Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Favre-tastic

By CosmicConservative
OK, I've never been a Favre fan, but I think today I'm becoming one. Update: Oh well, in the end Favre was Favre and I'm more or less back to my Favre-bashing ways...

Comments (17)

CosmicConservative
Favre had the game in his hand, he could have run the ball into field goal range, but he threw it away in what I would have called "vintage Favre" fashion... Oh well...
Chasester
I can think of no better way to end his career than in typical Favre-fashion. The game was won. And he decided to gunsling it. Poetic Justice.
pace
EPIC game. That final Vikings play though... I'm shouting "Run! RUN!! What the fuuuuu....?!"
Drax
My 3 year old is learning how to say: "NO BRETT NO!!!" and then hang her head in shame. Sigh. Brett has been fantastic all year, but he just HAD to go and try to win it all by himself with that play, didn't he? ARGH! go saints... yea
CosmicConservative
Well, the Saints in the Super Bowl is a good story. I was rooting for Brett there for a while after he came back in after the ankle injury. I really, really think his whole plan was to go out like Elway...
CosmicConservative
Heh, I gave him the CosmicConservative kiss of death... I started rooting for him...
Drax
Heh. I think his "whole plan" was to play with a chance at winning another superbowl SO LONG as he could play at a high level. He has played at a very high level this year. Of course, there is NO question that he (and every other football player past, present, and future) would LIKE to "go out on top." I mean, considering the alternatives...
Drax
Like, oh...I don't know...your last play as a quarterback being an interception in the Championship Game... AGAIN!!!!
Andy
Brett did blow it, but not any more so than several other Vikings. But, he's the guy that gets the ball every time... I was impressed with Favre. He's got a lot of guts. He went in on a bum wheel against a great team, in a VERY hostile stadium. I'll tell you who I would like to be...the guy that's gonna start when he quits again. Talk about some hosses on that Viking team...Man! New Orleans was lucky. In fact, if I was a Viking fan I'd be feeling cheated this morning. The OT definitely had some questionable calls against the Vikes. But, those things usually even out over the course of a season. They're just magnified in a big game like that. Oughta be a good Super Bowl. I'm actually looking forward to one for a change.
AndYet
Drax, looking through history posts, this game shows exactly why everyone liked Favre, but said he wasn't all he's cracked up to be. Sure he's a great QB and has been for a long time. But no football team hires a QB to do good in just regular season. They all want the big game win. And Favre can never get beyond Brett Favre and let himself win. Maybe he once was able to do more with less, but now he can't do more with more. Too bad too, I used to love watching him play. Well done Saints!
Drax
Oh, I agree AndYet...for the most part. But, he was on his back more than 1/3rd of the plays he dropped back. His receiver and running back both fumbled after he had gotten them into the red zone. (Brett was charged with Peterson's fumble once, but that was AP's fault.) And Brett kept picking himself up and kept pushing them down the field. Then....what happens. He gets them to field goal distance, at the very edge of Longwell's field goal distance, with nineteen seconds left to win the game... You really can't ask for better than that. Championship game. You have put your team in a position to win with no time on the clock. It was Favre who did that, who, on the strength of his arm, his courage under fire...not AP or anyone else. Then there are 12 men on the field and he's NOT in field goal range again. He CAN'T run. He HAS to throw. And he HAS to get yards...at LEAST 5. If he doesn't, then he's out of field goal range, and AT BEST there's a coin-flip for who wins the game in over-time, and AT WORST, Brees has time for 1 or 2 plays to win the game. HE HAS TO GET THOSE YARDS. But, no one is open and he's not sure he can get the yardage on his gimp leg, so he tries to force the ball in -- just as he had done in almost the identical situation with Dallas the week before. I think it was the wrong decision. He should have tried to run the ball for what yards he could get and hope Longwell hits it. But, I sure in hell ain't gonna put the blame on Favre for "losing the game."
CosmicConservative
Drax... Whether you put the blame on Favre or not, the general consensus is clearly that Favre blew it. Troy Aikman was singing Favre's praises all game, but he was harshly critical of that decision. From my memory of the play, unless Favre fell flat on his face, he could have gotten those five yards. Still, that would have left a 51 yard field goal, and that's no gimme. So I don't blame Favre for losing the game either, if I blame anyone I blame the guys who fumbled the ball away time after time, and that wasn't Favre. Whatever else you say about Favre, he is one tough dude.
Drax
I agree that it was a bad decision. I'm not defending the decision, I'm defending the fact that it was the ONLY decision he felt he had at the time. In retrospect, even he admitted that he probably should have run it although he didn't know whether he could get the yardage back to be in FG range. He did think that he could get the yardage with his arm -- just as he had made the almost identical throw last week against the Cowboys -- a decision and a throw which was declared "brilliant" by everyone who watched the SUCCESSFUL COMPLETION of THAT throw. Sigh...inches...split seconds...a bit of lost traction allowing the defender to get in front of the receiver... But, that's the difference in these kinds of games. Favre ALMOST made up for his team giving the ball over to the Saints over and over -- twice while in the red zone, ALMOST made up for his O-Line collapsing around him, ALMOST made up for the defense not getting a GLOVE on Breese but once all game (maybe twice -- once in OT, I think)...but, he didn't. I was cussin' him too... Sigh.
AndYet
Guess we see the game differently. I don't think anyone was overly surprised in the way it ended for Favre. That's the way he has been his whole career. It was not inches, was not seconds, was not traction. It was Favre throwing the way he always has - hero or zero. When the game is on the line, there is only one thing Favre is known to trust. And it's not his teammates. Too bad his SUCCESSFUL completion in the Cowboys game amounted to a hill of beans this game. I'd give a lot more credit to the Defense who ran Bush over like he was barely there and carry it in for a TD. Yeah they could have stepped up more on Brees, but they had their moments. Curious item though Drax, Earlier you criticized Rodgers for being sacked a lot. But with Favre you fail to do the same. Why's that. Whatever happens with Favre next year if he's not in I'll miss watching him play. I just hope he mans up and makes the decision. He sure did tough it out though this game.
AndYet
to clarify, by sacks I was meaning (and forgot to write) as the season went on. from week 10 through end of season Favre had 16 sacks to Rodgers 13.
Drax
AndYet: To the extent that I criticized Rodgers for getting sacked so much, I was making the point that he held the ball too long. Maybe you WERE watching a different game than me, but Favre wasn't getting SACKED over and over as Rodgers was throughout most of the season (and Favre was during a 3-4 game stint), but he was under pressure, getting hammered more than 1/3rd of the time he dropped back. As I stated in the Vikings/Cowboys game, the game is "won in the trenches." The Saints got to Favre; the Vikings didn't get to Brees. And, I do believe you were looking at a different game than me on that interception. When Favre made the decision to release that ball, there was a window. His receiver didn't get traction (and was nearly on his knees as he attempted to get to the ball) giving the DB the chance to get in front of him. (Saints had shown nickle, but had dropped out of it -- great defensive call which Favre didn't catch while he was being chased all over creation) Don't get me wrong. I've watched Favre over the years too. The same thing which makes him great, the complete belief that he can make any throw at any time, the willingness to stand in there and get hammered and not get "happy feet" (which Too Tall told me he saw on Aikman the year before Aikman retired, predicting he was done) -- is the same thing which made me sit there with fingers crossed with 19 seconds to go yelling at the screen: "NO BRETT NO!!!" -- BEFORE he threw it... (And, I've had him in my fantasy team enough times to follow him with great interest, suffering the "feast or famine" which has typified his career -- although there has been much more "feast" than "famine.")