Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

More "science reporting" nonsense...

By CosmicConservative
CNN.com - Rediscovering the New World - Mar 5, 2006 This is actually an important story. Somehow the story neglects to mention that the Clinton administration literally dumped millions of tons of dirt on top of this find for reasons that remain quite murky. But this portion of the story is just so incredibly representative of what passes for "science reporting" in the mainstream media:
Sophisticated forensic techniques have allowed scientists to plumb these remains for secrets of how life began in the New World.
Perhaps some "sophisitcated editing techniques" should be applied to this reporter's nonsense. What the reporter is trying to say is that this find might shed some light on how humans first colonized and ultimately conquered the "New World" but this seems to be saying that before 9,000 years ago, North and South America were as lifeless as the surface of Mars. Then there's this pablum:
And thanks to a deeper understanding of Kennewick Man and much more scientific research into ancient artifacts and migration patterns, scientists are piecing together a picture of human life in this hemisphere that's far more complex and certainly much older than anyone had previously imagined.
Oh really? older and more complex than ANYONE imagined? Anyone? Man I hate it when lame-brained writers make such moronic sweeping statements. I am quite certain that if you wanted to you could find scholarly articles which speculate that humans evolved in Mexico, and colonized Asia. If not that, then I am sure that you can find legends throughout North and South America that say that humans have lived in these lands since the world was created. But according to this reporter, not one single human being in the entire history of the planet could have imagined that human life was older and more complex in this hemisphere than the anthropology texts say. This isn't just bad writing, it's quite literally junk science. And the worst part of it? This story is a cover story for Time magazine and is featured on CNN as a top story. Somebody got paid a LOT of money for this intellectual mish-mash. Man that bugs me.

Comments (1)

Brian
Someone at Time isn't doing their research. I'm pretty certain I recall that artifacts have been carbon dated in Texas past 30,000 years, midden heaps found etc. These jokers weren't our native Americans but a different race altogether.