Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Soldier files suit against Obama's legal residency

By CosmicConservative
This might get interesting.
U.S. Army Maj. Stefan Frederick Cook, set to deploy to Afghanistan, says he shouldn’t have to go. His reason? Barack Obama was never eligible to be president because he wasn’t born in the United States.
An actual trial could force Obama to produce the actual documents "proving" his Hawaian birth. I, for one, would like to see this settled once and for all.

Comments (27)

Old Goat
It just seems quite odd to me that Obama has spent so much money and effort to block this when releasing the documents would put this question to rest. I was skeptical when I first heard about the questions raised about Obama's birthplace. So many cases have been brought up and each one gets pushed out of the way without resolving this. That is what has me wondering if there truly is a problem with his birthplace not being on American ground. I wonder where this will lead. A Major is a fairly high rank in the military, but I bet we will see all kinds of attacks against him for questioning the "one".
CosmicConservative
This is an interesting approach to trying this in court. I know that several attempts to try this have failed so far, mostly because of legal technicalities. In one case a case was thrown out because the judge ruled that the plaintiff could not demonstrate harm, and so there was nothing to sue over. This is different. The major is using the conscientious objector clause to get this into court, saying that he is unwilling to go to war for Obama because if Obama's presidency is ruled unconstitutional, he could be personally held liable for acts of war committed under Obama's command. That's going to be tough to throw out on the same sorts of technicalities other cases have been bounced over. As they say in the press, this one probably has "legs." If it does get tried, look for it to go all the way to the SCOTUS.
Boyd
I'm skeptical that this will go anywhere, but we'll see.
CosmicConservative
If Obama's residency becomes an issue of legal fact, then we should quickly put to rest this pervasive meme on righty blogs that he is unqualified to be President. Frankly I'm not sure what I want. I am torn in trying to decide whether Obama's overt ideology will do more damage to this country than Joe Biden's monumental incompetence.
mtnlurker
Hawaii has already produced a birth certificate. They will trot this out whether is it real or not.
CosmicConservative
mtnlurker: In a court of law the Hawaiian Birth Certificate can be challenged and can be put to tests to ensure it is real. That's why these lawsuits keep getting filed, because there are people who want to put their hands on the actual document. If all they can produce is an after-the-fact birth certificate which can't be demonstrated to be historically accurate, then other evidence can be submitted, such as evidence that his mother was not in the US at the time of his birth. It will be interesting. If it gets that far. I would guess there are powerful forces at work to get this thing killed quickly.
Old Goat
The document produced by Hawaii has some glaring problems with it. From a legal point of view, if it is found that he was indeed not born in the USA, would that render all his actions illegal? Biden is an idiot, but the whole democrat party would suffer from this if it goes against the one.
Drax
This will go nowhere because it can't go anywhere. Obama must be an American citizen because he's been elected President, and the President has to be an American citizen. The time to challenge his residency was when he put his name on each state's individual ballots. It doesn't matter what challenge is made or how legitimate it might be -- it cannot be that a sitting President is doing so contrary to the Constitution -- so no challenge will be allowed -- no examination of birth certificates -- nothing.
CosmicConservative
I'm afraid Drax is probably right, but I've seen more interesting contradictions of such compelling logic in the past. Frankly I think it depends almost entirely on which judge they get.
Drax
The problem is, as it has always been, one of standing. http://docs.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/pennsylvania/paedce/2:2008cv04083/281573/28/0.html First, there must be an injury. Second, the injury must have been caused by Obama -- not some third party (such as registrar of voters or DOJ or some such). Third, the asked for action could address the injury. In other words, unless someone can show that there has been some real and concrete injury caused by Obama not being an American citizen -- and proves that that injury is caused by Obama (not necessarily his STATUS as "President"), AND that the court's ruling could somehow REDRESS that injury, we ain't getting anywhere. To put another way.... The Major fails the "injury" part. Whatever "injury" he claims is pure conjecture. He "might" run into problems "if" he does "something" which "might" result in "someone" doing "something" to him. He fails on the causation issue for that same reason. If he somehow is tried for war crimes, then is Obama at fault for those war crimes because he isn't a Citizen and, therefore, not eligible to be President? He fails the "redress" part as well. Could the Supreme Court (or the lesser Federal Courts) tell the President (a Co-Equal Branch) that hee has to step down when the Constitution states clearly the remedy for removing a President? This is a political question. There's no way that any federal court will open this can of worms -- especially when, under existing law, I don't think ANYONE (currently) has "standing" to bring the issue before any court. (Might be interesting for someone who gets fired by the President, though....)
CosmicConservative
McCain could show injury. So could Sarah Palin. I'm just sayin'
Old Goat
Here's something interesting... the soldier who was bringing this suit had his orders revoked. NO reason given. Tell me this isn't smelling more and more and more with this guy. Last night Obama was at the All Star Game for baseball. He kept saying over and over about his childhood in Hawaii. As a quick aside during his interview with Costas he did mention that he did spend a part of his younger years overseas. This after talking up the minor league in Hawaii. Along with bringing up a KC Royals game he went to when he was 11, and yet he couldn't remember the year even though he knew he was 11. Why would the orders get changed if there is nothing to hide? Why not let this play out in court and get dismissed as the other cases?
Andy
My two cents. I know that Obama was not born in Hawaii. I just know it. Logic tells you that NO ONE would spend so many resources, and evade something that could be so easily answered. Besides, I'm pretty sure he was born in Bethlehem. Drax would know that this ain't going anywhere. Before I read his comment I figured that "potential harm" would not fly. Thanks for the legalese, and the explanation. But I do believe that a fired Executive Branch employee would have a leg to stand on. Of course, we would be in the crapper if Obama was disqualified. Biden was born on Uranus, as Dadman noted. Pelosi was hatched under some rock, and probably doesn't have proof of which rock. Then we would have President Robert Byrd, who obviously is mentally unfit to serve. So, we'd get President Hillary. I never thought I'd say this, but at this point...that wouldn't be so bad.
CosmicConservative
I'm not sure I am entirely in agreement with Drax on the "no harm" analysis. As I said I think it depends on the judge. I've seen amazing interpretations of what constitutes "harm" and what constitutes "responsible party" in courtrooms. For a judge to decide that in this case the Major has as much as 1% of a point may be all the justification needed to put this on the docket. I'd say the odds are slim, but I've seen more bizarre decisions by judges. Including one about to be put in the Supreme Court.
CosmicConservative
As Goat says, the Major's orders have been revoked without explanation. I consider that to be an odd thing. Did the revoke order come from the White House? Very odd.
Andy
The attorney in the case is slobbering all over herself about "winning." I don't see how it is a "win." The guy claims that he "wants" to serve with his unit in Afghanistan. Maybe their definition of a win is different than mine. A win would have been the Major getting the "proof" he sought...not his deployment stopped. I'm just saying.
Old Goat
I guess its winning if the whole point was just to avoid being deployed. I personally would be disappointed if that was what this was truly about. I am more troubled that this gets swept under the rug by the deployment being stopped rather than it playing out. I was not one who totally bought into this before, but when there are SO many suits brought up that question Obama being a natural born citizen it has brought me to re-evaluate what all this adds up to. If it gets proven that he did not qualify with the parameters set in the constitution then that would make every single thing he did illegal. If he was not an American citizen by birth he is not the President.
CosmicConservative
Goat: I'm not sure what the result would be if it is proven that Obama was not qualified to be President. My guess is Congress would create a law that allowed him to be, he would sign it and the SCOTUS would rule it to be Constitutional. There is precedence for that, I believe. John McCain was born in Panama and because of a technical loophole in the citizen definition, it was arguable that McCain was not a citizen. In recognition of his contribution to his country Congress passed a law to address his specific situation to avoid just this sort of potential problem. I dunno if that's how it would play out, but I think that's more likely than that he'd be exiled to the Dominican Republic while the Organization of American States filed a formal protest and Hugo Chavez asked the UN to reinstate him.
Old Goat
The difference with McCain was that he was born on a military base which is technically American ground. If Obama was proven to be a Kenyan lets say, it would take a constitutional amendment to change the requirements. The outrage of the nation that they were lied to would be interesting to see. Even with the Dems running the show right now getting a constitutional amendment passed for this guy wouldn't happen. The SCOTUS can't rule a law constitutional when it would be amending the constitution without going through the proper process. If the last part came about... the UN trying to reinstate him... then the military would take over. Besides, Biden would become President more than likely, even though his status could be called into question being that he was essentially elected by fraud. It would be a mess.
CosmicConservative
Goat: I'm not sure McCain was born ON BASE, although he was born in the Panama territory. My recollection is that Congress passed a law specifically to recognize McCain's birth quite a while ago, but maybe I'm just thinking of an urban legend or something. Anyway, every legal scholar I found on Google on this subject says that there's a legitimate constitutional question with McCain, but that it would almost certainly have been ruled Constitutional by the SCOTUS had the issue been pressed. My last part of the comment was in jest, making a comparison to the Zelaya situation in Honduras... I wasn't serious.
Andy
Cosmic, what you are remembering is that the Senate passed a non-binding resolution recognizing McCain's status as "natural-born" in 2008. I know that Goldwater had to get it all cleared up to run for President, as he was born in Arizona before it was a State. But then, Goldwater didn't have much of a chance anyway. ;) If you care, the wiki-take on this all is: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural-born_citizen
Andy
Just in case you missed it, the DOD has pulled some strings (maybe) to get this guy fired from his civilian job. You can check it out at WorldNetDaily.
CosmicConservative
The Goldwater situation wasn't nearly as troublesome since he was born in a territory which BECAME a state and that was very similar to the situation of the first dozen or so Presidents, all of whom were born in British colonies which then became states.
Old Goat
Actually, others have joined this suit. A retired General as well as others. http://www.ledger-enquirer.com/news/story/778482.html In the comments section there is a question being raised about a class action suit being a possibility regarding taxes raised. Not really sure if that will fly or not, but till his birth certificate issue is cleared up this stuff will continue. Funny how we don't hear much about this issue on the MSM news.