Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Obama Birthers...

By CosmicConservative
I've commented a couple of times on the whole "Obama wasn't really born in Hawaii" thing. I commented on and linked to a story last week where a Major in the US Army had refused to deploy using the "Obama isn't an American Citizen" argument. Well, that apparently generated a lot of commentary last week, including a statement from the White House yesterday which CNN is describing as the White House "shooting down" the theory. And if CNN says it is shot down, you know there's more to the story. The fashionable thing to do on this story is to compare conservative "birthers" to moonbat "9/11 Truthers" or imbecilic "Moon Landing Hoaxers". Now, I have two thoughts on this, so I want people to read this carefully. 1. I don't give a fig about Obama's birth. He was born to an American citizen who happened to be less than 18 years old. The whole "birther" argument is completely dependent on the "his mother was not 18 years old when Obama was born" because if she HAD been 18, then it wouldn't matter if Obama had been born in Antarctica. And I consider this technicality to be nothing but an oversight on the law. Why they put 18 as the arbitrary age in which a mother's child automatically becomes a citizen is beyond me, and I think it's a stupid thing to have done. If Obama's mother was a citizen, then Obama is a citizen as far as I'm concerned. 2. To compare those who question Obama's citizenship to fruitcakes who accuse the US of murdering 3,000 of its own citizens, or flat-earthers who believe the moon landings were faked is a disingenuous and unfair comparison. I've looked pretty hard at the "Obama isn't a citizen" arguement, and even though I think the whole thing is frivolous and pointless, I am quite convinced that there is in fact some legitimate question about where Obama was born. So if someone wants to make a technical argument about Obama's birth meeting the fine print of the citizenship law, that's a completely legitimate and defensible argument. It is also somewhat facilitated when we learn, as CNN's Lou Dobbs has reported, that Obama's "Long Form" birth certificate (which would be the only actual ORIGINAL document) was "destroyed" by the Hawaiian hospital in which he was supposedly born. So even though I think the whole thing is a waste of time and hinges on a totally arbitrary legal technicality that nobody would care about if they SUPPORTED the guy as President, I think comparisons of "birthers" to true nutcases is unfair and unwarranted.

Comments (22)

Drax
Obama has many vulnerabilities. This ain't one of them. Any serious person who has the aim of affecting public policy will not pursue this phantom.
CosmicConservative
Drax: I concur, but telling people they are tilting at windmills is quite different from calling them nutcases.
Cullen
Yet, while believing this does not necessarily a nutcase make, there are plenty of nutcases who do believe it. Like Drax said, Obama has many vulnerabilities. It would be nice if some of the "birthers" would focus more of their energy on them.
CosmicConservative
Cullen, I concur, but I still think it hurts conservatives in general for us to allow "birthers" to be compared to "9/11 Truthers" who are virtually all liberals who believe that GW Bush murdered 3,000 of our own citizens to start an evil war against Iraq. Allowing this moral equivalence to go unchallenged either legitimizes the "truthers" or deligitimizes fringe conservatives. In fact what we SHOULD say when this comes up is "Our fringe dwellers are confused maybe, but they aren't INSANE!"
Jack
Here’s Obama’s dilemma in a nutshell (READ VERY CAREFULLY AND DIGEST): If BHO shows his original long form birth certificate, indeed showing he was born in Hawaii, it will also show his father was American citizen, Frank Marshall Davis, not the Kenyan/British citizen, Barack Obama Sr. While that would allow Barack Jr. to be POTUS eligible as BOTH a "citizen"/“native born citizen” AND an Article 2 “natural born citizen” -- that is, born to two American citizens on American soil -- it would simultaneously show he is a fraud hiding his real father -- a unacceptable political debacle. If, on the other hand, BHO keeps hiding his original long form birth certificate -- while simply repeating, without showing, he was born in Hawaii -- he can still CLAIM BOTH he was born in Hawaii AND his father was the Kenyan/British Barack Obama Sr. This would enable Barack Jr. to claim he's a "citizen"/“native born citizen” but it would mean (if a federal court would ever get around to declaring and thus far no one has standing to bring the suit) that he’s NOT an Article 2 “natural born citizen” and thus not eligible to be POTUS -- a legal/constitutional debacle since all acts under an illegal POTUS are void. So it seems, BHO has elected option one until forced to go option two because for now it looks like no federal court will ever find a plaintiff with standing. (Of course, there’s the additional issue of BHO losing American citizen status if/when he became an Indonesian citizen -- that is, IF he returned and was naturalized he would be a legal citizen, but would lose both native and natural born status, and, IF he returned and was not naturalized, he would be an illegal immigrant unlawfully in this country -- but we’ll leave that for another day.)
Cullen
Oh, I don't know. There are plenty of fringe conservatives from which I wouldn't mind being disassociated. And I'm not necessarily talking about the "birthers" or those that think "Obama is a seekert Muslin!" However, I think almost all fringe conservatives that are ... unseemly ... can be found in those groups. What we need to do is separate those that are the truly whacked-out fringe, and I mean right-wing extremists like neo-Nazis and those that preach violence to achieve their political and/or religious ends, from those that get caught up in political/anti-political memes. Both parties do a piss-poor job of weeding out their whackos. Where PETA/environmental extremists bombing car dealerships or destroying animal research facilities often falls in the laps of liberal philosophy, so does abortion clinic bombings and the like fall in ours. I'm not going to put "birthers" or "truthers" at the same level of "out there" but it is a slipper slope. If you're willing to become distracted by something like that, then you begin to lose credibility in the big picture (oh, I'm thinking of someone like Glenn Beck). You entertain the idea, even if it's just a, "This probably isn't true, but guess what ... ?" and you've become part of that conspiratorial mind set. Even if you're really not. However, if you take ample time to point out sources and make your "According to's" prominent enough, you can avoid a lot of that. I think the problem is that in today's age of editorialization in the place of reporting, the public has lost some of their ability to discern who's saying what. So, yeah, while I'm not saying that you should have equivalence between "truthers" and "birthers" there will always be a stigma when anyone goes down that path. Ack, that was kind of rambling. Hopefully I've made some kind of point.
CosmicConservative
Cullen: I agree with the loss of credibility point, and in that sense that's similar to the 9/11 Truthers, but to me there's a huge difference in saying "I've never seen real proof that Obama is a citizen" and "Bush deliberately and purposefully murdered 3,000 innocent American citizens and framed Al Queda so he could go to war with Saddam Hussein for putting his daddy on a hit list." But no doubt both do impune one's credibility if they are pursued. Which is a major reason I don't care to pursue the whole "Obama isn't really a citizen" meme. It's just not worth it. But it ain't the same as accusing someone of mass murder to start an illegal war.
Drax
Truthers are insane. Birthers are misguided. Only an insane person or an idiot could believe that Bush was behind 9/11. Birthers have a legitimate beef which could be put to rest by producing the original birth certificate. There is no legitimate comparison between birthers and truthers (or any other lunatic conspiracy theorists...)
Boyd
While there's a difference in degree of lunacy, they're all still lunatics. The Birthers will never be satisfied, regardless of what evidence is presented. That's why there's a laundry list of laughable "questions" about Obama's birth. I don't want to be associated with the Birthers. They live in a different universe from me.
CosmicConservative
Boyd: I simply disagree. I've looked at the known facts on both sides of the "birther" question, and frankly I am convinced there is some "there" there. I think its pointless to pursue it, but "pointless" is not "lunatic."
reggie
I can put my hands on my "official" birth certificate in a flash. I had to produce it to get a job. I had to produce it to get my first drivers license. What has Obummer got to hide? Seems as if he's hiding quite a lot. Typical Chicago political thug
Andy
I have enjoyed reading the comments on this thread. I really don't view myself as "insane," or even "misguided." And I have learned that I am a "birther." I didn't know that society has come up with a new name for what I am...I'm flattered. ;) I hope that I have made it clear in past comments that I believe that this is not going anywhere. And I hope I have also made it clear that it really does bug me. Those pansies...the guys that wore powdered wigs, knee-stockings, and funny jackets that wrote The Constitution of The United States had tremendous fears. I won't go on about them all, but one thing they fretted over was a President with divided loyalties. I believe that they foresaw a day when someone like Obama might try to win the highest post in the land...someone with divided loyalties. Again, I know that this is not going anywhere. Obama will not be removed from office because of his lies about his birth. Obama will be removed from office because he will self-destruct. People with divided loyalties always do. Anti-Obama forces may be marginalized by tagging them as in cahoots with "birthers" for a while. But eventually, a fake falls to pieces.
Drax
Andy: Not "misguided" in the belief that there's something fishy about the whole affair, but "misguided" in their zeal to publicize the issue, allowing the MSM to marginalize the conservative base. Before the election is one thing...but once elected it's too late. There's no way SCOTUS will render the election invalid -- no matter the facts. That's what I mean by "misguided." Why waste time on, not a losing cause, but a lost cause especially when the very act allows your opponents to gather ammunition to use against you on issues which are not yet lost?
CosmicConservative
Drax: That's about my position too. Life, politics and marriage is all about picking your battles. This is a battle conservatives should not pick.
Andy
Drax, I probably misspoke, or left the wrong impression. I know what you meant about "misguided." It is a losing battle at this point, and not worth pursuing. As Cosmic noted, (however veiled) if you know there ain't no winning, just don't back-sass your wife! But it still bugs the crud out of me... :)
Drax
Hmmmm..... http://www.wnd.com/index.php?fa=PAGE.view&pageId=105764
Drax
Nope....another forgery... http://washingtonindependent.com/53494/birthers-latch-onto-forged-kenyan-birth-certificate
CosmicConservative
I suspected as much, which is why I didn't comment on this. Of course we could argue, like Dan Rather, that the DOCUMENT may be fake but it is still TRUE (what was the comment? "Fake but accurate?")
Drax
I thought that no one would have added it as a document in a court case without due diligence. silly me...
Drax
A long, but really well-researched read on the controversy. http://patdollard.com/2009/08/clearing-the-smoke-on-obamas-birth-certificate/
CosmicConservative
I will have to read that tonight. Things are crazy here at work today. I have decided that the proper comparison on the left for the birther issue on the right is the whole GW Bush Air National Guard AWOL foofooraw. The similarities in the two are quite remarkable, actually, including the creation of fake documents to "prove" the contention of one side or the other. Both stories are quite plausible, but neither has any smoking gun to prove or disprove them. And also comparable is how little the proponents of "their guy" even care if the charge is true in the first place.