The ethics of blogging...
By CosmicConservativeBlogging is becoming more mainstream every day. It's sort of odd for me to think that I've been doing this for four years now. When I started blogging it was still a relatively unknown thing on the web, although there had been some blogs out there for years already, but the term "blogosphere" had just been coined, and Google and Technorati had just begun to provide blog searching and indexing services.
I didn't start blogging for any specific purposes. I started blogging primarily as a means to get my brain back into the mode of writing on a regular basis, something I had gotten very lazy about in the previous decade. And it has worked for that, I'm sure that my blogging has been prolific enough that I've probably written as many words in the past four years as many novelists or journalists.
But my own guidelines about blogging have always been driven entirely by my OWN ethical guidelines, not some sort of blogging industry approved ethics.
I believe that my own personal ethics would be more stringent than any official published ethics anyway, but it's worth talking about what are now being circulated around the blogosphere as the "ethics" of blogging.
It is not surprising that most of the ethical guidelines being proposed are around transparency of motives, both in the sense of disclosing political ideology and in the sense of disclosing any financial arrangements the blogger has with any entities, be they political, commercial or ideological.
I've seen some people criticize Glenn Reynolds on occasion because of his frequent links to Amazon.com. Glenn links to reviews and products on Amazon.com on a daily basis, sometimes several times a day. Nowhere on Instapundit.com is there any indication that Glenn has a financial arrangement with Amazon.com. Does Instapundit gain financial benefits from his links to Amazon.com? Or is Glenn Reynolds just a fan who thinks Amazon.com is a great site, which also happens to sell his books? Who knows? Do you care? Would you consider it unethical for Glenn to make all those links and not disclose that he makes a penny for every hundred click-throughs?
One reason I have avoided putting any Google ads on my blog is because I frankly find the ads that get thrown up to be unacceptable on occasion. Dean's World does google ads, and if the discussion happens to be on the subject of video games, you're pretty likely to see an ad for video games like "Grand Theft Auto." Well, maybe I don't like video games like "Grand Theft Auto" (I don't). But more to the point, should a blogger who puts Google ads on their site disclose that they get paid if you click through them?
What about bloggers who get paid to blog? Let's say that the RNC decided I was a successful and like-minded blogger (I'm not, btw) and offered me cash payments if I were to blog in support of their agenda and hand-picked candidates. Should I disclose that I am being paid for my "endorsements"?
The FTC is talking about monitoring and regulating blogs. Their argument is that since blogs can become powerful influence peddlers in their own right that ethical guidelines that apply to broadcast signals should also apply to blogs. But that would mean that my own pitiful little blog would be held to the same standards as a TV or radio station. Which would mean that if the FTC re-introduces the "Fairness Doctrine" I would either have to shut down my blog, or provide a "dissenting view" which effectively countered my own desires.
I have to admit that I find this discussion interesting. In general I don't think it makes sense to place the crushing weight of government regulations on the head of people like me who just installed some content presentation software on a server somewhere and then started posting their own personal opinions.
But there is no doubt that blogs like Instapundit or DailyKOS are powerful sources of influence in society. So is there some boundary you cross where your blog goes from a personal vanity site (like mine) and becomes a public influencing site which puts you under FTC scrutiny?
Very interesting to think about. Especially when you think that this sort of thing from a government enforcement perspective would be an ideal way to shut down the voices of the opposition.
Interesting times we live in.
Comments (2)