My Way News - Jet May Be 10X Faster Than Other Planes
Sigh, I guess I should be relieved to see that "science" reporting down under is every bit as bad as it is here in the states. A few quotes from this story:
Researchers in Australia's Outback launched a test flight Thursday of a supersonic jet designed to fly 10 times faster than conventional airplanes.
OK, so what does this reporter think a "conventional airplane" is? Apparently he thinks "conventional" is interchangeable with "civil" or perhaps "subsonic." Of course "conventional" in the normal sense means "has wings, a fuselage, a tail and engines." A "non-conventional" aircraft would be a lifting body design, or perhaps one with the tail in front and the main wing in back. "Conventional" has nothing to do with speed.
The so-called Supersonic Combustion Ramjet - or scramjet
When did this "so-called" trend start in reporting? I'm seeing it all the time now. Don't reporters (much less editors) even consider how words provide connotations anymore? The implication of using the words "so-called" is that the speaker or source is trying to pull something on the reader. It's not a phrase that should be used in any factual story, it's more of an editorial comment sort of usage. Yes I know that it does not absolutely imply a negative, but that's what editing is all about, understanding the potential negative connotations of the writing and removing them.
Some observers say scramjet technologies could revolutionize air travel.
Who wrote this? A sixteen year old High Schooler? Is this a last-minute weekend term paper assignment? "Some observers say"... AAuugghhh!!! If there is anything worse in legitimate reporting than "so-called" it's this lame "Some observers say" nonsense. What, you couldn't be bothered to call a local expert on aeronautics or even a local college professor? Heck, "Some observers say" Elvis is on the far side of the moon eating Krispy Kreme donuts all day, so I guess we should listen to them, eh?
But it might be possible to use a scramjet-powered plane within the next 10 years for limited purposes, such as delivering vital organs for urgent transplant operations.
Who said this? Was it the same mysterious "some people" as above? So that's what we can expect, a fleet of waiting scramjets standing by for urgent liver delivery? What is this, a Saturday Night Live skit?
And finally, just a few comments on the whole "ten times as fast" issue.
Modern passenger jets such as the Boeing 747 travel at roughly 600 - 650 mph while cruising, just under the speed of sound. As has been demonstrated for decades by the European Concorde passenger jet and an entire fleet of military jets, it is not difficult to fly faster than the speed of sound, so the reason modern jets fly below the speed of sound is primarily due to two things:
1. Fuel efficiency
2. Environmental concerns (breaking the sound barrior tends to break a lot of windows)
In general you can't afford to fly passengers in planes that break the sound barrier because the fuel cost drives the ticket cost to astronomical levels (which is why the Concorde was used primarily by the super-rich) and you can't land supersonic aircraft where they have to come in over cities (which is why the Concorde was primarily an ocean-crossing service, where it accelerated to supersonic speeds over the water, instead of over high-rise office buildings.). These two limitations are not solved by using scramjets, so putting passengers on hypersonic aircraft isn't coming anytime soon regardless of whether we can build one or not.
But on the subject of pure speed, when you AREN'T carrying passengers...
Scramjets travelling at 5,000 mph will be travelling at roughly mach 6.5, maybe they can push it to mach 7 just for a round number. Official speed records for the fastest "conventional" aircraft are around mach 3.3 (actual speed records set by the SR-71 Blackbird are classified, but are probably pushing mach 3.5). Mach 3.3 is roughly 2,500 mph. So it is actually accurate to say that a scramjet flying at 5,000 mph is actually roughly TWICE as fast as the fastest conventional aircraft, not TEN TIMES as fast.
And that's just the public record for conventional aircraft. There have been persistent rumors for over a decade now that the US military has a
classified hypersonic airplane that routinely hits mach 7, and is rumored to fly as fast as mach 10. Perhaps the Aurora is a scramjet powered craft already in production, who knows.
Just for comparison purposes, the workhorse fighter of the US military is the F-16 Fighting Falcon. It's top speed is roughly 1,500 mph, or roughly 1/3 the speed of this scramjet. The fastest production fighter jet in the US inventory right now is still the F-15 Eagle, with a top speed of mach 2.5. Perhaps the F-22 Raptor is a bit faster in a pinch, but that's about the current state of the art for military fighters.
One has to wonder whether this reporter (and their editor) even have the slightest idea about modern aircraft and their capabalities.
Comments (0)
No comments on this post.