.
CosmicConservative
Now, there are some interesting caveats to the random mutation theory. One is that it is known that DNA is prone to "breakage" in certain areas which lead to certain mutations happening more frequently than others. DNA has weak spots. One of the most common and most frequently mentioned in the literature is the tendency of certain species of birds to lose the ability to fly. Without the constant environmental danger of being killed and eaten without flight, those species tend to mutate smaller wings. Since smaller wings require less energy, if the environment is such that flight is not needed, then that mutation actually is beneficial (because the body more effectively manages its energy diet). So when birds of those species populate islands without natural predators, the ability to fly quickly disappears. But it's not because the environment "pressures" the DNA, it's because the DNA has a natural weakness or propensity to mutate that way, and when the environment is conducive to promoting that mutation, it leads rapidly to flightless birds.
Drax
I'm not sure how, when the "environment" doesn't REQUIRE flight to survive and does REQUIRE energy to survive, it isn't "beneficial" to lose the ability to fly -- or that it isn't an "environmental pressure" to follow the path of least resistance to survival. But, who knows... It really doesn't matter to me what arguments are advanced to support random evolution; I won't buy them. The sheer number (not infinite, but certainly huuuuuuuuuggggggeeeee) of potential random mutations, the vast (vast, vast, vast, vast) majority of them benign or harmful, just, by happenstance resulting in the complex life forms which, in almost every way, have little which isn't completely functional -- but completely functional for the environment in which the life form is found -- simply cries out for the application of Ockham's Razor. But, I'm open to it. Once it's PROVEN -- not by consensus.
CosmicConservative
I'm pretty handy with Occam's Razor myself, and it's absolutely on the side of natural selection and random mutations. So far anyway. Nothing simpler has been proposed outside of divine intervention, and that is arguably cut down by Occam's Razor too since an infinitely powerful being is really pretty highly unlikely compared to the alternatives.
Drax
Really. It's MORE likely that a life form is randomly mutated in such a manner that the mutation is not harmful -- but is not needful -- but that random mutation BECOMES needful at some later point in time some hundreds or thousands or tens of thousands of years later -- even though, in the interim -- that same life form undergoes many more mutations which -- as happenstance would have it -- ALSO are not needful at the time of mutation but are needful at some later time ... WITHOUT littering the planet with millions upon billions of "dead end" mutations, or benign but useless mutations being the NORM rather than remarkable... Than it is to conclude that lifeforms have a built-in mechanism which is responsive to the environment which allows biological changes over time to stressors placed upon the life form? Okay...
CosmicConservative
Drax. The planet is littered with dead end mutations. But since they are generally unique events that don't progress to being a viable organism, the vast majority are aborted or never hatch, and thus never leave any trace. The fossils we do have are generally the result of massive numbers of successful species individuals so that the exceedingly rare circumstances that lead to fossilizing a creature almost always fossilize a generic member of an established species. I am sure I'm not going to convince you, but until you propose an agent that provides the mechanism for the environment to control the act of mutation, I'm going to stick with the explanation that actually HAS a mechanism that is clear, understandable and demonstrable. Thus my reference to Occam's Razor. Find the change agent that your theory claims must exist and I'll reconsider.
Drax
See...you SAY there is an actual proven "mechanism that is clear, understandable and demonstrable." But, there isn't. Is it "cosmic rays?" I'm not talking about "natural selection" which is the mechanism which is as operative in my notion as "evolution." But, the CAUSE of the mutations themselves. Is it radiation? (Which kind? All?) Viruses (which?) Transposons and mutagenic chemicals? Errors that occur during meiosis or DNA replication.? (Thanks Wiki...) What? Any? All? More? Here's the problem: Random mutation is INDIVIDUAL. It happens randomly to a single individual. Period. Now, for that random mutation to be passed on THROUGHOUT THE SPECIES, the time scale has to be pretty large. So, by the time the random mutation has somehow crossed the Alps, crossed the seas, and affected the entire species (because, obviously, until such point that the species diverges sufficiently to be a different branch, they all be the same...with the same mutations...) there will be other random mutations which must, likewise, be transmitted -- AND those mutations must, by the time they are so transmitted, STILL be beneficial (or at least benign (which begs the question as to why such benign mutations "happen" to be present in the "fittest" who spread their seed...) at the time they manifest. I dunno. We've had this conversation before....
Drax
I go back to this link (from our previous conversation): http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn14094-bacteria-make-major-evolutionary-shift-in-the-lab.html 44,000 generations. The ONLY major evolutionary change is BENEFICIAL. What is missing? The thousands upon thousands of dead end major evolutionary changes which resulted in species death. Or non-beneficial or harmful mutations. That's a really neat scenario, isn't it? The ONLY major mutation was for a life form to gain the ability to eat something which it couldn't eat before. Which, since the food was AVAILABLE, supports MY argument as well, i.e., "Life finds a way."
CosmicConservative
Drax, how large do you think the timescale has to be to pass on a random mutation? Let's look at deer, who reach sexual maturity after two years. Let's say that a deer mutation provides a more secure footing allowing the deer to better escape predators. Let's say the deer is a male. Male deer collect harems, usually of six to a dozen females. If the mutation is a dominant one, half of that male deer's offspring would have the mutation. That means within two years there would be as many as 8 or 9 deer will have the mutation. They will be sexually mature. Some will be male, for each male that succeeds (and remember they will have an advantage to succeed and become the father of a new generation) they will have 8 or 9 additional offspring. So if half of the first group is male, by the second generation you'll have at least 64 with the mutation. A generation (2 years) later you could have as many as 512, and that's only tracking the MALE deer. Within a decade the trait could become the dominant trait within the population, and it will then spread outward at the rate that deer wander. Within a hundred years it would likely spread throughout a continental population. A hundred years is an eyeblink in evolutionary or geologic terms. 100 years is not a "pretty large" timeframe by anyone's reckoning, much less from a biological evolutionary perspective. This is the nature of exponential population growth of mutations. They spread FAST, not slow. This is why, for example, bacteria get resistant to anti-biotics in weeks or months. Geographical barriers are a major reason that species differentiate. It may be that a deer population crossing the alps only happens once in a million years. So the deer on one side of the alps differentiate quickly. Also, you are full of benign mutations yourself. You are also generating harmful mutations, but the cells that produce them tend to die off quickly. Anyway, I'm not going to come up with better examples than I did last time. If that didn't convince you I'm not sure what will. Of course neither one of us has access to ultimate truth, but I'm quite comfortable in my understanding of the processes of evolution, the timescale of it, the speed at which it can propagate and a lot more about it. As I said, I'm completely open to reconsidering my position on this if you can come up with some plausible mechanism whereby the environment directs the process of mutation in a particular direction. If you can you should publish it because it will be Nobel Prize worthy. Seriously.
CosmicConservative
Drax, the only reason you only see a beneficial mutation is because the non-beneficial mutations tend to kill off the bacteria immediately, and the mutations which are neither beneficial nor harmful are virtually impossible to spot.
pace
On the topic of the original post; I recall reading a paper several years ago where data collected from autopsies of males who died over the age of 90 (I think) found that the overwhelming majority of them had some progression of prostate cancer present. These were men who had not been diagnosed with prostate cancer, and whose death had been attributed to other causes...
Drax
Again you SAY that "non-beneficial mutations tend to kill off the bacteria immediately" but there's no PROOF of this, and I'm virtually certain that it CAN'T be proven. You also SAY that "the mutations which are neither beneficial nor harmful are virtually impossible to spot" but, again, this is just an ASSUMPTION, isn't it? With the sheer number of births throughout recorded history, animal and human, it would seem that non-killing, non-beneficial random mutations would be RAMPANT in order for there to be the slim chance of a RANDOM and BENEFICIAL mutation to take hold and, ultimately, change the species. We would SEE these random mutations all over the place -- all the time as our genes are mutated randomly. We'd see all kinds of examples of this: as a matter or course, rather than the oddities that they are.
CosmicConservative
Drax: Again, the vast majority of mutations that occur in the DNA affect the production of enzymes. That's mostly what DNA does is control the creation and production of cellular enzymes. Mutations which alter the chemical makeup of an enzyme or the 3-dimensional shape of an enzyme happen all the time both genetically and somatically (genetic means it occurs in the reproductive cells and has a chance to be passed on to offspring, somatic means the mutation happens in the non reproductive cells and only affects the individual). For this reason cells are full of enzymes that do nothing but float around. DNA has multiple redundancy built in so that if one part of the DNA strand stops producing a necessary enzyme, other portions of the strand keep on producing it. The kind of mutation you are talking about, one where a radical and obvious change to the morphology of an individual occurs, is extremely rare in comparison to those that only affect enzymes or other cellular biochemistry. And as rare as it is, the vast majority result in non-viable results which are almost always spontaneously aborted (in mammals) or in non-producing eggs. Most of these spontaneous abortions or in-egg deaths occur very early in the formation of the organism and many are not even noticed by the mother. But in this case "rare" means "rare in proportion to basic biochemical mutations." As we will see below, that doesn't mean "almost never happens." They happen all the time. For a mutation with an obvious change (like a five-legged cow) to occur and to reach a stage where it is delivered alive or fully formed, the mutation had to get past the organ differentiation phase without killing the fetus. That's still a very rare situation, but it happens enough that you can find hundreds of examples of it in our lifetimes. Two headed frogs, six-toed people, etc. Happens all the time. In many cases the resulting mutated individual can survive into healthy adulthood. But usually those sorts of mutations interfere with the natural abilities of the individual and make it more prone to disease or predation. The fact that you see examples like the one you posted and view them as "oddities" is not, as you assert, a demonstration that these are so rare that beneficial ones must never happen, on the contrary, the fact that you see so many examples of these in your short lifetime on this planet shows just how frequently such things occur and greatly boosts the possibility that a purely beneficial mutation CAN occur. In other words, the fact that you see what you see is an indication that such mutations indeed ARE RAMPANT. They happen all the time. So much so that in the course of a middle-aged man's experience you can point to hundreds of examples. Now take that experience and multiply it by, oh, say one million years. Now you're talking about HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS of examples of the sort of occurance you are talking about in the relative evolutionary and geological EYEBLINK of a million years. And we only see those that happen in our civilized experience. Farm animals and humans mostly. The vast majority of life on earth exists outside of human society and those mutations you are seeing are happening all the time in the Amazon, in Africa, in New Zealand.... So multiply what you see by several orders of magnitude, then multiply that by the millions of years involved in evolutionary timescales and you should understand that major mutations that significantly change the morphology of an individual must happen BILLIONS of times every million years. Your own argument is working against you Drax. You think you are showing how rare mutations are, but you are doing exactly the reverse, you are showing how incredibly common they are.
CosmicConservative
... and just for full disclosure I do feel compelled to point out that the difference between somatic and genetic mutations is quite profound. The vast majority of visible mutations that come full term (like the five-legged cow) are purely somatic. Assuming that five-legged cow survives to breeding age, it is highly unlikely that it will have five-legged offspring. It's possible, but highly unlikely. There are lots of reasons for that, most having to do with the actual biological processes of cellular differentiation and development, where a minor mutation (or even a physical event) can have a major impact to the morphology of an individual, while a genetic mutation can only be successful if the result does not break some other part of the organism development process. That's one reason most evolutionary biologists argue that major changes in a genetic mutation are very rare and for that reason species evolution is very slow. However there is a growing group of evolutionary biologists who argue that major changes can happen in genetic mutations just as they happen in somatic ones. They acknowledge that such events must be extremely rare, but they argue that those major events are critical to the overall process of evolution and act as a sort of evolutionary supercharger. Examples of what they mean would be the appearance of arthropods, or the appearance of birds. In both cases a major morphology change (legs in arthropods and feathers in birds) created an entirely new form of creature with a major evolutionary advantage, and the result was that arthropods and birds exploded into environmental niches that had previously been unpopulated, leading to further differentiation within the new form at a vastly accelerated pace due to the opportunity to exploit those environmental niches. Looking at arthropods is instructive. Arthropod essentially means "jointed leg." The distinctive feature of arthropods is that they have a profusion of legs. Once the jointed leg appeared and the biological and biochemical mechanisms were in place to produce jointed legs, minor mutations which modified existing leg structure could happen (and did happen). For example, the mouth parts of arthropods are basically legs repurposed as mandibles. Same with antennae, or reproductive organs. To create the first arthropod was a major and highly unlikely mutation, but for that original arthropod to differentiate into spiders, insects, lobsters, crawfish, etc. required only relatively minor mutations. And since the DNA of arthropods is so heavily invested in makeing legs, mutations which alter legs (more, fewer, longer, shorter, etc..) are actually quite common. So it is no surprise that arthropods use legs for just about everything. Evolution tends to modify existing tools far more commonly than it tends to produce entirely new tools. The same applies to feathers and birds. Once feathers existed, wings became possible. Once wings became possible differentiation into the thousands of species of birds we see today was virtually inevitable.
Drax
My point was much simpler than that: We SEE the effect of "random mutation" all the time (where "all the time" is the infrequent (as related to number of births) "oddities" which result in 3 headed dogs, etc.). What we DON'T see is other, non-beneficial, benign changes THROUGHOUT THE SPECIES. In the recorded history of Man, we haven't seen a species-wide EVOLUTION -- or even the beginnings of one -- on ANY species. All of those changes which have been working on each and every species for the last hundreds of thousands of years, it would SEEM that some of them would have "kicked in" at SOME point in the past 7000 or so years and there would have been a species-wide transition of said mutation -- or, at least, the beginnings of one. But, we DON'T. Even though there are more people living NOW than have DIED throughout the history of Mankind, we don't see ANY "random beneficial mutation" amongst Mankind -- or any non-harmful mutation which hasn't existed in known history. Is "time" on an evolutionary scale measured in TIME or "generations?" Are "generations" notable due to number of BIRTHS or how the mutated genes are transmitted species-wide? To put a finer point on it... In the past 100 years, more births have occurred in the Human Race than in the previous tens of thousands of years of the existence of the human race -- from its inception. Random mutation had an equal chance of affecting each of those births as it did every previous birth which are argued brought about "evolution." Yet, we don't see any change. Nothing which hasn't existed before. Logic would seem to demand that we would see the results of random mutations which, if passed on to the next generations, would result in the next evolutionary step -- even if only in the Jones family in Kansas. Where is this change? Ain't happening. Ain't gonna happen.
CosmicConservative
Drax, we have seen exactly the evolutionary change that you say we haven't seen. We've seen it with dogs, cats, donkeys, virtually every domesticated animal has a known progenitor and has become a new species through direct interaction of humans breeding them. And that's just animals. The effect on crops is far more obvious. Virtually all of the crops that humans tend and grow for food have known "wild" progenitors which are no longer the same species due to humans breeding food stock. In many cases we've seen multiple new species of those food stocks. Weve seen it in bacteria in spades. Even with humans themselves there is significant debate about whether modern humans are a different species than the "caveman" cro-magnons who lived a hundred thousand years ago. From a purely morphological perspective you could make a strong case for speciation of human beings. The problem here isn't that it isn't happening, the problem is that you aren't seeing it.
Drax
Come on. You equate the purposeful breeding of animals and plants with "random mutation?" You then answer my "where are the mutations at today?" with Cro-Magnon Man? (Is he is or is he ain't "human?" Depends on who you ask and when you ask...) You say that it happens to bacteria in spades. Um..prove that? That it's "random?" I like how viruses "mutate." Amazingly enough, they seem to "randomly mutate" to conform to their environment. Find a way to kill it? Don't worry, it'll "randomly mutate" so that your antidote no longer works on it... I'm just not seeing how your argument addresses, let alone defeats, mine.
CosmicConservative
Humans simply create an environment where random mutations are "unnaturally" selected Drax. They don't initiate or direct the mutations, they only control the filter. I haven't made any attempt to "prove" that mutations are random. I've simply said that the theory states that mutations are random. I also clarified that to point out that the randomness is somewhat dependent on existing genetic factors, such as DNA geometry which introduces weak points (meaning some genes are more prone to mutation than others) and also pointed out that once a mutation becomes ingrained (such as the legs of arthropods) then future mutations tend to exploit that same technique, meaning that an ant is more likely to mutate another leg than it is to mutate feathers. You seem to have a problem understanding that random events can produce non-random results through the application of filters. I'm not sure how to get you to understand that, but it's a fundamental, if not THE fundamental principle of natural selection itself. Random mutation does not mean random result. It means that certain mutations are selected by the natural (and in the case of human breeding, unnatural) filters. The difference between your assertion and mine is that mine works with purely random mutations while yours doesn't work unless there is some change agent that is directing the genetic changes based on the environment itself. Again, until you can propose a plausible change agent, yours doesn't work. Mine works in the absence of a change agent. That's why Occam's Razor says mine is more likely to be true. It requires less to explain, and requires nothing that isn't known to exist. The known and/or theorized sources of random molecular DNA changes are: 1. Radiation 2. Cosmic rays 3. Molecular thermal activity 4. Chemical bonding 5. Quantum mechanical effects at the molecular level 6. Physical interaction between molecules All of those (and no doubt much, much more) can rearrange the amino acid bases in DNA and/or RNA. And all a mutation is is a rearranged amino acid base sequence. That's all it is. My theory says that the things listed above create such rearrangements randomly. Your assertion requires that those base sequences are arranged in some pre-determined manner by some unknown change agent that simultaneously works at the molecular level and is aware of the outside environment that it is attempting to exploit. The only change agent that I can remotely postulate that would satisfy those conditions is, well, God.
Drax
Dogs are still dogs. They have different attributes, but they are dogs. No matter how you breed them, they ain't gonna start growing wings. But, they should have. Or something should have. Or started losing them. Or come up from the muck, sprouted lungs, transformed fins to legs, ... something... The notion you have exhaustively explained is that the process of random mutation is that the mutations occur at a random time, then, if the mutation is beneficial, then it is passed along and becomes dominant. Rinse and repeat. A small part of a wing appears, then more, then more, all the while scales slowly transform into feathers, legs elongate, feet become claws...until finally, hundreds of thousands or millions of years later ... a bird. But, for hundreds of thousands or millions of years, that "bird" is developing (alongside all other lifeforms) and, if we picked different "snapshots" during the timeline of it's evolution, we would SEE it in its various stages of development. The same is true of all other life forms. Some would be completely transformed while the "bird" is first forming the first vestiges of its wings. Others would be just beginning their transformation at different eras along that transformation. Others would begin theirs long after the bird became a "bird." This process has to happen for each species at different times (being "random" and all) so that, logic DEMANDS that we should see thousands of species in varying stages of evolutionary change and/or see the results of a final change -- and/or the BEGINNINGS of evolutionary changes in some species. It is either "randomly" created by the exertion of outside forces, in which case it's going on now, or it's not. Evolution is like dominoes falling in a row. Tip the first and the process continues ... it doesn't STOP. Unless it's not "random." Yet, nowhere do we see the dominoes falling -- at any stage -- in any species. No vestiges of wings forming. No beginnings of lungs. No scales turning to feathers. Etc. Etc. Etc. And, if the evolutionary process is random and continuing, across the millions of species and the thousands of years of recorded history, given the scale of years required to effect evolutionary change ... we should. At least, that's where my train of logic leads.
CosmicConservative
Heh, well I'm clearly not going to convince you. From my perspective you simply have monumental misunderstandings about how the theory of evolution works. It doesn't work at all how you keep describing it. Wings don't evolve a feather at a time, and dogs exist today because they evolved from wolves through human intervention. Give it another hundred thousand years and it's quite possible we'll see another species of domestic canine evolve. You basically are saying that since you can't visualize how it works that it must be wrong. There's really no rebuttal to that. I agree that you don't seem to visualize it. I do. So we'll just have to agree to disagree.
CosmicConservative
Drax, I've done this before, but since it didn't stick, I'll do it again. Here is more or less how the theory of evolution explains the existence of birds. I won't go through the whole origin of life theory which would take you form the formation of the first RNA molecule (randomly, of course) and through the first self-replicatable object (the precursor to the cell) to the differentiation of the cell itself, then through the Cambrian Explosion where multi-cellular organisms suddenly took over the world... I'll just start with the dinosaurs. The currently most accepted theory of bird evolution is that birds evolved from a particular group of dinosaurs. The group includes the Tyrannosaur for whatever that's worth. Anyway most members of this group of dinosaurs were about the size of a turkey, and had long arms. They also had scales, much like other dinosaurs. But through a random mutation, some of the scales on these dinosaurs became fuzzy. They were still mostly scales, but they had fibrous protrusions that spread out in a fractal pattern to create a sort of fuzz. Well, fuzz is better at regulating heat than scales are, so these dinosaurs thrived, even when temperatures cooled, which other dinosaurs didn't handle that well. Now, remember what I said about arthropod legs and how arthropod evolution is mostly all about how the original leg mutation allowed for further mutations which repurposed legs to new tasks? Well the same is true for other things, that's why we have hair on our head that's different from the hair on our eyelashes, and more different still than our fingernails (which are made of the same stuff that makes hair). The fuzzy dinosaurs had other random changes which further modified the fuzziness so that it became differentiated itself. Eventually you had fuzzy dinosaurs with fuzzy scales that were different colors, sizes and consistency and no doubt they were used for mating rituals and other things. These small dinosaurs were also tree-climbers. That meant they jumped around a lot. In some cases some random mutations created longer, stronger less fuzzy "scales" on the arms of the dinosaurs. It so happens that this allowed the dinosaurs to jump further than dinosaurs without the adaptations. Over time this process selected for dinosaurs with more refined fuzzy scales until they became recognizable feathers. Now they still weren't "birds" yet, other changes were also going on at the same time, including changes to the mouth and jaw that eventually became beaks. But that's pure coincidence, there was no road map that said a bird would have a beak. It just happened that way, with the beak evolution following a similar logic to the feather evolution. As time went on the feathered tree-jumpers continued to experience random mutations. Some of those were beneficial, some were not. One that was very beneficial was an expansion of the chest and clavicle which provided more muscle attachment for the muscles which controlled the feathered arms. That provided the dinosaur with more strenght to flap their arms, which extended their jump/glide into what might have actually been true flight. This, by the way, is about the point that a bunch of these dinosaurs were caught in a swamp with very fine sediment and suffocated, being discovered later as the fossils for "Archeopteryx" the feathered dinosaur with a reptilian tail with long feathers, feathered "wings" which were still not anchored like modern birds and a toothed snout that would look much more appropriate on a dinosaur than on a bird. But it didn't stop there. The changes kept occurring as the chest expanded, the tail shrank and the feathers grew more specialized. Eventually a true bird evolved, and once it did, it began to aggressively colonize the ecological niches that no other animal could exploit, which led to further specialization. That's how it works, according to the theory. The reason archeopteryx is no longer around is because true birds simply out-competed it. Done in by it's own progeny, in effect. Which is the story of evolution, virtually all transitional forms are wiped out by superior competing forms which evolved from them. What you see around you today are all transitional forms. They will all be replaced eventually by new progeny which alter the balance of power in the ecosphere. Animals or plants which can continue to compete with newer forms are rare, but do exist. Crocodiles have been around for a long time and show no signs of being replaced any time soon. That's because it's hard to out-compete a crocodile in it's natural environment. Anyway, the idea that a bird had to have a beak and therefore it's some sort of amazing coincidence that feathers and beaks evolved on the same animal is really a meaningless point. We think of birds as having beaks because they do. Had the evolution of birds proceeded with jaws and teeth instead, we'd find birds with jaws and teeth to be the "natural order" and you could say "it's an amazing coincidence that birds evolved wings and fangs at the same time." It's not amazing. It's just a coincidence.
Drax
You don't understand what I'm saying. I'm merely saying what you're saying using a "domino" example. At any given time, the process is incomplete -- for birds, for dogs, for beetles. It is ongoing. It's happening now. So, those random mutations must be happening now. SOME species must have had SOME beneficial change which has been transmitted across species lines SOMEWHERE during the course of human history. Meh. Maybe it's like global warming. You just have to take it on faith.
CosmicConservative
Heh. I said the process is continuously complete and in transition at the same time. There are synergies involved within the ecosystems which tend to be self-stabilizing. That gives an appearance of completeness when the actual environment is not really stable. Evolution is stress-dependent. The more stress the environment feels, the more filters will be modified to allow for different mutations which would previously have been ignored or detrimental to suddenly thrive. Autism has been proposed by some to be an evolutionary step for humans, a naturally selected response to a world where too much stimulus is hitting humans all the time. I don't buy it, but it's an example of what some evolutionists believe. You continue to assert that humans have never seen any beneficial change across species lines when I have given you several examples of exactly that. Why you won't accept them is a mystery. Do you not agree that modern wheat is a different plant than the scrawny, spindly thistles that it evolved from? That evolution was entirely due to human beings changing the environment and selectively picking the biggest, fattest grains to replant for tens of thousands of years. There could not be a more compelling example than one that exists in your daily diet, yet you say it hasn't happened. Do you have to watch the mutation occur to believe it? There are hundreds, probably THOUSANDS of examples of exactly the process you say doesn't happen, happening over and over again in human history. Dogs, cats, wheat, roses, rice, horses.... I could come up with dozens without even trying hard. What do you not see?
Drax
When will you accept that I don't accept the actions of Man to get specific results in wheat or dogs as "random?"
CosmicConservative
Drax... The only action that men applied was to choose certain grains over others. Which is the same thing nature does, it just chooses differently. Wheat is what it is today because early man found out that certain thistles produced an edible kernel. At first they just ate what they found, and so had no real impact on the evolution of wheat. But with agriculture all that changed. Men went out and gathered all the thistle seeds they could, then they sat down and said "I can plant this so I don't have to go out and gather it from all over the wilderness." But man didn't just randomly pick grains to plant. Man CHOSE specific grains from the randomly grown grains in front of him. He picked the biggest grains. The logic was that if he wanted bigger grains to pick, he'd plant bigger grains to grow. A brilliant concept for it's simplicity and effectiveness. So from the millions of grains that he collected he ignored all those mutations that led to grain that was smaller or the same size as other grains. However very few mutations that led to bigger grains got past him, and those were planted. He also made choices about taste. And growth period. And insect resistance... etc. All of these were SELECTIONS that man made from a set of randomly mutated grains. The random mutations that did not meet his SELECTION criteria he removed from the gene pool by eating them. Over time that means mutations which pleased man were selected over mutations which displeased man. That's the filter. That's how random events lead to non-random outcomes. Nature's filter is less refined, but just as effective. Nature filters out according to pure survivability. I don't see why you don't accept this as how wheat evolved. But if you don't see how it works with man choosing wheat grains, I suppose you won't see how nature chooses the reproducing organisms either.
Drax
Certainly, I accept that this is how wheat evolved. It has nothing to do with "evolution." It has to do with "selection." It has to do with "breeding." "Evolution" is random mutation followed by natural selection. Kahn is eugenics. I don't know why you tout selective breeding as evidence of "evolution." The argument that, since we can MAKE it happen, therefore, it MUST happen naturally doesn't seem persuasive.
Drax
Again. You don't seem to understand. I don't have any issue with the fact that mutations occur. I just have an issue with the notion that evolution is BASED on random mutations when we don't have any evidence of random mutations (beneficial, benign, or harmful) existent in any species today - CAUSED RANDOMLY which is transmitted species-wide. I still maintain that, with the millions of species and the thousands of years, we'd have seen something EVOLVE or begin to evolve or SOMETHING. You know...other than that which WE CREATE.
CosmicConservative
Oh well, I guess we'll just have to wait then..
Drax
I mean...every species should be in varying degree of evolutionary undress....
CosmicConservative
Drax, every species is in varying degrees of evolutionary undress. Snakes have vestigial leg bones, so do dolphins. Humans have appendices and vestigial tails. Every animal is full of evolutionary detritus that is either a remnant of something that was once used or is something that has no discernible use. You won't accept the obvious evidence of animals and plants evolving literally right under the noses of mankind because mankind was involved in that evolution. If the arguments and observations I've outlined here won't convince you how evolution works, then I probably can't convince you. I'm pretty confident that I've laid out a pretty solid case though, so I'm not thinking it's a deficiency in my argument. :)