Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Summer(?) in the Rockies....

By CosmicConservative
So yesterday, on June 14, we did our first deck barbecue of the year. It was chilly. Coming inside after eating I ran across several weather related stories. Here's a short rundown: 1. Alaska is having record cold weather. 2. Canadian crops are at risk due to late frosts, late snow and continued cold temperatures. 3. Snow has fallen across the northern US and norther Europe in many countries/cities later than ever previously recorded. 4. Ice levels in the arctic are not falling as fast as previous years. 5. Cities from Washington DC to Portland Maine have been having record cold temperatures. 2009 may end up colder than 2008. 2008 continued a trend since 1998 of continued global temperature drops. So... when you see stories about the "fierce moral urgency" of worldwide CO2 reductions because of the "dangers" of Anthropogenic Global Warming, remember that it has nothing to do with weather, nothing to do with sea level rises, ice caps melting or the plight of polar bears. It has EVERYTHING to do with governments of the world seizing control of the life-blood of the world ecnomomy, which is the generation of cheap, sustainable energy. That's all it is.

Comments (14)

Drax
Not knowing the science surrounding these issues, I, like the vast majority of the world, have to rely on those who have devoted their lives and reputations to researching them. There are simply too many scientists who conclude otherwise for me to simply dismiss them out of hand. Likewise, there are too many scientists who conclude as you do for me to believe this to be a settled scientific inquiry. Accordingly, as usual, I think that prudent measures -- especially ones which have independent beneficial effect -- should be pursued to prevent the catastrophic effects that scientists who conclude contrarily to you.
Dadman
I agree with Cosmic on this one. AGW is science being used as a political weapon. Phoenix, btw, is experiencing the coolest June I can remember having in the 18 years I've lived here...
Drax
Dadman, I don't disagree that there are some who are using science as a "political weapon." I simply assert that there are such a huge number of scientists who conclude both that GW exists and that it is caused (or increased) by Man that it is necessary to listen to them (subject to the caveat listed above). The politicians and environmental wackos USE their findings -- they don't CREATE them.
CosmicConservative
Drax: The vast global "consensus" of scientists is part of the politicization of this issue. It has become impossible to gain access to federal grant money if you don't toe the AGW line. My problem is not that I know too LITTLE about the science of AGW, but that I know too MUCH. For example, I know that the graphs Al Gore used to "prove" AGW were factually incorrect. I know quite a bit about how the climate computer models are created, and how much they DON'T cover, including such obvious things as variegated ocean temperatures and variable cloud cover. On top of that I know that every computer model prediction that has been made has been proven wrong. In 1998 computer models showed a continued increase in temperatures through the next 50 years, when the reality has been a decade of consistent cooling. The models were not only wrong in quantity, they were wrong in direction. They predicted higher temps, we have had, and continue to have, lower temps. And that isn't even beginning to address the critically important issue of whether there is anything acutally to FEAR from increased global temperatures. One thing we DO know from science is that COOLER temperatures are a serious threat to crop production, growing seasons and human health. WARMER temperatures, throughout human history, have been associated with higher crop yields, longer growing seasons and reduced human mortality. I am fine with monitoring CO2 output. I am fine with taking reasonable measures to reduce CO2 output. I generally believe in the concept of doing as little to impact the environment as possible, and I am also a huge fan of efficiencies, large and small. So sure, let's see what we can do to produce energy without burning billions of gallons of oil and billions of tons of coal. Absolutely. But lets do so RESPONSIBLY, and based on ACTUAL SCIENCE as opposed to reacting to panic that appears to me to be purposefully created specifically to allow governments to take more control of our daily lives.
Drax
CC: Just because Algore is an idiot with an agenda who presents fiction as fact doesn't mean that all scientists who claim that global warming is real, is caused by Man, and is potentially catastrophic to Man are idiots with agenda presenting fiction as fact. And, there's a BUNCH of them who say GW is real. Of course too much cold is bad, just as too much hot is. Both could be catastrophic. (There is an "upside" to either, however. We could solve the nagging question "What happened to the dinosaurs? by asking them -- directly.) As I said (and with which I think you agree) "Prudent measures" should be taken -- especially ones which have independent beneficial effect.
Andy
Cosmic, "fierce moral urgency" is an interesting way to frame the AGW alarmists method. I do not accept for one moment the possibility, and can not wrap my brain around ANY way that mankind can change the weather on our planet. Whether warmer or cooler is better, really makes no difference. It's all about money. (With the exception of the few moronic "true believers.") Without this world-wide panic/scare/alarm many thousands of "scientists" would be managing a Burger King, and fighting over University teaching positions. But because there is a "crisis," the money pours in like water for "research" from governments. That money would just go away if there was no "crisis." ("You want fries with that?") The whole thing is a sham. It is a con-game contrived by otherwise useless (or of very little use) guys that like the study of weather, but don't want to stand in front of a camera and report it on the 10 pm news. It is promoted by guys like Gore, who would be a footnote in history without it, and companies like GE with billions to make if the public swallows the hook, and by those like Obama that see an opportunity to control businesses and the public generally, and by morons like Senator "I support cap and trade legislation" McCain who doesn't really have a clue. (Man, that was a long sentence.) The "scientists" that say global warming is real are liars with an agenda. Well, maybe they are not "liars." We do not have the ability to know what the climate was like eons ago, nor do we have the perspective required. There is a lot of supposition, study, etc. But the hubris required to make a claim like that disqualifies the statement out of hand. So, maybe they are not liars. But they are intellectually, and "morally" arrogant, and definitely have an agenda.
CosmicConservative
Drax: Here are the reasons I am an Anthropogenic Global Warming skeptic. 1. The fundamental data which has been used to demonstrate Global Warming has been REPEATEDLY proven to be false. In some cases the falseness has been accidental (as in the computer tracking which repeated old data when an entire Russian series of temperature sensors went offline). In other cases it has been deliberate (when the famous "hockey-stick" graph was put together by actively cherry-picking some data and leaving out other data). In fact NASA has had to republish YEARS worth of temperature data when fact-finders have demonstrated that their data was flawed. 2. The actual SCIENCE of AGW is flawed. The THEORY of AGW is that CO2 is a "greenhouse gas" and as such it causes temperature increases in a closed system. However, the ACTUAL temperature increasing effect of CO2 is INFINITESIMAL on its own. The actual scientifically MEASURED impact of CO2 as a greenhouse gas is TRIVIAL. If you plug the ACTUAL VALUES for CO2 into any computer model, you DON'T GET WARMING. So, AGW proponents have advanced a THEORY that CO2 is an ENABLING AGENT which magnifies the effects of WATER VAPOR. This is known as the "MULTIPLIER EFFECT" and the THEORY is that increasing amounts of CO2 (which would have NEGLIGIBLE greenhouse impact on their own) cause more water to evaporate into water vapor, and it is the increased water vapor which results in the increased temperature. THIS HAS NEVER BEEN PROVEN, either in the laboratory or in the real world. IT IS A COMPLETE AND UTTER FABRICATION. 3. The means of predicting AGW is ENTIRELY through computer models. Those computer models have NEVER BEEN CORRECT. Prior to 1998 they predicted a slower increase than we actually saw. That was one reason for the Al Gore led worldwide PANIC about AGW. "OMIGOD! IT'S WORSE THAN WE THOUGHT!!!" Since 1998 they have predicted MORE warming when the world has actually cooled. It is my (pseudo)scientific opinion that THE MODELS ARE FLAWED. I pointed out two major areas where they are flawed already. There are many other flaws, including the fundamental belief that we are able to model something as complex as climate in the first place. Now, I am willing to concede that human activity MIGHT be having an impact on global temperatures, but the scope and specifics of that impact are simply not "science" at this time. Why then do so many scientists believe it is real? In part some are simply true believers. I could point out that the VAST majority of physicists (which may be the single group of the "smartest people in the world") BELIEVE in String Theory when String Theory has been the biggest 30 year bust in physics since modern physics was born. Yet believe they do. In part that's because if you want to get money for research in physics, you have to toe the String Theory line. Gee, doesn't that sound familiar?
Drax
As I noted in an earlier thread, I have no problem whatsoever accepting that human activity can alter the atmosphere and, ultimately, the weather. When you have to wear a mask to breathe the air, the atmosphere has been altered. When you can see the air you breathe, the atmosphere has been altered. When rain kills flora and poisons fauna, the atmosphere has been altered. The degree can be argued. The consequences can be argued. But whether Man has the ability to alter, and has actually altered, the atmosphere simply is an argument which, for me, is settled.
Dadman
Hmmm...it may be true that human activity impacts the atmosphere (although I would argue most of that impact is limited to areas in and around population centers); it is far less certain that our atmospheric contributions are FUNDAMENTALLY altering the earth's global climate system in ways that inevitably will be detrimental to all life on earth. I'm for prudent,incremental adjustments to the way we live, however, what is presently being proposed by Democrats in Congress, e.g. cap and tax, is anything but prudent, particularly in the midst of a recession. Nevermind that CO2 is no pollutant as has been declared by the EPA...
Drax
Dadman, considering that wind currents pretty much take air from anywhere and put it (eventually) just about everywhere, even though the concentrations of pollutants will be greatest where they are created, I don't see how they have their "impact limited" to those areas. Certainly, the effect is greatest in the areas where the pollutants are the greatest. But, just because you can eat the air with a spoon in Mexico City doesn't mean that the air in Arizona is "clean."
Old Goat
The thing to do is follow the money with Global Warming, or now as it is being called because of the warming portion going the wrong way for them, Global Climate Change. There is actually a larger group of scientists who disagree with the whole GW debate as its presented. More believe it is tied with the sun activity. The means used to gather temperature changes are greatly flawed, and there are tons of articles about this. Its a separate issue when you go into the environmental impacts, but because it has been linked together now through GW it has gained political clout. This has a lot more to do with politics than anything else. The Environmentalists are a large voting block.
CosmicConservative
Drax: Air pollution is probably not nearly as convincing an issue as water pollution to make your point about pollution having an "impact" across the world. However, nobody denies that soot and chemicals from Mexico City end up in Beijing eventually. What people question is whether the concentrations are significant enough to alter climate measurably. It is my personal opinion that in terms of global impact to the biosphere, the damage humans have done to water quality is literally millions of times more damaging than CO2 emissions have been. And that is one of my big problems with AGW politics. The laser focus that Al Gore and his ilk have put on AGW convinces gullible fools that if they "reduce their carbon footprint" they are "doing something to help the environment" all the while pouring massive amounts of chemicals down the drain, and into their yards and gardens. We have become bizarro world. Seriously.
Drax
CC: While the air in one area of the Earth may not be "as" polluted as air in another, if we keep pumping things into the air which we cannot safely breath, sooner or later all the planet will look essentially like Mexico City. That's inevitable. Keep putting things into the air (and, at an ever-increasing rate as more people enter the picture and more countries become industrialized), and eventually the air in Arizona's desert will be as polluted as that of Mexico City. As you know, I'm no "eco-nut." I just think that there's absolutely no downside to exploring alternative energy sources. If the GW fanatics are right, then it helps out there. If they're wrong, then we're going to run out of oil and coal at some point anyway. Etc. So...that's what I mean by "prudent measures which have independent beneficial effect."
CosmicConservative
Drax: If by "run out of oil and coal at some point anyway" you mean "sometime in the next 300 years" then I agree with you. But I expect by then we'll be off oil and coal entirely, not because of political pressure, but because fusion will be much more economical anyway, and coal and oil will be more valuable as a component of new materials anyway (like carbon fiber super cables employed in space elevators). I agree there is no downside in "exploring alternative energy sources." However there is a huge downside in being forced to abandon an abundant, cheap and proven energy source while chasing unproven, expensive and uncommon ones.