Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Fusion news

By CosmicConservative
Fusion research is about to get a big boost. My favorite line?
However, environmental groups have criticised the project, saying there was no guarantee that the billions of euros would result in a commercially viable energy source.
Environmental groups are opposed based on a return on investment analysis? Right. Sure they are. Actually environmental groups are opposed on purely ideological grounds. It's science. It must be bad. So, who is involved?
The seven-party consortium, which includes the European Union, the US, Japan, China, Russia and others, agreed last year to build Iter in Cadarache, in the southern French region of Provence.
I'm glad the US is involved, although I am less than thrilled that they are building the facility in Southern France. You gotta give the French credit for that though, they certainly need the jobs. Of course I can't comment on a science news story without snarking about the reporting itself:
Fusion taps energy from reactions like those that power the Sun.
"Those" that power the sun? As far as I know, the sun is powered entirely by a single fusion reaction, the conversion of hydrogen into helium. Now some time in the far future there will be a shift as the hydrogen runs out and the sun shrinks, heats up and begins to fuse helium into heavier elements, but for now, and for the next few billion years, it's pretty much hydrogen to helium in the sun. Continuing this snark, it isn't likely that fusion reactions on earth will be converting hydrogen to helium. It is much easier to work with deuterium or tritium than with hydrogen. But perhaps I'm being too critical now....
One kilogram of fusion fuel would produce the same amount of energy as 10,000,000kg of fossil fuel.
Oh, really? Which fossil fuel? Coal? Kerosine? Gasoline? Natural Gas? This is such an ignorant statement that it simply dumbfounds me that it gets past any decent editor. First of all there is no "standard fossil fuel" energy measure to compare to, and the amount of energy produced by fusion is unknown at this time. Besides, measuring the amount of "fuel" consumed in fusion reactions may be a completely meaningless measure. It may be far more important to measure the amount of catalylsts, reagents or other materials "consumed" by the process of generating fusion energy. Nobody has any idea at this time if it will require billions of gallons of water to generate feasible fusion energy reactors. Or if it can only be accomplished through the use of specific catalysts that have to be created in a process that consumes tons of petroleum. Who knows? Such speculation is factually meaningless until we have something up and running somewhere. I am as optimistic as anyone about fusion power, and believe that it will one day solve the world's energy problems, but I am not about to go around saying fusion will generate 10,000,000 times the energy based on the same amount of fuel. That's just meaningless gibberish at this time. Oh well, I could go on, but I'm not feeling particularly snarky anymore. Besides, I have to get back to work, lunch is over. UPDATE: Well I couldn't resist snarking on this quote:
"Investment in energy efficiency and renewables is the only reliable way to guarantee energy security," said Silvia Hermann, from Friends of the Earth Europe. "Giving billions of euros to a single nuclear project that is so far from reality is ill judged and irresponsible."
This is so insanely blockheaded and wrongheaded that I find it difficult to believe a human being with functioning gray matter could make such a statement without laughing so hard she couldn't stand up. "Energy efficiency and renewables is the only reliable way to guarantee energy security." What insanity. What stupidity. Oh yeah, we're going to conserve enough energy to launch our galaxy-wide colonization program. Sure we are. All we need is a bit better insulation in every home in the world, and Alpha Centauri is right there for the taking. Idiot.

Comments (5)

mark nelson
I'm kinda hoping the line "like those that power the Sun" just refers to the countless fusion reactions that happen in the Sun--all of them of the same type of course. Seems a minor point. It certainly isn't wrong to refer to hydrogen reactions being used, even though Deuterium and Tritium are easier to use, because (as you know) it's ALL hydrogen! After all, only hydrogen has different names for its isotopes, but it's all still the same element. For the scientifically illiterate, that's an easier concept to explain. Completely agree with the rest of your snarks.
CosmicConservative
Okay, I'll try to give the reporter a break, yes there are countless hydrogen atoms fusing to helium, and to be completely fair, there are some deuterium and tritium atoms fusing to helium too, so that snark may be been unfair. The reason I made an issue of it is because the reporter made it seem like there are all kinds of wild fusion reactions going on in the sun, when the sun is as simple a fusion engine as you can imagine. The reason I made an issue of deuterium and tritium is because if you call that the "fuel" of the fusion reaction, you are overlooking the billions of gallons of water you had to process to isolate deuterium and tritium to fuse, and in that case, what's the weight of the fuel? The miniscule amounts of deuterium and tritium, or the copious amounts of water you processed to get it?
Aaron
The only reason I don't like some of the fusion power popularizations is that it is regularly used by politicians as a distraction when we try to hold them to sane policies on nuclear energy. Whenever someone proposes giving nuclear fission a break and letting companies build actual power plants or dispose of their waste in actual disposal sites, along comes fusion power research to distract people while the functional parts of a bill are gutted and a whole lot of nothing happens, if not more red tape being thrown in the way. Furthermore, most people don't even have a clear idea of what a fusion plant would look like or require. It's thought of as "magic" power, that solves all our energy needs, no questions asked. What will power our spacecraft? Fusion power. What will power our submarines? Fusion power. What will power nanomachines (which also have a lot more magical thinking involved?) .... ..... .... fusion power! It's magic! In reality, fusion plants of the Tokomak variety are likely to be massive, extremely expensive fixed installations. At least as presently formulated (which may change with modernization). Fission, by comparison, is relatively portable and simple, and most importantly, works perfectly fine right now!
CosmicConservative
Aaron: Well said. I can't think of a thing to add.
John
Tritium is not found in seawater. It's halflife is 12 years. It's generated in situ from the lithiium. Billions of gallons is a bit of an exaggeration. 2000 L of water will give you about 1kg of Deuterium which is what a 1GW fusion plant will need/day. (Actually quite a bit more water is needed in practice because isolation of heavy water isn't 100% efficient, but the ratio is more like 300 000 to 1 not 10^9 to 1.) Heavy water is easily isolated with distillation or chemical processes. And has been done for years for use in heavy water moderated fission. When has fusion been used as a distraction to fission? Fusion has always been presented as a longterm project. Fission has been working for decades. Though I work on fusion, I'm all for fission and predict you'll see ground broke by one of the existing permit holders on fission in the US in the next three years. It's the only viable technology to meet growing demand that has little C02 production (mostly associated with fuel extraction, and construction of the plant). I agree with Aaron's last point. Fusion plants are inherently large (1GW+) fixed installations. They will never be small systems on submarines, etc. Expensive is hard to say. The cost per watt of installed power is hard to estimate at this point until after ITER, but studies put it in the $2/Watt range. Which is in the ball park of fission and coal (if you include sequestration costs). The size of the installation is on par with other GW scale facilities whether they be fission, hydro, or coal. GW solar and wind of course are much more massive. One last point, without breeding, fission faces serious fuel shortages in the next 50 to 100 years if it actually is used to meet most of the growing demand. Besides being clean, fusion faces no fuel shortages, at least short of geologic timescales.