Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Ragnarok update 2

By CosmicConservative
Yeah, I'm still messing around with the wargame "Ragnarok". It's not exactly the same as it was 30 years ago, but that's because I want it to be more playable. In the past when my brother and I worked on these wargames, we really did it in a vacuum. Other than Risk, Diplomacy, Kriegspeil and Axis&Allies we hadn't played any "standard" wargames. We certainly hadn't played any of the highly complex games with 20 page rule books. In the last week I've done some research on wargames. I had sort of expected to find a lot of games more or less similar to Ragnarok. But that's not the case. Which could be good, or could be bad. Basically there seem to be two major styles of wargames, one called "German" or "European" and the other called "American." The difference between the two styles is that the European style seems to focus more on the creation and management of resources, while the American style seems to focus more on the tactical and strategic details of the battles themselves. Even within the two genres discussed, there are also differences between "historical" and "fictional" games. Historical games are almost entirely based on actual battles, such as Gettysburg or Waterloo, etc. The level of detail in these games is unbelievable. The fictional style of game may have identical game mechanics to a historical game, but they are not based on an historic battle. Some fictional games are set in fantasy or science fiction settings, but the level of detail is just as severe as the historical games. Ragnarok is obviously more like the "fictional" wargames because it makes no pretense of duplicating any historical event. But the level of detail is much less than the wargames I found on the web. This may not be good, it is possible that wargames have such an incredible level of detail because that's what wargamers like. In the wikipedia entry on wargames they imply that games lacking sufficent detail are sneered at as mass-market games. So Ragnarok would most likely receive nothing but ridicule from the hard-core wargamer. However, the casual gamer, used to games like "Axis&Allies" or "Risk" would probably find the level of detail of Ragnarok quite intimidating. As it stands right now the game has about 20 different pieces, each with it's own special attributes including movement type, movement rate, attack and defend values, etc... So to play the game each player needs a cheat sheet to keep track of the different values. Right now that fits on less than half a standard 8x10 page, so from a wargame perspective, it is laughably simplistic. So far Ragnarok has three different land based forces, four sea-going, two air going, transports, engineers and a few stationary pieces which represent air bases or seaports. Land-based forces can be transported by amphibious transports which move across land or water. The game has the basic concept of Aircraft carriers, fighters and bombers, cruisers, destroyers, etc. It also has a fundamental economy which is based on mining resources and transporting those resources to bases, seaports or airports where "builders" can convert them into forces to increase combat. If the game plays as I hope it does, the winner should be the player who best manages the competing priorities of mining resources, transporting and protecting resources, building forces and utilizing those forces in strategically and tactically effective ways. I've play-tested it a bit where I am both sides, and I've so far been pleasantly surprised with how well it is working out. To assure a true victory in battle (meaning that you destroy a chunk of the enemy while taking relatively minor damage yourself) you really need to commit double the forces at least, or else you need to out-maneuver the enemy so that your forces concentrate their power on fewer forces at least for one turn, which hopefully is enough to greatly reduce the enemy's ability to counter-attack on his turn. So far I've only tested the sea battles. My board is all sea right now. I need to create some islands or continents to allow for land battles. To make the board I printed out 16 pages of .4" hex grid and then cut and pasted them together, covering the result with clear shelving paper (a technique I've used for a long, long time). Game pieces are disks of 1.5mm thick colored foam circles with hand-drawn icons to represent different forces. The foam circles fit just inside a single hex, and stack where appropriate (three infantry units can stack, fighters can stack on carriers, etc.) It may be possible that the pieces are too small, but the tradeoff of making the pieces bigger is to have an effectively smaller play area since the hexes would have to grow as well. Right now I like the size of the board, so I've used smaller circles. I suppose this will become part of the play testing and it may end up with me needing to make a new board with larger hexes and new pieces. I hope not because it takes a while to punch out all those circles and then draw the icons.

Comments (2)

Old Goat
So who won? The 16 pages, are they 8.5 X 11? It seems that the board size would get pretty big being that is only the sea portion, or am I comprehending that wrong? Some of the problem with wargames is you tend to have very little in the middle ground. It could be that your game would have enough of a niche to fill that void.
CosmicConservative
Yes, the pages are 8.5x11. However, due to the limitations of printing, I had to trim some of each page off. The resulting board is 35.5x40 inches. The board is about 60 hexes by 60 hexes. Each hex is a bit more than 5/8" wide from one flat side to the other. Right now I just haven't bothered to put any terrain on it. I'm just using it with the grid alone. I'm still working out the best way to handle terrain. So that means so far I've only used ships and aircraft in combat. I'd have done some terrain this weekend but I had to work for a big chunk of the weekend, including all night last night. I'll probaby end up just drawing terrain using erasable markers.