Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Would you take this test?

By CosmicConservative
The comments on this story are interesting.

Eye test that spots Alzheimer's 20 years before symptoms: Middle-aged could be screened at routine optician's visit

A test that can detect Alzheimer's up to 20 years before any symptoms show is being developed by British scientists.

The simple and inexpensive eye test could be part of routine examinations by high street opticians in as little as three years, allowing those in middle age to be screened.

via Simple eye test for Alzheimer's could catch disease at crucial early stage | Mail Online.

Would you take this test knowing that if it is accurate it could well be telling you that you have an incurable and eventually fatal degenerative brain disease?

Comments (8)

Cullen
Absolutely! Can you imagine how many arguments this automatically would absolve you from? "You told me what? Um ... sob ... I guess I forgot."
Andy
Heh! Cullen makes a good point. Cosmic, I think I would like to know, for a variety of reasons.
Old Goat
My father is suffering from Alzheimer's. If there were something that was a cure, then I would do the test, but knowing you have this disease and that things are going to get progressively worse, I would rather not know. Seeing how hard it is to watch my brilliant father slide down this dark hole, I'd rather not know that is where I am going, and what I will be doing to my children. Sometimes ignorance is bliss.
Cullen
OK, serious answer: My mom's side of the family (her mother and grandmother) suffered from adult onset dementia. As my mother ages, I begin to worry about her lucidity as well. Alzheimer's appears to run in my father-in-law's side of the family. I've seen the effects and I would like to know. While ignorance is bliss there are also some things I'd like to be prepared for. If I knew I was going to begin suffering from Alzheimer's I could start stocking away now to better provide for my family and to put myself into a care facility if necessary.
CosmicConservative
When my dad was passing away from gastro-intestinal cancer, my older brothers (Drax and a different older brother who doesn't visit here) and I were spending a lot of time with him in the hospital, then in the nursing home, and finally in the hospice. One evening as we were having drinks with a friend, we learned that this friend was dealing with a father who suffered from Alzheimer's. That discussion gave me a new perspective on dealing with a loved one's final days. My dad remained sharp, witty and perceptive up to his final conscious moments. That in itself is a blessing of sorts. I would probably take the test, but I could certainly understand why someone would not.
Old Goat
My father has insurance for long term care. I also carry that kind of insurance (though that might have to change under the Zero's administration.) If there is no cure, heck, they don't even know what causes this disease, why would you allow that to destroy the rest of your cognitive life being concerned over how your family will have to deal with you becoming a blank? Responsible people would be making their plans from early on, no? I have my will, my insurance, my savings, I even have my burial plots (for my wife and family as well) all set. I have insurance for my funeral costs as well. If there were a cure that was found, then its a different story.
mtnlurker
If your doctor knew would he/she tell the insurance company? Would they drop you or would it prevent you from getting insurance in the future? I would not mind knowing. My grand-father had Alzheimer's. It was very hard to watch him decline. He was a master sergeant in the Air Force. As Cullen said, I would want to know so I could prepare.
Andy
Yeah, I'm seriously with mtnlurker & Cullen. I've had family go that way. And, I'm also concerned that my mother is possibly in the early stages. I'd want to know, so that I could let my wife and kids know that "it's okay...put me in a home...don't pull me out if they don't get my pants changed immediately...don't guilt yourself into taking care of me...live your life, etc." Or, I might want to know so that when it becomes clear that I'm almost there...I can walk off in the woods, and leave on my own terms.