Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Cash for Clunkers

By CosmicConservative
... and the Law of Unintended Consequences... I am fond of saying that among the major differences between conservatives and liberals is how much respect conservatives have for the Law of Unintended Consequences, and how much liberals seem to simply ignore it. The "Cash for Clunkers" program is a perfect example to show what I mean. There are two political motivations for this program. One is an economic one, the other is ideological. The economic motivation is to prop up automobile manufacturers by artificially creating a demand for new cars. The argument for the economic motiviation is that doing so will save jobs and will provide a return on the American investment in socializing a large chunk of the automobile manufacturing market. The ideological motivation is to replace presumably "less green" automobiles with "more green" ones, therefore reducing both the amount of gas that Americans consume and the amount of CO2 pumped into the atmosphere. Now, both of these can be argued on the merits, and even accepting that they might have some legitimate impact on those two areas, it is still questionable whether MY tax money should be apportioned out this way. I guess I'm not sure where in the US Constitution it says that the government can use my tax money to help pay for ANOTHER person's property accumulation. But all that aside, I would rather point out that there is a very severe unintended consequence to this program that should have been immediately apparent to anyone who was involved in birthing this laughable monstrosity. That consequence is that the most immediate and long-lasting result of this program is going to be a significant inflation in the price of used cars. In effect this whole program is going to remove millions of otherwise perfectly resalable automobiles from the highways, and replace them with later model, more expensive cars. Which means if you have kids who are going to be needing a car soon, you'll be spending more for that car than you thought you would. I also means if you are too poor to buy a new car, even with this program, that your options for purchasing a quality used car have just been significantly eroded as well. In the short term this could well put a lot of used car lots out of business entirely.

Comments (4)

Drax
Used car sales are hurting even more than before. For a different take: http://therightanswer-huey.blogspot.com/2009/08/what-cash-for-clunkers-teaches-us-about.html
CosmicConservative
You are approaching the "Cash for Clunkers" program more as an object lesson for healthcare, and I agree with you completely. I wasn't really making that connection here, mostly I was just trying to point out that the program has unintended consequences. To extrapolate that to health care, I would say that Obama's health care approach will also have major unintended consequences, some of which we can predict (like your prediction that waiting rooms will be jammed and doctors will be overwhelmed) and some we can't (will people still invest fifteen years of their lives and mortgage years of their future to become doctors once the government decides what doctors are allowed to earn?).
Drax
There are a bunch of things which Cash for Clunkers teaches Americans if they have any recognition of history as a teaching element: 1) More people will purchase something if the price is right. (Free in the case of health care services -- resulting in overwhelmed doctors and treasury...) 2) Whenever the government is involved, the bureaucratic red tape becomes so entangling that those providing the service are overwhelmed by the process of interfacing with the government that it is not worth the effort. (So many medical providers won't deal with medicare simply because of the red tape and delays in payment even if they're willing to provide services at a discount. 3) Whenever the government is involved, the potential of overreaching is huge. (Cash for Clunkers HAD a warning when you signed on the government site, that, by doing so, your computer then belonged to the government and that you had no privacy interest in the computer's contents. The warning has been taken down. It is unknown whether the government is continuing to dump the contents of the users' computers into its databases. What rights will we be forced to give up once the government is in charge of our health care records? 4) When it becomes apparent that a government program isn't working as intended, the government, rather than scrapping the program, will increase spending on that program. (Medicare, Medicaid, Social Security, Cash for Clunkers, whatever...) Ah, well. I used "Americans," "history," and "teaching" in the same sentence. More fool I.
CosmicConservative
More and more I'm thinking that the "cash for clunkers" program is an allegory for the entire Obama administration. It is ideologically and politically driven, without respect or concern for unintended consequences. It blatantly abuses the power of the federal government in an outright redistribution of wealth (in this case to ANYONE who has an old car, not even to the "needy" or the "poor"). It was implemented with virtually no thought to how to administer it effectively. At the first sign of trouble the IMMEDIATE reaction was to throw more money at it. The money being spent on it isn't even real money, it is borrowed from our children's children. It doesn't fundamentally address any actual problem, it just shuffles the game pieces around (people will buy new cars when they need to, this just artificially makes those purchases more likely to occur in the summer of 2009, which means it will artificially DIMINISH new car purchases for up to the next 3 - 5 years). I could go on, but I think the point is clear. One comparison I've seen that I like is between the "Cash for Clunkers" program and the Roosevelt program that paid farmers to plow their crops unharvested back into the ground during the Great Depression. This was to artificially boost food prices paid to farmers, payments that were AGAIN subsidized by the federal government (so they paid to DESTROY existing corn, and then paid MORE for the corn that was harvested). At that time the gag was that Roosevelt was "dumber than a jackass" because the donkeys and mules used to do the plowing frequently refused to plow the harvestable crops having been trained for years not to destroy good crops. Whatever else the cash for clunkers program is doing, it is DEMONSTRABLY reducing this nation's usable assets in the form of completely viable automobiles that are being destroyed when they are "cashed in." These are assets that would have traded hands multiple times in normal economic circumstances, providing service for years to come. All of that is now destroyed for the sake of propping up, for a very short time, the ailing auto industry in this nation. It is hard to justify any systematic destruction of usable hard assets, but this nation has just embarked on a program to destroy millions upon millions of usable vehicles.