Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Cutler, Romo and Orton update

By CosmicConservative

Cutler got a two-year extension last week through the 2013 season, an extra $20 million guaranteed as a sign of the Bears' faith in him. In his first game since the show of confidence, Cutler threw three interceptions, fumbled two snaps and finished 26 of 37 for 251 yards.

Chicago Bears vs. Cincinnati Bengals - Recap - October 25, 2009 - ESPN.
Orton didn't play this weekend and still had a better day than Jay Cutler. Romo finally showed some signs of life again, throwing for over 300 yards and 3 touchdowns with zero interceptions. I have to say, this is classic Cutler. If you can rattle him, you can get a five turnover day from him. It's really that simple. I know he's the darling of the "experts" and has been the next big thing for four years (five?) now, but I'm happy to see him doing this in (3 - 3) Chicago instead of Denver. After six games he's had two games like this, which is actually a bit more than he even had in Denver. I think he had about four games he stank up the field last year, with two of them being games he quite literally threw away himself. At this pace he'll probably have five this year. Maybe not. Maybe he's finally over all that. But after a game like this in Denver is when the petulant finger pointing would start. I haven't been watching the Bears games this year, but I suspect Cutler spent a lot of time alone on the sidelines today.

Comments (11)

Drax
Didn't see the game. But, when you can't run the ball and play from behind against a team that runs and passes at will, you're going to throw some picks. The Bears have a terrible defense this year...the loss of Urlacher ended their ability to stop the run...and their inability to stop the run ended their ability to stop the pass. (And, frankly, the Bears' defense wasn't top tier last year with a healthy Urlacher...) We'll see if they can pull it together to go 10-6 this year. Bengals are looking good though. A healthy Palmer makes mucho difference.
CosmicConservative
Yep, move Cutler from the Broncos to the Bears and see exactly the same behavior in both cases, and it's all about the unique circumstances in each case. Yep, got it.
Drax
Lol. Yep. It's Cutler's fault that Benson ran for nearly 200 yards. Yep. It's Cutler's fault that Palmer threw for 5 TD's. Yep. It's Cutler's fault that he was sacked and/or chased all over the field. Yep. It's Cutler's fault that the Bears had 9 rushes for 30 yards. Pretty much the same kind of circumstance he faced in Denver last year. Crappy defense. Crappy O-line. Crappy running game. Playing from behind -- way behind. Amazing how similar circumstance results in similar results. At least last year he had the outlet of a pro-bowl receiver. Cin...Touchdown (7-0) Chi..get a 1st down..then 3rd & 14...punt. Cin...Touchdown (14-0) Chi...sack..3rd & 14...punt [End 1st quarter] Cin...Touchdown (21-0) Chi..deep pass to Hester who funbles..Cin recovers. Cin...Touchdown (28-0) Chi..(2 minutes in 1/2...on own 31..Interception) Cin...Field Goal (31-0) Chi...Field Goal (31-3) End 1/2 Chi...on 3rd & 21, got all but 5. Went for it on 4th and 5...Intercepted. Cin...Touchdown (38-3) Chi...Interception Cin...Touchdown (45-3) Chi..Touchdown (45-10) Cin...OH MY GOD!!! BENGALS DIDN'T SCORE (but only because they were running and running the clock out...) Chi...3 and out Yeah....all Cutler's fault..
Drax
Oh, Cutler had a bad day. But, to blame his bad day entirely on him rather than the way his team performed (penalties putting them on 3rd and long, dropped passes, fumbles when they're driving, a defense unable to stop the Bengals so he's playing from WAY behind, and trying to force something (anything) to happen, bad play calling, an inability to run the ball) is just as silly as giving him all the credit when he plays well and the team wins.
CosmicConservative
Drax: Look, I'm sure that you are right, you are certainly more of an expert than I am on sports in general, football in particular and the quarterback position specifically. All I'm saying is that it is amazing how accurate my predictions of Cutler's performance have been so far. And since I based those predictions on Cutler's behavior, tendencies and history, I tend to think that the fact that my predictions are coming true does provide some validation of how I read Cutler himself. Sure it could all be coincidence. Absolutely. But if so, it's an amazing coincidence.
Drax
Heh. Layin' it on a bit thick... I have never said anything other than that Cutler had all the physical tools but had yet to convince me that he had all the mental tools. That's all. Nothing more. You seem to take those statements and attempt to make me out to be some sort of "Cutler apologist" or some such nonsense. I'm not. Never have been. But, as I've said in so many ways in so many threads, "football is a team game." You remember...TEAM? (I can put the "caps" on too...) Any quarterback, faced with what Cutler is faced with is going to have horrid days. You can't be playing from behind, especially way behind, and not have horrid days. When you no longer can run, they can stack the defense against the pass. When you have to pass into that defense, you're predictable and vulnerable. When you have to come up with two or three TDs just to catch up -- and you know that your defense can't stop the offense so even those 2 or 3 TDs ain't gonna do it -- you force things. Your offensive co-ordinator forces things. You get picked. It happens. When you aren't in this kind of trouble, you can have better days. Of course, there are days when you just have bad days -- no excuses. Unless you're Manning (Peyton, that is). He's about the only one out there who almost never has a "bad day." But, even he has a few. Cutler may turn out to be Jake Plummer. He may turn out to be a great QB. But, unless Chicago gets a running game and shores up its defense, we may see all too many "bad days." There. Can we stop with the snarky shots now?
Drax
Oh... As to my contention that the QB is only as good as his team, I'll see you a Cutler and raise you a Cassell.
CosmicConservative
Hmm... I wasn't being snarky at all. I was being completely sincere. I would not even pretend to have your knowledge of sports, Geebuz man, you ran a store that sold collectable sports items. You'd BETTER be more knowledgeable about sports than I am. I'm just saying that as much as any sport is a team game, there are players who demonstrate certain tendencies no matter what the team around them does. Or at least I think that's true. I'm not much of an apologist at all frankly. These guys get paid insane amounts of money to throw and catch balls, a behavior mostly associated with children. And by the time they get to the pros, virtually all of them have done nothing of consequence in their lives but play that game for over a decade. It has been my observation that Cutler gets picked because of the decisions he makes, not because of the circumstances he is in. It is my opinion that he has a completely unwarranted confidence in his ability to throw the football. Because he occasionally makes a remarkable throw, he thinks he can throw across his body, into double or triple coverage, 20+ yards down the field. I'm no expert, but I've watched a LOT of football, and the only other quarterback I have ever seen who routinely makes such boneheaded throws is Brett Favre. Even John Elway, a man with a demonstrably superior arm to Jay Cutler, didn't try to make those throws. What I find amazing about Jay Cutler is that he has grown up (allegedly) doing nothing but throwing a football, and he continues to make these boneheaded decisions on the football field. I simply can't understand what is going on in his head when he does these things. What does it take for him to look at the situation, realize that he is about to throw 30 yards back across his body into triple coverage against the most accomplished pass defenders in the world, and make the damn throw? This, more than anything else, is why I am glad he is no longer a Denver Bronco. And I predicted he would continue to do the same thing in Chicago. This has nothing to do with his team or his circumstances. These plays are brain-dead plays that nobody else (even Matt Cassell) makes. Yes, he does it more when he's under pressure and his team is behind. But that's when the good quarterbacks realize that they have to PROTECT the football. Nothing takes a beating and turns it into a blowout quite as reliably as an interception. How long is the guy going to play this game before he learns that?
Drax
I tend to agree about his unwarranted confidence. He has all the tools. He can make all the throws (including your example). I've seen him do it. The problem is that he thinks that he can do it all the time -- on demand. No one can. There are times when you have to attempt those throws (and he's been in more than his share of those situations. Two of his interceptions last game were entirely understandable. Third and long and way behind, if you see even the glimmer of a window or think that your receiver can "make a play" even though covered -- you gotta make the throw..or 4th down...you gotta make the throw (but hopefully a long one as it's a "punt" if it's intercepted..) But, I've seen him manage games and make good decisions as well. I think I'm on the side of the fence that he's a selfish child who hasn't yet put behind his glory days from college. He still thinks that he's BMOC -- at least he comes off that way in his interviews. He seldom takes responsibility for his performance when, even if (maybe especially if) much of his performance isn't his "fault" but the "fault" of circumstance and good play by the defense. A good leader puts that on his shoulders so that his teammates can move on from the bad game feeling good about their leader and how he feels about them. He doesn't have that leadership ability. I'm not sure that it's something which he can learn (and it CAN be learned). He's shown no evidence that he's willing to do the hard work (mental and emotional) which is required of a leader who has people who willingly and happily follow him. He just comes off as a brat. And, that's saying a bit when it comes to professional athletes who, without many exceptions, tend to be arrogant brats from an early age.
CosmicConservative
I agree that Cutler can sometimes make the across-the-body throw into triple coverage and have it work. I've seen him do it. But I cringe every time because it's a low percentage play that should only be done as a "last resort." Tony Romo also has a tendency to do similar things, and I cringe when he does it too. But I cringe about 1/10 of the time with Romo than I did with Cutler. Drew Brees makes those throws, and sometimes gets burned. With Cutler my opinion is that he lacks the ability to know when it is appropriate to roll those dice. He makes those throws when it IS appropriate, for sure, but he makes them when they aren't appropriate either. In a game last year, down the stretch with Denver needing a SINGLE WIN to lock up a playoff spot, Denver was driving WITH THE LEAD and in the red zone when Cutler uncorked a throw that was so unbelievably unfathomable that the homer announcer, Dave Logan, an admitted Jay Cutler fan, said "Holy cow! Why would you make that throw?". It was intercepted. The offense took the field, drove downfield and scored a touchdown to go ahead, leaving Denver in a desperate situation where Cutler was forced to make bad throws and he was intercepted again to seal the deal. My issue isn't the LAST interception he threw, I understand that one. It's the FIRST one he threw that cost the Broncos a playoff spot. I think I said before that my first inkling that Cutler was not the "real deal" came when Mike Shanahan said after putting Cutler in as the starter that he had to "cut the playbook in half" for Cutler to keep it straight. There is no rationale for such a situation that I can make that allows me to conclude anything other than Jay Cutler is not that bright.