Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Best Sit-com Ever

By CosmicConservative
OK, so my rant on culture has made me think that it is time to investigate the subject of "what is the best sit-com ever?" Here are my nominees: Beverly Hillbillies (Probably my all time favorite) Andy Griffith Show (just warms the heart) Seinfeld (Best ensemble cast?) Family Ties (Maybe a reach here) Cosby Show (When Cosby was still Cosby) Home Improvement (Great premise, great cast chemistry) I Love Lucy (A bit too slap-sticky for me...) The Addams Family (When people still knew what parody meant) Frazier (some of the best. writing. ever.) One Day at a Time (Just for Barbara Cooper, and Mrs. Cooper's blouses) That's enough to start with I think. (Additions based on comments) Cheers (best sexual tension between characters) WKRP in Cincinnatti (perhaps the best characters in all sitcom land)

Comments (26)

CosmicConservative
... I was tempted to put Star Trek in this list... But that would be "Most unintentionally funny TV show..."
Andy
Cosmic, I'd put Andy Griffith above Granny & Jed. But it is a close call. I notice that you left "Gomer Pyle, USMC" off the list. Probably for good reason. But that was one of my favorites...probably because it made my Daddy laugh so hard he'd throw up cornbread and buttermilk. (long story, good memory) "Home Improvement," and "Frazier" were both completely entertaining, from start to finish. Don't throw anything at me...but I think I'd put "Cheers" in the Top 10, and drop "Family Ties."
CosmicConservative
Hmm... Cheers vs. Family Ties.... I watched both religiously. I guess I'd have to say Cheers was more laugh-out-loud funny, but I found Family Ties to contain quite a bit of subtlety and relevant social satire. And fairly evenly handled too. I'll add Cheers...
CosmicConservative
You know, I absolutely have to put "WKRP in Cincinnatti" on this list. "As God is my witness, I thought turkeys could fly."
Andy
Oh man...I forgot about WKRP! Dr. Johnny Fever...Loni Anderson...superfly (whateverhisnamewas), and Mr. Whoever that ran the station. Classic! Top 10 won't do it. Gotta be a top 20. Ya' know Cosmic, TV used to be fun to watch. But from these posts, I'm figuring you already know that.
CosmicConservative
WKRP was the 80s version of Gilligan's Island. "Jennifer or Bailey?" Well... actually I liked Bailey a lot, but that Jennifer.... Never mind...
Drax
Gee...taste is everything, isn't it? Andy Griffith doesn't belong on that (or a longer) list. Neither does Family Ties. Nor Home Improvement. Nor One Day at a Time. Andy just ain't funny without Don Knotts. Don Knotts is funny. Andy is homespun. Homespun ain't funny. Family Ties and One Day at a Time were too politically correct (may as well have Maude in there...) Home Improvement just wasn't funny. Chucklish, maybe, but never fall out of your chair funny. Best sit-coms? Or best FUNNY sit-coms? Funniest of all time: Beverly Hillbillies Greenacres Early I Love Lucy Burns & Allen Malcolm in the Middle Soap The Odd Couple Get Smart Taxi Many of the episodes in these shows could make you laugh out loud. Cheers Frazier Seinfeld Everybody Loves Raymond WKRP The Honeymooners All in the Family Newhart (first one) Friends Dick Van Dyke Show Mary Tyler Moore Show These always were funny, and once in a while, fall out of the chair hilarious. Wings Newhart (second one) Cosby Happy Days These were seldom funny, but always comfortable. One Day at A Time Family Ties MASH These were frequently UNfunny, but with a cast we all were comfortable with. For me...I want the FUNNY, man. I want to SNORT when they throw turkeys from the helicopter...when they stuff chocolates into their mouth from the conveyor belt as it ever increases speed...or meet the cement pond for the first time...or climb up the telephone pole to make a phone call... The gentle family fun of the Cosby show type sitcoms just don't do it for me. I'd rather watch the political satire of MASH or All in the Family -- at least if it ain't funny, it's thought provoking...
Andy
Dang Drax...I forgot about Greenacres, too. And "The Odd Couple." I wasn't thinking so recently, but Everybody Loves Raymond had some really good years...until they made Patricia Heaton into a flaming bitch-wife...but it got better later on. And Archie, Edit', and the Meathead...now, that was some TV worth watching. Man... It's gotta be a top 40 now.
Cullen
I second: Soap Taxi Get Smart I nominate: The Tick (animated and live action) The first two seasons of Scrubs The Office (Brit) The Office (US, in fact, I believe this remake has surpassed the original) The first season of My Name is Earl
CosmicConservative
I loved the animated "The Tick." In fact the only action figure I ever owned (other than GI Joe as a kid) was The Tick. I still have it around somewhere. I guess I can't disagree with much Drax said. Still, I liked One Day at a Time, and I think Family Ties was frequently laugh out loud funny. Would I have liked One Day at a Time as much without my terrible crush on Valerie Bertinelli or if Bonnie Franklin had ever discovered the bra? Probably not.
CosmicConservative
I was somewhat reluctant to become a Frazier fan, but once I started watching the show, I found it to be probably the best purely written sitcom I've ever seen. Those writers were clever.
pace
I'm not a big American sitcom watcher, but I second 'The Office' nomination (I think the US and original productions are equally funny), and would also add 'Curb Your Enthusiasm'. For British sitcoms (Britcoms?) I'd say: 'Blackadder' 'Only Fools & Horses' 'Fawlty Towers' 'It Ain't Half Hot Mum' 'Red Dwarf' 'One Foot in the Grave' :)
Cullen
Speaking of clever writing - Arrested Development. I forgot to add that earlier.
Drax
Arrested Development and Curb Your Enthusiasm never floated my boat, nor either version of The Office. They each felt of that elusive brand of "witty" British humor, a brand which tend to elicit from me nothing but a great yawn. But... Man, we forgot British sitcoms... Second... Black Adder Fawlty Towers Never got into Red Dwarf or One Foot in the Grave Never seen It Ain't Hot Mum or Only Fools & Horses. But, have to add...Yes, Minister.
Cullen
Ah, but The Office is all about character development. It's taking some strong characters, having absurd things happen to them and watching the reactions. Wonderful TV.
CosmicConservative
I've watched a lot of Fawlty Towers. There are moments of surreal humor and long stretches of British satire and slapstick. It's watchable, but I may be culturally biased because I find Seinfeld much funnier and Seinfeld may not even be in my top five of sitcoms of all time. I left of "The Honeymooners" too, which was a mistake. That was awesome stuff too.
Cullen
Police Squad. Which also answers the question, which sitcom had the best introductory sequence. But what sitcom has the best theme music? My vote would be Sanford and Son with Night Court a close second.
CosmicConservative
OK, that's a whole new thread. I definitely have my opinion about theme music... Did you know the theme music for Gilligan's Island was composed by John Williams (of "Jaws" and "Star Wars" fame)?
pace
Cosmic - I have no doubt that I hold cultural biases where humor is concerned too. I occasionally tried watching Seinfeld, but there was just something about it that never worked for me. It somehow struck me as epitomizing all the least appealing aspects of American comedy, where the viewer is 'spoonfed' all the way up to an obvious punchline. 'Cheers' always struck me as being of the same brand of comedy. I don't know.. it's hard to qualify exactly why something doesn't resonate with oneself.
CosmicConservative
Heh, I have a very similar opinion of British comedy, specifically Fawlty Towers, where I always thought the jokes were telegraphed from miles away. I haven't thought about this before, but based on your view of Seinfeld and my view of Fawlty Towers, I suspect that what we are seeing are the expression of cultural "cues" that are so ingrained in our experience that we don't even react to them, but when we view another culture's cues, they stand out to us like neon paint on a black and white photo. It's even things like facial expressions and body language. I probably don't even notice some of that when George or Jerry does it because I totally grew up with it and it just blends into the background. But when John Cleese mugs for the camera as his wife is berating him, it feels like exaggerated telegraphing of intentions.
Interested
I think a lot of people had that take when it comes to Frasier. If you came into it part way it seemed shallow, mindless. but watch a few episodes and look out.
» Best Sit-com Ever CosmicConservative: Rational Conservatism from … - Classic British Sitcom Videos
[...] here: » Best Sit-com Ever CosmicConservative: Rational Conservatism from … Tags: and-long, anderson, fever, forgot-about, johnny-fever, may-not, much-funnier, satire-and, [...]