- There is not universal agreement among climate researchers on the conclusions of the CRU. This is clearly obvious when you look at the emails and see the efforts the conspirators went to in order to keep researchers who did not provide the "acceptable" results from getting grants, from gaining access to raw data or to publish their papers in scientific journals.
- The scientists involved in climategate are the principal authors of virtually every major "study" on climate that has been referenced by political figures such as Al Gore (who used Mann's "hockey stick" graph to launch his green empire) and the UN's IPCC, which allowed Phil Jones to virtually single-handedly write it's main reports on the subject. If a similar situation had occured in physics in 1900, it would have had to have involved Albert Einstein, Werner Heisenberg, Neils Bohr and Ernest Rutherford. To say "only four physicists are involved" would have been a laughable attempt to diminish the influence of the people involved.
- The biggest problem with the deniers claim though is the data itself. What people don't seem to understand is that there aren't a lot of historical temperature data sets floating around. In fact there are three generally recognized historical datasets used by virtually all climatologists. That still doesn't sound so bad, until you realize that two of those datasets are based almost entirely on the third. The main source of virtually all historical temperature records comes from the U.S. National Oceanagraphical and Atmospheric Agency, or NOAA. CRU is not a data gathering organization, it's a school. NASA is only the originator of satellite data, which only goes back some 40 years. CRU did go out and work out some deals with some data sources on their own, but the vast bulk of their data is the same as the NOAA data. All three of these data sets have been heavily manipulated by the "scientists" working on climate change. Some of those changes have been revealed in the "hacked" emails, but that is the tip of the iceberg. There is a reason NASA and NOAA have violated FOI requests for years to release their data. There are now lawsuits being filed to force the release of their data. Assuming those get resolved, and the data is revealed, we are going to discover that CRU is far from a rogue minor group of renegades, instead what is going to be learned is that climate science has been cooking the books wholesale for decades. Which is, of course, a powerful reason for people to hide their malfeasance.
Climatologists historical data sets
By CosmicConservativeOne of the things you'll hear the Climategate deniers saying repeatedly is that the CRU email scandal is a tempest in a teapot because that is only one small part of Climate science and all other results agree with the CRU. Some of the people saying this probably even believe it.
But it's not true. Here's why.
Comments (3)