Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Obama in retreat...

By CosmicConservative

WASHINGTON – Bowing to Republican pressure, President Barack Obama's administration signaled on Sunday it is ready to abandon the idea of giving Americans the option of government-run insurance as part of a new health care system.

Facing mounting opposition to the overhaul, administration officials left open the chance for a compromise with Republicans that would include health insurance cooperatives instead of a government-run plan. Such a concession probably would enrage Obama's liberal supporters but could deliver a much-needed victory on a top domestic priority opposed by GOP lawmakers.

White House appears ready to drop 'public option' - Yahoo! News.
Good news. Now if we can keep the pressure on the Senate we might be able to make some headway on the carbon tax and more fixes to this bill.... good news.

Comments (4)

Andy
Cosmic, you are right. The Senate is our only hope. From what I read in the article, the dems in the house are "saying" that they won't support a compromise bill without the public option (complete takeover) of health insurance. But I'm not so sure. If BozObama thinks he can take it "three yards and a cloud of dust," instead of a "Hail Mary post route TD," I'll bet on his patience. I don't trust either party on this issue. Or on anything else really. I fear that any health care reform legislation that gets the BozO signature will be just round one...and they'll be back to incrementally get what they want. I'd like to see a big nothing happen. Even if it means that some needed reform doesn't get done right now...I'd rather wait and see if we can manage to get some sane folks in charge before we tackle it. I can dream, can't I? There is a blogger that I read that wrote a post about this very thing this afternoon. If you're interested: http://www.basilsblog.com/2009/08/16/surrender-monkeys-surrender-or-did-they/
Drax
It's a feint. Nothing Obama does can be taken at face value. The reality is that the bill as it currently is (absent the "public option") REQUIRES a "public option." It simply will be forced upon us through the back door or explicitly at a later date. Here's the simplistic version: Section 102 (Protecting the choice to keep current coverage) is the "grandfather clause. It allows anyone who currently has an insurance police to keep it if they so choose (and that choice exists). However 102(a)(1)(a) forbids the issuance of any future policies which don't comport with the new bill. Sec 111 forbids denying anyone for pre-existing conditions. Sec 112 essentially forbids non-renewal for anything other than non-payment. Sec 113 sets limitations on premiums as determined by the government. Sec 114 requires that mental health and substance abuse treatment be covered. Sec 116 sets out that the government controls the profit margins of the insurance companies (although nothing about when they show a loss). Sec 2714 requires that, in the event the insurance company makes "too much profit," those monies are rebated back to the customer. Sec 122 sets out other rules, including the prohibition against setting out yearly or lifetime limit on how much the insurance company has to pay out on a policy (a)(3); forbids "cost-sharing" (aka "co-payments") for a wide range of routine (aka "ubiquitous") procedures (a)(2); Sec 162 sets out that no insurance policy can be rescinded except due to fraud. (Non-payment is the only other way to rescind the policy.) There's more, but this should be enough to convince any rational person that NO insurance company would be able to either predict or control costs sufficiently to write health care insurance policies. They gotta cover everyone. They can't cut anyone off for any reason other than fraud or non-payment regardless whether that person is going to the emergency room every day for no good reason. They can't limit how much they pay out for any individual PERIOD -- not yearly or lifetime. What rational insurance company would give EVERY person it insures a BLANK CHECK which they could, under NO circumstances stop payment upon? So, this is a feint. If this goes through in anything which resembles the current form (and there is NO WAY to change it without gutting it entirely) then there MUST be a "public option" because soon there won't BE a "private" one.
CosmicConservative
Well, Obama's already sent out an "unnamed White House Official" to tell the world that Sebelius "misspoke" and there is no intention to remove the public option. Man, this administration is pathetic in some ways. How many "misspokes" per week do we get from Obama's "crack" team? And on major stuff too, like, oh, nuclear weapons for Iran, for example. What a bunch of maroons.
Drax
CC: Heh. I keep coming back to my take on his "flawless campaign." Many (most -- almost everyone) said that he ran a great campaign. As I stated so frequently...he didn't. He, at best, ran a mediocre campaign. Frequent gaffes. Frequent misstatements. Frequent missteps. He just was given a pass. He hasn't shown me yet that he's actually GOOD at anything other than speaking the words of others.