Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The Four Smartest Humans

By CosmicConservative
So apparently the Discovery Channel ran a program last night and proposed the four smartest humans to have been: Albert Einstein Isaac Newton Galileo Galilei Steven Hawking I get the first two, but I would strongly debate the second two's place on that list. Others who I think are the equal of Galileo and Hawking (and debatably stronger candidates for this list) are: Aristotle Euclid Marie Curie Carl Gauss Werner Heisenberg Neils Bohr James Maxwell Henri Poincare Hendrik Lorentz Richard Feynman Nikola Tesla I could probably go on, but this is not a bad start. Any of these are the equal of Galileo or Hawking in my opinion. And I would put several of them above both. This is not to discount the contributions of Galileo or of Hawking, but if "impact on society" is the measure, then I would have a different list (including the names of Mohammed, Abraham, Thomas Jefferson, etc...) and if the measure is "impact on science" then Aristotle is head and shoulders above anyone, his ideas ruled the world for 1,500 years or more. But in terms of just "who is the smartest" It is hard for me to top Nikola Tesla, Carl Gauss or Henri Poincare.. just to pick a few. What do you think?

Comments (12)

JSullins
I went to school with a descendant of Gauss... think it was a grandson, not sure. Great-grandson? Anyway, this fellow was a steriotypical math geek. Absolutely brilliant. Not socially well-adjusted. Anyway, pointless comment I suppose :)
JSullins
Now how about that! I haven't thought about the guy in many many years, but remembered his name. And he's all over google: http://www.uams.edu/biostat/gauss
CosmicConservative
The apochraphyl story of Gauss is that while in elementary school his teacher wanted some free time to grade some papers so assigned the class the task of adding up all the numbers from zero to 100. Before he could even get his pencil out for grading, Gauss's hand was up in the air. "Yes Carl?" he asked. "5,050" replied young Gauss. "5,050 what?" asked the teacher. "The answer, it is 5,050". "That is silly, you can't possibly have finished the assignment yet, please get back to work." "No, it is the answer. Check for yourself." Gauss replied. And he was right. When asked how he was able to answer the question so quickly Gauss replied that it was simplicity itself. taking numbers from both ends of the list of numbers repeatedly gave totals of 100 like this: 0+100, 1+99, 2+98, 3+97 ... etc. all the way to 49+51, at which point there was a "50" left over. Gauss worked out quickly that there were fifty pairs that totaled to 100, which is 5,000, plus the 50 left over, to give 5,050. The teacher immediately recommended Gauss for special educational opportunities and the rest, as they say, is history.
JSullins
Interesting! ... and I do know how to spell "stereotypical" even if I can't seem to type it...
Dadman
I beg to differ. The four smartest humans are: KC (of The Sunshine Band fame) Weird Al Yankovic Joey Buttafuoco Jim Varney (aka Ernest)... tee...hee...
JSullins
Have to agree with Weird Al Yankovic. Can't say I'm with ya on Buttafuco, though. ;)
CosmicConservative
All kidding aside, there is a strong bias to assume that "smart" means "science" and that's actually a sort of prejudice that we have in evaluating people's intelligence. I don't think there is any doubt that Einstein was a genius, but I would argue that Thomas Jefferson was also a "genius" but one who chose another field. Genius in the arts is harder to quantify though. There is too much subjectivity. Is Paul Simon "smarter" than Bob Dylan? Is Bill Cosby "smarter" than Bob Newhart? (Boy that comparison really dates me, doesn't it?)
Cullen
Alexander Hamilton would be on my list.
Aaron
What about Euler? There are so many things in our classes that end up being called "Euler" equations that it's almost a running joke. Actually, what about some of our greatest inventors, while we're at it? Edison? (How in the world can Tesla be listed without Edison?) Alexander Graham Bell?
CosmicConservative
Euler is good. I think Tesla was in a different league than Edison was. Tesla was an actual theoretical physicist, Edison was a sort of hyper-tinkerer. Both contributed to the early adoption of electricity and both introduced several inventions that have become ubiquitous in today's world. But While Edison's generally accepted crowning achievement was probably the light bulb, Tesla pretty much created the field of electro-dynamics and today's means of generating and distributing electrical power are pretty much what Tesla conceived back in the nineteenth century. Means which Edison opposed, by the way, and Tesla was proven right. Tesla fought a bitter battle for most of his later years fighting to regain recognition as the inventor of radio instead of Marconi. The US Supreme Court finally (posthumously) reinstated Tesla's older patent, which effectively recognizes him as the inventor of the device for which Marconi received the Nobel prize. Tesla's life is one of the great stories in science, he was a man of singular breadth of vision. He was one of the few men who was said to have been able to understand Relativity when Einstein proposed it. His contributions to science range from electrical applications to field theory, robotics, computer science and many more. Given the choice between Tesla or Edison to work on new technology or a new theory, I would instantly choose Tesla.
Debra Jenkins
Nikola Tesla/Albert Einstein Scientific Achievement Mahatma Ghandi/Martin Luther King Jr./Nelson Mandela -- EQ The Wright Brothers/Henry Ford/Alexander Graham Bell - Sweeping and World Changing Inventions Louis Pasteur/Jonas Salk and all the other medical wizards who save our lives every day