Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

'Boys get first playoff win in 13 years.

By CosmicConservative
Or 14, or whatever it is. Wade Phillips and Tony Romo both get THAT monkey off their backs anyway. I didn't watch much of the game, I've been working on something else this evening, but I checked in from time to time. As usual I tended to see the Cowboys at their worst, including their miserable performance on 1st and ten on the Iggles 16 yard line, where they ended up not even trying a field goal after penalties and getting pushed back on successive plays. Still, overall it was a pretty thorough shellacking of the Iggles. The NY Jets looked pretty good today too. Could be an interesting playoffs season. Next week we get to see Tony Romo go up against Brett Favre... I would guess the Vikings aren't really looking forward to meeting the Cowboys right now.

Comments (70)

Andy
Cosmic, I am not quite sure what has happened with the 'boys. But I'll admit that I like it. I didn't watch much of the game, either. But man! To beat a good team (soundly) two weeks in a row. Man...they're hot.
Drax
Cowboys' defense looked great. Romo looked really good. Don't know how much of the 'Boys looking good was a result of some significant Eagles' defensive stinkage, though. Don't know. Philadelphia didn't impress me at all this year. Didn't beat a single playoff team all year. LOOKED like they couldn't beat a decent team yesterday. They looked horrible on both sides of the ball. Jets looked good. But...see above. Bengals looked HORRIBLE. Just HORRIBLE. I hope it will be a good game, the Vikings vs. the 'Boys. I'd rather that Favre wins -- it's a better story, to me. I just want to see a good game.....
CosmicConservative
Back in the heyday of the Aikman/Smith/Irvin years, the Cowboys owned Brett Favre. I think they knocked the Pack out of the playoffs three years running. Overall I think Brett Favre is something like 2 - 11 against the Cowboys. I'm not really a very good football analyst. To me it seems the way the Cowboys are playing right now it's going to be tough to beat them in the air. I think for the Vikings to win, they'll have to rely more on Adrian Peterson than Brett Favre. For the past four games the Cowboys secondary and pass rush have made some of the most explosive passing games in the league look pretty weak. I haven't been following the Vikings so I don't know how good they are on defense, but if I'm a defensive coordinator planning for the Cowboys right now I'm thinking the Cowboys have one of the most balanced attacks around right now. Tony Romo is hot, he's got several solid receivers and the Cowboys running game has been equally effective with both power and speed to deal with. Of course anything can happen, and Brett Favre is always capable of a record setting performance on any day of the week. But I suspect he'll be doing a lot of handoffs next weekend. If I had to predict I'd say it will be a hard-fought in-the-trenches game with a few big plays in the passing game. I think the most physical team wins, and right now I really don't know who that would be.
Drax
I've looked at the Cowboys' schedule and come away unimpressed. The Eagles aren't very good. Beat them twice. Beat Washington twice. Beat Carolina and Tampa Bay. Beat Kansas City and Atlanta. Beat Seattle. Beat Oakland. Lost to the Giants...twice. Lost to Denver. Lost to Green Bay. Lost to San Diego. In fact, the only "good" win I see is the one against New Orleans, and I've been wishy-washy about New Orleans all year. Could say much the same about Minnesota, though. Either team, if they play well, can win.
CosmicConservative
Sure, you could say the same thing about virtually every team in the playoffs. In fact I've seen the same analysis applied to the Vikings, the Saints, the Colts, etc... To me it's not much use to compare yearly schedules when looking at playoff chances. That makes more sense in sports where you have multi-game series where the odds and history come more into play. For football it has always seemed to me that the hottest team tends to be the one to look out for. Teams going into the playoffs on a winning streak are the teams to look out for. Football is, imho, the most emotionally momentum driven sport (except maybe Hockey). Right now I don't see a team in the league that has been playing better football in the past month than the Chargers and Cowboys. I would not be at all surprised to see that matchup in the Super Bowl. When I look at the individual matchups I see that the Dallas offense is a difficult challenge for the Vikings defense, and I see the Vikings offense having trouble with a Dallas defensive line that has been shutting down opponent's passing game with minimal reliance on the blitz. If that holds true for another game (and it's held true for four in a row so far) then the Vikings will have to hold more players in to protect Favre, meaning the coverage schemes open up for the Cowboys. That doesn't bode well for a 40 year old quarterback if he's running around and getting slammed to the turf for a good part of the game. In terms of momentum and confidence, I don't see anyone playing better right now than the Chargers and Cowboys. The Pack is right behind those two. Next week ought to be fun.
Drax
I agree that the Cowboys have looked good. But, the Vikings looked great their last game. And, this 'mo thing has only marginal significance. Colts, last two games? Make a difference? Saints? Same thing. It's hard to say what happens once teams get to the playoffs (see, e.g., Arizona last year). I like Favre and Peterson better than I do Romo and his stable of backs. I think the defenses are a push. For me, the difference might be whether Favre's O-line provides protection. If that happens, I think that Favre will rip up Dallas' secondary with play action. We'll see. I just hope for a good game!
CosmicConservative
Well, we'll see. Looking good against a Giants team that had obviously already given up on the season isn't saying that much. But you can't ignore what the Vikings have done all year and with a week of rest, Favre might be fresh and ready. We'll have to see. I do think the Dallas secondary is under-rated. But they depend on their front four getting pressure on the QB. Green Bay is getting clobbered by the Cardinals right now, and I wasn't expecting that.
Drax
You know what it looks like? A HOF quarterback leading his team against a quarterback who has never been on the big stage before. Hmmm....
CosmicConservative
Well, I think we can agree that Romo has at least been on the stage before, and has just had his first success. And Favre's post-season record isn't all that great, frankly, he's something like 12-10 in the post-season. That compares to a Tom Brady at about 14-4 or Joe Montana at 16-7 or Terry Bradshaw at 14-5 or even a Troy Aikman at 11-4. I know you're a big Favre fan, I never have been. I consider most of Favre's records to be due to his longetivy, not his consistent performance. Just the fact that he's been in the league almost 20 years and has only one Super Bowl victory says quite a bit to me. Of course most of my early introduction to Favre was when the Cowboys would beat him up pretty regularly. I have to admit I would enjoy watching Favre getting kicked out of the playoffs one last time by the Cowboys. That would be the perfect retirement for Favre. :-) (Of course, just my saying that just pretty much guaranteed the Vikings will win now... oh well.)
CosmicConservative
Heh, Brett Favre's post-season record for QBs with ten or more playoff games is closest to Donovan McNabb, whose record is 9-7 (which is slightly better in terms of winning percentage). I think that's probably a fairly reasonable comparison. And refresh my memory, which quarterback did Tony Romo just kick out of the playoffs?
Drax
I know, Favre has not had all that much success in the post season. Just one Superbowl in 16 years. Man...if only he had Rice. Or Craig. Sigh. Let's see. That's one more than: Marino, Kelly, Tarkenton, Fouts, McNabb, Brees, (sigh only 1 a year...). As many as: Manning, Manning, Warner, Young, sigh...only 1 a year. Every now and then a team dominates and wins with someone like Bradshaw. And, other times, insanely good quarterbacks don't play on good (enough) teams (Marino, Kelly, Tarkenton) I like Favre because, it's my assertion (as it has always been) that he has done more with less than any quarterback in history.
Drax
Hey! You've never heard ME sing the praises of McNabb! I'm with Rush, he's overrated by a large margin. The only time he's gone to the Superbowl is when he had T.O. and a healthy Westbrook. He hasn't had those weapons since, and his record shows that he doesn't.
CosmicConservative
Favre has done more with less than any other QB? How many Green Bay Packers from Favre's teams are in the HOF now, and will be in the HOF ten years from now? Compare that to, oh, I dunno, JOHN FRIGGIN ELWAY? In the "done more with less" category I don't know who can even lick Elway's cleats. And I'm not even much of an Elway fan. I've always considered Favre to be vastly overrated. Given a chance to pick a QB to lead my team from a standard set of "elite" QBs, Favre wouldn't even be on my list. He simply throws the ball away too many times. I don't like gunslingers. I like game managers. Joe Montana, Troy Aikman, Tom Brady, even Peyton Manning, those are guys who manage games and more importantly don't lose games. One of my biggest irritations in being a Cowboy fan the last few years is the constant comparison of Tony Romo to Brett Favre. Up until this year I've had to admit that those comparisons are reasonably accurate, Romo had a very Favre-like tendency to throw interceptions and fumble. I'm hoping he's finally outgrown that. Romo, by the way, has frequently stated that his favorite QB as a young player was Brett Favre. So next week he get's to play against his hero. I just hope he plays the way he's been playing most of this year and doesn't revert to Favre-worship and throw the game away.
CosmicConservative
It always amazes me when an onside kick catches a team napping. They've got a full-time coach dedicated to the special teams. Don't they coach to look out for that?
Drax
Um...on all of Favre's teams you have.... ONE HOF. Reggie White. That's IT. No more. Not one. Either Side. And that's at the end of his career. Let's see...Elway: Shannon Sharpe. Terrell Davis (still only 1 of 6 who have ever hit 2000 yards. Would be HOF absent injury.) Uh...huh?
Drax
And, I think TD will get into the hall eventually. He was the DOMINANT running back of his era, without anyone really a close second.
CosmicConservative
You don't think Adrian Peterson will make it? And Terrell Davis is no lock. I didn't think Shannon Sharpe had made it yet.... You could argue his brother Sterling would have had a HOF shot without injury. So, assuming Elway and Favre had reasonably similar teams, then I think Elway's 14 - 7 playoff record and two Superbowls just proves my point.
Drax
Dang, Green Bay is looking good now! But, so is Arizona.... GOOD GAME!
Drax
Wait a second! Favre ain't DONE this year! What does Peterson have to do with it? (And, no...unless he stops running downfield, Peterson will have a short career...)
Drax
Nah... Elway had a (potential) HOF running back. He never got anywhere until he had TD. He had a (I think Sharpe is still potential HOF -- a finalist last time around, will eventually make it) Favre didn't have anything CLOSE to the firepower available to him that Elway did. There's a REASON why, in the twilight of his great career, Elway was the best QB never to have won the big one. Then he got TD. End of story. Favre has Peterson. If they play together for 6 years or so, I'd expect two superbowl wins from them.
CosmicConservative
There's a reason Favre joined the Vikings and has repeatedly said this season that the Super Bowl is his only goal. He obviously feels his reputation as a big game quarterback is not where he would like it to be (much as Elway felt in 1997). He feels a second SB will prove his critics wrong. I'll even agree with that. If Favre wins the SB this year I'll grudgingly admit that I've been too critical of him. But if not, I'll continue to say that Favre is overrated.
CosmicConservative
This game between the Pack and the Cardinals is just making me more of an Aaron Rodgers fan.
CosmicConservative
Elway did not get "nowhere" without TD. He got to three Super Bowls. Granted he was as much a reason for losing those Super Bowls as he was for getting TO the Super Bowl, but Elway picked up his entire team and carried them on his back to three Super Bowls. That was well before TD arrived. I'd say that TD was the bit that got Elway two Super Bowl wins, but he played in three more. How many Super Bowls has Favre played in?
Drax
If you look at ANY (reputable) list of top 10 QB's of all time, you'll find Favre's name on it. It's really hard to be overrated when you're one of the top ten QB's of all time. And, he has BEEN on those lists for around a DECADE. It ain't just longevity. I have a hard time rating QB's (or any other position) against others in a TEAM sport. So many other factors play into how well your team performs. You can play a PERFECT game and lose. But, I have no problem listing them in TIERS, and in any ranking system I can conceive, Favre would be in the top tier of all time. TIE GAME! WOTTA GAME!
Drax
I'm not taking anything away from Elway. He's certainly in my top 10 of all time! But, it's a TEAM game. A QB can do a lot, but he can't do it by himself. I just assert that Favre did more than anyone else with less. He won a superbowl without any offensive weapons who will even be REMEMBERED in a decade, let alone in a discussion for HOF credentials. Elway did a LOT on the strength of his will, but, he had to have a hoss of a RB (with HOF credentials) to make it over the top. I wouldn't put Favre over Elway or vice versa. I was a HUGE fan of both.
CosmicConservative
Yeah, Favre is on the list of top ten QBs from all the same experts who have spent the last four years calling Jay Cutler an "elite" QB. Spare me.
CosmicConservative
We constantly debate the value of a quarterback on a team. There are rare exceptions, but in 90% of the cases, a team without a quality QB is not a quality team. Favre is a quality QB. He's had some amazing games and amazing years. I'd rather have him than, say, Danny White or Brian Griese, but he's not my idea of the KIND of QB I would want on my team in general. Cardinals came right back with another touchdown. So, who was it saying that Green Bay had the best defense in the league?
Drax
LOL. You really think that Favre wouldn't even crack the top 10? How about 20. Could you name TWENTY quarterbacks in the HISTORY of the game are superior to Favre? I got Manning, Elway, Favre, Montana, Unitas, Marino, Aikman, Young, Staubach, Tarkenton, in the top tier. (I just can't bring myself to put Brady there) I mean, come on. Overrated? I guess it's possible to be one of a handful of the best of all time (by any measure) and be overrated. By a hater, man. By a hater.
Drax
It's Warner, man. He's HOF. Rodgers is making a case for himself, too. Man, he's looking SHARP. And his team is responding to him. I believe that the QB is the most important position. I can't conceive of an argument that would make me believe otherwise. You can win with mediocre quarterbacks (Bradshaw). But, you've got to be dominant otherwise. But, a HOF quarterback can win all by himself. He just can't do it consistently, because he has to do too much, too often. I have always asserted that Favre's "gunslinger" reputation is an outgrowth of necessity. He has HAD to attempt to force things, and, being a leader, he is able to convince his team to respond and many throws which, for most QB's would be interceptions or incompletions, end up being great catches. He hasn't had to do that this year. What has he done? Oh, yeah...set ANOTHER record for most touchdowns with fewest interceptions. You can DO that when you have a running game.
CosmicConservative
OK, I only need to name 10 that are better than Favre. But I'll shoot for 20. (And I'm talking playoffs, not careers). Montana, Elway, Aikman, Starr, Brady, Roethlesberger, Manning, P., Staubach, Unitas, Bradshaw, let's see, that's ten, and I'm not even slowing down yet... Warner, Plunkett, Stabler, Young, Simms, McNabb... The above list, by the way, is all the QBs in NFL history who have a better playoff winning percentage than Brett Favre in at least ten playff games. Others with at least 10 Playoff games who have very close to Favre's results are: Bob Griese, Craig Morton, Danny White, Steve McNair, Mark Brunell.... I could go on... I just don't see Favre as a big game QB. I just don't. Pack just tied it again. What a game.
CosmicConservative
I don't even know who to root for in this game. I'm a big Warner fan too. 90 points so far, and tied.
Drax
Warner's bid for HOF. (You gotta be kidding. MORTON and WHITE and BRUNNELL and MCNABB and PLUNKETT and SIMMS better than FAVRE? That's laughoutloudable!
CosmicConservative
Warner's gotta be setting some sort of passing record in this game.
Drax
Heck, he OWNS the postseason records. CRUD, he missed it!
CosmicConservative
Wow... it's hard to believe that whoever wins the coin toss won't win.
CosmicConservative
Green Bay has scored five touchdowns in their last five possessions.
CosmicConservative
Heh, no matter who wins this game, it ain't the Cowboys who can claim to have the hot QB in the NFC anymore....
Drax
That'll learn 'em. You can never, never, never count Warner out.
CosmicConservative
One of the best NFL playoff games ever. For sure.
CosmicConservative
Holding it too long has been the knock on Rodgers for two years. Personally I've got nothing but admiration for the guy. To bring his team back from that disastrous first quarter was epic.
CosmicConservative
Back to Bradshaw... In the postseason, Bradshaw elevated his game to a completely different level than he played in the regular season. I don't remember all the stats but it's something like this: Bradshaw had seven games of 300+ yards in his career. Four of them were in the postseason. Two of them were in Super Bowls. Bradshaw's career completion percentage in the regular season was a pedestrian 51.8% I can't find his postseason stats, but I'd bet his completion % in postseason was closer to 65%. I believe he still holds some Super Bowl records. He threw for four touchdowns against Dallas in the Super Bowl. I remember that well.... So in a sense, yes, I do think Terry Bradshaw is one of the best all-time big game quarterbacks ever. Certainly better than Brett Favre, by a laughable margin.
pace
Just as a point of note, Favre edges out Elway in career passer rating and kills him in most every other statistic available, including TD/INT ratio. There are numerous records where Favre sits in first or second place, where Elway doesn't even rank. Favre does have the all-time career interception record, however. But Elway has the all-time career sack record. I don't believe Favre to be overrated by any objective measure. Stats available at NFL.com
Kevin in WI
I am exhausted! This game with the Cards just about killed me! Tough way to end the season for Packer fans. It would've felt better if the game ended in regulation with the Cards making the fieldgoal.
CosmicConservative
Pace, I'm not arguing Brett Favre's regular season performance and stats. I'm arguing that he has not performed as well in the post season as Elway and other QBs current and past. I'm not going to look up stats because I've read them many times in the past. Other than the two years when Favre took the Packers to the Super Bowl, his playoff performance has been somewhat lackluster to say the least. And in his second Super Bowl he lost to John Elway who won the MVP for that game. Even so, a great majority of Favre's NFL regular season records are more a result of his longetivy than his stellar play. In terms of major stats that really tell the tale at QB, Favre is not so stellar. Also, even though I use Elway as an example of a playoff QB that is better than Favre, Elway is in the lower part of my top ten. I'd put Montana, Bradshaw, Aikman, Brady and even Peyton Manning ahead of Elway in terms of QBs I'd want behind center in my biggest game of a lifetime. And Elway is still head and shoulders above Favre as a big game QB.
Drax
Again, I laugh in your general direction. All I know is that, when I think about the two superbowl wins, it's TD who won them, not Elway. He did his part, but TD won them. In 1997, TD set the record for most points scored during a post season. In the superbowl, he became the first person to have 3 rushing TD's. In 1998, he broke 2000 yards. A quote: "In his 8 postseason games from 1996 to 1998, his numbers were staggering: 204 carries for 1,140 yards and 12 touchdowns, along with 19 receptions for 131 yards. This included a streak of 7 consecutive games with over 100 rushing yards, all of which the Broncos won, breaking the previous record for consecutive 100 rushing yard postseason games held by John Riggins (6). Even in the sole playoff game in which Davis didn't gain 100 rushing yards, he still had an impressive performance, rushing for 91 yards and a touchdown and catching 7 passes for 27 yards." Yeah, Elway had some help those years... How's that stack up to...oh...ANYONE that Favre had? You put Elway over Favre based on his post season play, yet, he was second fiddle for almost HALF of those wins. FAVRE never played second fiddle to ANYONE on his team; there wasn't anyone to play second fiddle TO. Sigh. We'll never agree. I guess you will "change your mind" on Favre after his HOF career, his staggering numbers, his unbroken string of starts, IF he can "win the big one." Good thing Elway got TD else he'd be sitting down in the Quarterback Cheap Seats of your mind!
CosmicConservative
LOL, yeah, it's possible that without TD I wouldn't have as high an opinion of Elway as I do. But I might point out that it was John Elway who won the Super Bowl MVP in 1999, not Terrell Davis. He also threw for over 300 yards in that game. Look if # of rings on fingers doesn't matter for QBs then I've got Dan Marino and Fran Tarkenton on my above lists above Favre too. So you decide, do rings count or not?
Drax
In a general sense, I don't think that, when you're judging individual performance in a team sport, you don't look at a team result in judging that individual performance. It's really that simple. Marino has control over what he does. Barkley has control over what he does. Ted Williams has control over what he does. Elway played 16 years. Favre 19 (18 as a starter). Elway had a 57% completion record, Favre a 62%. Elway's TD/INT was 1.32. Favre's was 1.57. Elway averaged 18 TD's a season. Favre averaged 27. Elway averaged 14 interceptions a season. Favre averaged 17. Elway averaged per attempt. Elway averaged 3.1% interception per attempt. Favre averaged 3.2%. Elway averaged 4.1 TD's per attempt. Favre averaged 5.1%. Elway averaged 3217 yards per season. Favre averaged 3851. Favre was 11 time Pro-Bowl. Elway 9. Favre was 6 time All-Pro selection. Elway 5. Favre was 3 time MVP. Elway 1. In EVERY significant category (with the exception of interceptions, but when the enormous advantage Favre has in TD's, it results in an AVERAGE of 9 more TD's and 3 more interceptions per year.) Favre is SIGNIFICANTLY "better" than Elway. But, then I'm discussing FAVRE'S accomplishments as opposed to the PACKERS' while you seem to be concentrating on the BRONCOS' achievements and giving Elway credit for those.
Drax
Oh, as to Marino... Favre had a better completion percentage (62 to 59), had only a slightly worse TD/INT percentage (1.57 to 1.66), threw for more yards per season (and only 10 less per game, 253 to 243) Favre had a slightly better TD/Attempt (5.1% to 5.0). Marino had a slightly better INT/Attempt (3.0% to 3.2) They were even (Favre with slightest advantage) on TD's per game (1.74 vs. 1.73) When you add in Favre's 1800 yards rushing (and 14 TD's) as opposed to Marino's EIGHTY-SEVEN (and 9 TD's), things get a little more weighted in Favre's favor... Marino was GREAT and did as much with as little as anyone in NFL history. But, he never really had any help on either side of the ball, so he never won the "big one." But, from the individual stat thing, he was one of the top 10 in history in my mind, for sure.
Drax
Oh, I loved Fran as well. But, look at the HOF's on his teams: (Vikings: Alan Page, Carl Eller, and Ron Yary -- none on the Giants). (He played 18 seasons -- BAD BAD "longevity" player!) Favre beats him on completion percentage (62 to 57), Favre destroys him in interception % per attempt (3.2 to 4.1). Tarkenton edges Favre touchdown % per attempt (5.3 to 5.1). Favre destroys him in yards per game. (243 to 191.) Favre destroys him in QB rating (86.6 to 80.4). They're about equal in TD/Interception ratio: (1.57) Favre throws 1.7 TD's per game, Tarkenton 1.4. It's not even close, is it?
CosmicConservative
It's debatable. You have to put things in historic perspective if you're going to compare stats directly. Which is one reason I turn to success in winning championships as such a big factor. When Fran Tarkenton played, QBs did not have the advantages they have today. Just one example is the bump and run cover rules that were changed in 1980 or so. An 80 QB rating in 1960 is probably comparable to a 100 QB rating today in terms of actual performance. I know that QB ratings of 81 or so typically led the league pre-1980. I think Terry Bradshaw led the league one year with a QB rating of 86 or something. These days QBs consistently rate in the 100s to lead the league. The same thing applies to pass completion and % complete, etc. It was a different passing game back then. But comparing Favre to Elway, I have no problem saying that Favre was better in the regular season. I'm saying Elway was better in the post season.
Drax
Sheesh. Brett forgot how to play once he got into the playoffs. (Let's forget that he didn't need a HOF Running back and HOF tight-end/receiver to win a superbowl...) Playoff completion percentage: Favre 60.8. Elway 54.5. -- Domination FAVRE Playoff TD/INT ratio: Favre: 39/28 (1.39), Elway 27/21 (1.28) -- Advantage FAVRE Yards per game: Favre 241. Elway 236. Advantage FAVRE TD/Attempt: Favre 5.4% Elway 4.1% Domination FAVRE. Interception/attempt: Favre 3.8% Elway 3.2%. Advantage Elway. (But, when you throw TWELVE more TD's in ONE more game, I'll forgive a few more interceptions.) HOW you get that Elway dominates Favre in ANY aspect of the game OTHER THAN WINS in the post season eludes me. Elway was 7-7 until TD came along when he had a 7-0 run to end his career. (See my quotation about the DOMINANCE of TD in those games -- a performance in post season the likes never seen before or since.) Sigh.
CosmicConservative
I agree that Elway pre-1997 in post season is very comparable to Favre. No argument at all. But what was the general opinion of Elway at that time? "He can't win the big game." At least Favre managed to win one Super Bowl and has mostly managed to avoid that tag overall. But what if the Patriots had won Super Bowl XXXI? After losing two Super Bowls in a row, I think Brett Favre would have become the new John Elway "can't win the big game" poster boy. Especially after losing to John in Super Bowl XXXII. In fact that one game has a lot to do with Favre's "legend" (that and appearing in the blockbuster hit "Something About Mary" as Mary's old boyfriend). Just winning that one game allows Favre to have a winning post-season record (He'd be 11-11 had he lost that one) and to be a Super Bowl winning QB. And what was more important to Green Bay's run to Super Bowl XXXI? Favre's arm or the #1 rated defense that year? I'd argue that the defense had as much to do with that run as Favre, at least. I'm not dissing Favre, I think he's an elite QB and has been for most of his career, but there have been a lot more than ten elite QBs in NFL history, and Favre simply doesn't break my top ten for playoff performance. Maybe Elway shouldn't either, he's not high on my top ten list either. I didn't care much for Elway before 1996 or so anyway. It wasn't until Elway matured and learned the game wasn't all about him that he reached his fullest potential. I think I can say much the same about Favre. Except that he hasn't yet learned the lesson Elway finally learned. And at his age, I doubt Favre will ever learn that the game isn't all about Bret Favre.
Drax
Sheesh. Provide the INDIVIDUAL stats in which Favre is the equal or the better of all but a handful of QB's in the history of the game, and nada...you still think that Favre doesn't make your top 10 or 20 or whatever. You admit that you didn't think much of Elway until he WON the Superbowl, placing the TEAM performance (over which the QB has only limited control and, even there, only over 1/3rd of the game) then put Elway above Favre in post season play. Sheesh. No way to win. I say it's a team game and you try to say that it's the individual. I provide individual stats and you point to the team (Green Bay's defense). By any measure, Favre is in the top 10 of all time. By MOST measures, he's in the top ONE.
Drax
Oh, as to pre-97 Elway being comparable to Favre, I agree. But, when you compare them, Elway comes off a distant second.
CosmicConservative
LOL, you really think if there was a poll of football players, sports writers and fans that Bret Favre would end up #1 overall? Yeah, he'd probably be on the top 10 list, thanks to his appearance opposite Cameron Diaz on the big screen... Still, he remains 12-10 overall in the playoffs, and his one Super Bowl victory is almost certainly primarily a result of Steve Young's cracked ribs from the Philadelphia Eagles the week before the Pack played the Niners in the playoffs that year. Heck had Steve Young been healthy, Favre would be looking at 1 losing super bowl appearance and an overall playoff record of 9-11... And Steve Young would have no doubt gone on to win a second Super Bowl and a revised playoff record of 11-6, making him even higher than Favre on the list...
CosmicConservative
Would I list Bret Favre as a top 10 QB based on regular season stats? Yeah, I think I'd have to. I'd say that even longevity plays into that argument. Taken all together, his individual regular season stats factored in with his remarkable durability and longetivy, yeah, he's definitely top ten all time in that analysis.
Andy
Cosmic, I believe that just as Packers v. Cardinals set a record yesterday...you are closing in on a CosmicConservative comment record for # of comments. I can't remember which post brought something near this. But, if my rememberer is working, there was something like 90+ on another thread. You guys stay at it, and the old record shall certainly fall! Oh yeah, did you know that The Cowboys beat Philadelphia? In a playoff game? ;)
Drax
Gee. Who woulda thunk that a career rating might have something to do with the length of a career? And, yes. I think that, if you asked football players who was the best of all time, you would get a significant number to say Favre. (I saw two today, including one on the Cowboys say that very thing.) I KNOW that if you asked sports reporters the same question, they would put him in the top ten. Some examples: http://armchairgm.wikia.com/Article:Top_50_Quarterbacks_of_All-Time http://www.coldhardfootballfacts.com/Articles/11_2103_The_definitive_list:_Top_10_NFL_quarterbacks.html http://www.the-top-tens.com/lists/best-football-quarterbacks-of-all-time.asp Etc. Etc. Etc. There are FEW "top 10" lists in which Favre isn't in the top 10. There are FEW "top 10" lists in which Elway IS. It all depends on your perspective. If you're of the mind that one person on the offense is answerable for the TEAM'S performance, then you might put someone like Bradshaw at the top of the list even though, by any rational measure, he was mediocre at best. I like to base a quarterback's performance on...his performance. Silly me. I get a kick out of your question about who is more responsible for the Packers' superbowl win -- Favre or the Defense. It's as if you haven't paid attention to a SINGLE WORD of what I've been saying for YEARS. It's a TEAM GAME. It wasn't until Favre got Reggie White and that great defense that he won the big one. THAT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH HOW WELL FAVRE PLAYS. It has EVERYTHING to do with how the TEAM plays. If you can't admit that the QB is but one of many and only one-third of the team equation, AND follow that conclusion with the realization that you CAN'T base a quarterback's performance based on the TEAM'S performance, I really can't help that. Marino was a great quarterback, perhaps the best of all time. I CERTAINLY would put him above Montana (or at least in the same stratosphere of all-time greats). Who did Marino have? Who did Montana have? (On both sides of the ball...) I'd clearly take Fran Tarkenton over Terry Bradshaw. Fran only had THREE hall of famers on his team. Bradshaw had Mel Blount (defense), Joe Greene (defense), Jack Ham (defense), Franco Harris (offense), Jack Lambert (defense), John Stallworth (offense), Lynn Swann (offense), and Mike Webster (offense). Bradshaw's running back, BOTH his receivers and his CENTER were hall of famers. He had FOUR members of the defense go to the hall of fame. Gee. I bet they won lots of games. Who woulda thunk?
CosmicConservative
Heh, thanks Andy. That was the original subject wasn't it? Drax is probably right here. He's more knowledgeable about sports and football than I am. But whether I'm right or not, if I were a football coach or GM, I'd have to trade Brett to some other team just to keep myself from having a heart attack and dying. I love to WATCH QBs like Brett, but I could never handle having my career and livelihood depend on him... It'd just kill me.
Drax
Heh. I'm not sure about the "more knowlegeable" by any stretch. You keep up. I understand what you're saying about "heart attack" though. Until last year, I had Favre on just about every fantasy football team I had....
CosmicConservative
So, not to rekindle this argument (but since I had to free up one of your comments from the spam filter for all the links you put in it) let me address some of the incredulous comments you've made. It's an interesting question whether players make the HOF or teams make the HOF. Is the reason the 70s Steelers have so many Hall of Fame players is because they won so many Super Bowls, or is the reason they won so many Super Bowls because they have so many Hall of Fame players? You bring up the Broncos lack of HOF talent in your debate of Elway vs. Favre. In fact one of the burning resentments that Denver fans have is the lack of Hall of Fame players from the heyday of the Orange Crush defense and even during the late 90s run. Many people think Rod Smith, Floyd Little, Karl Mecklenberg, Steve Atwater, Randy Gradishar... Had the Broncos won two of the four Super Bowls they lost, would there be four to six Broncos from that team in the HOF? I think there probably would be. So just two games makes the difference between 1 and 5 HOF members? Yeah, that's how it works I think. Was Emmitt Smith a HOF running back on another team? Was Troy Aikman? It's a sorta circular argument, you know.
Drax
This is really what I've been saying all along. It's a team game. You can be a GREAT player on a poor team and have nothing to show for it in the way of TEAM accomplishments. And, if you're not good ENOUGH to rise above the mediocrity of your team, you'll have little in the way of personal accomplishments to show for it. But, if you're good enough, great enough, you'll be remembered for your individual accomplishments, leaving fans to debate endlessly "What if Dan Marino had Jerry Rice to throw to? What if Barry Sanders had ... well ANYONE to help him?" Dan Marino, Dan Fouts, Sammy Baugh, Sonny Jurgenson, Jim Kelly, Otto Graham, Fran Tarkenton, Warren Moon, Y.A. Tittle -- Barry Sanders, Eric Dickerson, Gale Sayers, Earl Campbell, O.J. Simpson Steve Largent, Chris Carter, Sterling Sharpe, Deacon Jones, Merlin Olsen, Dick Butkus, Derrick Thomas, Sam Mills, Lem Barney, Dan Dierdorf, Zach Thomas, Willie Roaf And most of those didn't even GET to the superbowl. And, when you start stacking good players one upon another, it begins to feed upon itself -- especially if you add to that a great coaching staff. Do I believe that the Terrible Trio of Aikman, Smith, and Irvin would all be HOFers if they had not played together on that team with that coach? I'd say yes as to Smith and Aikman. Both showed nothing but greatness throughout their lives. Irvin, however, wasn't anything special. This reminds me of last night's game. Did you SEE the great CATCHES which were being made? OMG! But, those catches were only great because the THROWS were great. And the THROWS only occurred because the plays were CALLED. And the throws could only be made because the O-line HELD long enough. Etc. Etc. Etc. Montana made Rice better. Rice made Montana better. Walsh made them both better.
CosmicConservative
See, you say it's a team game and then you say that two or three players make up a team. I think the truth is somewhere in between. I think it's about certain synergies and in some cases (I'd put Joe Montana as the poster boy here) it's simply about WILLING your team to win, and your team simply deciding it's easier to go along with Joe than it is to deal with the consequences of not going along with Joe. Some players make entire teams better, and some of those do that best when the stakes are highest. That's what I've been saying. I don't just want a great player, I want a great player who raises the level of the entire team in those circumstances. I think some do and some don't. I simply put Brett in a different category in terms of raising the level of the entire team than I do a Joe Montana or a Roger Staubach. You can talk to players from those teams and they will simply gush about the attitude of Joe Montana in the huddle of a big game. Years later they will talk about "Joe Cool". Not every player gets that sort of reputation because not every player walks into the huddle and the whole team goes "Thank GOD we've got JOE!" Elway also had this effect. I think they raised the level of the entire team. And it showed in their playoff success.
Drax
You really do see what you want to see sometimes, don't you. I, at no point, even implied that "two or three players" make a team. I'm not even sure that, if you picked through my posts and took words individually, you could make the sentence, let alone the implication. Team game. Team game. Team game. I think I've said that for years. Several times in this thread. Certainly, I've stated (or implied) that a single individual can make the team better and multiple great individuals make it better still. Checking.... Yep. There is no question that I said that. If you don't think that Favre had this effect in Green Bay, you're out of your ever lovin' mind. He was THE MAN. Who has the most come-back wins all time? Oh, yeah. Favre. And, it's this, along with his skill, that gives me the impetus to say that he has done more with less than anyone. He gets the most out of his people. But, he's not alone in this. ALL the great quarterbacks have this intangible. ALL the great team leaders have it. Jordan learned it. Favre has it. Elway had it. Marino had it. Montana had it. Let me check...yeah...I think I said something along the lines of "Montana made Rice better. Rice made Montana better. Walsh made both better." I think I've got a handle on the ability of leaders, especially leaders of exceptional ability, to raise the level of play of others. But, that only gets you so far. Especially against other teams who ALSO have leaders who can do the SAME THING to their guys. (We saw some of this last night as Warner got the best out of his team as did Rogers. We saw two teams (offensively) executing at the barest edge of their abilities.) What you refuse to admit is that, for the vast part, THAT AIN'T ENOUGH. You need MORE than just a great quarterback. It doesn't matter HOW good you are, unless you can run the ball, you have a problem. And, it doesn't matter how good your quarterback is if your defense can't stop a damn thing. And, it doesn't matter how GOOD your players are if you have terrible play calling. (We've seen enough teams attempting to buy a championship by assembling great players and having scant success to establish this, I hope.) And "will" doesn't win games. Execution does. The QB's attitude, words, or the way he carries himself mean little to the other PROFESSIONALS in the huddle. They believe someone can do it because -- he can do it. They believe even more strongly that the QB can win when he HAS won. You don't "will" that. You PERFORM. And, it don't matter none how you "will" things, if your O-Line doesn't block, your receivers drop your passes, your kicker misses his kicks, your special teams give up TD's, your defense can't stop the other guy who is "willing" himself to win, or your offensive co-ordinator is calling for going for it on 4th and 2 on your own 28.