The <i>definitive</i> Global Warming post
By CosmicConservativeIt's time to put an end to the confusion and he-said/she-said debate about Global Warming. So for that purpose I'm posting the definitive write-up of Global Warming and what the alarmists have been up to for the past 20 years.
"Unprecedented"
One thing that most people don't seem to understand is that Global Warming is only a problem if it is unprecedented. If it has happened before in historic times, then it's not a huge problem, right? So if you are trying to make the case that Global Warming is "unprecedented" it's a bit of a problem if someone says "what about the Medieval Warming Epoch?" Or "Aren't there records showing significant warming during Roman times?" If it gets out that the MWE was as much as 2 degrees C warmer than our current trend, people might not be inclined to spend a trillion dollars to stop it, since it didn't seem to be a problem last time. So that's why the emails from "ClimateGate" are so important. Among other things they show that Jones and his minions were actively engaged in data manipulation and computer hackery to erase those blips on the historical record. That's where the "Hockey Stick" graph came from, it came from a deliberate effort to manipulate the data and the graph so that the previous two historical warming periods mysteriously vanished. That was deliberate so that the last two decades could be called "unprecedented" when it really isn't.
"Hide the Decline"
I think even many of the skeptics don't understand what this meant. The "decline" that was being "hidden" was really a problem with two different means of tracking temperatures. Since we don't have actual thermometer readings going back thousands of years, climatologists use what is called "proxy data" to generate temperatures. The CRU's favorite technique for generating proxy data is to use tree core samples. But when they plotted out temperatures using tree core data, they had a problem. For hundreds of years they were able to cherry pick data that fit their model quite well, but for the last 20 years or so the tree data stubbornly showed a DECLINE in temperatures at the very time they needed to show the "hockey stick" INCREASE in temperatures. So to "fix" that, they simply threw out the tree core data for the last 20 years and plugged in temperatures recorded at weather stations instead. Sure enough, they got the dramatic rise in temperature they wanted. Of course there's a scientific problem with this. If tree data is not valid enough for the last 20 years, how is it valid enough for the last 200? Or 1,000? The answer seems to be "it's good enough when it gives us the data we're looking for, and not good enough when it doesn't."
The urban effect
Remember the "Hide the Decline" discussion about four lines above? Well, one thing that skeptics have shown is that weather stations have a strong urban bias, so temperature recordings taken from weather stations tend to be higher than other forms of temperature data. This is due to, among other things, the "urban heat island" effect. Cities essentially create their own weather and tend to be a couple of degrees higher than the surrounding countryside. So when Jones and his team threw out the tree core data and replaced it with weather station data, they put in data that they KNEW had a bias towards higher readings. This was no accident. This was, again, deliberate. Between the erasing of the previous historical warming periods and the artifical increase in temperatures using biased temperature readings from weather stations, they got exactly the hockey stick they wanted, the hockey stick that launched Al Gore on his Nobel Prize winning crusade which coincidentally netted him about $100 million in increased assets.
Existential Threat
Global Warming isn't a problem unless it's an existential threat to our civilization. This is part of the reason it is so important that today's situation be regarded as "unprecedented." Because if it's happened before, and we got through it OK, then we can probably get through it OK again. So once the "scientists" were able to convince the "intelligentsia" that the current warming was "unprecedented" they now needed to show that it was a threat. That's why they initially promised us dozens of category 5 hurricanes, huge increases in tornadoes and massive droughts across the world. As none of those have panned out, the alarmists have had to rely more and more on sea level rises and melting of ice caps. This is why the IPCC report "mistakenly" said sea levels would rise 20 feet by 2035 when even the fudged and corrupted models themselves predicted such rises only by 2350. To get people to give you trillions of dollars, you have to convince them that the problem is NOW.
CO2
But, even if all the above is true, none of it matters if there isn't some way to DO SOMETHING ABOUT it. So the alarmists needed a bogeyman. That bogeyman was CO2. Since the vast majority of alarmists are also anti-capitalists at best and socialists at worst, pinning the blame on CO2 was critical to the whole game. The problem is that actual geological data shows that CO2 has a correlation with warming, but that it tends to LAG warming instead of lead it. So the scientists had to somehow convince people that our warming was caused by CO2. The best way to do that was to show that warming had accelerated since the industrial revolution. That's why the computer code revealed in the leaked documents shows hard-coded adjustments to temperature readings since 1940. CO2 levels had been rising slowly since the late nineteenth century, but REALLY began to climb after the Great Depression. So by tying temperature increases (artificially) to the arbitrary date of 1940, alarmists could claim that CO2 was the culprit. But there's a problem with this too, and that problem is that CO2 is actually a very minor greenhouse gas, it's effects are DWARFED by water vapor, methane and other greenhouse gas contributors. But you can't tie water vapor or methane to industrialization, but you CAN tie CO2 to it. So the alarmists simply MADE UP a computer model "fudge factor" that they called the "multiplier effect." This is a wholly arbitrary and experimentally UNVERIFIED assertion that slight CO2 increases create a "multiplier" for water vapor greenhouse gas effects. Now, with that fudge factor plugged into their computer programs they could run simulations that "proved" that CO2 increases caused increases in temperature. This is just one reason that the computer models have NEVER actually predicted temperatures over any time period. It's just made up stuff.
Carbon demonization
And that brings us to the real goal of the whole cabal. Demonization of carbon and CO2 production. Because if they can get people to believe that CO2 is an existential threat to our civilization, then they can tax it, regulate it and force people to change their lifestyles.
Summary
It is important for people to see how this all hangs together. This is not some coincidental sequence of events. This is all planned. This is the narrative that the alarmists have been pursuing for 20+ years. If you understand this, you will find the ClimateGate emails to be far more revealing than just some sort of random scientific fraud. This is all about ideology, control, power and money. None of this is accidental. All of it is deliberate.
Comments (8)