Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Cutler vs. Orton, round one

By CosmicConservative
So tomorrow Jay Cutler will be in Denver again, leading the Chicago Bears against the Kyle Orton (ex Chicago Bear) led Broncs. The general opinion of the football community is that Jay Cutler is the second coming of Dan Marino and that Kyle Orton is the second coming of Rex Grossman. So far in the preseason I'd say Cutler is outperforming Orton by a significant amount. But I find it interesting that there is a story on ESPN today that Cutler and his wide receivers are not getting along. Watch the Bears this year, and if you see Cutler sitting alone on the bench during defensive series, with his head on his chin, looking bored and distracted.... ... well, I won't be surprised.

Comments (17)

Drax
I think that the consensus is that Cutler has all the physical TOOLS to be an elite quarterback. I also think that the consensus is that he hasn't developed either the mental toughness or the leadership necessary to exploit those tools fully. (As to the locker room BS. Brett (the legendary) FAVRE is undergoing some of that right now. McNabb undergoes it every year. Tampa Bay has that problem, as do the Jets. Whenever there's a "new guy" in town or there's a QB controversy, there's locker room BS.)
Interested
This is completely off topic - but I can't register at Deans world - it's been disabled. on the F102 ...From http://www.aerospaceweb.org/question/history/q0185.shtml: Regardless, the F-102 was still far more dangerous to fly than today's combat aircraft. Compared to the F-102's lifetime accident rate of 13.69, today's planes generally average around 4 mishaps per 100,000 hours. For example, compare the F-16 at 4.14, the F-15 at 2.47, the F-117 at 4.07, the S-3 at 2.6, and the F-18 at 4.9. Even the Marine Corps' AV-8B, regarded as the most dangerous aircraft in US service today, has a lifetime accident rate of only 11.44 mishaps per 100,000 flight hours. The F-102 claimed the lives of many pilots, including a number stationed at Ellington during Bush's tenure. Of the 875 F-102A production models that entered service, 259 were lost in accidents that killed 70 Air Force and ANG pilots. 2H4
Andy
Considering what "Interested" said, I'm thinking that maybe the 'Boys should put Aikman on the bench and let Meredith have a chance.
CosmicConservative
Nah, I think the 'Boys should go with Steve Walsh, Aikman's an overhyped mama's boy. Walsh is the real deal, I hear he's had about 700 hours in a T-38 Talon. Interested: I think the whole T-102 discussion on Dean's World has gone totally downhill. I've pretty much told McK to piss off.
Interested
Wanna really have fun - check out the loons on Hullabaloo. I'm no Bears fan, but I do agree - I think Cutler _could_ be something significant. Not to the level of Marino, Farve or Brady - but knocking on their door's. Just the whole McDaniels encounter leaves a bad taste in my mouth. I have a hard time thinking objectively when you see the Jay Cutler's or Eli Mannings or Michael Crabtree's (or today's Brett Farve) who forgot that playing NFL is a rare opportunity.
Drax
Hey, man...leave off the (legendary) Brett FAVRE. He's all that and a muffin, man. And a muffin.
Interested
lol, Yanno I love Farve. I love the man's abilities - and at 40 he's still better than most QB's today. His records were all earned in the traditions of any fine gunslinger. And I can feel the desire to keep on playing - the need to prove you're still the best - or at least still prove you're damn good. Because he is. But - let the drama go.
Drax
Heh...fair enough. But, gotta ask. If you were an aging (aged) QB who had just retired (again) after a season which demonstrated that, when healthy, you're one of the top QB's in the league, but that, when not ... you're not. And...you had been released by the Jets (which he didn't ask for BTW) so that you're a complete free agent (something unexpected). And...a team with an offense which you could slip into like, well, a #4 Green Bay Jersey -- the best running back in the game -- a legitimate #1 WR -- an elite defense -- offers you the starting QB job. But...you need an operation, and, even after the operation, you might not be 100%, and you NEED to be 100% (see last year). And, even if the operation goes perfectly, you still have a 40 year old body which couldn't take the pounding last year, so will it this year? So...you say..."I'm interested. But, let me have the operation and we'll see if my body can hack it." The Vikings salivate "YES!" You have the operation. It takes a while to heal. You begin to throw. The arm seems to be working fine. You keep the Vikings abreast of the progress of your rehabilitation. The Vikings, confident that you wouldn't have gone through with the operation if you weren't serious about coming back give you all the time you need...(But, they aren't going to announce anything until YOU announce something.) Training camp, decision time approaches. The arm feels pretty good. You can make the throws. But, your body sure feels 40 years old. Is it the prospect of training camp, followed by 16 games that tells you that your body can't take it? Or is it just your 40 year old body telling you that you shouldn't do it? Are you willing to make a fool of yourself AGAIN? Do you really want to play football THAT BAD? Doesn't matter. YOU set the deadline for your decision. You're not 100% sure. You tell the Vikings, "Thanks, but no thanks." The Vikings move on. You move on. They have Rosenfels and Jackson. They're not too excited about that. That's why they wanted you in the first place. After a while, like a jilted lover, they call you and say..."Are you really, really sure?" And...you weren't "really, really sure." Were you?
Andy
When is September gonna be this year? I'm weary of all the anticipation. I still say Aikman might work out for the 'Boys.
Interested
Are you sure about the Jets? Thought his agent did ask for the release. That's the drama problem - Farve's just not ready to let it go - I can't blame him but he's kind of like that hot chick we all had that strung us all along. Minus the beard of course.
Drax
Interested: I'm really not sure one way or another on whether Favre asked for his release from the Jets. Did a bit of research and didn't see anything definitive one way or another as to his asking for it. What I do know is that I didn't hear about it being requested when it occurred. I KNOW that if he had REQUESTED it and it had been granted pursuant to that request, it would have been all over the news -- "WHAT'S BRETT DOING NOW?" "Will the Vikings sign?" Etc. Etc. The media frenzy about "What's it all mean?" would have begun upon the RELEASE -- not when the Vikings initiated contact with him. I just think that any player who can get someone to pay him to play should do so for as long as he wants to do so. He should ride the train as long as there's a track because the world just ain't the same once you stop being a gridiron warrior. I mean...about the best you can do is sit around with other former stars or never stars talking about actual stars ... or ... go "Dancing With The Stars."
CosmicConservative
Hey, leave Emmett alone. He's a dang good dancer!
CosmicConservative
I am a huge fan of Emmett Smith. I always have been, the one exception being the two weeks he held out for more money during the midst of the Cowboy's heyday. But he is a miserable commentator.
Drax
Gotta get paid while you're in demand. Ask the former Arizona Cardinal, Emmitt Smith.
Interested
All I could find on it was. • Feb. 11, 2009: Favre retires again, calling it "the real deal" and saying he was unwilling to have surgery on his torn bicep tendon. • Feb. 13, 2009: Favre tells ESPN "there's no way" he'll play in another NFL game. • April 28, 2009: The Jets grant Favre his unconditional release. Favre reiterates he is retired and has "no intention of returning to football." Which following the season as it ended then - dumping the Coach. It's not like Farve got booted from the Jets. Which even if he did - If the man wants to play and teams are willing to pay - fantastic. I would be sitting infront of my team wearing the number 4 in whatever teams colors (unless he's playing against my Pats) cheering him on. But football is business and business is business. Farve can't expect an open invitation to any team that may be interested in him for however long he says no - but might say yes - wait no - well maybe - wait yes - wait no..... That's where the teams have gone wrong - they needed to set a deadline and once that deadline has gone - than move to plan B.