Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Thinking too much...

By CosmicConservative
So throughout my life a fairly common criticism of me has been that I "think too much." I have always found this to be an odd critique, comparable to such things as making "too much money," or having "too much stuff." How is it possible to "think too much?" In general these criticisms are lobbed my way when I provide an analysis of a situation or an item. Usually there is some indication on my part that I somehow "know" what other people were thinking when they did certain things, because I've gone through what I consider to be the likely cause and effect string that led to a particular event or situation. It has been suggested that this tendency of mine to "think too much" is at the expense of my "having fun" or "letting loose." I suppose at my advanced age, my wild oats are going to have to remain unsowed. But, having analyzed this criticism, I have a fairly typical compulsion to rebut it, or at least explain it. See, I find it enjoyable to analyze things. I have "fun" looking at a photo and trying to figure out what the photographer was trying to do. I enjoy analyzing a situation and working backwards to lay out probable causes which led to the effects of the situation. For some reason this activity must send waves of dopamine into my brain, much as other people's brains receive waves of dopamine for other reasons. This is what critics do for a living, is it not? Isn't every critical review of a movie, TV show, musical performance, art show or food tasting basically an analysis of the events, effects or results of the actions taken? Don't critics routinely ascribe motivations and rationale to the people involved in the artistic effort? They must find such activity to be enjoyable. I'd hate to think they spend their entire careers disliking their most basic job functions. In a sense I see myself as a critic of the human species, both in general and in specific subgroups. I especially find myself enjoying the analysis and critique of those I consider to be decadent, hypocritical, pompous or cruel. For me when I see a photo of a famous person, it is pretty much automatic to wonder what the artist and the model were trying to do, and then to judge how well they pulled it off. For the same reason, when I am watching a TV show or movie, I do the same thing. I automatically watch the show from the perspective of trying to figure out what the director, writer and actor are attempting to accomplish with a scene. That's part of the fun of it for me. Now, that doesn't mean I don't simultaneously experience the same event as a pure observer. I can laugh at a joke even as I'm analyzing the punch line. I can tear up even as I admire the jerking of the heart strings. The assumption by the critics who assume my lack of spontaniety and frivolity is that this hyper-analytical part of my personality is the reason for the lack of spontaniety and frivolity. But I don't know if that's true. It might be true, it's only recently that I've started to really wonder about my own personality in that way. It is conceivable that my tendency to analyze details of events reduces my enjoyment of them. But even if so, I'm not sure what to do about it. I don't seem to have an "off" button on my analytical cortex in my brain. It's there all the time, watching, calculating, predicting and judging. For example, on the "redneck comedy tour" Jeff Foxworthy goes into a spiel about how he is the lone male in a sea of estrogen. He lists his own daughters, his brother's daughters, and their friends as examples of his environment, describing his home as a "sea of naked Barbies." He says he spends every day trying to figure out why some female is crying. Then he goes into the big finish, the laugh line. He starts like this (paraphrased): "So, I come home one day and sure enough, there's tears." OK, my analytical mind is already getting suspicious. For some reason he's indicated that someone is crying, but he doesn't say who it is. "They won't let me play! They went into the room and won't let me be one of the fairies!" Back to my analytical brain... so I'm thinking "huh, there's nothing funny about a little girl crying because her sisters and cousins are being cruel... something else is going on here. He hasn't mentioned his wife.... aha!" So now the rest of the joke is just me waiting for the "reveal" when he lets the audience know that the sobbing bag of estrogen is, in fact, his supposedly adult wife. By the time he gets there, I've already processed the joke and am looking for how he's delivering the reveal. What body language is he using? How long does he string the audience along? Did he go too long? Could he have built it up even more? The Cosmic Wife usually complains that I don't laugh, but that's not true. I laughed ten seconds earlier, but I've learned not to laugh out loud when I "get" the joke because people don't like it when I do that. So I laugh silently and then watch how it plays out. Another example... At the end of the show, the four are sitting around and the joke of the moment is "You might be a redneck if.... you have opened a beer during a eulogy." So Ron White (I think) gets up to act this out. He walks over to an imaginary coffin swigging an imaginary beer. Now I'm getting suspicious that this is a big finish, it's a little too pat for me to believe it's improvised. But maybe it is. But I'm waiting for it... but his joke is pretty lame, I don't even remember what it was. Then Jeff gets up and saunters over with his own imaginary beer, looks in the imaginary coffin and says "That's not grandma!" Again, not so much what I was expecting, but not nearly worth the buildup and time investment in this little routine. But I'm waiting for it... waiting... Sure enough, Larry the Cable Guy gets up and saunters over with his own imaginary beer, glances in the coffin and says "Yeah, that's her, they just shaved her beard off." Now that was funny. And I didnt' see it coming. In fact I was giving up on the gag because of the first two lame jokes. Plus, Larry's running gag all night has been the moles on the female members of his family, so I'm expecting a mole joke. But Larry the Cable Guy is perhaps one of the least predictable comics I know of. He breaks all the rules. So, did I enjoy it more because I didn't see it coming? Hard to say. For that brief instant when he took a lame routine and saved it with a hilarious, totally in character joke, for that brief instant I laughed out loud, which is pretty rare. But at the same time, I have had to go back and recreate the setup after the fact since I wasn't ahead of the joke that time. So I dunno. It's like appreciation of humor on different levels. I admit that I get some pleasure out of being "in on the joke" as it is being delivered. I enjoy figuring out the reveal and following the buildup. I like to find the themes so that when Jeff Foxworthy goes into the final bow, I know he's going to return to that theme one last time to sew up the entire performance and build on that one ongoing joke leaving the audience laughing and feeling like they are part of the "in crowd" themselves. I appreciate the craft of it. It's nice to see it well done. Not sure if that makes sense.

Comments (5)

CosmicConservative
Heh.. it takes too many drugs or too much alcohol to get me to that point.
Dadman
Thinking too much is probably not the best way to describe it. I would call it 'hyper-analysis in appropriate contexts'. Heh. Sounds like a thesis title...