The fallout from Massachusetts
By CosmicConservativeOK, I'm going to delve into a little political punditry here. I don't do a lot of that, I mostly comment on my thoughts about things, but I usually don't make predictions or provide much actual analysis of things. And since as late as 6:30 pm mountain time last night I was still doubtful of a Brown victory, I think you can see why I avoid such analysis. But everyone else is doing it today, so here goes...
I would say that Health Care is dead in the Senate. Harry Reid is seriously damaged goods, he is being challenged strongly behind the scenes as the Senat Majority Leader and he has been completely unable to sway a single Republican to his side in spite of months of wheedling, pleading and attempted bribery. In fact far from gaining any Republican support, he is steadily losing the support of his own caucus. Reid is a dead man walking and everyone in Washington knows it. So unless there is a major upheaval in Washington that I'm not aware of, I don't see the Senate taking up Health Care again.
So that puts the onus completely on the House. Nancy Pelosi originally spoke out against the Senate version of the bill, but that was when she thought she could get some back-door deals done and another 60 vote win in the Senate for a "compromise" version of the bill. Now that it looks virtually impossible to take that approach, she will probably reverse course and proclaim the Senate bill to be the perfect bill and try to ram it through the House.
But the House is not the same House that narrowly passed the current House version of Health Care, and the version that was passed in the House has several critical provisions that the Senate Bill lacks, most notably the Stupak abortion amendment which gathered 11 critical votes that Nancy needed to get the bill passed in the first place. Again, much like in Harry's case, Nancy's hand is greatly weakened since then, not strengthened. Her leverage is much less, and her caucus has just seen Massachusetts, the bluest of blue states, dramatically reject health care. There can't be more than a few dozen House members who now feel their seat is totally safe if they vote for Health Care. Certainly there are dozens who now view a vote for the Senate version of the bill as certain political suicide.
Everyone is running the numbers now to see if Nancy can get to the magic number of 218 votes to pass the Senate bill. For the rest of this week and into next week Nancy will no doubt be trying to arm twist, threaten and bribe House members to put their own political future on the line to save face for Obama and Pelosi. She will be calling in every favor she can, and I have no doubt will be having conversations about potential Ethics committee investigations and leaks of damaging information to the press.
Drax said that this would now become all out war. I am afraid he is right. If the House can't pass the Senate bill by, say, mid-February, when Congress takes a Presidents Day (ironic, eh?) break for a week, I can't imagine that they can pass it when they get back.
So the next three to four weeks will probably be the final act on this particular piece of legislation. And on it's success or failure rests the political fortunes of Pelosi and Obama. If they can't get it passed, the only way to revisit health care is to do exactly what Obama promised in the first place, which is to have open, cooperative discussions leading to a workable compromise between Democrats and Republicans. Obama never once intended to do that and it's the last thing he wants. Pelosi will almost certainly receive a no-confidence vote from her own caucus if that happens since she has spent the last year making this version of Health Care her signature issue and she has made many, many enemies in the process.
This will be very interesting to watch. In my mind's eye I see Pelosi as Khan from Star Trek IV saying "From hell's heart, I stab at thee. For hate's sake, I spit my last breath at thee!"
Comments (5)