On Black Holes
By CosmicConservativeI am a physics heretic.
I don't believe in singularities. They may well exist, but I cannot wrap my brain around them, they violate everything I seem to know about reality and so I simply don't believe in them.
I'm not sure I believe in black holes or not, but I definitely don't believe there is some infinite density dimensionless point that sucks time and space into another dimension. That just seems crazy to me.
Now, it is not impossible that there are objects so dense that they are "black holes" in the classical sense, meaning that they are objects from which no light (and therefore no matter) can escape, except through Hawking radiation (which is sort of like magic too, but I actually do understand it and "believe" in it). But "dense enough to be a black hole" and "infinitely dense" are not the same thing.
So I guess what I believe is that matter has some basic degenerate state that is incompressible, and when it reaches that state, it can compress no further.
Why this is so may not be due to some inherent strength of matter, but could be due to something more akin to Heisenberg's uncertainty principle. It is conceivable to me that matter may reach a point inside a black hole that if you try to pack it any more tightly, it simply gets "fuzzy" in the same sense that Heisenberg talks about fuzziness. It doesn't compress any further, because nothing can force it any closer, it simply reappears outside of the boundaries that would make it collapse to nothingness.
Sigh, that doesn't sound very convincing. But I don't know how else to put it. What it boils down to is just my belief that infinite density and zero dimensions are meaningless statements in reality. As I said, I just can't wrap my brain around it.
Comments (5)