Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

"Birther" case dismissed

By CosmicConservative
A federal judge on Thursday dismissed a lawsuit that claimed Obama is ineligible to be president because he isn't a bona fide U.S. citizen. The lawsuit represented the claim by the so-called "birthers" movement that Obama was not born in Hawaii - despite a birth certificate to the contrary - or that if he was, his citizenship was invalidated by living overseas as a child.
Regular readers of this blog know that I am not dismissive of the claims that Obama may not have been actually born in Hawaii. However regular readers should also know that I don't have any sympathy for the effort to turn that into a claim to remove him from office. His mother was a US Citizen, the only reason this is even remotely a legal technicality is that Obama was born before his mother turned 18, by a few months. What is interesting to me in this dismissal though is that the court very carefully avoided any ruling whatsoever on the merits of the claims that Obama's birth is not adequately documented. The decision rested wholly on the court's claim that it is Congress's job to remove a sitting President, not the courts. I do think that's a significant element to the story that will get no play in the press. Had the courts found the evidence to be lacking, I believe that's what they would have ruled. So, look for this now to become an effort to get Congress to put Obama on trial. Obviously with a large Democrat majority that won't go anywhere, but if Republicans take the majority in 2010, who knows, this may get some legs again.

Comments (60)

Boyd
...this may get some legs again. Which would be a sad commentary on the delusions of these whackos. Lord knows I'm no Obama lover, but to pursue this is evidence of insanity.
CosmicConservative
Boyd: I don't agree that it is evidence of insanity. "Truthers" who believe Bush and Cheney deliberately killed 3,000 American citizens in order to go to war in Iraq are, in my opinion, quite literally insane. I find the "birther" thing to be misguided, but not insane. In my mind it is more or less identical in scope and concept to the Bush "National Guard AWOL" frenzy, which those who pursue are not insane, they're just wasting time and energy.
Drax
Boyd: How is this "insane?" Obama is either a natural born citizen or he is not. That is a constitutional requirement for becoming the President. There certainly is some evidence that, at the time of his birth, he did not meet the requirements to be a natural born citizen. The argument can't be dismissed out of hand as not having any merit. But....the time for this argument was before the election. And, frankly, there is NO time NOW to bring it up...AND there is no VENUE in which to bring it up. I agree with the Judge that it is a "political issue" where the proper venue WOULD HAVE BEEN in Congress (or in the individual states where Obama was ALLOWED to be put on the ballot -- or in the Electoral College where he was ALLOWED to be put on the ballot). But, not now. Congress doesn't have the constitutional POWER to impeach him for THIS. "The President, Vice President and all civil Officers of the United States, shall be removed from Office on Impeachment for, and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery, or other high Crimes and Misdemeanors" None of that here. The ANSWER to the question: "Was Obama eligible to be President" is an important question -- not for getting rid of him, but to ENSURE that such doesn't happen again.
smrstrauss
Re: "The ANSWER to the question: “Was Obama eligible to be President” is an important question — not for getting rid of him, but to ENSURE that such doesn’t happen again." First, Obama was born in Hawaii and has proof of it. Second, the theory that Obama is not eligible due to his father not being a citizen is untrue. The original meaning of Natural Born used at the time of the writing of the Constitution was simply "born in the country." A Natural Born Citizen was a citizen due to her or his birth in the country, just as a Natural Born Subject was someone who was a subject of Britain due to birth in Britian regardless of the number of parents who were subjects. There has never been a Supreme Court case that proved or disproved this definition of Natural Born, but it is clear from the Wong Kim Ark case that the original meaning of Natural Born was "born in the country." McCain did not fulfill this criteria, but it is assumed that he was eligible under an expanded definition of Natural Born that includes both those who were born in the country and those who were born abroad or in a US base of two US parents. To be natural born under the expanded definition, one can be born in the country or of two US parents, but the criteria does not require both.
mtnlurker
I think the courts ruled as they did, Cosmic, because if they had ruled that the evidence was insufficient then the court would be saying that they had jurisdiction. If what they said is accurate then they ruled correctly.
Andy
Cosmic, thanks for calling Birthers "misguided," while defending their sanity. I can't call myself a true "Birther," but I know what I know...and I am almost certain he was born in Kenya. I have thought from Day One that the real damage to be done when it was discovered that Obama is not qualified would be the mass confusion..."what now?" But, the truth is often messy business. I would never want to see a court decide such things, but as Drax said, we need to use this experience to make certain that it will never happen again. I have not read the Judge's ruling. But I understand that one of the deciding factors was "standing." Evidently, the door was left open for Keyes to sue, because he may qualify as one with standing. A blogger that I read addressed this: http://bornagainredneck.blogspot.com/2009/10/final-word-on-birthers.html Personally, I don't want Obama removed as President on a technicality. I want him defanged by the 2010 elections, and defeated in 2012. But, I think I would enjoy some sort of weird satisfaction if the truth of his lies about his birth were revealed. Perhaps the millions who still believe that this guy is straight-up will see how they've been scammed. Maybe it will help them grow up. Probably not. But maybe.
CosmicConservative
Drax: I disagree that Congress could not make an issue of this under the "High Crimes and Misdemeanors" clause. Spiro Agnew resigned the Vice Presidency because he was about to get impeached over a couple thousand dollars in "donations" from a milk supplier that looked like bribes from 20 years earlier. Lying about your citizenship while running for office is, in fact, an actual crime, and would more than qualify for impeachment in my humble opinion. I think it is highly unlikely and I'd rather see Obama impeached over more substantive things like using the power of the Presidency to unilaterally assume control of entire private industries. If that doesn't qualify as "abuse of power" then the phrase really has no meaning. mtnlurker: I might find the "no jurisdiction" argument more compelling if the courts were generally in the business of dismissing cases (such as, oh, Roe v. Wade) based on constitutional jurisdiction limitations. Since the courts routinely assume jurisdiction they do not have (say in California by overturning a completely legal vote against gay marriage) then I'm simply not swayed that in THIS case suddenly a court realized there were actual limits to their powers. I find it much more likely that the argument was advanced simply to allow them to ignore the evidence. Andy: My opinion on the "birther" thing isn't new. I'm sure you've seen me make the same statement before. I've seen the argument on "standing" and frankly I consider it to be a dodge as well. As far as I am concerned every single voter in this country has "standing" in this case since it essentially the job of this government to ensure that the people whose names appear on our ballots are qualified to appear there. I was materially "hurt" if Obama is not qualified, and yet was on that ballot. This appears to be as obvious as the sun in the sky to me.
CosmicConservative
smrstrauss: If Obama has "proof" of being born in Hawaii, he has never provided it. Every statement of every person who has been allowed to view his birth certificate has been curiously legalistic. They say things like "He has a proper birth certificate" or "The certificate satisfies the State Department's standards for proof." Hawaii, at the time of Obama's birth, allowed for at least four kinds of "birth certificates". Only one of them would be what most people assume a "birth certificate" is, which would be a statement, by a doctor, that a child was born, in a hospital, to a particular woman and/or set of parents. If Obama's birth certificate is that sort of birth certificate it is quite odd that nobody has said that, or provided a copy of it. The other three kinds of "birth certificates" allowed in Hawaii at that time ranged from a "midwife" certification of live birth outside of a hospital, to a simple AFTER-THE-FACT signed statement from a parent OR A GRANDPARENT asserting that a birth occurred in the state. That last version was acceptable for up to A YEAR after the birth and only required a county clerk's signature for acceptance. If Obama's birth certificate is of that last variety (which I am almost 100% certain it is) then it provides NO PROOF whatsoever of his live birth in Hawaii. All it proves then is that someone wanted him to have a birth certificate, and signed their name on the form that would allow one to be created. Simply saying "I have a birth certificate" does not prove anything in this case.
smrstrauss
Re: “As far as I am concerned every single voter in this country has “standing” in this case.” If you read the complete case (http://www.scribd.com/doc/21808122/Judge-Carter-Ruling-on-MTD), you will see that the discussion of standing has two wings. First, the person suing has to have been materially affected by something, in a personal way, and second, the court has to be able to rectify the situation. Carter showed that in the case of most of the plaintiffs the personal effect upon them was nebulous. In some of the precedents cited, US citizens sued against the Vietnam War, and the courts ruled that they had no standing to sue because they were not personally and materially affected, On the second wing, the court being able to rectify the situation, Carter shows that unless he has the power to remove a president, which the courts do not have, he does not have the power to rectify, and hence there is no standing to sue. He says that due to the separation of powers principle the courts do not have the power to remove a president. Hence there is no standing to sue.
Drax
smrstrauss: A more perfect "political question" could not be envisioned.
CosmicConservative
Drax and smrstrauss: OK, when Obama's taxes kick in, I'll refuse to pay them and use the argument that since the impact of an Obama election on me personally was determined by the courts to be "nebulous" that I am only obligated to provide a "nebulous" tax amount. As far as the courts being able to remove a President, well, that's probably a completely accurate assessment. That is, in fact, Congress's job. I wish they'd get to it.
mtnlurker
But couldn't the court convict the President of lying. Removal and impeachment are separate from conviction.
CosmicConservative
Yes, I believe the court could do that (but I'm no lawyer). That's actually close to what happened to Clinton, in fact. He was lying about his relationship with Monical Lewinsky in the Paula Jones sexual harrassment civil suit, which was quickly settled out of court once the Blue Dress was discovered. But even if he had been tried and convicted of perjury, he would still be President until Congress impeached and convicted him separately.
smrstrauss
Re: “If Obama has “proof” of being born in Hawaii, he has never provided it. “ Answer: “He has posted and shown to both Polifact and FactCheck the official birth certificate of Hawaii. It is the only birth document that Hawaii currently sends out. ( http://www.starbulletin.com/columnists/kokualine/20090606_kokua_line.html) Re: “Every statement of every person who has been allowed to view his birth certificate has been curiously legalistic. They say things like “He has a proper birth certificate” or “The certificate satisfies the State Department’s standards for proof.” Answer: “The two officials who viewed the birth certificate said that it meant that he was born in Hawaii. (http://www.swamppolitics.com/news/politics/blog/2008/11/obama_hawaaianborn_citizen_for.html) Re: “Hawaii, at the time of Obama’s birth, allowed for at least four kinds of “birth certificates”. Only one of them would be what most people assume a “birth certificate” is, which would be a statement, by a doctor, that a child was born, in a hospital, to a particular woman and/or set of parents.” Answer: ALL the other kinds, the three other kinds, required a delay of a month to a year or more before they could be filed. We know that there was no such delay because of the notices in the newspapers that were sent out for births in Hawaii by the government of Hawaii. These appeared in the newspapers within ten days after Obama’s birth, so there could be no delay. In addition, there is this witness, who recalls being told of his birth in Hawaii in 1961. (http://www.buffalonews.com/494/story/554495.html) The Wall Street Journal commented: "Obama has already provided a legal birth certificate demonstrating that he was born in Hawaii. No one has produced any serious evidence to the contrary. Absent such evidence, it is unreasonable to deny that Obama has met the burden of proof. We know that he was born in Honolulu as surely as we know that Bill Clinton was born in Hope, Ark., or George W. Bush in New Haven, Conn." (http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970204619004574320190095246658.html)
Andy
mtnlurker poses a good question. I'm too ignorant to know the answer...but it is a good question. I do not know the arguments presented on each side, nor whether in the arguments BozObama states firmly that he was definitely born in Hawaii. But if he did, he would certainly be deceiving the court. Ooooohhhhhh...he might get his law license suspended...like Bubba did by the Arkansas Supreme Court!!! I'm sure he'll lose a lot of sleep over not being able to practice law for a few years. Early on in the "birther" movement, I thought that it was important. When a Dem. Philadelphia lawyer took it seriously during the campaign (a Hillary supporter btw), it got my attention. It's really not important to me now...except for the normal human tendency to say, "I TOLD YOU SO!" After three+ years of watching this guy, I know without a doubt that he is the biggest liar I have ever seen. I'll bet he's married to Morgan Fairchild, and feeds the Untouchables of Calcutta with his own hands. He can turn tobacco into H1N1 vaccine, and make the lion lay down with the lamb. I do believe that every American has "standing," as we have all been harmed by this lying African...our Constitution being violated, etc. But then again, we've been harmed by "natural born" citizens, too.
Boyd
The rejection of concrete, physical evidence is sufficiently close to insane for me to call birthers insane. Their rejection of reality qualifies them as such. Sorry, folks, but I has to call 'em as I see 'em.
Drax
Boyd, Boyd, Boyd... Please provide "concrete, physical evidence" which conclusively supports that Obama was born in Hawaii. Ummmm.... It might exist. If it does, it hasn't been released. Might it be "insane" to accept as conclusive something which isn't? Just sayin...
Interested
True or not, if the GOP gains the house and/or Senate (which I hope they do). It'd be a costly mistake for them to pursue it. General voting public dislikes messy politics.
Drax
As we learned to our chagrin by the Clinton impeachment.
CosmicConservative
smrstrauss: I'm not convinced. But as I have said repeatedly, I don't care. The mere fact that his mother was a US citizen and he would have been a US citizen if born on Mars if his birth had been a few months later is fine with me. But I'm not convinced by your "evidence" even with the Wall Street Journal's editorial board statement. The Wall Street Journal has a vested interest in distancing themselves from "birthers" That's why the Wall Street Journal led the way for the "intellectual right" in savaging Sarah Palin. I read the Wall Street Journal, but sometimes they do the same thing the NY Times does, and print what they think makes them look good to the east coast "intellectuals" who send out dinner party invitations.
smrstrauss
Let's suppose that some president, say Gerald Ford, was born in a place that did not have good records for its birth certificates. Say that he was born in Michigan, and that his city, say Flint, had messed up its birth certificate files. Would that mean that Ford was born in Canada? No. To make someone believe that he was born outside the country requires you to show BOTH that the records are faulty and that he was born in the other country. Now in the case of Obama we have the official certificate, and the confirmation of the officials. Both say flat out that he was born in Hawaii. We have the newspaper notices of his birth, and we have the witness who recalls being told of his birth. On the out-of-Hawaii side we have nothing. Or, I should be more clear, nothing that was not made up. The claim that his grandmother said that he was born in Kenya was made up. She actually said that he was born in Hawaii, and it is on tape. Listen to the complete tape, and you will hear her say "America, Hawaii" right after she is asked "Whereabouts was he born." Here is the complete recording on Berg’s site. Be sure to listen for at least five minutes until the question is asked. (http://obamacrimes.com/Telephone_Interview_with_Sarah_Hussein_Obama_10-16-08.mp3) If it is too difficult to listen to the complete tape, here is a transcript (http://www.obamaconspiracy.org/wp-content/uploads/2009/03/obamatranscriptlulu109.pdf). Then there is the shear improbability of Obama's mother going to Kenya when she was pregnant. Yellow Fever was endemic in Africa in those days, and a Yellow Fever shot is risky during pregnancy. Virtually all airlines in those days refused to carry pregnant women, and not merely late in term, but in the seventh and eighth month, because of the risk of stillbirths. So, when pregnant women wanted to travel, they usually waited until they delivered. I saw a movie made in 1963 the other night, and it showed the regular plane from Washington DC to New York. The plane had PROPELLERS. Yet, we are supposed to believe that Obama's mother took the long trip via Tokyo or via New York and London to see relatives that she could also see after she had given birth. Then, she is supposed to have given birth in Kenya, not have been proud of that fact (which is strange because an anthropologist WOULD have been proud of that fact) and somehow smuggled Obama back to Hawaii, where she convinced the officials that her son was born in Hawaii, and kept quiet about having given birth in Hawaii for the rest of her life. To have gone to Hawaii is unlikely because of the distance, the Yellow Fever shot and the general risk of stillbirth. To have gone, given birth, and not admitted it, is even more unlikely. To have gone, given birth, not admitted it, and somehow convinced the officials that the child was born in Hawaii, makes the chances extraordinarily slight. Virtually nil. NOw, let's imagine a child born in Kenya and the things that would have to be done to get that child to Hawaii. Do you think that the USA would allow a Kenya-born black child into the USA without some kind of travel document? Not today, and not in 1961 when there were a large number of white southerners working for the State Department. So, what would have been needed to let the child in? He would have needed a US travel document of some kind. If he was considered Kenyan/British by the US authorities (which is most likely), then he would need a British passport and a US visa on it. If he were considered a US citizen, then he would need either his own new passport, issued in Kenya, or a revision to his mother's US passport to include him. If any of those things had happened, there would be a record in the State Department files. Not the passport files. The files of visas issued and passports issued in Kenya in 1961, and there would be copies in the State Department records in Washington. No such document has surfaced. So, in addition, to the improbability of his mother going to Kenya. The improbability of doing it and also not acknowledging it. The improbability of all that plus convincing the Hawaii authorities of birth in Hawaii, somehow she did all that without getting US documents to get the kid to the USA. The absence of Kenya documents also is a problem. To be sure, there have been repeated forgeries, the latest by a convicted felon (http://www.wnd.com/index.php?fa=PAGE.view&pageId=108005). Birthers explain the lack of Kenyan documents as being caused by the Kenyan government being part of the conspiracy. This is possible. But is is very difficult to seal all documents. For example, the records of arrivals at Kenya's airports in 1961 would show the arrival and departure of Obama's mother and the child. For this to have been sealed, all the arrival/departure records for that period would have had to have been sealed, or it would be possible for a reader to spot the omission. You do not like the editorial page of the Wall Street Journal. How about the National Review? It said: "The theory that Obama was born in Kenya, that he was smuggled into the U.S., and that his parents somehow hoodwinked Hawaiian authorities into falsely certifying his birth in Oahu, is crazy stuff." http://article.nationalreview.com/?q=ZmJhMzlmZWFhOTQ3YjUxMDE2YWY4ZDMzZjZlYTVmZmU=&w=MA I quoted the National Review and the Wall Street Journal as a cogent way of making the point that Obama has shown an official birth certificate and that the Kenya story is both unproven and implausible. I do not quote them as authorities. They simply summarize the facts shown above.
CosmicConservative
Heh. "Crazy stuff." Tell me smrstrauss, what's your opinion on Bush's National Guard service records? I assume you also know that John McCain's citizenship was a major source of discussion on Daily KOS and Huffpo during the election and we'd likely see exactly the same sorts of lawsuits from the Left had he won. Is that all crazy stuff too?
smrstrauss
Re: "Tell me smrstrauss, what’s your opinion on Bush’s National Guard service records?" What has that got to do with the discussion of whether Obama was born in Hawaii? Re: "assume you also know that John McCain’s citizenship was a major source of discussion on Daily KOS and Huffpo during the election." It being a free country they are entitled to discuss. You also are entitled to discuss Obama's citizenship. The fact that someone discusses something does not mean that what they say is true. Because the left wing thought it was of interest to them to raise questions about McCain's citizenship, you can do the same thing with Obama. BUT just because that motive is rational does not make the facts you discuss true. There is a slight difference between the Natural Born status of McCain and Obama. Obama falls under the original definition of Natural Born, born in the country. McCain falls under the expanded definition, born outside of the country to two US parents (and in his case, born to two US parents inside a US naval base). Most Constitutional scholars hold that both of these are valid, but there is somewhat more doubt about the expanded definition. Moreover, the discussion you refer to was during the election, before election day, when it is legitimate to raise the issue whether a candidate has too much dandruff to be president. Yes, citizenship and Natural Born status are more important than dandruff, of course. I'm just saying that the motive to raise these issues before an election is strong and natural, after the election is over, that is a different matter.
CosmicConservative
smrstrauss: Surely you realize that the discussion of Obama's birth was also before election day. The "birther" argument is that the press ignored legitimate concerns about Obama's birth and as such we now have doubt about his actual citizenship. I'm not a "birther" anyway, so I'm no longer going to present their arguments to you. If you really want to get into a "birther" argument there are no doubt plenty of blogs you can go and do so. I've said from the beginning that I simply don't think "birthers" are "insane." Not like "truthers" are "insane." They are misguided like the Bush National Guard AWOL liberals are misguided. That's the point I've been making. Not that the "birthers" are "right" but that their particular brand of obsession is more comparable to the eight-year-long fetish on the left with Bush's supposedly being AWOL from the ANG with no proof whatsoever of it. That's why it's relevant. However, I do hope you hand around smrstrauss, I have appreciated your ability to discuss this issue without resorting to insults and demagoguery.
Drax
Heh...."insane" not being too big of an insult, I suppose.... CC: I agree. I'm "unconvinced" of Obama's birth status. I'm also uncaring personally and unsympathetic in general. Whatever truth there is to the citizenship claim against Obama, it is not only misguided, but counterproductive to Republican aims, giving the increasingly irrelevant media ammunition to hammer "conservatives" with to their ever diminishing audience, an audience who laps up the ravings of sportscasters and comedians as their "news."
Interested
frankly I'm amazed at the levels of energy expended from Birthers (which so far has been less than the Bush Guard duty and far less than the McCain citizenship ones). IMO - I like to focus on tangibles. #44 gives plenty of cannon fodder to use against the misguided feeling the left had for any so-called mandate. Not to mention he gives us more than sufficient proof that progressives = good progress for America.
Interested
er meant to say more levels of energy had been expended on birthers than mccain - but less than the National Guard.
Tom DeGisi
smrstrauss has been a genteel debater. I commend him as well. He hasn't kept up with the National Review on this subject. Current speculation is that Obama was born in Hawaii, but that there is something embarassing on his birth certificate. For example, maybe his given name is Barry, not Barack. Sounds very plausible, and no conspiracy required. Yours, Tom DeGisi
Drax
Tom: I find the notion that there's "something" which might be untoward on the One's birth certificate to be possible. There is no reason to continue to allow this issue to fester when it could be so easily resolved -- IF the "proof" actually is proof of citizenship and not something else.
CosmicConservative
Yeah, I've seen the speculation that the actual birth certificate doesn't cast doubt on his residency but reveals something else embarrassing that Obama wishes to hide. I find that plausible as well.
smrstrauss
Re: "That’s why it’s relevant." It's only relevant if it is true. For the birther nonsense to be true, there have to be facts showing both that Obama was born outside of the USA and that the Hawaii birth certificate plus the confirmation of the facts by the officials, plus the notices in the newspapers, plus the witness who recalls being told of his birth--are all false. One reason that Obama does not show his original birth certificate is that he does not have it. He cannot show it if he does not have it, and Hawaii sends out only the Certification of Live Birth. (http://www.starbulletin.com/columnists/kokualine/20090606_kokua_line.html). The next reason, is that the Certification is the official document, and hence is legally sufficient to prove his birth. The third, as the Wall Street Journal points out, is that IF he could get the original, and showed it, he would be giving birthers respect that they do not deserve. Re: "current speculation." Yes, that is what it is, total speculation. Not a fact involved in it. As the Wall Street Journal commented: "What are we to conclude about someone who refuses to accept an official state birth certificate as proof of birth but expects us to accept utterly preposterous theories with no documentary evidence whatever?" (http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970204619004574322281597739634.html)
CosmicConservative
smr: So, you ignored all my questions, misunderstood or misrepresented what I was calling "relevant" and then repeated the same arguments as before. I stand by my statement that the birther argument is at least as plausible as the Bush ANG AWOL "story" that was chased relentlessly by every liberal media organization in this country, to the absurd point that one actually made up crap to try to "prove" it. Again, I'd like to hear if you think the "ANG AWOL" people (up to and including Dan Rather and every major media anchor who covered the story while ignoring the "birther" story) are as crazy as the "birthers" are. If you don't think they are, please point out how the ANG AWOL story has more facts and documentation than the birther story. The reality of the situation is that if the ANG AWOL story deserved front page attention from the NY Times, Wash Post, CBS, NBC, CNN etc... then the birther story deserves just as much attention. If the birther story is nonsense and people treating it as plausible are insane, then by that same logic you've just called virtually the entire media culture in this country insane for giving the ANG AWOL story the attention it got. I'm good with that. Are you? If not, as I said, demonstrate how the ANG AWOL story was more plausible than the birther story. If you can't, and you won't call Rather, Jennings, Brokaw, Couric, Matthews, et. al. "insane" as you call birthers, then you pretty much have no credibility on such issues. Again, that's why it's relevant. Sauce for the goose, sauce for the gander. So put up or shut up. Is the entirety of the mainstream media insane, or are the birthers rational? It's one or the other.
smrstrauss
Re: "then the birther story deserves just as much attention." The media has given the birther story some attention. The Wall Street Journal for example wrote: "Further, if Congress were to pass the so-called birther bill, Obama would be able to comply easily. The bill would require presidential campaigns to submit “a copy of the candidate’s birth certificate” to the Federal Election Commission. The certificate Obama has released publicly would meet this requirement." And, it concluded: "Obama has already provided a legal birth certificate demonstrating that he was born in Hawaii. No one has produced any serious evidence to the contrary. Absent such evidence, it is unreasonable to deny that Obama has met the burden of proof. We know that he was born in Honolulu as surely as we know that Bill Clinton was born in Hope, Ark., or George W. Bush in New Haven, Conn." The birthers are not rational to believe that Obama was born in Kenya and his parents managed to get the child to the USA without any US travel document showing up. The USA required then, and requires now, either a US passport (or that the child be entered on his mother's passport) or a US Visa on a foreign passport. Either of those would have had to have happened in Kenya just after Obama was born, and any of those would continue to be on file in the US State Department. It is the conjunction of the absence of official documents (except for forgeries) from Kenya and from the US State Department showing birth in Kenya, and the presence of an official birth certificate, the facts on which have been twice confirmed by the officials in Hawaii, that make the birther theory insane. And part of this insanity is the constant willingness to believe in any document that shows up. The latest "Kenya birth certificate" is an obvious forgery, as WND shows, (http://www.wnd.com/index.php?fa=PAGE.view&pageId=108005). Yet when WDN debunked the forgery, birthers said that WND had let the side down. Then, there is the "Obama has spent $1.7 million defending suits" baloney. The answer to that is when someone files lawsuits against you, you have to defend or lose. The vast bulk of those case were to stop the election last year. The bulk of the remaining cases were to stop the Electoral College, stop the certification of the election or stop the Inauguration. Re: "Is the entirety of the mainstream media insane, or are the birthers rational? It’s one or the other." The entirety of the mainstream media is NOT insane. Birthers are NOT rational.
CosmicConservative
smr: I'm starting to think you aren't serious in this discussion. Do you truly think a single editorial in the WSJ is comparable to months, even YEARS of the mainstream media HAMMERING on the ANG AWOL story? Are you kidding me? Please, be serious. You completely ignored my request to show how the ANG AWOL story had more legitimacy than the birther story. You pretend that a few editorials here and there are comparable to YEARS of constant hammering ending up with a major news organization LITERALLY MAKING SHIT UP to try to make a story out of nothing. You are very much invited to stay and post here, but I no longer consider your opinion on the birther issue to be credible. You won't respond to direct questions, you make laughable comparisons in order to avoid a clear logical conclusion. But, that's nothing new on the interwebz.
smrstrauss
Re: "You completely ignored my request to show how the ANG AWOL story had more legitimacy than the birther story. You pretend that a few editorials here and there are comparable to YEARS of constant hammering ending up with a major news organization LITERALLY MAKING SHIT UP to try to make a story out of nothing." The fact that Bush was not proven to have been AWOL does not mean that Obama was born in Kenya. I failed to comment on your AWOL story because I could not understand how it could be relevant. The MSM commented in great detail about Whitewater and the sexual doings of Clinton. It commented on the AWOL allegations, but it considered it stupid to publish the allegation that Obama was born in Kenya if there was no evidence that Obama was born in Kenya. In fact, there may have been dozens or scores of reliable MSM newspapers who looked into the Kenya story. They may well have asked their stringers in Kenya to look at the files, and they never published anything. Why not? Because it is not news that they did not find anything. The fact that they could not find anything in Kenya merely confirms the official documents that Obama was born in Hawaii. And, it is not news that he was born in Hawaii. He said it, the COLB said it, the two officials said it, the newspaper announcements said it, this witness said it (http://www.buffalonews.com/494/story/554495.html).
Drax
Wow -- not even close to addressing the issue. The "AWOL" story ran in every major MSM outlet, print, television, internet for years without a SHRED OF PROOF of its validity, going so far, as Cosmic said to "make shit up" and say that the story was true even if the facts weren't. The Whitewater story was FORCED into the MSM after YEARS of the MSM running interference for Clinton and his cronies. It took years and years of investigation (and cover by the MSM and democratic cronies) before Starr sent recommendations to Congress to IMPEACH CLINTON because of his alleged perjury in the Whitewater investigation. (What? Clinton commit PERJURY? Who woulda thunk?) 14 people were convicted of 40 crimes as a result of the Whitewater investigation (including the sitting Governor of Arkansas, Jim Guy Tucker). The MSM, on the other hand, has not only ignored the "birther" controversy, but has DEMEANED any who advances it (rather than advancing it themselves as they did with the "AWOL" story). There is MORE "PROOF" of the "birther" theory than the "AWOL" theory. In the "AWOL" theory, ALL EVIDENCE pointed to it not being true. In the "birther" theory, evidence EXISTS which could prove or refute it, but it has not been released. When evidence which could prove or refute a theory EXISTS but the person who the evidence affects DOES NOT PRESENT IT, one logical conclusion is that HE HAS SOMETHING TO HIDE. Logic leads to a possible "birther" issue. Evidence EXISTS which could prove or disprove it, but that evidence will not be released. The OPPOSITE was true in the "AWOL" issue. The evidence EXISTED and was RELEASED, but the press didn't BELIEVE the evidence so had to CREATE some to support the story. Sheesh. Why it's necessary to post this befuddles me.
CosmicConservative
Drax: I guess it's necessary because smrstrauss likes to accuse those he disagrees with of being insane while exhibiting very similar traits himself. The logical conclusion to the question of why smr won't address the issues I've raised is because he CAN'T. Not without proving my point. "O wad power the giftie gie us, to see ourseles as others see us."
smrstrauss
Re: "Evidence EXISTS which could prove or disprove it, but that evidence will not be released." You say that, but in fact the evidence has been released. It is the official birth certificate of Hawaii, the facts on which have been confirmed twice by the officials in Hawaii. It is the notices in the newspapers on the weekend after the birth, which were sent out by the government of Hawaii for births in Hawaii (and not for births outside of Hawaii). There is even this witness who recalls being told of Obama's birth in Hawaii in 1961 (http://www.buffalonews.com/494/story/554495.html) The Wall Street Journal commented: "Obama has already provided a legal birth certificate demonstrating that he was born in Hawaii. No one has produced any serious evidence to the contrary. Absent such evidence, it is unreasonable to deny that Obama has met the burden of proof. We know that he was born in Honolulu as surely as we know that Bill Clinton was born in Hope, Ark., or George W. Bush in New Haven, Conn. The release of the obsolete birth certificate would not “resolve the issue” to those for whom it is not already resolved. They claim without basis that today’s birth certificate is a fake; there is nothing to stop them from claiming without basis that yesterday’s is as well. The president would gain nothing politically for his trouble. By acknowledging the birthers’ demands, he would lend them a modicum of credibility."
CosmicConservative
smrstrauss: How does repeating the same tired argument three times increase your credibility? The fact is that Obama has NOT released his birth certificate. That is a fact. Why he has not done so is open to speculation. The fact that he has left it open to speculation is also a FACT. The question is WHY? It is, as Drax and I have repeatedly told you, a RATIONAL, LOGICAL conclusion to reach to say "there is something on that document Obama does not want public." You can throw as much mud at the wall as you like hoping something will stick. The FACT is that this is MORE than the anti-Bush brigade EVER HAD on Bush's supposed AWOL story. Bush and the DoD RELEASED everything they had, including Bush's performance evaluations during that period. The left MANUFACTURED out of WHOLE CLOTH a "story" about Bush being AWOL, with ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to suggest it was true, and ALL THE RELEVANT DOCUMENTS PUBLICLY RELEASED which refuted it. The FACT is that the birther situation is not the same. ALL THE RELEVENT DOCUMENTS have NOT been publicly released. Your final statement is the most revealing because it is flat out laughably wrong. IF there is nothing embarrassing on his birth certificate then he has PLENTY to gain from releasing it. Not the least of which is removing a distraction from his plate. The fact that he DOESN'T is pretty compelling evidence that HE HAS SOMETHING TO LOSE if he does release it. What is that something? I dunno, but I gotta conclude it's something Obama doesn't want us to know. And besides, you continue to argue as if the issue here is whether Obama was born in Hawaii. The ISSUE here is that you claim birthers are "insane" and I have provided compelling evidence that if they are, then so is the entire left side of the political spectrum including the vast majority of the mainstream media for pursuing a LESS PLAUSIBLE story about Bush being AWOL for EIGHT FRICKIN' YEARS, to the point that a supposed "News organization" literally MADE SHIT UP to run a story, which effectively destroyed their credibility entirely. So again, either admit that birthers are as rational as the entire mainstream media and virtually every Democrat in the nation was five years ago, when Bush AWOL stories ran every day in the news, or admit that the mainstream media and virtually every Democrat in the country is as insane as the "birthers." I'm done with this, you won't address the real point because you know you can't. Your continued hypocrisy on the subject is quite revealing. I could make similar arguments about many of the Sarah Palin "stories" that ran in the news with ZERO evidence but which Democrats sucked up like parched sponges. Birthers are misguided, but they have far more support for their claims than Democrats and the media ever had for Bush being AWOL, or for a variety of vicious stories about Sarah Palin that MANY DEMOCRATS still believe to be true to this day.
smrstrauss
Re: "How does repeating the same tired argument three times increase your credibility?" Same to you. You are repeating that he has not released his birth certificate. However, he HAS released his birth certificate, the official birth certificate of Hawaii, the only birth certificate that Hawaii currently sends out. Re: "The fact that he DOESN’T is pretty compelling evidence that HE HAS SOMETHING TO LOSE if he does release it." He cannot release the original if he DOESN'T HAVE the original. He has what Hawaii sent him, the Certification of Live Birth, which is what it sends to everyone. The National Review Commented: "The fundamental fiction is that Obama has refused to release his “real” birth certificate. This is untrue. The document that Obama has made available is the document that Hawaiian authorities issue when they are asked for a birth certificate. There is no secondary document cloaked in darkness, only the state records that are used to generate birth certificates when they are requested. If one applies for a United States passport, the passport office will demand a birth certificate. It defines this as an official document bearing “your full name, the full name of your parent(s), date and place of birth, sex, date the birth record was filed, and the seal or other certification of the official custodian of such records.” The Hawaiian birth certificate President Obama has produced—the document is formally known as a “certificate of live birth”—bears that information. It has been inspected by reporters, and several state officials have confirmed that the information in permanent state records is identical to that on the president’s birth certificate—which is precisely what one expects, of course, since the state records are used to generate those documents when they are requested. In other words, what President Obama has produced is the “real” birth certificate of myth and lore. The director of Hawaii’s health department and the registrar of records each has personally verified that the information on Obama’s birth certificate is identical to that in the state’s records, the so-called vault copy." As for birthers being insane, you say they are. I see no evidence of it. As the National Review concluded: "The theory that Obama was born in Kenya, that he was smuggled into the U.S., and that his parents somehow hoodwinked Hawaiian authorities into falsely certifying his birth in Oahu, is crazy stuff." http://article.nationalreview.com/?q=ZmJhMzlmZWFhOTQ3YjUxMDE2YWY4ZDMzZjZlYTVmZmU=&w=MA
CosmicConservative
Hmm... smrstrauss, I see I conflated your argument with Boyd's assertion that birthers are "insane". You merely called them "not rational." I suppose that's not quite the same as calling them "insane." I stand by my comparison of birthers to ANG AWOLers and Sarah Palin conspirators. My issue in this whole debate is not whether birthers are "right" but whether they are being unfairly attacked, frequently by the same people who have shown themselves to be AT LEAST equally irrational on similar, if ideologically reversed, issues. And I stand by my statement that your unwillingness to admit this is evidence of some level of hypocrisy.
Drax
"The so-called 'vault copy.'" Um... Right there. Dur....
smrstrauss
Re: "not whether birthers are “right” but whether they are being unfairly attacked." An old expression is that "two wrongs do not make a right." So, if the MSM were to say "the world is flat," does that make it right for you to also say "the world is flat?' Thus, if the MSM was wrong on the AWOL, it does not make you right to say "Obama was born in Kenya" unless he was born in Kenya. Moreover, when people say that they do not believe that Obama was born in Kenya, and that the birthers are nevertheless right to say it, is only to say that the birthers have the right to their opinion--which I agree with--but it is not to say that they are factually right. We have mainly been discussing the question of whether the birthers are factually right. Are they being unfairly attacked? Well, if they are factually wrong, it is not unfair to say so. Is it unfair to point out the facts that substantiate Obama's birth in Hawaii, and the lack of facts that he was born in Kenya? No. Is it unfair to point out that the Kenya theory does not explain how IF a child was born in Kenya and got to the USA how that child traveled without a US travel document? Is it unfair to point out, that in the unlikely event that that happened (Kenya birth plus return without a travel document) the family would still have been traveling on a plane or ship, where they most likely would have been seen, and to then file documents that (in this scenario) lied and said that Obama was born in Hawaii? The latter would be risky, since people would have seen the child on a ship or a plane, and the claim that he was born in Hawaii could be challenged, and it is likely to be illegal to file a false document. AND for filing a false document a foreign student in the USA on a student visa could be deported. And, as the National Review says, to believe this myth, you still have to believe that Obama's parents filed a false birth registration and got away with it. The myth also requires you to believe that the Hawaiian authorities and the Kenyan authorities are part of a vast conspiracy. It is easier to believe in Santa Claus.
CosmicConservative
"We have mainly been discussing the question of whether the birthers are factually right." No, smr, YOU have been discussing that. My original comment and my focus all along has been that birthers are at least as rational and reasonable as those who pursued the Bush AWOL story, a group which included virtually every liberal with a pulse, including the vast majority of the mainstream media. As I said, I'm done.
Drax
Dur... He says: "Birthers are insane." We say: "Misguided, but not insane. Some evidence (or the failure to provide conclusive evidence) exists to support their claim." He says: "I'm going to argue that the birthers are wrong. Here let me prove that they're wrong while ignoring the single, salient fact, i.e., the "vault copy" has not been released." We say: If you're going to call "birthers" insane, then you have to call those who believed in the "AWOL" theory insane as there was even less evidence to support that theory than there is to support the "birther" theory. In fact, all evidence was released (at Bush's order) to disprove the theory and the MSM STILL pursued the theory -- going so far as to "make shit up" in an attempt to prove the correctness of the story. He says: "I'm not going to accept that the two are anything alike. After all, both are just theories accepted as true by some people, without any evidence to back them up, because they are detrimental to a President they oppose. They don't have anything in common whatsoever." We say: "Durrrrrrr...."
smrstrauss
Drax said: "There certainly is some evidence that, at the time of his birth, he did not meet the requirements to be a natural born citizen." I replied with the facts. Drax now says: "(or the failure to provide conclusive evidence)" I reply now that the evidence IS conclusive. There are official documents whose facts are confirmed on the Hawaii side. There is no evidence on the Kenya side. We at least were discussing the facts.
CosmicConservative
smr: The conclusive "fact" remains in the vault. Nobody here has said that there is anything in Kenya. Nobody here has said anything but "there must be something embarrassing on the vault copy or it would be public by now." You have spent hours and pages of text repeating completely irrelevant information that is only conclusive to YOU. You have repeatedly misrepresented the arguments presented here and ignored the points you can't rebut. You are either deliberately disingenuous or unable to comprehend what we are saying. Since you seem pretty bright, I have to assume you are deliberately disingenuous. And I really hate that, it's so sophomoric. We know you believe it. What we don't understand is why you think repeating the same thing five times makes it any more relevant to the actual discussion than it was the first time.
Drax
smr: In a court of law, when there exist evidence which could prove/disprove a material fact and that evidence is within the control of a party and that party does not present it, then the finder of fact (judge or jury) may conclude (and may be INSTRUCTED to conclude) that the "missing evidence" would PROVE the material fact as argued by the opposing side. The reason for this rule is simple: When one side has control over evidence which is material to a case and FAILS TO PRESENT IT, it has the potential to pervert justice, i.e., prevent the finder of fact from viewing all material evidence before rendering its verdict. In such a case, the person withholding the evidence is PUNISHED by the court by instructing the jury that, had the evidence been presented, IT WOULD PROVE THE MATERIAL FACT that the opposing side argues it would prove. In this case, the "missing evidence" is the "vault copy" of the birth certificate. It would contain such things as who the father was, the given name of the child, who provided the information as to the time/place of the child's birth, and which of Hawaii's several methods of obtaining a birth certificate was the one used. Obama can have that "vault copy" available for public examination. ONLY Obama can have that "vault copy" made available for public examination. Since he does NOT, that is "evidence" which any RATIONAL person could conclude (and a jury might be instructed TO conclude) that one or more bits of information on that birth certificate would be detrimental to the President ELSE HE WOULD RELEASE THE DOCUMENT(S). I haven't a clue whether there is any "damning information" on those documents. All I do know is that there ARE some documents, they are in the EXCLUSIVE (legal) control of Obama, and that, if they were released to the public, they potentially could prove or disprove every material fact in this "controversy," and that Obama WILL NOT authorize or demand the release of those documents. While there may not be anything in those documents, the failure to release them is "some evidence" to support the "birthers" argument -- which, of course, is what I have stated. Apparently, you think that, since the ONE DOCUMENT which could prove or disprove the "birthers'" case hasn't been released, then the WITHHOLDING of "evidence" translates into the LACK of "evidence." It does not. So, we're back to... Durrrr.....
smrstrauss
Re: "In a court of law, when there exist evidence which could prove/disprove a material fact and that evidence is within the control of a party and that party does not present it, then the finder of fact (judge or jury) may conclude (and may be INSTRUCTED to conclude) that the “missing evidence” would PROVE the material fact as argued by the opposing side." Total baloney. None of this is right. No judge would ever say that if one side did not present evidence the case goes to the other side. Moreover, by far most of these cases were not for the birth certificate. They were to stop the election or stop the Electoral College or stop the Inauguration. Re: "All I do know is that there ARE some documents, they are in the EXCLUSIVE (legal) control of Obama." We do NOT know that. We know that Hawaii does not send out the original birth certificate to anyone. (http://www.starbulletin.com/columnists/kokualine/20090606_kokua_line.html) Re: "ONE DOCUMENT which could prove or disprove the “birthers’” case hasn’t been released, then the WITHHOLDING of “evidence” translates into the LACK of “evidence.” My point is that the birthers have to show two things, that there is something wrong with the official birth certificate AND that there is evidence that he was born outside of the country. There is nothing wrong with the official birth certificate, and the only allegations that he was born outside of the country were either forged or manipulated by birthers (such as saying that Obama's grandmother said that he was born in Kenya, when he was born in Hawaii.) Moreover, every time a forged document appears or a old Kenyan newspaper's mistake is published, the birthers think it is equivalent to having found a cure for cancer.
Drax
Are you a lawyer? I am. In EVERY jurisdiction the rules of discovery are clear: If one side requests documents which are in the possession of the other side and the other side does not produce them without proper cause (privilege, work product, whatever) then the rules of discovery allow the judge to rule that the requested material would have proven the "material fact" (not the CASE -- just the "material fact" which may or may NOT prove the "case") had it been provided. As to your notion that the Hawaiian government doesn't send the original document to "anyone," that's BS. ANY person with standing has the absolute right to petition the government for those documents (which DO exist as per YOUR post, and, of course by the statements of the Hawaiian representative who claims to have "seen" them). But, the ONLY person(s) who would have such a course of action would be: Obama, his parents, and, when of age, his children (for medical reasons). Obama could easily file a lawsuit against the Hawaiian government to produce his birth certificate (perhaps even a Writ of Mandamus) in the event he requested it and they would not release it to him. So, really... if you're going to talk legal stuff...do some research. Louisiana Code of Civil Procedure Article 1471: "Art. 1471. Failure to comply with order compelling discovery; sanctions A. If a party or an officer, director, or managing agent of a party or a person designated under Article 1442 or 1448 to testify on behalf of a party fails to obey an order to provide or permit discovery, including an order made under Article 1464 or Article 1469, the court in which the action is pending may make such orders in regard to the failure as are just, and among others any of the following: (1) An order that the matters regarding which the order was made or any other designated facts shall be taken to be established for the purposes of the action in accordance with the claim of the party obtaining the order." Rule 37, Federal Rules of Civil Procedure: "(b) Failure To Comply With Order. (1) Sanctions by Court in District Where Deposition Is Taken. If a deponent fails to be sworn or to answer a question after being directed to do so by the court in the district in which the deposition is being taken, the failure may be considered a contempt of that court. (2) Sanctions by Court in Which Action Is Pending. If a party or an officer, director, or managing agent of a party or a person designated under Rule 30 (b)(6) or 31 (a) to testify on behalf of a party fails to obey an order to provide or permit discovery, including an order made under subdivision (a) of this rule or Rule 35, or if a party fails to obey an order entered under Rule 26 (f), the court in which the action is pending may make such orders in regard to the failure as are just, and among others the following: (A) An order that the matters regarding which the order was made or any other designated facts shall be taken to be established for the purposes of the action in accordance with the claim of the party obtaining the order;" Every jurisdiction has similar provisions for the reasons I set forth in my last post.
smrstrauss
Re: "If one side requests documents which are in the possession of the other side and the other side does not produce them without proper cause (privilege, work product, whatever) then the rules of discovery allow the judge to rule that the requested material would have proven the “material fact” (not the CASE — just the “material fact” which may or may NOT prove the “case”) had it been provided." I was under the impression that you were saying that if one side did not provide evidence in court, then the judge would say that the absence of evidence shows that that side lost its case, which would have to be given to the other side. IF a court case existed and a court had ordered discovery and the plaintiffs asked for certain documents and the defendants said that the could not provide them because they did not have them, then the judge would not order a damn thing. What we have is (1) NO existing case, hence no discovery; (2) no order of discovery ever made; (3) IF a court had ordered discovery, and the plaintiffs had asked for the ORIGINAL birth certificate, the defendants could reply that they do not have it; (4) If the defendants say under oath that they do not have it, then the count will either (a) accept the OFFICIAL birth certificate as legally sufficient, or (b) ask Hawaii to provide the original birth certificate. The latter action is unlikely, but if it were to occur, it would show exactly what the OFFICIAL birth certificate has already shown, that Obama was born in Hawaii in 1961. So your analogy with discovery does not hold.
Drax
Start again... LOL! The LOGIC behind the discovery rules in EVERY JURISDICTION stands, i.e., when one side has evidence which could be material to the case then the other side has every reason to believe that the reason for withholding it is because what producing it would reveal would be harmful to its case, HOLDS. Well, in my universe, anyway...
smrstrauss
Re: "The LOGIC behind the discovery." This has nothing to do with discovery. There has never been a discovery ruling. If there had been a discovery ruling and the judge said that plaintiffs had to produce a specific document, then if the didn't that would apply. But this is not the case, and it has never been. Moreover, if a judge were to ask the plaintiffs to produce a particular document, and they replied that they did not have it, then that would be a different matter entirely. Re: "when one side has evidence which could be material to the case then the other side has every reason to believe that the reason for withholding it is because what producing it would reveal would be harmful to its case." IF the other side has the evidence, and we do not know that it does. The other side, of course, could have believed it whatever.
Drax
I must again laugh... LOL... You say: "IF the other side has the evidence, and we do not know that it does." But...you also cite your WSJ source as saying (and you're relying on this source...): "The director of Hawaii’s health department and the registrar of records each has personally verified that the information on Obama’s birth certificate is identical to that in the state’s records, the so-called vault copy." You CITE the quote in which it is clearly stated that there are "original documents," then say that there ARE no "original documents." I'm done. I can only laugh and point so much without hurting myself...
CosmicConservative
smrstrauss again demonstrates the "legaleze" that all who have seen the original document use to address it. They say the information that is on the released document is identical to what is on the birth certificate, but we don't know what is on the ORIGINAL that is not on the document sent. That's why it's important and it is fairly reasonable to assume that's why we don't get to see the original. We are back (again) to what was said roughly 2 miles up on this thread.... there is something embarrassing on or about that original document. The longer this drags on with Obama continuing to hide it, the more convinced I am that it is something significant that could hurt him politically. And that's because I don't think Obama cares about much of anything except what helps or hurts him politically.
Drax
Here's some information which is not on the birth certificate which could be important: 1) Who gave the information on the birth certificate? There is no doctor's name, no hospital, nothing to indicate who helped in the birth or where it occurred. These are things which could be CHECKED OUT. If he was born in a hospital, assisted by a doctor or mid-wife, that information would be on the "vault copy." 2) There is no indication as to the type of birth certificate this is. At the time, Hawaii allowed for relatives simply to state that the when and where the child was born. The original "vault copy" would HAVE that information. 3) The 4 day delay between birth and information submitted to the Registrar would be EXPLAINED in any "vault copy." The "birth certificate" which is for public consumption almost certainly DOES comport EXACTLY with the information contained on the "vault copy," but there is almost certainly MORE INFORMATION on the "vault copy" than is on the "birth certificate." Unless, of course, one believes that one could give birth in Hawaii in 1961 and have NO RECORD OF THE ATTENDING PHYSICIAN, mid-wife, or who provided the GOVERNMENT with the INFORMATION on a GOVERNMENT DOCUMENT. One would have to be, what is the word...oh, yeah...INSANE to believe such nonsense.
smrstrauss
Re: “One would have to be, what is the word…oh, yeah…INSANE to believe such nonsense.” In order to believe that Obama was born outside of the USA, you have to believe BOTH that there is something wrong with the birth certificate and that Obama was born somewhere else than the USA. Say we have some other president, say Gerald Ford, and it was found out that when he was born the officials in Nebraska did not carefully check that the child was born in Nebraska. Would this mean that Gerald Ford was born in Canada or Mexico, or somewhere other than the USA? No, the fact that the Nebraska birth certificate was not iron-clad would not prove birth outside of the USA. Moreover, if Nebraska was sloppy in its birth certificates, then maybe other states were sloppy too. And, no matter how sloppy they may be, their official birth certificates still legally establishes birth in those states UNLESS THERE IS PROOF to the contrary. Hence, the issue of believing such nonsense returns constantly to the myth that Obama was born in Kenya and that he was smuggled back to the USA without a US travel document, such as a US visa, and that when he was smuggled back to the USA, his parents lied about the place of birth and got away with it. This, as the National Review has said is absurd. It said: “The theory that Obama was born in Kenya, that he was smuggled into the U.S., and that his parents somehow hoodwinked Hawaiian authorities into falsely certifying his birth in Oahu, is crazy stuff.” http://article.nationalreview.com/?q=ZmJhMzlmZWFhOTQ3YjUxMDE2YWY4ZDMzZjZlYTVmZmU=&w=MA In addition to this, there is reason to believe that Hawaii was not sloppy. The officials who looked into the file state repeatedly that the documents in the file mean that Obama was born in Hawaii. Not that he might have been born in Hawaii, but that he definitely was. This is what they said: “Does this mean Obama was born in Hawaii? "Yes," said Hawaii Health Department spokeswoman Janice Okubo, in both email and telephone interviews with the Tribune. "That's what Dr. Fukino is saying." (http://www.swamppolitics.com/news/politics/blog/2008/11/obama_hawaaianborn_citizen_for.html) Re: “1) Who gave the information on the birth certificate? There is no doctor’s name, no hospital, nothing to indicate who helped in the birth or where it occurred. These are things which could be CHECKED OUT. If he was born in a hospital, assisted by a doctor or mid-wife, that information would be on the “vault copy.” Yes, it IS on the vault copy, but Hawaii, like several other states, no longer sends out copies of the vault copy. It only sends out the official birth certificate, which is a short-form certificate, but it is the official birth certificate. Yet, as you yourself say, the information is on the Vault Copy, and the two officials (and probably more officials, since it is legal for officials to look into the file) looked at the Vault Copy and concluded that he was born in Hawaii, as they stated. It is also NOT Obama’s fault that Hawaii does not send out copies of the long-form birth certificate. That is Hawaii’s decision. The logical way to get the long-form birth certificate is from Hawaii, which definitely has it, and not from Obama, who may not have it. Re: “2) There is no indication as to the type of birth certificate this is. At the time, Hawaii allowed for relatives simply to state that the when and where the child was born. The original “vault copy” would HAVE that information. This is not true. At the time, Hawaii did NOT allow relatives to simply state where and when the child was born and also receive a Hawaii birth certificate that said flatly that the child was born in Hawaii. There were provisions for delayed birth certificates and certificates of Hawaiian birth, but all of them required a delay of some months or a year. Yet, we know from the notices in the newspapers that there was NO delay in granting the birth certificate. The original vault copy would have the information, as you say, but Hawaii does not send it out. Whose fault is that? Hawaii’s. Still, we know that the officials have seen the vault copy and repeatedly state that it flatly means that Obama was born in Hawaii. Re: “3) The 4 day delay between birth and information submitted to the Registrar would be EXPLAINED in any “vault copy.” The four-day delay is largely explained by August 4 being a Friday, and such delays were normal. Re: “The “birth certificate” which is for public consumption almost certainly DOES comport EXACTLY with the information contained on the “vault copy…” I agree. Now, let’s get back to the insanity discussion. In order to believe that Obama was born outside of Hawaii, the birth certificate that is for public consumption BOTH must NOT comport with the information on the vault copy AND there has to be good evidence that Obama was born somewhere else than Hawaii. Re: “there is almost certainly MORE INFORMATION on the “vault copy” than is on the “birth certificate.” We agree, and it would be nice—but not necessary—to see it. But, as you have said: “The “birth certificate” which is for public consumption almost certainly DOES comport EXACTLY with the information contained on the “vault copy…” Re: “Unless, of course, one believes that one could give birth in Hawaii in 1961 and have NO RECORD OF THE ATTENDING PHYSICIAN, mid-wife, or who provided the GOVERNMENT with the INFORMATION on a GOVERNMENT DOCUMENT.” We are in agreement that the name of the doctor and hospital (since the witness indicates he was born in Kapolani Hospital) is on the vault copy. But Hawaii does not send out the vault copy. IN sum, I do not hold that it is “insane” to want to see the original birth certificate. Seeing the original would be nice. I hold that it is illogical to demand that OBAMA show it, when we do not know that Obama has a copy of the original. It is illogical NOT to seek that Hawaii release a copy of the original, when we know that Hawaii has it. And, it is insane to believe that Obama was born in Kenya, when there is sufficient evidence of him being born in Hawaii, and NO evidence of him being born in Kenya, plus the near impossibility of him being born in Kenya without some obvious evidence of him being born in Kenya.
smrstrauss
Obama, who really was born in Hawaii, as his birth certificate and the officials of both parties in Hawaii and the Index Data file and the birth notices sent to the newspapers of Hawaii by the DOH of Hawaii in 1961 all show, and who is a Natural Born Citizen because the US Supreme Court has ruled that the meaning of Natural Born refers to the place of birth (not parents) was re-elected President of the United States last night. He won both a majority of the popular vote and a clear majority of the votes of the Electoral College.