Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

War Games...

By CosmicConservative
Seriously, actual war games. Not the kinds in the movies or that the Pentagon runs, but the kind nerdy geeks like to play. I used to play a lot of war games with my brothers, particularly my oldest brother who loved all sorts of war games. We didn't BUY war games, we made them up. Or mostly I made them up but my brother provided some ideas and did all the play-testing which polished them up. Eventually we settled on two long-term games, one modeled on a fairly gritty WW2 model, and the other a highly abstracted game with movement and rules borrowed from games like chess or go. Lately I've gotten the urge to resurrect at least the WW2 game and see if I can recreate it (I long ago lost most of the boards and pieces we used to play on, and the rules are mostly worn out or aged beyond readability). Interestingly the rules were originally typed out on a typewriter. Yeah, an actual typewriter, isn't that just all kinds of awesome? Anyway the original game was highly complex. Because I have an aversion to dice rolls (I am convinced that I am cursed when it comes to random chance) I originally built the game to be completely dice free. It was all based on tactical movement, positioning and providing support for engaged forces. Outside of my oldest brother (now passed away, sadly) I doubt there is anyone else on earth who would be as willing and eager to wade through the arcane complexity of those rules. So in recreating the game (called "Ragnarok" by the way) I am returning to the more capricious, but much less complex, mechanics of rolling dice to determine outcomes of battles. My biggest frustration with most mass-market war games (such as Risk, for example, or Diplomacy or even Axis & Allies) is that the board is so constrained that it becomes tiresome to play within its limitations. Coupled with that is a static board that has to be re-used so that within a few game sessions the most effective strategies are pretty well known and become somewhat boring. So my wargames have always had immense boards with no permanent geography and no standard paths (seriously now, Spain to Brazil is a move in Risk? Why can't I send my troops to Florida?) To me one of the greatest challenges in combat simulations is dealing with unknown terrain and unclear strategic objectives. That's what real war is like. You see two armies marching towards each other and suddenly some little known topographical oddity becomes the critical strategic goal in part because of it's geography, and in part because that's where one army, at least, is going. That dynamic competition between forces seeking advantages in changing conditions is what separates the real military geniuses from the merely mundane. The key to making an engaging war simulation is in how you balance out the combat mechanics from the resource management and supply mechanics. Most military experts will tell you that armies must be resupplied to be successful, and the most effective way to destroy an army is to cut off its supply line and wear it down by attrition. But virtually all mass market war games do not even simulate this. Risk and Axis & Allies simply allow you to build and place forces more or less where you want. There is no need to keep supply lines open because there are no actual resources being managed. They are fairly engaging combat simulations but don't really mimic the strategic and tactical objectives of an actual war. The simplest way of demonstrating this is to piont out that neither game employs the concept of transportation at all. There are no roads and no bridges, only territories. In a real war roads and bridges are major targets and keeping roads and bridges open is a major goal of successful armies. That means roads and bridges become tactically important on their own. So Ragnarok incorporates resource management such that it isn't enough to simply hold territory, you have to CONTROL and protect territory. If you build a bridge and leave it, your enemies are very likely to just come and blow it up. I've got the first full draft of the rules finished and have a suitable board available. I just need to come up with something that works for pieces and I'll be ready for extensive play testing. Wish me luck.

Comments (5)

Foobarista
I never got into board-based wargames - never was social enough - but played (and sometimes still play) lots of Civilization on the computer, which does a decent job of terrain and such things. Also, it has randomly generated maps, so you can't rely on existing knowledge. One other entertaining element is you often get tech mismatches which make for interesting battles, especially if you're the "mismatch-ee"; the oh-crap moment when your knights come over the hill to see the panzer divisions mustering in the distance is always fun...
CosmicConservative
I played Civilization and, I think, Civ II, then played Alpha Centauri. I enjoyed it but after a few weeks of play the only challenge was seeing how fast I could overwhelm the computer. My ultimate goal, to build EVERY wonder (Pyramids, Aquaduct, etc.) I don't think I ever accomplished, but I got very close on occasion. In tech mismatches it was almost always my battleships running into the triremes, not the other way around. ;) If I ever started with two savages, I just tore up the computer.
Foobarista
I always liked to play the hardest levels, and wasn't patient enough to spend hours per turn in most games. I was usually way ahead in tech, but there were a few times when I wasn't, especially in my first couple tries at "Deity" levels... Civ 2 was just Civ 1 prettified, and the "merchant prince" strategy I used pretty much always worked, but Civ 4 is more interesting; merchant prince strategies aren't quite as effective, and you can't just buy a military the way you could in the past. And some resources are rare and require defense (or offense).
CosmicConservative
I haven't played a computer wargame in years. I may have to look into them again. I've gotten pretty bored with World of Warcraft. But first, I have to perfect Ragnarok...