Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

NFL notes - week 8

By CosmicConservative
I didn't get much of a chance to watch any games this weekend. I had other things going on. However I did check out the results once I got my duties completed yesterday. My thoughts:
  • Denver finally found out what it's like to play Denver. Hopefully they'll get back on track before meeting the defending Super Bowl Champion Steelers next Monday night.
  • New Orleans is playing tonight, trying to stay undefeated. To an old New Orleans fan like me that's a remarkable statement to make about any New Orleans team, much less one halfway through a season. Gotta root for Drew and the boys.
  • Chicago managed to win convincingly in a game where Jay Cutler threw no touchdowns, one interception and about 250 yards. Good day for the Bears, not so much for their $35 million franchise, pro-bowl QB. But it's all about winning, so good for them.
  • I met a guy from Iowa and Wisconsin who was all mixed up over the Minnesota-Green Bay game. He was really struggling trying to decide whether his boyhood idol did well, or his lifelong favorite team did well. I hope he's OK with the outcome today. Favre is simply having another career year. In two victories against Green Bay this year I think Favre has seven touchdowns and no interceptions. That's not very Favre-ish.
  • Romo has now had three 300-yard+ games in a row with no interceptions and, I think, seven touchdowns. The Cowboys are quietly back on top of the NFC East (tied with Philadelphia) and playing well. Good for the 'boys.
  • What the heck has happened to the NY Giants? The past two weeks they have looked like the Kansas City Chiefs. Eli is back to his pre-Super Bowl levels of incompetence. Hopefully that will continue.

Comments (23)

Drax
Denver was unimpressive in all areas of the game. It happens even to the best teams. Once is a coincidence. Twice is a trend. Orton was harried all day and didn't overcome it. New Orleans has been impressive in all areas of the game. They look to be at least bound to go deep into the playoffs. Chicago played Cleveland. Nothing to learn there. Favre has weapons. He has an elite defense. He doesn't have to do it all himself which, for the greatest part, he has had to do his entire career. I still envision a Vikings/Colts super bowl. Romo is looking great. Three great backs, a premiere receiver and tight end, a good offensive line and a decent defense helps. But, Romo looks to be on track for a pro bowl season and playoff bound. The Giants began playing good teams.
CosmicConservative
On the Giants and "good teams" I still think that Romo threw that game away. I think that may have been a wake-up call for Romo. I hope so anyway. I think the Cowboys are better overall than the Giants and I still think Eli can be rattled and when you do, bad things happen.
Drax
I think that the Cowboys have gotten better as his rapport with Austin grows. Having his entire complement of RB's available doesn't hurt any, either. They are certainly a better team now than they were when they lost to the Giants. The Giants...dunno. I don't think that they're any worse...just that they weren't all that good to begin with...an average team with average offense which performed well against bad/underperforming teams supported by a better than average defense which, of course, fed off those bad/underperfoming teams... I always enjoy watching as the teams begin to fall apart and to gel as the season progresses. It's even more fun to watch the pundits as they continue to tout their favorite QB's and downplay those they don't think are any good. Favre? Playing great. But, if Favre and Rodgers switched places, the pundits opine that Green Bay would have lost by even more. Sigh. I guess they simply weren't watching all those years when Favre won with inferior teams and, for the most part, went 13-3 with almost the same team Rodgers currently has, one interception from the Superbowl... Rodgers is good. He holds onto the football too long. Favre wouldn't get sacked 8 times in a game...over and over. Just wouldn't happen. But, like Cutler, the pundits want Rodgers to be an elite QB when, when wins/losses are considered, he doesn't do enough to warrant it.
esox67
Drax, I disagree, Brent has had plenty of people around him over the years, in fact the year the Packers won the Super Bowl, the Packers had the # 1 ranked offense and defense. Not to mention, he did not win three MVP's by himself. They also had a pretty good team in the early 2000's when Ahman Green was in his prime. They were not a great team 2 years ago, but Brent was pretty average in the NFC championship to my memory after a very good year. Right now the Packers are in desperate need of offensive lineman that can block and defensive lineman that can pressure the quarterback, neither side the ball will excel until that is fixed.
Drax
Disagree all you wish. It's the nature of the game. The one Superbowl Favre won was when he had Reggie White on the other side of the ball and a defense second to none. Ryan Grant was GREAT with Favre at the helm, not so much now. Jennings as well. Driver (2 years older -- true) has been a solid workhorse throughout his career -- but not a HOFer. Football is, as I always say, the ultimate team game and -- one with actually THREE "teams" on each team (offense, defense, and special teams). Of those, if the defense or offense is elite and the other two average, you can win championships. But, if you don't have one elite element, you're not going to win championships. When you have two elite (offense and defense) you DOMINATE. But, each "team" has such components that it is difficult for any of them to be "elite" if they are not solid all around -- or have such an advantage in one area that it can make up for failings in another. An elite QB can make up for average or less than average running backs and/or receiving corps...but no elite QB can make up for a below average O-line. No elite receivers can make up for a below average QB, but if you add a better-than-average running back corps, it makes up for a below average QB.... A great linebacking corps can do much, but if the secondary sucks, they ain't winning. Favre has won with average running backs and, at best, workmen at wide receiver. His O-line has been, at best, better than average. In his entire career (until now) he has played with exactly ONE hall of famer (or potential hall of famer) -- and in that year, he won the Superbowl. Like Elway, he could win...he could WILL his team to win...but not the big one -- until he had that elusive missing piece of the puzzle (Terrell Davis -- who, had he not been injured would have been HOF, he certainly was playing at HOF level when he was injured...) But, no matter what... when you have an ELITE component, it has the potential to elevate the level of play of all other components. When the defense has to put 8 in the box to stop the run, the QB has the potential to exploit it...and vice versa. A great QB makes all his receivers better and vice versa. Favre makes EVERYONE better on his team. His quick release makes his O-line better. His bullet-speed makes his receivers better. The threat of his arm makes his RB better. Putting points on the board makes his defense better. Knowledge that, whenever Favre is on the field, winning is possible no matter the score, makes EVERYONE better. Rodgers doesn't do that. I'm a Favre fan. Always have been. I'm convinced that he has done more with less than any quarterback in the history of the game. As with every sports opinion, mileage varies....
Andy
Favre brings something to the field that few do. He loves the game. He really loves it. I was one that thought he should have stayed home after his second retirement. But I don't fault him for taking the money, and having the fun. Favre is a rare cat. When the arm, and the legs finally wear out, I don't know how long he'll remain sane. Cosmic, when it comes to the Saints...I know that you have been a fan since from forever. I've never truly been a Saints fan. It has been fun in the few seasons that they have done well to watch the success (but not get caught up emotionally as a fan). Man, at this point they look like the best "team" NO has ever fielded. I'm pretty sure that they will make the playoffs. ;) As you know, I'm a Cowboys fan. I tried to get a divorce in the miserable Chan Gailey days. But the judge said, "NO!" My 'Boys are finally coming around. Romo has something deep within him that he has not yet tapped, and he does have the weapons. We shall see... Rogers is good. He's really good. Regardless of the fact that Favre has beat him twice, the Packers were wise to move on. The guy has class, talent, and will eventually be a champ...probably twice, if he plays long enough. The New York Midgets are just not that good. I guess Plaxico is still in jail, and Toomer, and Tyree, etc. are elsewhere. It is a "team" game.
CosmicConservative
Aaron Rodgers is currently the best rated quarterback in the league, as measured by quarterback rating. His 14 touchdowns vs. 2 interceptions and 2,000 yards passing so far are all stellar stats. Favre, in comparison, has 16 TDs vs. 3 interceptions and also is right at 2,000 yards, and his 106 rating compares very well to Rodgers 110 rating. So on paper there is no reason to think that switching quarterbacks would have had any difference in the outcome of the game. But we all know better than that, don't we? One thing I will say is that I cannot believe that any 40 year old quarterback in the history of the NFL has had a year like Favre is having. The knock on Favre is that his advanced geezerage will kick in the last six games of the season, when his arm and legs start to wear down and he plays more games in cold joint-aching weather. Over the last few years this does seem to hold true for Favre. Let's hope that is not the case in 2009. I'd love to see Brett Favre get knocked out of the playoffs by the Dallas Cowboys one more time, just for old times' sake. ;-)
Andy
Amen! On all counts! 40 doesn't seem "old" like it once did. But in that game of crazy fast monsters (young monsters), it's pretty remarkable what Brett has done so far. We'll see. Time will tell. That's the great thing about "time." It always "tells," and it always tells the truth.
Drax
We'll see. Last year he was actually INJURED as opposed to minor "hurts" like a broken thumb on his throwing hand... I tend to believe that his late wilting over the past few years is a result of a couple of things... First, he's Brett Favre. He believes that he can win a game with his arm. He is correct more often than not, but oftentimes his "winning" with his arm is actually a combination of his efforts and his receivers (see, e.g. Percy's TD last game.). When he trusts his receivers and his receivers trust him and everyone knows that, no matter what the play is, THEY'RE LIVE and Brett will throw to them at ANY time, magic can happen. Second, he was playing the "best of the best," i.e., the teams who would go on to play deeper into the playoffs. It's simply harder to beat the better teams. Playing better teams (especially in overtime) requires that you make that "magic" happen, because if you don't -- THEY WILL. Third, he was older and playing in the cold simply sapped him more than it did when he was younger. He's in a dome now, and, if things continue as they are, he'll have home field throughout the playoffs (in that dome) and the Superbowl will be played in Tampa -- no cold -- no snow. We'll see. I'm hoping he'll continue playing until Blanda age...
Andy
Drax, if Favre plays to Blanda age, I'm hoping that I'm not around to see it. Heck, we know that he can throw. But can he kick? Just askin'...
Drax
Heh, last QB I know of who tried a drop-kick field goal was Flutie...
Drax
CC: Oh...a bit more on Rodgers. He's been sacked, what...30 times thus far this season? Those sacks don't figure into the QB rating...the interceptions and incompletions you throw when you're trying to AVOID the sack do... This is the biggest difference between Favre and Rodgers....Rodgers simply doesn't have that "clock" in his head yet. While he can run pretty well for a QB, he isn't 1/10th as mobile in the pocket as is Favre.
Interested
Problem with the Colts is - they haven't played anybody. I have to totally disagree with Rogers. Even when the man lets the ball fly fast as humanly possible (to a receiver) he's getting sacked. Get a better O-Line. Your bit about QB rating is correct - but again if Rogers O-Line afforded the level of protection that Farve's does - look for even higher QB rating than his current 110. He cannot make his receivers get to their spots faster just because his line isn't doing their jobs. Those benefits you see in Farve are true - benefits. Fast, hard throws. But Farve doesn't have the ability to finess. Farve's biggest weakness was displayed in that final drive during the Vikings - Ravens game. That call (whoever made it) cost them the game. Heck even injured he continued to allow himself to play. Why he wasn't getting fined right along with Mangini is beyond me. If it came down to it. I'd pick Rogers in place of Farve with the current Vikings team. You would have at least the same level of performance - but Rogers would pull it through when necessary. Well actually I'd pick Brady.
Finigans
The Giants have fallen off, but I wonder if some of the problem is Eli's plantar fasciaitis. That injury doesn't go away unless it is rested. He hasn't thrown like he usually does since that happened. Favre was great. He handled the whole thing very well, even though I know the jilted girlfriend attitude toward Favre, the GB fans showed a lack of class. Yes, Favre is playing for another team, but it was GB that didn't want him. Favre gave that team a lot of years and great memories. Boo him during the game, but cheer him for the good times when he first steps out on the field. Rogers is never going to come out from under the Favre shadow. That is all on how Green Bay handled the whole mess.
Drax
Interested: In 2 years, I'd take Rodgers. (Farve would be sitting on the couch in Mississippi.) I'm sorry...you think that all Favre can do is "throw hard" -- with no ability to finesse? How fortunate that he has never needed to "finesse" a single pass in his roughly 6,000 completions! It was thoughtful for all those defenses to set things up so that he never had to "finesse" any throws! As to Rodgers...I agree. His O-line is 1/2 newbies. He has to learn along with them. Just as Favre has done...over and over and over...through the years as his O-line corps has changed. It is a LUXURY in today's NFL to have an O-line composed of veterans -- especially veterans who have been on the same team for a while. Maybe by the time RODGERS is a "veteran," he'll have a fully trained O-line? I hope so...I'm still a GB "fan" (to the extent that I'm a "fan" of any team in any sport). He certainly has all the tools, seems to be a leader, and seems to have all the mental tools to be a winner.
Interested
He hasn't completed 6,000 passes this year Drax, Whatever completions he made in the past gives him no yards in a game played on Sunday. Farve's biggest asset is he's Brett Farve, Farve's biggest liability is he's Brett Farve. Especially his last 6 years It's been Brett Farve - (and other guys who wear the same color uniform), against the other side. How much finesse does it take to break a receivers finger? works for one pass, how about pass number 2 to the same guy a few minutes later? There's times when you need to do the play to get a game moving - moments that seem to happen quite a bit to Farve. Why throw when the game winning move is to run it. Is any team there to improve their QB's total yardage or to win games and win the SuperBowl? In this day in age, Rogers is a better QB right now than Farve is right now. If the two men were of the same point in their career's - maybe a different story. But all the stats in the world show that Rogers outperforms Farve - despite being sacked like mad. Rogers (QB Rating #1) - 65.3 % completion, 1989 yards, 2 int. 31 sacks. Farve -(QB Rating #4) - 68.0% completion, 1925 yards, 3 int. 18 sacks. I mean cmon. Farve's Farve, but the proof is in the pudding.
Interested
some more situational stats. Farve's first full year at Packers. Team went 9-7 60.9% completion, 3,300 yards, 14 int, 30 sacks, 14 fumbles Rogers first full year at Packers. Team went 11-5 63.6% completion, 4,038 Yards, 13 int, 34 sacks, 10 fumbles. Rogers is only on year 2.
Drax
Heh, if QB rating were the be-all and end-all of any conversation about the worth of a QB, then Montana wouldn't be in the conversation, would he? (He's #7 all-time, in case you wondered...) Daunte Culpepper outranks Dan Marino, Brett Favre (#17), Roger Staubach, Len Dawson, Troy Aikman, Bart Starr, Fran Tarkenton, John Elway (#48...), John Unitas (#58), & Y.A. Tittle. Should we put him in the hall now? I mean, why wait? His QB rating exceeds, by far, that of Johnny U! Elway ain't a wart on his butt, man! I watched the game. Both games. Favre, in my opinion, FAR exceeded Rodgers in decision making, timely throws, "finesse" and understanding his receivers tendencies and trusting them to make a play. 7-1 to 4-3 (and the one loss would have been a win had Taylor CAUGHT a ball which he should have caught but turned to an interception instead.) 9-7 to 6-10 (with Rodgers having almost the identical team as Favre had -- a team he had studied for THREE YEARS -- compared to Favre on a team he had just joined and where he went 8-3 until his ARM BROKE) Yeah...I'll take Favre...no disrespect to Rodgers who might turn into an excellent QB in the future (see, e.g., CULPEPPER) but hasn't yet...
Drax
Where you get 11-5? Green Bay went 6-10 in 2008. 13-3 with Favre with essentially the same team.
CosmicConservative
I like Rodgers (I think it's "Rodgers" right?) I like Favre too. But if I were an NFL GM and had a pick between Favre and Rodgers, I would take Rodgers. I've just seen Favre throw too many big games away. I'd do it as much to avoid having a heart attack as anything else. To me it's the same argument I've had for years with football fans. I always pick the steady game manager over the flashy arm. (I have a similar reaction to pitchers in baseball.) So given the choice between Dan Marino and Joe Montana? I pick Joe. Roger Staubach and Terry Bradshaw? I pick Roger. Peyton Manning and Tom Brady? I pick... waitaminute, what's up here? Peyton is BOTH a great game manager and a hurler..... Hmm..... I'm a huge Brady fan, but if I really had to make that pick? I might go Peyton.
Interested
First, you cannot begin to compare timely throws unless you want to compare Farve having 5, 6, 7 seconds in the pocket vs Rogers having 3, 4 seconds tops. We can compare the two in any unique situation you'd like to, Rogers is matching Farve in every aspect of the game. The one and only question is - will Rogers have the longevity of NFL's Ironman. If he does - the only record he probably won't beat is the all time interception records. And that's where you are amiss with your comparisons. Farve did this or that, until an injury (which he didn't pull himself out either so it's equally on him). vs Rogers who almost had this or almost had virtually that. You also compare how Farve does with the rest of the Vikings Team with Rogers with the Packers. The only part of the two teams that are roughly equal are their QB's. Taylor dropping the ball is exactly the point. The throw was the wrong call for that point in the game. That's typical Farve. hmm stand corrected on Packers record for 2008. Not sure what I looked at. If Rogers is the #1 rated QB with a team like he has now. Yeah Rogers, any day of the week.
Interested
Yea Rodgers - sorry had about 2 1/2 hrs sleep last night and got another 15 hours to go
Drax
I have no problem with anyone picking Rodgers over Favre. But, I pick Favre over Rodgers. I think my reasons for doing so are superior for your reasons for picking Rodgers. That's sports, folks!