Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Thought experiment

By CosmicConservative
OK, this is just for fun... First off, pretend you are not married, have no children, etc... Let's say you wake up one morning and find yourself accosted by an alien with a time machine. The alien informs you that you have just been selected for a test of the human species to see if they are worth saving from extinction. The test is for you to be sent back 5,000 years into the past to a random location on earth, at a random time of year. You don't know if you will find yourself cut off from other human society, or in the midst of a stone age culture where you will have to fit in or be killed. You are told that you can take whatever you can fit into one standard backpack and the clothes you can wear. They provide you with the backpack. Your progress in the past over the course of the next 20 years will determine the fate of the human race. You can only take with you personal items you have in the house at that moment. What would you put in the backpack, and what single item would you consider to be absolutely essential to humanity being saved from extinction? Hurry, you only have 30 minutes to pack...

Comments (19)

JSullins
I'm probably missing the point by making the too obvious choices, but... A good knife A water bottle A boyscout manual (yes I do have one), which contains such gems as how to start a fire... Some prepackaged granolabar"ish" food. Boots. That might keep me alive a little bit, now for the single item... Well, obviously I'd have to take the scriptures of my faith. I doubt that's what you were looking for. Can I ask the alien for the time machine and take that? Assuming it would fit. Also, what constitutes progress? Survival? Cultural achievement? Scientific advance?
Brian
A really good knife. An MRE. Poncho liner. Box of matches. THEN I'd jet to the library and/or Barnes and Noble and hunt up all of the books I can find on survival, 'how to make stuff', woodcraft, fieldcraft, etc. (paper back by choice) and I'm set.
Cullen
Knife, poncho and wubbie (poncho liner), waterproof matches, 2 sets cool-weather clothes, 2 sets warm-weather clothes, water, dehydrated foodstuffs... Books, including the Bible and the Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy. One item ... I'm not sure. Maybe an MP3 player. "Some day, you'll discover electricity and when you learn to harness it, you still won't have one of these. It'll take years, but it'll change your life. You have this to live for." That'll bring 'em to now at least. :)
CosmicConservative
Best way to use a boyscout manual to start a fire? Use the pages of the manual as kindling... What I am driving at is precisely what you think the aliens would consider "progress" and what you think would be critical to bring along to help in achieving that progress. Assuming, that is, that you don't want the human race to be exterminated. The rest of the backback should be filled with whatever you think will work best to keep you alive, healthy and sane long enough to figure out how to survive for 20 years while working on that progress thing. This does imply that you will have to interact with the indigineous humans of the period, whether you are dropped on top of them or not...
Dadman
Hmmm...I believe I would bring the following: - knife - hatchet - rifle (the kind you can disassemble into smaller parts), scope and ammo - water to last a few days (keeping my fingers crossed that a good - water source will soon be discovered) - matches/flint - sheets of plastic for water collection and/or protection - dehydrated food - high-tech (e.g. GoreTex or something like it) warm and cold weather clothing (with sturdy shoes and several pair of thick, warm socks) - rope/cord - first aid kit (antiseptics) - copy of U.S. Constitution and Declaration of Independence (political issues will be unavoidable in a 20 yr. span) - seeds of all varieties (corn, potatoes, carrots, etc.) - one hot female (of small stature) for procreation purposes - a puppy (to sustain sanity, and to eat if necessary...just kidding!) - copy of the Lord of the Rings - gold and gems for bartering (if necessary) - toothpaste, toothbrush - shampoo I think my backpack is full now...and the aliens are tired of waiting.
Ed Minchau
Hi there, This is totally off-topic, but... I maintain the Space Blogroll, a group of blogs that write about space and astronomy. I just added your blog to the Space Blogroll today, bringing the total number of blogs on the list to 127. If you would like to display the Space Blogroll on your blog, you can find the necessary code here.
JSullins
To determine what constitutes progress, I'd want some more info on the aliens: Are they a race of warriors, impressed by honor and strength? Are they philosophers and artists who abhor violence? Are they massive hedonistic gluttons? Are they cold, logical, and calculating? Are they actually evolved versions of ourselves from the distant future evaluating their own worthiness to exist? Without this knowledge I might be playing to the wrong audience, so to speak.
Dean Esmay
Several good knives. A sturdy rifle with about a thousand rounds of ammo. Several MREs. A large supply of waterproof matches. A copy of the 11th edition of the Encyclopedia Brittanica,circa early 20th century.
Dean Esmay
Without knowing what they're going to judge humanity on, however, I'd be hard pressed to do anything but introduce republicanism and technology to them.
CosmicConservative
See, not knowing what aliens find to be progress is what this thought experiment is all about. The rule was that you can only bring what's already in your house, so unless Dadman has a break-apart rifle and a diminutive procreative partner there, he's not following the rules, as others are also not following the rules. Here is how I would answer the question, for what it's worth: In the backpack, or in my pockets, on my belt, etc... - Leatherman multi-tool. - Binoculars (two pairs, actually) - Buck folding hunting knife and sheath - .22 pistol with a reasonable amount of ammo, not an arsenal - Pocket compass - A change of clothes - My good rugged layered outdoor stuff - Sleeping bag - Hatchet - Folding hand saw - My set of Foxfire Books (not "Firefox" this is a set of books about how to build a log cabin, how to make soap, what plants are good to eat, how to make rope, weave baskets, etc... - Magnifying glass (good for making fires) - Portable spinfishing rod and a set of basic lures. - Portable flyfishing rod and boxes of flies - All the fishing line I could fit and hooks - Fly-tying kit and tools - All the string and wire I could find in the house - All the magnets I could find - Flashlight and extra batteries - Whetstone - All the needles I can find in the house - Medication and first aid kit - Tape, preferably duct tape, but even electricians tape would be good. - As much paper as is feasible and some pens or pencils - Butane lighter (not cigarette, but woodstove) - Harmonica (I can't play now, but in 20 years I'll be pretty good) That's about all I could fit in the backpack, if I could even fit all that in. I'd add some food, but not a whole lot, maybe a few days worth is all. I wish I had a pocket water purifier, but I'll just have to deal with it I guess. So outside of this, the one thing I would consider essential for the trip would be my portable 60mm telescope. Oh, if the alien would allow it, I'd sling my .22 rifle over my shoulder too. So the question now is why I would consider the telescope to be so essential?
Brian
So the question now is why I would consider the telescope to be so essential? I'm probably paraphrasing what he actually said but "But still, it moves"
Brian
See, not knowing what aliens find to be progress is what this thought experiment is all about. P*ss on what they think is progress. Who are _they_ to judge? Who sent them around to be the Galactic police, eh? Mr. Alien if you exterminate humanity best do it right or we'll bounce back and exterminate you. The rule was that you can only bring what’s already in your house, I admit I did not see that bit. T
Dadman
You could use the telescope as a means to determine your precise time and place in the space-time continuum. Knowing that, you could accurately predict known astronomical events (such as a passing comet or eclipse) and establish yourself with the natives as a omnipotent, god-like being thus increasely your likelihood of survival...and a pampered existence. Of course, such self-indulgence might annoy the aliens and doom humanity to certain destruction. By the way, I was thinking if I brought along a diminutive mate stuffed into my backpack it might give the aliens a good chuckle...and humor might be just the quality they are looking for...
CosmicConservative
Brian actually seems to have figured out both aspects of what I was looking for. The telescope is essential becuase I believe it was the telescope more than any other invention that put humans on the road to rationality. When Galileo demystified the heavens, he demystified the universe. The purpose is exactly the opposite of what Dadman was suggesting. It is not to set up a God, but to demonstrate the power of reason. On the subject of "what is progress?" Since you don't know what the aliens are looking for, your only hope is to go with your own convictions.
Dadman
Oh brother. I believe you're taking your thought experiment a little too seriously. I was trying to have a little fun with it. One could certainly demonstrate the power of reason without a telescope. And there is no guarantee those you encounter would respond to your telescope induced 'demystified universe' and might still seek your destruction (perhaps so they could steal your telescope). Using your unique knowledge of the universe to establish supremacy might still be necessary to secure your survival and perhaps the survival of the human race. Afterall, we have no idea what these stupid aliens are looking for.
CosmicConservative
Hey, it's my thought experiment.... ;) It is likely that trying to show a telescope to a hunter-gatherer tribe 5,000 years ago would not have the same effect as showing medieval folks the same thing 500 years ago. It is likely you'd have to work them up to it, it might take 20 years to get them ready for it. As far as establishing my deity credentials, I don't think I'd use the telescope for that, that's in part why I packed all the magnets, wires, magnifying glass, flashlight, pistol, etc... I think I could pass myself off as a quite respectable wizard using those items alone.
Brian
I think I could pass myself off as a quite respectable wizard using those items alone. Until your bullets run out. THEN we'll see who is the smarty-pants.
CosmicConservative
I don't think it's only the bullets that I would use to convince the locals of wizardry. But that's probably a subject for a different post, so I'll post a new one!