Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Greatest invention/discovery in history?

By CosmicConservative
I had a good conversation on the way home today with the Cosmic son about the most important invention in history. So of course I spent the next 30 minutes or so describing what I thought the most important invention in human history was. The thing is that most of the reasons I picked the one I picked probably don't occur to most people as using that particular invention, but those uses of that invention are critical to virtually everything human beings do. So what is your pick for the greatest invention and/or discovery in history? And perhaps more importantly, why?

Comments (37)

CosmicConservative
Tom, that's a good one, but I am not sure language actually qualifies. If it did, I would put it at the top. So I'll just say "except language."
Drax
How to create fire. Warmth and cooked food. Cooked meat is a big deal.
Tom DeGisi
Well, we do have human beings who are speechless, but given that humans who are not taught speech sometimes reinvent it, I guess it might be somewhat wired in, and therefore not discovered. Yours, Tom
CosmicConservative
Drax: Cooked meat is indeed a good thing. But does fire cross oceans?
Drax
The knowledge to create it does... (And, there's a new school of thought that it was cooked tubers, rather than meat, that accelerated human evolution around 2 million years ago... Google -- love it/hate it...)
CosmicConservative
New schools of thought come and go. Humans cooked meat first. I guarantee it. Why? because they SMELLED cooked meat after a forest fire and couldn't stop drooling. If they cooked tubers, it was probably by accident at first, and then they figured it tasted good so they kept doing it. This is absolute truth, I will brook no discussion on it. Fire is a good choice. It's not MY choice though.
CosmicConservative
By the way, I'm pretty sure I can figure out the logic of this "new school of thought." It probably goes like this.
Humans cooking meat to gain an evolutionary advantage isn't PC enough, we need something else. Hmm... It has to involve plants, but most of the plants we eat today are domesticated and we really don't know that much about the domestication process. Plus it's not easy to cook individual grains of wheat or rice in a fire... Let's see, what sort of plant do humans eat, that grows naturally, and has no real animal competition because it's virtually inedible uncooked? TUBERS! That's the ticket! Tubers have very few natural grazers because of their inedibility and/or their inaccessibility. They cook fine in hot coals. They provide lots of carbs... IT'S THE PERFECT FOOD! YAY, we got rid of the meat thing. Next problem?
Drax
Maybe...writing? Hard to beat writing. It's not "language," so it's not forbidden. Time would be a good one as well. You might invent something, but, without time, you wouldn't know when... Numbers? Couldn't have time without numbers. No math. But, even numbers didn't really get going until someone invented nothing (i.e., the zero...) Computer is hard to beat. Don't know if it can be beat. It might beat us, but... The scientific method? Without it, we would be left to our superstitions regarding weather trends and might think that it's actually cold out there... HAH! Electricity! Screw fire! Who needs fire when you have central heating and an electric range! If it's not one of those, it's gotta be that sheet with sleeves that's advertised on late-night t.v....now in plaid...
CosmicConservative
All of those are good options. Particularly writing and math. The scientific method is also excellent. But my choice is more where the rubber meets the road.
Tom DeGisi
It's rather hard to beat agriculture and domesticated animals. I didn't think this was a guessing game, though, but if it is you are surely talking about the wheel. There is a reason geeks say, "Don't reinvent the wheel." But food will always trump travel with me. Yours, Tom
Andy
The wheel would have to be way up there. But, with the nation in the grips of a coming ice age, I've gotta go with fire. I mean, I think that if a guy had to choose, he'd burn his wheels if he had to, to survive.
CosmicConservative
Well, it's not about "survival" its about what invention has had the most impact on humanity. I think its the wheel hands down. Here's why. The wheel is not just something that you put on an axle and roll down a highway. The wheel, as a concept, is the most common, powerful and adaptable machine ever invented. Gears are wheels. Electrical generators are wheels. Jet engines are wheels. Motors are wheels. Power saws are wheels. We wouldn't have electricity without wheels. Every form of locomotion we use relies on wheels. Grinding flour from grain requires wheels. Your car engine is nothing but a wheel-turner. In fact virtually every motor ever made is nothing but a tool to turn energy into a spinning wheel. Once you have that spinning wheel, you can do ANYTHING with it. The reason our electricity is AC and is measured in Hertz is because it is generated from a wire-wrapped wheel turning in a magnetic field. And what turns that wire-wrapped wheel? A motor that is designed from the ground up to... turn a wheel. Not only are virtually all motors designed to turn wheels, virtually every means we have of converting that motor's power into a usable form involve more wheels. Axles are just long skinny wheels. Gears are just wheeled levers. Once humans learned to convert energy into wheeled motion, that's when our civilization truly became free to get beyond the stage of simply staying warm and finding enough to eat. The application of wheeled motion to grind grain into flour is one of the most fundamental requirements of a civilization. Many towns were formed by the building of a mill which did that grinding of grain into flour. A mill is essentially a wheel connected to an energy source (such as a river, waterfall or engine) which uses more wheels to direct the energy to a big stone wheel which does the actual grinding. A lumber mill is almost exactly the same except the wheels turn to spin a saw blade. It's no coincidence that when someone is thinking hard, we tend to say, "quiet, the wheels are turning."
Tom DeGisi
Well, reputedly the Incans were able to build a whole civilization using the wheel only for toys, but I'm willing to except that as the exception that proves the rule. Great explanation, Cos. Yours, Tom
CosmicConservative
Tom: I thought about mentioning the Incas myself. And they did use the wheel in other areas than toys. There are Incan tools, like stone drills, that use the concept of rotary motion involving wheels. But they didn't use the wheel for transportation. This is usually attributed to the lack of domesticated hauling animals like the horse, ox or mule. Llamas were the only animals used in that general area to haul things, and they were used primarily to haul pack goods along very treacherous roads that wouldn't accommodate wheels anyway. It is interesting to me that the wheel took as long as it did to get invented in the first place. I believe it was invented in or around what is now Iraq somewhere around 5,000 years ago. From there it exploded across three continents, but did not make its way across the ocean for several thousand years. It was re-invented in what is now Mexico a few thousand years ago, but was never applied to transportation for the previously mentioned reasons. I can't find any evidence that the wheel was ever invented in Australia.
CosmicConservative
In fact, one of the uses of drills in Incan civilization was to perform trepanations, the removal of a chunk of a person's skull. This was thought to be done to allow evil spirits to escape from the brain. In some cases it is thought trepanation was done as a religious or cult ritual. Even today people have trepanations done because they believe it frees the brain to access the "spirit world." Man it's a weird world we live in...
CosmicConservative
Comparing the wheel to other inventions it is fair to say that wherever you find the wheel in wide use, you find civilizations that are in the process of industrializing. Wherever you don't find the wheel, or the wheel is only used in very limited, specific ways, you find civilizations that are essentially stagnant from a technology perspective. That isn't true of other inventions or discoveries such as fire, language, math, writing, etc. In my mind the wheel is the very foundation of technology.
jeffsullins
Here they are: 1) The plow. Revolutionized and allowed agriculture, we'd still be hunter gatherers without this. 2) The longbow. Ending the reign of heavily armored elite class, this did more that just win England some battles against in the French. It set in motion social changes that led to the downfall of feudalism and the rise of middle class. 3) The toothbrush. No longer do aging people have to live out their later years in agony because of rotted teeth.
CosmicConservative
One more comment on the Incas. I may be unique in believing this, but I believe the Incas were on the verge of industrialization when they were wiped out by the Spanish. Incan weaponry, for example, was mass produced and included a wide range of weapon types, from the atlatl to the bow (an atlatl can actually hurl a projectile with more force than a bow) and including stone and some metal daggers and large slicing weapons made by drilling holes along the boundary of a large wooden "sword" and then gluing razor-sharp flint shards all along the outside. This technique allowed them to essentially make stone swords, something you can't do with just a flint-knapping approach. A flint "sword" would be too fragile to be useful, but the wooden swords with stone shards were robust enough to withstand battle, and the broken shards could be easily replaced. Incan weapons using this technique included long spears with flat blades (essentially halberds), war axes, war hammers with blades on one end and many more. When the Spanish arrived in South America, the Inca were busily building an empire comparable to the Roman Empire or the Greek Empire. Had the "New World" been left alone, I firmly believe the Incans would have conquered most of South and Central America. Incans also had discovered the smelting of metals and worked gold, silver, copper and tin. There is some evidence that they had just begun mixing tin and copper, which is how you make bronze. I put the Incan civilization more or less at the very beginning of the bronze age when compared to Western history.
CosmicConservative
Hmm... apparently what I had previously posted about the width of railroad rails was an urban myth. Never mind... I've deleted it. I hate getting caught by an urban myth...
Dadman
The wheel is nice, but my vote is for the flushing toilet... :)
Tom DeGisi
Well the wheel is probably necessary for the widespread use of the flushing toilet. Clean water and sewage removal have saved a rather large number of lives.... I just read a book called Flushed, Dadman. Well written, entertaining and educational. Recommended. Yours, Tom
CosmicConservative
Flushing toilets depend on capturing, storing, filtering, processing, transporting and pumping water. There are lots and lots of wheels involved in those actions. And I'm sure you know that Dadman. :)
CosmicConservative
Hmmm, Jeff, you usually comment as "jsullens" "jsullins" so I had to approve your comment so it didn't get posted while I was working. Plow? Well, modern plows are actually wheels. ;) Longbow? It had its moment in the sun, but you probably personally engage and benefit from a couple hundred wheels every day, and I bet you don't benefit from a single longbow. The toothbrush? I actually like this one. Tooth decay is one of my personal pet peeves in this universe (it is not generally known that tooth decay is almost entirely a human phenomenon. Most animals do not suffer from tooth decay. The bacteria that cause decay are almost exclusively found in human mouths.) Still, you can live without teeth, and tooth extraction was a completely successful means of fighting death by tooth decay. Wheel still rules.
Dadman
Hmmmm...your definition of a 'wheel' is very broad, albeit technically accurate I suppose. I think you could argue the invention of the microprocessor might prove to be (if it already hasn't) the most signicant invention of all time. Since I work for the company that invented it you can thank me later. :)
CosmicConservative
Heh... now I just have to come up with some rationalization that the microprocessor is actually based on wheels... In all seriousness, it's hard to envision the infrastructure necessary to have come up with the microprocessor without the wheel first. Then there's the question of whether a microprocessor is, in itself, an invention. After all the only difference between a microprocessor and the same circuit created using standard electronic devices (resisters, transisters, diodes, capacitors, etc...) is size and construction technique. The real invention that allowed microprocessors to be created was the transister. And that might well qualify as the greatest invention ever because that is what ushered in the age of digital electronics. You could certainly make a case for it.
JSullins
Plow: Not referring to a modern, wheel plow. Referring to the first plows, which moved human culture into one based on agriculture and made virtually all our technology possible. Longbow: No, I don't use bows. But I do benefit from the modern western democracy made possible by the social changes brought about by the end of the elite knight classes that were the backbone of feudalism. And it's Sullins! Not Sullens! I get that from so many people :p
CosmicConservative
Sorry J-dude... Seriously, I grew up with everyone misspelling and mispronouncing my name so I know it's irritating. I'll do better. Here's the deal, it's the same thing as with fire, language, etc... Plows were used in most stone age cultures. If you are referring to steel plows, that's not really an invention, it's just a steel version of wooden and stone plows that had been used for centuries. The "first plows" are lost way back in the antiquities of time when agriculture first began to be widespread. They were, I think, mostly made of wood, and were used by hand. Many cultures, after the invention of the plow, never advanced another whit until wheel-based cultures overran them. The longbow is a bit different, but as a military weapon it's impact was no different from dozens of other weapon innovations over the centuries. If I had to pick the absolute most impactful weapon developments in human history, I might not even put the longbow on the list. Here are some that would make my list:
  1. The flint knapped knife
  2. The atlatl
  3. The bow
  4. The sword
  5. The spear
  6. The cannon
  7. ...
The impact of the first flint knapped knives are obvious. It is thought that flint-knapping was discovered very early in human history, before the movement into the New World, meaning that all flint knapping can probably be traced back to one person who first figured out how to do it. The use of stone tools chipped from flint, chert, obsidian and other such materials may have had the most impact of any single weapon/tool. Wherever humans went, they flint knapped. The atlatl is another similar story. Atlatls are thought to be the reason that mammoths, giant sloths and other giant mammals are extinct. Atlatls are as accurate as a bow and deliver a larger and more energy-packed projectile. In fact atlatls could have done the same thing as the Longbow in England. Incan warriors using atlatls easily pierced the armor of the Spanish conquistadors. The advantage of the longbow is that it had a higher firing rate and companies of bowmen could be packed tightly where using an atlatl requires some running room. I've read some articles on the most important weapon development in history and the most commonly referenced weapon that had the most impact is the Roman Short Sword. Not the longbow. :) (I'd probably pick the atomic bomb though...)
pace
The 'wheel' seems like more of a discovery than an invention. Rather like fire. Perhaps it's just semantics, but there are some naturally occurring organisms that rely upon rotary structures or 'wheels'. The first guy to discover that it was easier to roll a heavy object along logs technically was not using a wheel, but his discovery certainly laid the groundwork for the next guy who came along and said "Let's try cutting a slice off that log, punching a hole in the middle, and sticking a shaft through it." Certainly the wheel has revolutionized humanity, but I tend to think of more complex or multi-component devices as more impressive inventions from an 'abstract thought' perspective. My vote for the greatest inventions would include: - The internal combustion engine. - The transistor. - The incandescent lightbulb. - The cathode ray tube. - Concrete and it's derivative aggregates. Just my 2c.
Drax
That's why I said the "creation" of fire. Being able to make fire out of ... nature, however it was first done ... at will ... where will. I'm still on that instead of the wheel.
CosmicConservative
Pace: One of the websites I went to had a description of what archaeologists supposedly think is how the wheel was invented. And it wasn't from watching logs roll according to them. The story is that people needed to haul stuff. Hauling stuff is a big problem, but it's made easier if you have big domesticated animals that can pull harder than you can. That led people to try to haul bigger and bigger stuff. Well, eventually they found that adding more horses, oxen or mules to the train didn't make hauling any easier. But they did notice that things hauled easier on some terrain than on others. This led to the invention of the sled. It's much easier to haul a big rough rock over the ground if you have a smooth sled under it. For 2,000 years, supposedly, sleds were the preferred hauling mechanism. But even then limits were reached, and of course someone was always looking to make it easier. At some point someone started laying smooth logs under the sled. When it moved over the log, a team of workers would grab it, run back around to the front and put it back down again. Some of those logs started to wear down, and to the surprise of the haulers, logs which had been worn down in places actually worked better than logs that were perfectly cylindrical. So someone got the idea to deliberately wear them down. This led to a progressively longer cut down middle, and progressively thinner outside edges. This eventually led to logs that were basically a thick axle with wheels on each side. That's when someone got the idea to make the wheels and the axle separately, and that's when the true wheel was born because once you have an axle and a wheel, you can attach it directly to the sled, and you don't have to carry logs back and forth to keep something moving. And back to fire Drax. Fire is important, and all civilized people use fire. But fire does not lead to civilization. All evidence is that the wheel DOES lead to civilization. Cultures with complete knowledge and expertise to make and use fire stagnated for tens of thousands of years. In fact there are still cultures today which have made and used fire the same way for tens of thousands of years. They definitely know how to make fire much better than I do. But cultures which widely employed the wheel industrialized within a few thousand years without exception.
Drax
The wheel is important, but the wheel doesn't affect human evolution. There is a great deal of scientific evidence that fire (and the cooking which shortly followed it) altered human evolution. I'm still with fire.
CosmicConservative
Drax: I'd say the jury is still out on the impact of the wheel on human evolution. And while there are surly anthropologists and biologists who point to fire as an evolutionary impact, there are others who point to agriculture, others who point to tool making (which was co-incident with fire, so it's hard to pick one impact) and language as the cause of evolutionary changes early in man's history. We'll have to agree to disagree. To me the fact that thousands of human cultures stagnated for tens of thousands of years after developing somewhat sophisticated means to start, maintain and manipulate fire, while every culture that developed the wheel went immediately on a one-way trip to technological advancement is enough of an argument for me to conclude that the wheel has had more impact on humanity than fire. Fire no doubt allowed more humans to live than could live without fire, but it seems to have done little to nothing to inspire humans to improve their lot in life further. The wheel seems to have immediately started allegorical wheels turning in many, many minds, with amazing and nearly immediate results in improving humanity's future.