Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Civics lesson to the press...

By CosmicConservative
OK, if a President authorizes release of classified information, it isn't classified anymore is it? That's by definition, understand? Therefore it is not possible for the President to authorize the "leak" of classified information. As soon as it is authorized to be released, it isn't classified anymore, therefore releasing it isn't leaking classified information, get it? How much do these people get paid? Let me put it in words that are as plain as possible. "Presidential classified information leak" is a physical impossibility. Think of it in the same way as "The Democratic War Plan." It's simply a physical impossibility, no matter how much you try to make it so by repeating the words like a deranged parrot.

Comments (6)

jp
but the leak (wilson) was for personal political gain, and the President said that he would dismiss anyone in his administration that leaked info and endagered cia ops. Again, Bush will change the rules of the game - heh - what rules does he need right? He is above the law right?
CosmicConservative
OK, so do you understand that the information Bush declassified had nothing to do with Valerie Plame? He declassified information that was no longer critical to national security, which is his prerogative as President. He leaked it to explain the rationale for war. Yes, the President, who the Left has repeatedly attacked for being "the most secretive administration in recent history" declassified information to give the public more of an understanding of the rationale for the war. I suppose it doesn't occur to you that Joe Wilson and his wife acted out of personal gain? Since you leveled the accusation, please explain to me how the Bush declassification of the NSA report endangered CIA Ops. So, you also understand that in the case of declassifying information Bush IS the law right? I mean you understand that don't you? Don't you? Maybe the press isn't the only one who needs a civics lesson, eh?
jk
True, that at this point, it is unclear what exactly Scooter thought he was allowed to leak. The recent court papers only refer to the claim that Bush allowed leaking portions of the classified NIE to the press (Judith Miller). The WH has not disputed this, so it is probably true. However, I don't think anyone knows what is in that report and specifically, if it includes the Plame - Wilson connection. I expect Mr Fitzgerald will have to re-interview Mr Bush and Mr Cheney, and Ms Miller to find out what was leaked to directly implicate the President or Vice President in the leaking of Plame's name, and compromising national security by revealing an active CIA Agent. This story is clearly not over, and we need more information to understand exactly what occured in the WH. However, I do find it hypocritical that Mr Bush has repeatedly criticized the leaking of classified information, yet he himself did here. Even if the President has the executive authority to declassify information, there is a process for doing so as outlined in Executive Order 12958 (April 1995). So, having the VPs Chief of Staff speak to a Time reporter and requesting that the source the information be attributed to a "Former Hill Staffer," clearly was done in tone of a LEAK. Again, ironic, given recent statements made by Mr Bush regarding leaks: President Bush, 9/30/03: "I don't know of anybody in my administration who leaked classified information. If somebody did leak classified information, I'd like to know it, and we'll take the appropriate action." President Bush, 9/30/03: "If there is a leak out of my administration, I want to know who it is. And if the person has violated law, the person will be taken care of. . . . I have told our administration, people in my administration to be fully cooperative. I want to know the truth. If anybody has got any information inside our administration or outside our administration, it would be helpful if they came forward with the information so we can find out whether or not these allegations are true and get on about the business." President Bush, 10/28/03: "I'd like to know if somebody in my White House did leak sensitive information." President Bush, 10/28/03: "I want to know the truth. ... I have no idea whether we'll find out who the leaker is, partially because, in all due respect to your profession, you do a very good job of protecting the leakers." President Bush, 6/10/04: Reporter: "Do you stand by your pledge to fire anyone found to have done so?" President Bush: "Yes. And that's up to the U.S. Attorney to find the facts." President Bush, 7/18/05 issue of USA Today: "If someone committed crime, they will no longer work in my administration."
CosmicConservative
JK: Apparently you have evidence of some crime committed by Bush or in his administration who has not resigned from their job. Please forward that information to the FBI immediately, I am sure they will be glad to get it. If you don't have such evidence, then you are wasting time complaining about crimes committed by Bush or his administration, without proof, you're just a whining partisan. Many people seem to be incapable of distinguishing between "classified" and "declassified" information. That's their problem, not mine, not the Justice Department's and not Scooter Libby's. I have twice explained that when Bush declassifies information, it isn't classified anymore. What part of "declassified" is such a mystery? This is what is so frustrating in attempting to talk to anyone on the left these days. You go seamlessly from "classified" to "hypocrite" to "crime" as if there were any such connection in this case. You completely ignore the actual facts of the case, which are that Bush declassified the information, therefore it is not classified, therefore whether it is a "leak" or not, it is not a "leak of classified information" then you go to "he's a hypocrite" for not firing someone who did not do what you accuse them of doing, and then you go to "a crime" when nobody who has even the slightest understanding of the law has suggested that this "leak" was criminal in any way. Quite the contrary, even the New York Times, the Washington Post and CNN grudgingly put in their first or second paragraph that Bush is completely within his legal powers to declassify information. But none of those facts are relevant to you because you simply want to say "Bush is a liar," or something similar. I guess I'll just have to continue to be satisfied with the simple reality that the facts, as usual, are all on my side on this. I will give your side this: Bush may well have declassified information specifically to allow it to be leaked to the press so that he could pursue a political goal. I believe that is exactly what happened. The political goal in this case was to contain the damage being done by Joseph Wilson who was lying to everyone in the world about his trip to Niger, his report to the CIA and his and his wife's role in the whole affair. When he told the press that the VP had authorized his trip to Niger in an attempt to damage the VP and the Pres, Bush and Cheney most likely got together and said, "How do we get the truth out." And they realized it was all in the NIE report, so then they asked themselves, and likely their intelligence experts "if we declassify this, will it hurt our national security, will it hurt any covert operations, or will it reveal damaging information about our future plans? They conclued it did none of that, and since it did refute Wilson's lies, they said, "OK, declassify it and then release it to the press." That is almost certainly what happened. Is that illegal? No. is that hypocritical? I do not believe so, Bush was obviously trying to react to lies being told agianst him, Cheney and his entire administration. I know that to you Joseph Wilson is some kind of hero. To me he is not remotely a hero. He is a partisan hack who disagreed with his President's agenda and lied to the press to damage the President. This is not merely unethical and immoral, it is a direct violation of his ethical responsibilities as a member of the administration and a direct violation of the oath he took when he took his job. I am certain those things mean very little to those who are out to get Bush at any cost, but they mean something to me. I don't blame Bush a bit for declassifying and leaking the information. That's one advantage he has as President, he uses that power very judiciously in my opinion and in this case it was, to use a baseball term, "well struck" and he hit a home run with it. More power to him. That's one thing I like about Bush, and I liked it about Reagan. He's not afraid to BE President. That's in his favor most of the time.
jk
CosmicConservative- I'm not saying Mr Bush committed a crime per se at this point. I suspect that will come out in the following weeks and months as the investigation of Mr Fitzgerald continues. What I am saying is that Mr Bush took a very interesting path to declassifying the information in the NIE and disseminating it to the press. What ever happened to the good old press conference, policy speech, or following the process outlined in Executive Order 12958? So, let's call what happened by the appropriate term: A leak. As to my comment alleging that Mr. Bush is a hypocrite, what I am saying is that he should stop whining about all the leaking to the press going on in DC, and pick up a pair of Depends, because he seems to have a bit of a leakage problem himself. :-)
CosmicConservative
JK: Heh... I guess a lot of it is perspective. From my perspective the complaints about leaking classified information that have come (the complaints that is) from the Bush administration have been about truly damaging leaks. Leaks that have revealed the existence and sometimes the location of prisons which hold dangerous enemies of the United States, leaks that were not only damaging to US Credibility, but which turned out to be untrue (like the supposed flushing of Korans down toilets in Guantanimo) and leaks about troop levels in combat areas that can provide critical tactical advantages to the enemy in the field of combat. Those are the leaks that Bush has complained about by and large, although there have been a few leaks that have merely been damaging to Bush and I don't blame him for being angry about those either. But many of those are also untrue. Look, there is a raging battle in Washington, primarily in the State Department, but also in Defense. GW Bush has made a lot of enemies in both areas by pushing the GWOT so aggressively. My problem is that many people in both organizations have decided to use the leaking of information as a weapon against Bush, and this is a violation of both their codes of ethics and their oath of office, not to mention an actual criminal act. I also hold the MSM culpable in this, and you may be among those very surprised if and when the New York Times finds itself the target of a criminal probe themselves. If the "leak" from Libby authorized by Bush contained that sort of sensitive strategic or tactical revelations, I would have a different opinion of it. But as it stands now, I do not believe that anything damaging was unclassified, so I am OK with it. I am NOT okay with disgruntled liberal State employees leaking truly sensitive information that will get people killed, and then saying "well, Bush does it too." That is not accurate. And it is utterly irresponsible. And criminal. If I were Bush I would be going after them with everything I could throw at them.