Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Ward Churchill update

By CosmicConservative
Well, I suppose you could argue that the Ward Churchill appeal decision that came down this week wasn't much in the news because of Michael Jackson, Obama's trip overseas and Sarah Palin's resignation, but I still find it interesting how every time the Ward Churchill case has a positive event for Ward it gets all over the news, but when things go badly, you don't see much. Here's the deal. Ward Churchill sued the University of Colorado for firing him and earlier this year a jury ruled that he had been fired unfairly but then they only awarded him $1, signaling that they felt the firing was justified and that they had to rule he had been fired unfairly only because of the presumed technicality that the university would never have examined Churchill if he hadn't written his "little Eichmans" essay. Which could be true, but I believe that is an overly technical reading of the law. So CU appealed. (Yes, the "University of Colorado" is known by the initials "CU" for historical purposes). The appellate ruling is quite interesting. As I understand the 450 page decision brought down by the judge, the ruling is that Ward Churchill's case never should have gone to court in the first place. It completely vacated the Jury decision, reversing the "unfair firing" decision and vacated even the $1 judgment against CU. Furthermore it ruled that reinstating Churchill to CU was not only not a remedy for the firing, but that to do so would be to significantly damage CU's ability to have hiring and firing standards AT ALL, as well as stating that ANY employer has the right to fire an employee who publicly and repeatedly makes disparaging comments about the institution, the people and the policies of the employer. Among other things Churchill said during the trial was that any random sampling of homeless people would have more intellectual honesty than the faculty at CU and that CU was nothing but a glorified trade school. The judge essentially said "Listen Ward, YOU can't want to work there having said what you said, and to FORCE the university to employ you would simply create an uncollegiate environment which would make OTHER employees feel uncomfortable. You made your own bed here." There is one really significant and satisfying aspect of this ruling that really, really makes my day though. With the jury decision which has now been vacated even though Churchill was not awarded his job back, and was only awarded $1, that was TECHNICALLY a victory in a case that was TECHNICALLY about a first amendment case. The law says that in such cases the winner also gains the benefit of having the loser pay all court costs, filing fees, attorney fees, etc. Estimates of the amount of money spent on Ward Churchill's behalf for this case range up to about $2,000,000. It is almost certain that his attorney has been paying those costs since Churchill is essentially a professional chiseler and bum. So that means that while Churchill is out $1 and won't get his job back, his attorney has likely spent up to $2,000,000 of his firm's cash on this case, and now they won't see a penny of that coming back. Of course it will get appealed again, but this judge seems to have crossed a lot of "t"s and dotted a lot of "i"s. So there is a good chance that if they do pursue this through more appeals, it's just going to cost his attorney more money. I love that. I really do.

Comments (7)

Boyd
They've got this new-fangled thang called the "World Wide Web," and it uses a brand, spanking new technology called "hyperlinking." You should check it out, Cosmic. :P
CosmicConservative
LOL, I am lazy about hyperlinking actually. However, in this case I didn't hyperlink it because I was listening to this analysis on the radio. Here's a quick link I found by using the wonderful new technology called "Google" which allowed me to type in "Ward Churchill vacated" and hit "send". You should check it out. :)
Boyd
Sorry I didn't respond sooner, Cosmic. I was busy reading the court's decision which I found here (PDF). Googling "ward churchill appeal." :) :P
Andy
Ya' gotta love it... Heck, I'd pay money to see (the other) Churchill's face...and his attorney as they read this judge's decision. Gives you some hope that the whole world isn't completely INSANE just yet.
CosmicConservative
My favorite part in the article I linked is when they asked the jury member why they awarded $1, and he said "Well, his attorney kept telling us it wasn't about the money, so we took him at his word." I love that.