Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

That much-vaunted "German Engineering"

By CosmicConservative
So, we own an Audi A4, 2003 model. We've had it for about three years. We were looking for a used Subaru Legacy or Outback when we were steered to the A4 by a savvy used car salesman. After a test drive up into the foothills on I-70, I fell in love with it. There's a lesson in that. After a couple of months the in-dash cupholder broke. It's a flimsy little thing, apparently designed to hold demitasse cups held by dainty poofy haired European aristocrats. It simply could not hold up under the pressure of American 20oz soft drinks. No big deal though, right? How much could it cost to repair a flimsy piece of broken black plastic? About $500, actually. So we drove with a broken cup holder for months until I finally decided we should just bite the bullet and fix it. Soon after the glove compartment door broke. Apparently it wasn't designed to be opened more than a few times a year. Actually using it on a daily basis for holding things like iPods as you went into a store was apparently well beyond it's design parameters. Europeans must carry their iPods everywhere. Again, no big deal, how much can a broken glove compartment hinge cost to fix? $650. In the meantime I was discovering that "German Engineering" can be roughly translated as "temperamental specialty parts." So every time I took the car into the shop, some new and heretofore unknown mechanical, electrical or electronic part was broken and needed to be repaired immediately, at a minimum cost of $1,000 or so. So every three months as we took the car in for "maintenance" we were told time and time again that some critical element in the car needed immediate replacement. And the repairs were never cheap. Case in point. Six weeks ago we took the car in to the dealer because it was time for a maintenance check and the car was making a faint rumbling noise on the left front side. Or that's what it felt like. Remember that for later. So they look the car over and blame the noise on a loose plastic guard that was intermittently rubbing against the tire. I told them that was not the cause of the problem because I had noticed the plastic guard and had put it back in its proper place and the noise continued. Did they listen to me? Nope. They insisted nothing else was wrong with the tires or wheel and that the noise was now gone. In the meantime though, they "discovered" a faulty engine mount that needed to be replaced immediately. Cost? $1,200. So, like any good sucker, I paid the cost. Within a few days the Cosmic Wife was complaining that the noise was still there. Of course that's about when I caught the swine flu. Then we had the snowfall, and then the Cosmic son's birthday, so we didn't get the car back to the dealer. Monday though, the CW informed me that an engine light had come on. So I set an appt. and took the car in to the dealer. So I just got off the phone with the dealer. Remember that noise it was making they said they couldn't find six weeks ago? Well, now it's a problem with the alignment which has caused the tires to "cup" and now all four tires need to be replaced. And that engine light? Well, the turbocharger is failing. Total cost? $2,500. The car is only worth about $5,000. So now I'm looking to get rid of it, and I will likely never buy a german engineered car again in my lifetime. I'm looking for a good solid Toyota now.

Comments (14)

Drax
Two things: 1) Super glue, 2) Never take your car to a dealer, especially one who finds things wrong each time you take it in. But, most importantly...super glue.
CosmicConservative
We tried glue and tape, it's one of those deals where the piece simply is under too much stress and no repair is ever as strong as the unbroken piece. Yeah, never going back to that dealer, that's for sure.
CosmicConservative
Oh, and actually, the Cosmic Wife has mentioned that she'd like a Subaru. Our other car is a Subaru Outback. Yeah, we have three cars. Because I'm an idiot.
esox67
Do not fall for a Passat while you are looking, or we will be hearing this story all over again. Talk about over hyped piece of crap, and that is being nice. I could be telling the same story as you are about your Audi. I dumped that turd for a loss and now have a Camry to go with my Chevy Trailblazer.
pace
Don't feel too bad (about owning three cars). There's only two people who drive in my household, and we have five cars plus several motorcycles. And I don't like to think about how much money I've blown on stupid car projects over the years. Anyway, I hope the new car works out better for you than the lemon Audi.
CosmicConservative
I'm not sure the Audi is a lemon, I think it's just too fragile for the sort of driving we do, and the lifestyle we have. It's just high-maintenance I think. And everything that needs to be fixed is ridiculously expensive. And they will never try to figure out a way to fix something other than the "buy a new part and throw it on the car" approach. They have a business model that I would describe as: "Soak the rich customer as much as possible because anyone stupid enough to buy this car has to be rich."
Old Goat
This is why I do all my own work on my cars. I've rebuilt engines, transmissions, body work, pretty much any job on the cars other than painting them (mainly because though I have the equipment to do a paint job, I don't have the space to do it where it won't get fuzz on it). Any job you are quoted $1000 to do, you could do it yourself for about $200. European car parts are not cheap, though. They tend to run at least twice to three times the amount of Japanese or American car parts. Dealers tend to be the worst in terms of finding things to fix and costs. A local shop that is independent but knows how to work on the car is a better way to go. One thing to also think about when buying a car is to see how many of those type of cars are in your area. If its fairly common then there are indy shops to work on it, if they are rarely seen, you probably don't have many options for other places to work on them. Another thing to determine how costly repairs are for cars is how cheap they are for a used model compared to others of the same age. High repair costs drive the resale value way down.
Andy
Have you driven a Ford lately? I'm on my second Mercury Sable (1997 model). It's got 130,000 miles, and I've spent about $400 bucks on really mechanical repairs. I bought a set of front tires a few months ago...$260 total. Just my two cents...
Finigans
I have a SAAB that has 190,000 miles on it. I expect to run it to 300,000. The key is knowing how to do your own repairs. I may spend about 3-400 a year in parts for the car, but it has been dependable. Ford cars and trucks aren't bad, but they rust... a lot.
CosmicConservative
Well, I was planning on getting a new (used) car today, but we are in the middle of a refinancing so I figured I better wait until that is done to keep from causing any delays in the refinance. As usual, the instant I entered the refinance market, rates started to climb. It's simply amazing the impact my financial decisions have on the world economy...
Cullen
I've dumped a lotta change into my '96 Camry lately. That said, it has almost 160K miles on it. I hope it lasts another year or two. After that I'd like to get something newer. I've always been a Ford fan and the fact that they didn't take bailout money makes them more attractive to me.