Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Game Review: Axis and Allies (Anniversary Ed.)

By CosmicConservative
So I was fortunate enough this weekend to be invited to play the updated and expanded version of Axis and Allies known as the Anniversary Edition since it was released to help commemorate the 50th anniversary of Avalon Hill, the game's publisher. (JSullins, who posts here, was the one who invited me.) He said to expect at least four hours, maybe more. For those who may not know (is that even possible?) that game is a historical simulation of World War II. There are six countries in the game that can be controlled by a player, plus China which is controlled by the USA (heh, irony). The game is based on abstracted military battle mechanics and a basic economic model. Fundamentally the more land you occupy, the more "money" you make, and that "money" can be spent on military units like infantry, tanks, battleships and airplanes. Pretty simple concept, but with lots of specific rules. For example, each country has one or more economic "bonuses" they can gain by holding certain areas on the map. Plus there is a rudimentary research and development aspect where you can invest "money" into a search for military or economic advancements which provide a benefit in the game. More on that later... I have a copy of the original version of A&A, and I used to play it with some regularity with my brothers and other folks. It's probably one of my favorite games, although (as you would expect from me) I have a lot of suggestions for improving the game. The Anniversary Edition of A&A has been improved in many ways from the original game, but it retains the flavor and feel of the original game (which means it carries over both its strengths and weaknesses). JSullins sent me a writeup of the new rules and some frequently asked questions so I could get somewhat prepared for the game on Saturday (10:00 AM, we figured we'd be done well before dinner). So, 10:00 Saturday morning I was... stuck in traffic due to some road work supposedly financed by the massive TARP bill passed last year... But by 10:15 I was there and we were ready to go. Quick introductions all around and we proceeded to play the game. One each of five country markers was placed face down and mixed up in the upturned lid of the box. Each player (we had five, you can play with up to six, for less than six there are rules for how to double up on countries) chose an overturned marker and then turned it over to see what country they got. (Since we were playing with five players, Italy was to be played by the player who chose Germany.) I got Germany, which means I had to play Italy as well. The group I was playing with are all experienced A&A players. I hadn't played A&A in over 20 years. So I had some quick getting up to speed to do. And it showed when I decided to let Italy try to fight the U.K. in Africa. Things started out well enough, my German and Italian attacks in Northern Africa cleared out the UK forces and I captured Egypt. But my inexperience and lack of understanding of the rules led me to make a couple of critical mistakes with Italy, which pretty much crippled Italy for the rest of the game. But I did a little better with Germany. And with Italy no longer able to do anything in Africa, at least Italy was providing some badly needed reinforcements in Europe as the USA and the UK began their inevitable assault on the mainland. Soon a huge fleet was parked off the coast of France and Germany was having to beat back waves of amphibious assaults. At the same time Japan (Germany's ally) was rapidly spreading across the Pacific, capturing everything from Hawaii to the Phillipines. Soon Japan was attempting to drive through China to assault Russia. Russia was busy building armies to fend off a potential German invasion, but I (Germany) had my hands full with the UK and the USA. At one point the allied fleet off of Germany had a battleship, four cruisers, a couple of destroyers an aircraft carrier and several transports. The fleet was too big to fit in the sea zone it was parked in. Italian troops rushed to the French front to defend Europe, but in yet another example of poor tactics, Italy was left exposed to an amphibious attack. The USA swooped in, bringing her aircraft carrier based planes, a battleship, destroyer and two transports. Soon Italy suffered the shame of victorious American tanks filing through Rome. Things looked bad. But for the previous two turns I (Germany) had been building the Luftwaffe. Now with the massive UK and American fleet split (roughly 2/3 off the coast of France, and 1/3 in the Mediterranean) The Luftwaffe attacked. In a stunning example of the effectiveness of air superiority, the Allied Atlantic fleet was sunk. Totally wiped out. And Italian troops immediately counterattacked and liberated Italy. However, the damage was severe, and Italy effectively lost three turns of economic growth, leaving Germany the only power left in Europe. The UK had built a factory in South Africa, and that was now paying off as waves of tanks first captured all of Africa, and then began sending those waves into Asia to support India and help defend Russia. Japan was bogged down in China and facing a growing American pacific fleet threat of its own. But now the German juggernaut was building. In a stroke of great fortune, German scientists developed heavy bombers, effectively doubling the offensive firepower of German bombers. Soon Germany had four bomber units, each capable of inflicting as much damage as two normal bombers. One bomber was sacrificed to destroy the last vestige of the American fleet in the North sea, but the other three began devastating air support attacks on the Russian forces. Russia had been pushing Germany back for several moves, as Germany dealt with the American and UK onslaught. But with the Atlantic fleet sitting on the bottom of the sea, alongside the Spanish Armada, Germany now invested heavily in infantry and artillery to provide cannon fodder for the massive bomber fleet. In a dramatic reversal of the Battle of the Bulge, German forces crashed through the Russian front lines and captured Russia's southernmost city. Japan had finally overrun China, but was stalled as the UK forces were building ominously in India. The Battle of Burma had been raging for several turns, and India itself had changed hands once, but the UK had regained it using critical tank reinforcements from Africa. Germany's second invasion army was now on the move towards Russia's northwest flank. But America had established a factory and foothold in Finland, and American engineers had managed to increase factory output so much that America was generating five tank units per turn, which were reinforcing Russia, and threatening a northern invasion of Europe. But just as the climactic battle for Northern Europe was about to be joined (German troops were massed on the outskirts of Karelia and more bombers were on the way), the massive Pacific fleet battle was joined. When the dust, smoke and steam finally settled, Japan stood alone in the Pacific with any semblance of a fleet surviving. It was now 9:00 at night, and the Allied forces suggested ending the game due to lack of time. But as far as I'm concerned, the mighty Axis alliance of Japan and Germany crushed the Allies. It was only a matter of time before Russia fell, and America had the money, but not the time, to build and deploy a new fleet. So, yeah, it was fun. My major problems with Axis & Allies is how they arbitrarily create game mechanics to lead toward pre-determined results, but I suppose that's what historical simulations are supposed to do. I learned a lot, and remembered a lot. In the first three rounds I made several major mistakes that almost cost us Europe and the game. They did cost us Africa and kept the UK in the game as a major player right up to the end. I feel terrible about how poorly I played Italy. But I feel like I mostly made up for that in how I played Germany. Germany was able to hold off the invasions of the UK and America long enough for me to remember how to play wargames. And remember that Italy fiasco? Well, war is a funny thing. When America swooped in and took Italy, it was such a devastating loss that Japan almost surrendered. But the funny thing is, by splitting their Atlantic fleet in that manner, they gave Germany the opportunity to not only destroy that fleet, but to do so with enough overwhelming force that the Luftwaffe returned home not only victorious, but still strong. And that proved, in the end, to be the difference in the game. So by losing Italy we actually won the game. Funny how that works....

Comments (21)

CosmicConservative
I left out one other critical event in the game. After capturing the southern Russian city, I realized that my forces were in a position to severely disrupt the UK reinforcements coming to the support of India. Japanese forces needed both a path through Asia to crush India in a vice, and needed some breathing space from the constant South African and Egyptian tanks that were pouring into India at the rate of four per turn. So I sent my tanks and air force into the mideast to destroy a column of UK tanks and block additional reinforcements for as long as I could. It was another tactical blunder. I did not leave enough forces in the Russian city, and Russia's counterattack wiped out all of Germany's fighters, and several tanks. But, the strategy worked, even if the tactics were terrible. By blocking off the incoming supply of tanks, and opening a second Japanese front on India, Japan was able to capture and hold India. That coupled with the destruction of the American Pacific fleet finally turned the tide in favor of the Axis forces. So two major tactical blunders in the game led to two major strategic victories. And both were unintentional, I had not planned on losing either Italy or the Southern Russian city. (I wish I could remember those Russian city names...) But those two tactical blunders almost certainly led to the Axis eventual superiority in the game. It really is funny, and has made me think a bit differently about strategy for future games.
Drax
Germany needs tanks. Dunno how much you spent on R&D before you got bombers, but, those rolls represented tanks, man... Tanks. And more... Tanks.
CosmicConservative
Drax, have you played the anniversary edition? There are different rules, but I honestly don't remember how different. I don't think there's just one way to win with any of the countries. In this game had Germany bought nothing but tanks, I could not have wiped out the American and UK fleets, and I'd have been fighting the Normandy invasion every turn for the entire game. The strategy I chose was to remove the threat of an amphibious assault on Europe to let me then focus on building an invasion force to conquer Russia. When I think invasion force I think two things. First is offensive power to blast the other guy's pieces off the map. Second is cannon fodder to absorb their blasts. Tanks are not good cannon fodder, and they are not the best offensive power. A tank costs five, a bomber costs 12, but a heavy bomber that you can keep alive attacks twice, effectively making them cost 6 each per attack. Plus a bomber attacks on a 4 while a tank attacks on a 3, so for 5 gold you get a 50% chance to hit while for 6 gold you get a 67% chance to hit. Plus bombers can hit ships. That's a no brainer to me. I did build some tanks, at one point I had two tank divisions, one with eleven tanks and one with nine. One of those took the southern Russian city. But once I got heavy bombers, I stopped buying tanks and started buying bombers, and that was, I think, the superior strategy.
CosmicConservative
Oh, one of the differences in the new version is that you don't lose your R&D until you get a discovery. So I spent ten on R&D and it took about five moves before I finally got bombers. By then most of the other countries already had tech, some had two discoveries already.
Drax
Heh. R&D for me was always a money-sink which I only used gambled with when playing the USA. Never get anything on the R&D cheaply, sigh. But, bombers...MAN when you get those...TOTAL game changer...
CosmicConservative
Most of the tech advantages are huge. Increased factory capacity turns a lame city into a tank producing powerhouse. Long range aircraft puts all of the Atlantic ocean in reach of planes from France. Super subs make your subs surprise attack a major advantage. Paratroopers isn't that great, but it can be useful. If I could choose what to get it would be a combination of long range aircraft and heavy bombers...
Drax
Yes, that increased capacity is insane, and if you get it, the rest of the tech becomes cheap as well...(I don't remember if the actual tech rolls are cheaper, but, since the cost of maintaining an army is significantly cheaper, you can put the savings into tech...) But, if I'm playing the Axis, you ain't gonna be putting your money into tech on the first couple of turns (unless you're the US) 'cause I'm coming HARD and the Allies will need every penny just to stay afloat. (And, if I'm the allies, unless you DO come "hard" in the beginning, I'll consolidate the main industrial plants in indochina and africa and bleed you to death until the US finishes you off...)
CosmicConservative
Well, I think you are still thinking of the old traditional Axis&Allies, the new game does play a bit differently. Transports don't defend, and you can't choose to lose them first in a sea battle (so much for your cannon fodder at sea), China has been expanded so now it can take Japan six or eight turns to get through to Russia, Tech is so much cheaper that you really have to invest in it to have a chance to win, because everyone else will, countries get specific bonuses for holding specific areas on the map (which creates artificial strategic targets which can bleed you down), etc. In general the game is designed to be a war of attrition where the best economy wears down the opposition. To beat down someone who buys nothing but infantry takes a lot more money. To win by buying tanks, you have to outspend your competition significantly. In a battle between all tanks on one side and all infantry on the other, to be certain of winning you need at least a 1.333 to 1 margin in cost. For example, for 60 bucks you can buy 12 tanks. I can easily defend that with 20 infantry. But I can't defend it with 10 infantry. If I have 15 infantry, it's gonna be close. So your 60 bucks is roughly equivalent to my 45 bucks. Of course building infantry doesn't help you invade... unless you build tanks, planes or bombers and use the infantry as cannon fodder so your heavy artillery can remain effective longer. That's what I was doing Saturday, and it was just destroying the opposition. I'd come in with 12 infantry and four heavy bombers and just crush a defender with 12 tanks. A typical fight would go like this. Round 1: I kill 8 on my first attack. The tanks kill five. Round 2: I kill everything remaining, the tanks kill 2 or 3. With normal bombers it would have been more like this: Round 1: I kill 5 on my first attack, the tanks kill 5. I kill 4 on my second attack, the tanks kill 2 or 3. I kill the rest on my third attack, the tanks kill one. So even with normal bombers the odds were pretty good. But I'm leaving out artillery since I'm not sure if artillery was in the original A&A. Artillery costs 4 and not only attacks on a 2 but allows one infantry to also attack on a 2. So my normal attack was something like 10 infantry, five artillery and four heavy bombers. That will kill around 10 on the first round, and can absorb a lot of damage. If the fight goes to 2 rounds I would kill at least another 6 or 7. So if you didn't have 20 defenders, you were just dead. And those bombers could attack anywhere within three squares at any time, so I could build (as I did) two completely separate armies of infantry and artillery, and one round use my bombers to pound Karelia, and the next round use the same bombers to pound the Middle East. That's something you can't do with tanks.
Drax
I'd have to see the new game. But, anyone who is defending with just tanks deserves to be hammered without mercy. If memory serves, in the original game, tech allowed for artillery, but only then. I think that your AA guns doubled for artillery (or, perhaps, that was some sort of alternate rule...can't remember) I loved the old game, but there were a couple of strategies which, if followed, were almost universally successful (regardless of country played) if the correct, opposing, strategies weren't employed -- saving, of course, for the luck of the roll. Generally, when playing defensively, I tried to have a cushion against such bad runs of luck by optimizing my defenses, i.e., many infantry supported by as many aircraft as I could deploy, moving the aircraft around as needed. Man, I used to play that game almost every day in the navy...
CosmicConservative
Wanna play online? http://www.ewarzone.com/
Drax
Heh...Just downloaded the Warzone and am in waiting room, lol....
CosmicConservative
I guess you have to join the AAWC or something... I submitted a join request but haven't got an email back yet.
Drax
Heh...I did too. Haven't received the notification as yet.
CosmicConservative
OK, I think I see the problem. The War Zone client isn't the game, you have to download the game too. And it's huge. I'm downloading it now from here: http://www.megaupload.com/?d=67WORQKK Might take all night.
CosmicConservative
LOL, it's a .rar file. Which means I'll have to download a .rar decoder. This is how you get viruses and trojans... Oh well, gonna do it anyway, interested to see if I can actually play this on the internet
Drax
downloading it....we'll see what happens. Won't be able to do it today, regardless.
CosmicConservative
Nawp.... But I'm gonna at least try to get it running. Still got 20 minutes to go to finish my download. Then you gotta apply the patch.
CosmicConservative
Here's a blast from the past Drax... http://www.planetmule.com/
CosmicConservative
Oh well, I finally got it installed and it just crashes.