Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Irony is a Brees....

By CosmicConservative
So one of the most common stories on the sports blogs in the run-up to the Super Bowl was how the game would cement Peyton Manning as the best quarterback of his generation (Tom Brady now having been relegated to smelly old cheese status, I guess). But the stories I've read since seem to be how Drew Brees has elevated himself to Brady/P. Manning status instead. I find that sort of funny.

Comments (33)

Drax
Brees has long been an underrated quarterback. However, all fantasy football players know that he's been a top 3 QB pick for the past 3 years. http://www.nfl.com/fantasy/story?id=09000d5d80fe1a11&template=no-right-rail-with-comments&confirm=true Amazing that a QB who has been in the top tier of QB's since 2004 and, arguably, in the top 3 for the past 3 years (including setting the NFL record for most completions in a season in 2007 and for pass completion percentage in 2009) suddenly jumps to "elite" because his team won a SINGLE GAME. You know. I'd just bet that Brees was EXACTLY as good a QB the day before the superbowl win as he was the day after. But, you know, that's just me... Because, for some reason, I evaluate an INDIVIDUAL based on what the INDIVIDUAL does -- not his team.
CosmicConservative
I've put Brees in my list of top QBs for a while. "Elite" is a more difficult call. Is Ben Roethlesberger "elite?" He's won two Super Bowls. I'm still not sure Brees qualifies as "elite" though... He's definitely been as good as anyone for the past three years, but do you have to go six or seven years to gain "elite" status?
Drax
Big Ben? Pittsburgh won the first superbowl despite him. They won the second largely because of him, and could have easily have lost it because of him and his willingness to pit his size against those who attempt to (and almost succeeded many times) sack him. Again, I DON'T CARE how many superbowls a TEAM wins in my evaluation of how good a SINGLE PLAYER is. Drew has been, not only an "elite" (as compared to his peers) quarterback for the past three years, he has been an historically good quarterback. If Manning had not thrown that interception, and, instead Porter had guessed wrong when he jumped the route and Wayne was on a stop-and-go, tying the game -- and the Colts won on a kickoff return in overtime, then Brees would have EXACTLY been the same QB he is NOW -- with EXACTLY the same stats -- having played EXACTLY the same game, yet, this discussion wouldn't exist. It would all be about Manning's "legacy" when, the difference would have been ONE PLAY. Whether an individual has "won" a title (or how MANY he's "won") in a TEAM game just strikes me as a mind-numbingly dumb way to evaluate the performance of an individual.
CosmicConservative
Well, for a "mind-numbingly dumb" way to evaluate performance, it sure has a long and cherished history. When someone talks about Bill Russell, they don't talk about his shooting average, his points scored, his rebounds or his steals. They talk about his 11 NBA titles. Michael Jordan and Wilt Chamberlain get a lot of kudos for their individual abilities, but they also are acknowledged to be clutch players in the big games that decide titles. Whether it is fair or not is certainly open for discussion, but the reality is that winning titles counts. Joe Montana is not on everyone's list of best QB ever because of his regular season yardage totals. He's there because he's "Joe Cool" the dude who can walk into a huddle and take control no matter what the circumstances. He's there because when he was in the playoffs, his team was sure they would win. It's a team game, for sure. But each player on the team contributes. It is my opinion, stated here many times, that some players just make other players around them better. Some players elevate their performance in the playoffs, and some put their team on their shoulders and carry them. I think it is fair to consider championship performances in measuring a QB's "elite" status. This is why I have said Tony Romo has to get to the Super Bowl before I'll consider him elite. That may be unfair, but that's just the way it is...
Drax
Many things are done simply because it's a good story. Period. Talking heads have to have something to talk about. They have to have stories to craft. They can, out of one side of their mouths, talk about how much championships mean, while, on the other hand, say that Ted Williams was the greatest baseball player of all time. They can say that "winning a championship" sets quarterbacks apart from their peers, yet, at the same time, put Marino in the top 5 (sometimes the top 1) QB's of all time, while leaving Dilfer out of the conversation entirely (and you'll find FEW "all-time" QB rankings which put Bradshaw above Marino...) You talk about Russell. He certainly is talked about in terms of his rings, but he is also spoken of as one of the greatest centers of all time. Of course, his nemesis, Chamberlain, with only 2 rings, is routinely listed above him (as is Kareem and the Dream). (Was Magic a "better" player than Larry? Malone is routinely listed above McHale...) Why does Montana rate above Manning? His ability to execute a play to a receiver able to execute a play called by the offensive co-ordinator is superior to Manning's ability to CALL the play, execute it to a receiver who is able to likewise execute it? I'm sorry. I can't rate the worth of a QB based on what a team does. I can rate him on what HE does. Which is why Bradshaw, Nameth, Dilfer, Williams, Simms, Plunkett, Rypien, or Johnson don't even make my list of great QB's while Manning, Kelly, Graham, et. al. do. And, why Elway WAS on my list of all-time greats BEFORE he got T.D. and won two.
CosmicConservative
So... is Brees on your list of elite QBs now?
Drax
In a comparison to his peers, he has BEEN on my list of "elite" QB's for three years now, and in my top 5 since 2005. (I have NEVER had Brady in my "elite" category. I give almost all the credit for their wins to play-calling and scheme rather than to individual excellence. The team was good before him and it was good after him. It isn't so good now, but that's because 1/2 of the equation (the defense) is sub-par, not allowing for a "game management" type of quarterback. I paid for falling into the media hype this year and chose him for my fantasy pick over Brees and Favre when I KNEW BETTER, but hoped to see a repeat of the Brady/Moss magic. Didn't pan out...) Historically, Brees have to have at least two more excellent seasons. But, if he does, he's HOF, being one of the top QB's STATISTICALLY for pushing a full decade. (In terms of touchdowns, he's #1 for the past 3 years total, set the NFL record for completion % in a season, set the NFL record for # of completions in a season, tied the NFL record for completions in a Super Bowl, and played an almost flawless post season -- including the Super Bowl. I mean, what more does one need to DO to be termed "elite" at one's position?
Drax
AND dang near broke Marino's yardage record, falling short by yardage which could have been made up in a single pass, becoming only the second player in history to pass for 5000 yards. I mean, really. The pundits are just NOTICING this guy? Sad. Sad. Sad.
CosmicConservative
So, is Joe Montana on your list of historical elites?
Drax
Of course. Unlike you, I give a GREAT deal of weight to "longevity." There's generally a reason why a quarterback plays a long time, and, in general, that's because at least one team believes that he's the best one available for the money. (I also believe that good/great play over a long period of time is MORE impressive than good/great play over a short period of time. Call me crazy.) I also don't penalize someone for being on a good team. It ain't Montana's fault that he had Rice to throw to or that he was on the ground floor of the "west coast offense." He was a great quarterback. I just don't put him at the TOP, but certainly in the top TIER. I found an interesting site talking about this here: http://www.pro-football-reference.com/blog/?p=3378 It's an interesting way of looking at things. It takes much of the "team" aspect out of the equation -- especially wins/losses. (Since the QB only throws the ball and doesn't catch it, or design the plays, or call the plays, or set the defense, or miss tackles, or get determine starting field position, etc., all the "team" aspects of his performance can't be eliminated. This is pretty good, though.) What is remarkable (to me) is that, of those listed above Favre, ONLY Marino has anything like the number of attempts as does Favre. The fact that he's been able to maintain such a high level of consistency over such a long period of time (as Marino) is impressive. Manning will (if he stays healthy) surpass Favre in almost every category, including attempts, and will likely have a better result with his attempts. My top tier, all time is: (I know I'll forget someone): Montana, Marino, Elway, Favre, Unitas, Starr, Manning. Second tier is much larger. Then, there's everyone else.
CosmicConservative
Hmm... I read through the logic from the link you provided and I can appreciate the effort and logic behind the calculations, I can't say I'm all that impressed with the results. If I were to create a formula for ranking quarterbacks, I'd have it include the following things (not in any particular order): 1. TD/Int ratio 2. Completion % 3. 3rd down conversion efficiency 4. Yards/attempt 5. Two-minute drill effectiveness 6. Sack avoidance 7. Red zone efficiency 8. Fumble rate 9. Number of targets 10. Big Game performance Using that as a basis I think you'd get a much different picture of who the best QBs were. I think the linked approach is far too dependent on passing yards, which greatly enhances the ranking of QBs who played in a pass-happy offense (which is why Elway ranks so low, but Ken Anderson ranks so high when I don't think anyone seriously would put Ken Anderson ahead of Elway on a list of top QBs.) My list of top QBs would be similar to yours, although I might or might not have Favre on it, and I'd probably have Brady on it in spite of your constant Brady bashing. By the way, I do give a lot of weight to longevity, and I've even said that's one of the prime reasons Favre would have a shot at my list. Just as you think Brady is overrated, I think Favre is. Favre has lost as many big games as he's won, you can't say that about Brady, and I continue to try to express how important I think it is for quarterbacks to not LOSE games. That's why in general I don't care for the swashbuckling chunk it downfield and hope for the best style of QB.
Drax
I have never, never, never "bashed" Brady. I simply state that he isn't in my top tier, giving most of the credit to the coaching and the scheme instead of him. (Gee, Bledsoe did pretty good the year he got hurt and when he had to replace Brady -- and Cassell looked like a top tier starting QB while on that team, eh?) You, on the other hand, "bash" Favre. Interceptions play a heavy part (and an equal part to every QB); sacks are taken into account (equally for everyone); fumbles are taken into account (equally for everyone). And...as to "big game" wins...sigh... I can't say it more clearly...QB's don't lose games; they don't win games; they play games. Teams win and lose games -- whether big or small. Which, of course, is the point of my posts.
Drax
Switzer, of course, was a great coach, since he won a superbowl. And Gruden! The fact that Switzer won with Johnson's team, doesn't matter any more than Gruden winning with Dungy's! They WON THE BIG ONE! All you gotta do is count the rings to determine GREATNESS! BRADSHAW, the GREATEST OF ALL TIME! PLUNKETT infinitely greater than Marino! FAVRE infinitely greater than Tarkenton! Eli Manning and Peyton are EQUALS! Doug Williams NEVER lost a superbowl and Kelly LOST FOUR! OMG, how BAD CAN ONE PERSON BE?!?!
Drax
I mean...Favre HAS to be a significantly superior quarterback to Marino, doesn't he -- by your standards. He has a better winning percentage in the post season. He has won the superbowl. AND, in the regular season he has surpassed every record Marino ever held. So, by your reckoning, he MUST be superior to Favre -- but, of course, he's not, is he?
Drax
Let me put the following for consideration as a reason for my objection to rating QB's based upon "big game wins" (in this case, I suppose it's "biggest game wins" and only Super Bowls count): In Super Bowl 36, had Vinatieri missed his field goal, then it's entirely possible that Warner would have 2 Super Bowl Wins and Brady 2. The "win" that Brady is credited (by you) was on a play over which he had NO control. (As was the SACK of Warner which put them out of field goal range two series earlier...and let's not forget the "tuck rule" which allowed them to advance to the Bowl to BEGIN with.) Super Bowl 38 was a repeat. Had Vinatieri missed again, then it would have been overtime, and Brady possibly with only 1 Super Bowl and Warner 2. Had Santonio Holmes dropped big Ben's rocket in the end zone, then Warner would have won (with this reckoning) 3 Super Bowls and Brady 1. So, based on play which had NOTHING to do with either QB, the RESULT could be Warner with 3 and Brady with 1. (By the same token, had Dyson not been tackled on the 1 foot line, Warner could easily have been 0-3 -- through NO FAULT of his own as a result of three single plays over which he had NO CONTROL.) This is why I put so little emphasis over "winning the big one."
CosmicConservative
Heh... if ifs and buts were candy and nuts, we'd all have a Merry Christmas... I go by what DID happen, not what MIGHT HAVE happened. And no, I don't only count Super Bowls as "big games" Here is how I'd define "big games" Any game that determines your playoff disposition is a "big game" and is awarded 1 "big game point" (bgp). Any game that determines the outcome of a division race is a "big game" and is also awarded 1 bgp. Thus a game that determines both a playoff spot and a division title is worth 2 bgps. Wild card playoff games are awarded 1 bgp. Divisional round playoff games are awarded 2 bgps. Conference championship round playoff games are awarded 3 bgps. The Super Bowl itself is awarded 5 bgps. Thus losing two conference championship games is slightly worse (-6 bgps) than winning one Super Bowl (5 bgps). So Favre, this year, accumulated 1 bgp. He gained a total of 4 (1 for division title, 1 for clinching playoff and 2 for winning divisional round) while losing a total of 3 (losing the Championship round). Romo, this year, accumulated 1 also (playoff and division clinch, wild card round vs. losing in divisional round). Brees accumulated 12 while Peyton Manning accumulated 2 (losing the big game hurts don't it?) So, let's total all that up and see who comes out on top in the big game portion of my quarterback rating system (which comprises ONE-TENTH of the total calculation). I'm guessing that would put Terry Bradshaw, Joe Montana, Troy Aikman, Tom Brady, John Elway and a few others way up in that category. Once we've done that, let's deal with the other nine categories I've listed.
CosmicConservative
Nah... that's too harsh. Let's keep the Super Bowl at 4 and add clinching a bye as another bgp. Then let's say that you can only lose 2 bgp points by losing a playoff game. That way Favre would be at 3bgp, Romo would be at 1 bgp, P. Manning would be at 6 bgp and Brees would be at 12 bgp. That sounds a bit better. Every QB that didn't make the playoffs or win their division is at -2 bgp by definition. So Big Ben would drop 2 points this year.
Drax
You still don't "get it." What "did" happen was that a QB "won" or "lost" a super bowl on a SINGLE PLAY which was ENTIRELY OUT OF HIS CONTROL. Yet, this elevates Brady to one of the greatest of all time, and Warner to "maybe he's HOF." Sad.
CosmicConservative
LOL, it's not just me you're railing against Drax. It's pretty much every HOF voter since the system began. That's why John Elway was never considered a HOF choice until he won the Super Bowl. I get what you are saying. I just don't AGREE with it. I think winning big games counts. That's all.
Drax
Elway not a HOFer before winning 2 Superbowls? You've GOT to be kidding me! He was a FIRST BALLOT HOFer before he won his FIRST. What have you been drinking? That's not even CLOSE to reality. (And, I have no problem with the notion that "winning big games counts," I just don't agree that a QB, with very few exceptions, "wins" ANYTHING in a team sport. Any argument to the contrary is worthless.
CosmicConservative
LOL, I lived in Denver when Elway was in his "decline" during the mid-90s. Believe me, there was a LOT of buzz that Elway would not be HOF. All of that stopped when he won his first Super Bowl. Would he have actually been voted in? Probably, but not first ballot. You keep insisting that I'm saying that ONLY big games count. I'm not, I very specifically said that is one out of ten measures I would use to rank quarterbacks. Would that alone put someone on the top of any list? No, but it might separate a Jim Kelly from a John Elway. Or a Joe Montana from a Dan Marino. It depends on how each of the ten areas is weighted. I'll stand by the ten categories I listed. I haven't done the math but I expect that if you did calculate all of those things for all of the QBs, you'd end up with a list that put Joe Montana, John Elway, Dan Marino and Peyton Manning ahead of most other QBs. Yeah it just might put Troy Aikman ahead of Brett Favre. I wouldn't lose any sleep over that.
Drax
Here's another argument against your "win the big one" meme. Peyton Manning, arguably the greatest of all time, an argument I won't even attempt to counter as he is as deserving as any other for the reasons I've set out before. He's "won" 1 Super Bowl. In the road to the Super Bowl (in which he was a meager 1-1 and Dominic Rhodes "won" that game), his playoff performance was 3 TD's and 7 INT's with a whopping 70 QB Rating. (Until this year he was 22-17 TD/INT, hardly remarkable, at least in a positive fashion). He has been unremarkable, even horrid, in the post season. But, he "won" one, eh? Thank goodness he had 10 other people to help him out, I suppose because in his one successful run at the ring, he SUCKED. (And, the reason, I think is clear. The same thing which makes his so good in the regular season makes him vulnerable in the post season. He can get by on talent and his offensive play calling sufficiently in the regular season -- especially against the lesser teams (he almost NEVER could get past New England even in the post season for nearly a decade) but, in the post season, he's playing against GOOD teams with GOOD defensive co-ordinators who have had TIME (especially if they had a bye or the Super Bowl week off) to PREPARE for him. And, no matter how good Manning is at offensive play calling, he is, AT BEST, a "part-time offensive co-ordinator," and he's going up against the best full time defensive co-ordinators in the game (usually). For the most part, it's not even close to a fair fight. But, still, he "won" one.
Drax
I refuse to accept wins and losses as a valid criteria for greatness for an individual in a team sport. Period. OJ was likely the greatest running back of all time. If not him, Jim Brown. Perhaps Barry Sanders. Not Emmitt Smith. Not Terrell Davis. But, I guess your criteria only applies to Quarterbacks. (And, I don't know what people were saying in Denver (notably cynical about a Bronco going into the HOF, to be sure...), but everywhere else on the sports watching planet, Elway, the King of Combacks, the author of "The Drive" (one of the handful of events in football history with an actual NAME) -- was a LOCK for a 1st ballot.)
CosmicConservative
No, I'd apply my criteria to all the "skill" positions, QB, receiver and running backs. Win the big one and your stock goes up in the "greatest of all time" sweepstakes.
CosmicConservative
So, would you apply your "wins don't count" attitude to pitchers in baseball? That's a team game. Pitchers don't even score runs. How can you grade them on wins?
Drax
Sigh. A picture can control what a pitcher does, not what his team does (or his middle relief or his closers, for that matter...) He has a GREAT deal more control over the team's destiny than does a quarterback (or a Running Back or Wide Receiver). So, do I credit Fergie Jenkins with a degree of greatness greater than other pitchers of his generation since he was able to string together 6 20 win seasons for the CUBS? Yep. I do. But, do I penalize Ryan for playing on crappy teams? Nope. If your team can't score 3 runs with some regularity, I'm going to penalize a pitcher for having a 3.5 ERA? YOU KIDDING ME? Over time, a dominant pitcher, even on a bad team will have a decent win/loss ratio. But, the same pitcher on a better team will have a BETTER win/loss ratio. (Just as a great QB will win more games with a mediocre team than will a mediocre QB with the same team (or a mediocre QB wins more games on a good team than on a bad one -- ask Cassell...) In roughly 35 starts, a pitcher who dominates will win more games than he loses almost every season IF he has an average team. Sometimes, you get someone SO good that they'll have LOTS of wins even on a crappy team (Clemens, Jenkins, whatnot). The pitcher has a HUGE amount of control over how many runs the OTHER team scores. Once what HE has control over becomes OUT of his control, he is no longer ANSWERABLE for the "win" or the "loss." Baseball understands that one pitcher who holds the other team scoreless into the 9th, shouldn't be answerable if the TEAM loses after he's pulled. The guy who LOST the game gets credited with the LOSS. So, apples...potatoes. Not even a reasonable comparison.
Drax
(Don't get me wrong. I think that any Quarterback, the one person who has the most control throughout the game over the success of the offense) should be "judged" somewhat by his success in winning games. But, always carefully, cautiously, not just a "counting of the rings." Most QB's have little control over the team on which they play. They have no control over their coaching staff (usually); the scheme, the defense, etc. etc. etc. They DO have control over their decision making and their execution. And, without question, great quarterbacks tend to rise up and WIN games that lesser QB's couldn't -- including Super Bowls. But, many times, QB's are CREDITED with the wins when they had little to do with them, in fact, when their play was SO POOR that the team won DESPITE them, and, of course, this includes Super Bowls. Further, many times a game is won when the "winning play" was something which was entirely out of the hands of EITHER QB. (It reminds me of the Green Bay/Arizona playoff game. It would be difficult to find a game in which two quarterbacks could have played any better. Warner "won" that game as a result of a defensive play.) It's just one of my pet peeves. The Malones, Stocktons, Barkleys, Williams, Sanders, Marinos of this world played where they played, with the team mates they had and did the best they could with what was presented. Were they as great as any who have ever played the position? Of course they were. Did they play on inferior teams? Yes. That doesn't detract one WHIT from their "greatness."
CosmicConservative
Drax, I think you and I are approaching this from totally different perspectives. Any means of identifying the "greatest quarterbacks" is going to be subjective. All the statistics that are collected during their careers eventually become a form of noise instead of information. I'm simply proposing an heuristic which I think filters the noise to provide one view of ranking the QBs. In that filter, I think winning big games counts. That's not to say it's perfect, that's to say that it has as much validity as yards gained, or completions or touchdowns, etc. ALL of the statistics rely on other players on the team performing, so there is no PURE means of evaluating a quarterback. My proposal is just one way of addressing things that I think a quarterback influences and using them to filter down the noise. That's all.
Drax
Again, I agree that "winning big games counts." There's a REASON they call it "The Drive" and credit Elway with it. Sometimes a quarterback (or running back and no others) can take over a game offensively, putting the team on his back, and "win the game." (Again, it's a team game, but, Brees "won" that game with excellent execution.) What I'm saying is that, far too often, all that is REMEMBERED is that a QB "won" a ring, REGARDLESS of the circumstance, even if the QB played terribly and someone ELSE "won" the game (if such can be credited to anyone). Warner "won" his ring only because Dyson was tackled in an EXTRAORDINARY defensive play. Did Warner play exceptionally well otherwise -- both getting to the Super Bowl and in the Super Bowl? No question. But, he played JUST as well or BETTER in the two he "lost." Yet, too many pundits, in search of a story in a 24 hour news cycle, talk about the "greatness" of a QB and, what seems to put too many "over the top" on their ranking of a player is the NUMBER of rings a QB has (although this is almost NEVER true for anyone else, even middle linebackers, arguably the equal to a QB in importance to winning or losing). This wasn't always the case. Not too long ago, there was an almost complete consensus that Marino was the greatest of all time -- even while Montana was winning all those rings, and NO ONE put Bradshaw in the argument. Now, the consensus is Montana being the greatest with Brady a close second and Manning (if ONLY he could "win" another one...like one game alters in any fashion his body of work...) vying for the title. Marino is an afterthought. It just irks me.
CosmicConservative
Man, why you diss Bradshaw so much? He's a Shreveport boy!
Drax
I have no problem with him! He was a good QB, and he played his best in the biggest games, but come on! He had a career 70 QB rating. (And before you go off on..."that was then...QB's had low QB ratings back then..." let me remind you of the following: 1) He is #101 all-time. 2) He is surpassed by: Otto Graham (#8), Roger Staubach (#17), Sonny Jurgensen (#20), Len Dawson (#21), Bart Starr (#33), Fran Tarkenton (#36), Dan Fouts (#38), Johnny Unitas (#48), Phil Simms (#46), Bob Griese (#56), Kenny Stabler (#68), Norm Van Brocklin (#72), Sid Luckman (#73), Don Meridith (#75), Y.A. Tittle (#76), Roman Gabriel (#77), Earl Morral (#79), Ron Jaworski (#87). In other words, he was surpassed in almost every fashion by just about every quarterback who came before him or were his contemporaries. He does beat Namath by 20 slots, which, of course, doesn't surprise me as, statistically, Namath SUCKED in comparison to ANY Hall of Fame QB (other than Bradshaw). I wouldn't have put him in the hall. Having those rings doesn't a body of work make. Nor does their absence.
CosmicConservative
Man, Bradshaw was worth a Hall of Fame slot just for his speech.