Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Phil Jones starts to come clean

By CosmicConservative
I wondered if Phil Jones would start a mea culpa tour. It looks like he might be in the beginning stages of one. In this interview he admits that his data is flawed, his results unreproducable due to his "disorganized data" and that his own research shows that the world climate has not shown signs of warming since 1995. Now what is important here is that these are all things that "skeptics" like me have been saying for a decade. If he continues with this path, next we'll hear him admit that he helps "hide the decline" in the famous hockey stick graph and that the computer models are riddled with errors and assumptions. I believe he is now trying to figure out how to re-establish some sense of academic integrity. Good luck with that Phil.
The academic at the centre of the ‘Climategate’ affair, whose raw data is crucial to the theory of climate change, has admitted that he has trouble ‘keeping track’ of the information. Colleagues say that the reason Professor Phil Jones has refused Freedom of Information requests is that he may have actually lost the relevant papers. Professor Jones told the BBC yesterday there was truth in the observations of colleagues that he lacked organisational skills, that his office was swamped with piles of paper and that his record keeping is ‘not as good as it should be’. The data is crucial to the famous ‘hockey stick graph’ used by climate change advocates to support the theory. Professor Jones also conceded the possibility that the world was warmer in medieval times than now – suggesting global warming may not be a man-made phenomenon. via Climategate U-turn: Astonishment as scientist at centre of global warming email row admits data not well organised | Mail Online.
Now the questions is if the media is going to start recognizing how thoroughly they've been had.

Comments (10)

Drax
Too much money and prestige (and power and influence) is tied to this theory for it to be surrendered without a long, protracted fight. What I find to be astonishing is that ANYONE would believe that he was simply "disorganized" when he "lost" the VERY BASIS upon which his world-renowned conclusions were based. No rational person could believe that.
CosmicConservative
Walter Russel Mead has had a series of articles about this, and I've been a pretty regular commenter on them. Mead is a believer but is honest enough at least to start examining the reality behind some of these revelations. One of the things I've repeatedly told him in his comments is that he is treating this like some sort of science ethics thing, and it's not, it's pure, raw corruption at its worst. Phil Jones and his cronies are quite literally criminals, the British authorities who looked into the FOIA requests have stated that they broke the law but that the statute of limitations has run out so they can't prosecute. That they are criminals is beyond dispute. The question is what motivation could have caused so many prominent members of the "science" of climatology to break the law. Most detectives are quite well aware of what motivates people to break the law, and Phil Jones is no different than any other man when it comes to those base motivations. The three most powerful motivations are money, power and sex. My guess is that Phil Jones profited significantly in all three areas, but mostly in money and power. This will go down as one of the, if not THE, biggest frauds in the history of science. This is bigger than "Piltdown man" and implicates NOBEL PRIZE WINNING "scientists". It is no coincidence that Al Gore has been in hiding since this hit. He knows that people are connecting the dots. The big, unspoken elephant in the room is the global carbon trading market. When the facts finally reveal how this is all tied to the multi-TRILLION dollar carbon trading schemes, that's when the lid will fully blow off. And that's what the crooks are trying desperately to avoid. And among those crooks I include companies like GE and financial trading companies who were looking to cash in on the carbon trading systems. This is really a big, big deal. People have no idea how deep this rabbit hole goes.
Old Goat
It's been building up for a long time. It was tied to a noble cause, that of preserving our environment, which I support as someone who camps and hikes regularly. They used the good cause, taking care of our earth, as a jumping off point for making lots of money. After all, you are simply evil if you don't care about the earth. I wonder how long it will be till its realized that many of the laws that are on the books are just means of control and gaining money. Just saw this morning on Wimp.com that there was a video showing how easily people will follow a "noble" cause. This was for banning Dihydrogen monoxigen. Its worth a watch. (Just think about the dangerous chemical that is... 2H and O...) hilarious. This is the Global Warming movement.
Old Goat
I think the biggest problem with this global warming stuff is the method and the end goal beneficiary of it. I don't know anyone who advocates for more pollution, dirty water, destruction of any and all resources without regard for how it impacts things. Reducing emissions isn't a bad thing. Its how they are going about doing and how they are looking to gain control over others that is the real problem. Finding new forms of energy that means less pollution and better efficiency is something all can embrace. I think that is the whole problem with this science. They started with great intentions, and because of that they got side tracked by the nobility of their purpose so that the ends justified the means. They allowed their goals to be driven by politics, and the politicians who got fired up by this were looking at the control they could exert as well as the financial benefits it would reap. When that happens ethics fall by the way side, and reason gets disregarded.
CosmicConservative
Movements like the worldwide "Environmentalism" example almost always devolve into the ideologically pure leading the gullibly naive. The Global Warming cult within the Environ/mentalism movement is an example of the ideologically pure becoming corrupted. It's really that simple.
Drax
On any subject, when "science" is by "consensus" (i.e., more "scientists" believe this theory than that theory -- it becomes "accepted") it is not "science" any longer -- it is faith.
CosmicConservative
I'll go one further than that Drax, and say that any "science" or "scientist" who mocks or ignores "skeptics" has left any pretense of science behind. Skepticism is one of the very foundations of scientific thought and is the fundamental rationale behind the most critical principle of science itself, that of "falsifiability." One of the reasons I have been so leery of the AGW movement is because from the moment it hit the world scene it wasn't just NOT science, it was in fact anti-science. It not only is a belief system, it is one that jeers at actual science.
Old Goat
One of the things that bothers me most about all this is that many have been saying for years that this doesn't add up. While I get it that there were a number of scientists that were on board, and it bore watching, it was not some complex science experiment that we had to do to say there was a problem with it. I've read for years about the middle ages having a bigger heating period, I've read for years that the "hockey stick" was faulty. This has been propped up by politicians and the UN was a BIG player in that game. Making this even worse is Global Warming has been taught in our schools for a long time, feeding the kids the distortions as truth. This alone helps illustrate the problem with our public school systems. It has turned into a propaganda machine. Its bad enough that most of the teachers seem to think it their duty to talk about politics even when that is far from the subject they are supposed to be teaching, they have taught a lie, a falsehood to these kids. How much credibility will they have after this?
CosmicConservative
What is being accurately reported in England (by the BBC, the Times and other news sources) and is NOT being reported at all in the States, is that Phil Jones in this interview has pretty much admitted that Global Warming is a fraud. Here are some of the things he admits: 1. The Mann hockey stick graph omitted two periods of warming that are statistically indistinguishable from the period from 1985 to 1998. 2. The "data" he used to generate his predictions is not reproducable, he doesn't have the data and he can't even say with certainty where the data supposedly came form. 3. The data he does still have his hands on is riddled with errors, duplications, fake weather stations and weather stations with acknowledged urban heat island biases as well as weather stations placed in direct proximity to heat-generating systems such as air conditioner exhausts, incinerators and in one case, the exhaust of jet airplanes. 4. The cooling since 1995 - 2010 is statistically identical to the cooling which occurred in the 1970s, the VERY SAME cooling trend that led to the cries of a "global cooling crisis." In other words, the SAME DATA that is now used to claim that humans are generating a dangerous global warming could JUST AS EASILY be used to claim another pending ice age. At some point you just have to say its all hogwash.