Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The "Explosion" of culture

By CosmicConservative
Drax, in another post, presented is skepticism that human culture could have suddenly "Exploded" from stone-age neanderthal-like beginnings, into complex societies which exhibit a full range of language, art, tools and culture. This was in response to a documentary he watched on TV about how neanderthal and "cro-magnon" cultures co-existed at more or less the same level for thousands of years, but neanderthals disappeared and "cro-magnon" developed the cultures we see as human civilization. The documentary explained this by asserting that the explosion of culture was driven by the development of complex languages. (Drax, if I'm misrepresenting, let me know). I don't have time at the moment to give this due attention, so I'll add to this later today when I get a chance.

Comments (52)

Drax
That was how it was presented, i.e., that, even though homo sapiens had existed for thousands upon thousands of years with what is thought to be the same brain as current Man, the "explosion" of culture was due to the discovery of language. I just don't buy it.
CosmicConservative
Not having seen the show I am having to base my response on your representation of what the show said and how they explained it. I have to say right off the top of my head that as you present it, I would also disagree with that assertion. It is not in accord with what I understand about our anthropological understanding of the development of human culture. However, there is a nugget of accuaracy in the statement which I will try to address. Although I need to be clear that it is not my intention to defend the perspective of the show you saw, only to express my own understanding of what anthropology tells us, coupled with my own critical reasoning from what I have observed in life. Human culture is an intersting subject to explore. It is especially interesting to explore when you contrast different cultures from different times and even more so when you contrast different cultures from the SAME time. When you look at archaeological investigations of human civilization you are in a situation similar to looking at fossils of dinosaur bones. You have some "hard evidence" in the form of physical remains, but all the "soft tissue" has disappeared. So you have to make judgment calls. When you look at the archaeological remains of an early Mesopotamian city (Ur, for example) you find artifacts in the form of ruins, pottery, tools, jewelry, etc. In viewing those artifacts it is easily and abundantly clear that ancient Mesopotamians had a "rich" language which allowed for most of what we do today, such as telling stories, keeping records, doing calculations, communicating governmental rulings, etc. So we KNOW with certainty that ancient Mesopotamians had a "rich" language. When you look at the remains of a "cro-magnon" dwelling (or a neanderthal one from the same period) you find artifacts as well. Those artifacts also include tools, jewelry, bones and dwelling places. But what they DON'T include is writing. From that you can conclude that the people of that time did not carve their thoughts into stone, or otherwise write them down. But the level of language that existed at that time is a "soft tissue" thing. It didn't survive. However, it is possible to do a comparitive study to gain some insight into the richness of cro-magnon language. To do so all you have to do is ask if there are any CURRENTLY EXISTING cultures with a similar "hard evidence" factor to ancient cro-magnons. And as it turns out, therre are PLENTY of such cultures, some which exist to this day, and MANY which existed only a few hundred years ago, and for which detailed records have been made of those cultures by their contemporaries. So the question is "how realistic is it that a stone age culture of 10,000 years ago lived more or less the same as a stone age culture of 200 years ago?" And to me the answer is "pretty realistic." In the other thread I used the example of doing an archaeological dig in a Lakota Sioux village site and comparing it to a cro-magnon site of 10,000 years earlier. What you would find in the two sites would be remarkably similar. Stone tools, beads, burials, remains of meals, etc. So it is fairly reasonable to suggest that cro-magnons lived much the same way that Lakota Sioux did before the arrival in their area by Europeans. So the question is, "how 'rich' was the language of the Lakota Sioux?" As it happens, that language survives. Not only that, but it was converted into a written language in 1850 by Christian missionaries. Which means that before 1850 the language was purely oral. Now, as to "how rich" the language is, that's entirely debatable. The language had a similar grammar to other languages and had the concepts of verb, noun, article, direct object, etc. In other words if you wanted to tell a story in Lakota Sioux, you could tell a story every bit as complex and nuanced as the oral stories of the Mediterranean which were eventually transcribed by Homer. The language allowed for physical and metaphysical concepts and had provisions for describing past, present and future. But, it had virtually no math. And few specific classifications and sub-classifications. It would be difficult using the original Lakota Sioux language to describe a complex technical procedure, for example. So from this I would presume that cro-magnon cultures had similar "complexity" in their languages. More later, have to go now.
CosmicConservative
OK, back... for a bit. So... if cro-magnon had a language that was rich enough to tell stories, track seasons, and locate preferred hunting grounds, why, 10,000 years ago, did India, China, Europe and even parts of South America suddenly develop a full-blown culture, complete with public buildings, monuments, calendars, statues and more, while in North America none of this happened? In North America many of the indigenous tribes had developed agriculture. In fact our modern corn plant was bred for thousands of years by North American aborigines. So clearly they knew how to plant and even breed crops. I've actually never seen this addressed in the reading I've done on the subject. Although I am sure there are no doubt dozens of highly technical papers addressing the subject. Here is my theory. Metallurgy. Every civilization that I know of that can be said to have "advanced" to the point that they have public buildings, complex governments, calendars, organized growing, harvesting and storage of grain, etc... ALL that stuff, in every case I've seen, is associated with cultures that have learned to work metal. The pyramids were built with copper and bronze tools. The temples of Athens, the Parthenon in Rome, etc. All done with bronze tools. China's Great Wall, India's ancient palaces, all carved with bronze tools. Recent evidence of bronze tools in Incan and Mayan digs demonstrates that those cultures used bronze for axes, knives, plows, etc. My theory is as follows, and it's pretty simple. When you are trying to sow, nurture and reap grain, you have to first plow the ground. When you are trying to build a plow, you have to cut down trees and create lumber. Then you have to put the business part of the "plow" on the plow. You can do that with stone tools. In fact that's exactly how it was done for all cultures originally. When the Iriquois showed European settlers how to plant and harvest corn, they used stone tools. But stone tools are incredibly expensive. It takes great skill to manufacture a stone axe. And the axe head is easy to break. Same with a stone plow. Each stone axe or plow had to be PAINSTAKINGLY (and I put that in caps because I LITERALLY mean PAIN is involved) cut from a stone block, a process that takes hours or days to complete, and one in which a high number of stone blanks are broken and have to be discarded. And once in use, they chip and break extremely easily. Copper is much better. Once you learn how to smelt copper, you can pour your molten copper into sand or mud molds and make dozens of axe blades or plows a day. And they last forever, compared to stone tools. This is a self-reinforcing phenomenon too. Once you have copper picks and hammers, it is much, much easier to dig and break apart the ore so you can smelt more copper. Once you have copper axes it is much easier to cut down trees and create the lumber you need to make more pick, plow and axe handles. The problem with copper is that it is soft. It is estimated that a typical copper chisel in use carving the stones for the pyramids was being sharpened twice as much as it was being used to carve the stone blocks. However, it is fortunate that it is a far less exacting skill to sharpen a chisel than it is to use that chisel to carve a stone. So having three chisel sharpeners constantly sharpening chisels keeps your stone-carver constantly carving stone. Bronze is much better. Bronze, an alloy of copper and tin, is far harder than copper or tin are by themselves. The creation of bronze was likely rediscovered several times in human history, in part because there are natural ores which contain both copper and tin, and in part because tin and copper are two metals that are both abundant and have a relatively low melting point which could be reached with nothing more technically difficult than a large charcoal brazier. In fact the better a culture was at making bronze, the more successful they were at building roads, buildings and long-lasting cultures. Bronze samples from South America were "cold-worked" bronze. Cold worked bronze is softer than annealed bronze and requires a lot more effort to make a usable chisel or plow. ("Cold worked" means the metal-worker literally shaped the item "cold" by beating on it with a hammer. In the case of South America, the hammers were usually rock hammers, another indication that bronze, although it existed, was not nearly as common as it was in, say, Mesopotamia or Egypt.) Anyway, once you have a viable metal-working infrastructure you can make thousands or tens of thousands of axes and plows that can be used to grow vast amounts of food, cut down entire forests and carve stone for every conceivable purpose including laying down paving stones for wheeled vehicles. So in my mind you put three things together and you get the explosion of art, culture, tools, etc... Those three things are: 1. Rich language 2. In-depth knowledge of farming and animal husbandry 3. Metallurgy You have those three, you will have an explosion. If you have 1 and 2, but not 3, you will probably not have the explosion.
Drax
The traditional view is that "culture exploded" in Europe some 40,000 years ago. (There is some evidence that it was some 100,000 years ago...same link.) Homo sapiens appeared between 200,000 and 300,000 years ago, meaning that sufficient humans existed that we can find remains of them today for anywhere from 160,000 and 260,000 before "culture exploded." This is what they were talking about on that show. WHAT explains this extraordinary length of time -- with the same brain -- before Man "found culture?" THEY posited that the explanation is the creation of language. (Those were the words used -- "creation of language.") In other words, prior to the explosion of culture, homo sapiens didn't have language; homo sapiens discovered language; culture blossomed. Utter balderdash. Frankly, I think they have it all wrong. I don't think Man became Man UNTIL he found language, and that the difference between the ability to communicate (in a human sense as opposed to that of an animal) is what MAKES us human. Maybe not expressing that well. IF "Man" went a quarter of a million years without language, he wasn't "Man." What is accepted as "homo sapiens" aren't. IF "Man" went a quarter of a million years without language, THEN "got" language, it is at THAT point that homo sapiens arose. IF "Man" went a quarter of a million years without language, THEN "got" language, then "something" happened BIOLOGICALLY which ALLOWED him to "get" language, a "something" which was MISSING for a quarter of a million years. So, I guess I'm saying that I don't think that the "cultural explosion" was created by the discovery of language, but that there was an evolutionary event which created homo sapiens out of something which was NOT homo sapiens -- and homo sapiens NECESSARILY have "language" as a skill-set, and "language" has, as a necessary component, CULTURE. Or something along those lines.
CosmicConservative
Oh, you are going WAY back. I thought when you talked about an explosion of tools, art, etc. I thought you were referring to what we generally consider the dawn of civilization. The show you watched was going back much further than I was thinking. I'll have to give some more thought to that. I haven't really given a lot of thought to "human" culture that predates stone tools even... Hmm.... something to think about...
CosmicConservative
OK, I'm officially embarrassed. I totally missed the point you were making and spent 20 minutes pontificating on a completely irrelevant topic. I probably do that a lot... I am seriously going to have to think more about this. They aren't just saying "language" at least in the article they aren't. They are saying that "symbolic thought" is represented by the beads, which is a more fundamental concept even than language, but I think most people would agree symbolic thinking is required for any abstract language to be understandable.
Drax
No need to be embarrassed. Like I said, I wasn't doing that great of a job explaining things. As to what the article stated, I agree. I was using it more a guidepost to the linked paragraph rather than to establish what was said on that t.v. show. But, that's the fundamental underpinnings of what I'm saying. You can't have language without "symbolic thought." Not above that of animals, anyway. And, as soon as you're capable of "symbolic thought," language is almost certain to almost immediately follow. After all, when you're able to "symbolically think," you're going to try to express that thought orally, through tangible representations (paintings, carvings, etc.), and other means. Thus, language creates culture ... but this creation is almost IMMEDIATE in the great scheme of things. This being my thought process, I can't CONCEIVE of "humans" running around for the better part of a quarter of a million years being capable of "symbolic thought" WITHOUT there being evidence of a corresponding expression of that thought through "culture."
CosmicConservative
Like I said, I have to think about this. My gut feeling is that there's something deeper going on here and that understanding that may be key to understanding not just culture, but consciousness itself. I haven't had a juicy conundrum like this to ponder in a while. I'm excited.
Foobarista
An interesting theory that makes some sense is a combination of climate change + the Toba supervolcano eruption of about 75K years ago. (An aside: I'm not an AGW fanatic, but have always been something of a weather + history nut) Sudden climate change would favor "generalist" survival strategies and would be one of the few evolutionary periods when intelligence of the human variety would be an evolutionary advantage. Genetic analysis shows that Homo Sapiens very nearly went extinct after Toba, and was reduced to only a few hundred breeding pairs. The survivors were likely a lot smarter than their peers, and the sudden changes favored breeding for smart offspring.
Drax
Foobarista: Interesting thought. A couple of things, though. As to the number, it's clearly an unknown. I've read that some believe that 10,000 "humans" or thereabouts lived. (Of course that number is predicated on many different assumptions and incomplete facts.) As to "breeding pairs," that assumes that such existed at that time, rather than dominant males impregnating their females. I haven't a clue as to how "human" society formed in those days, but, as it's BELIEVED to be pre-language, I wouldn't have any problem concluding that it didn't resemble anything we would recognize as "human." Accordingly, I'm not sure how useful DNA evidence is in determining how many humans existed, since we have no way of determining the ratio of male/female and no way of determining, of those remaining, how many bred. As to the sudden climate change (and the resulting weather change, the destruction of flora and fauna humans were accustomed to eating, etc.) causing environmental stressors favoring a "generalist" human being resulting in evolutionary changes making humans "smarter," I'm not sure how that works. First, the change was "sudden." My understanding is that evolutionary changes are random and that it takes thousands upon thousands (millions) of years for evolutionary changes to occur. (The long time frame would be magnified due to the very low number of people evolution could "randomly" experiment upon before it "randomly" hit upon the "smartness" jump in our evolutionary path.) Since the change was "sudden," I don't know how it explains the ability of the first few generations' ability to survive the stressors which would eventually result in "smartness." And, if untold generations were able to survive WITHOUT that "smartness," then, it could be argued that those stressors weren't sufficiently stressful to cause the evolutionary change, and that, at the point when "smartness" kicked in (some 30,000 years later or thereabouts) the effects of the volcano had long since been dealt with. (Of course, if you believe (like me) that evolution ain't so "random," and doesn't take that long (since it isn't "random...") then...okay...) Finally, I find it difficult to believe that there WASN'T a time in human evolutionary history when "intelligence of the human variety would be an evolutionary advantage." But, it certainly was an event which could have been the spark for the transition from pre-human to human thought. It's as good a theory as any I've read thus far.
CosmicConservative
Drax: More later, but evolution doesn't "respond" to events. Evolution randomly creates mutations and those mutations can be SELECTED through events. So let's say some mutation caused the brain to be more receptive to symbolic thought, and that capacity generally resulted in more intelligent humans. That could have happened a thousand years earlier than the Toba supervolcano, but without environmental pressure to naturally select the smarter humans, it would have simply existed in the population like a new eye color or something. However, when the supervolcano went off, the few thousand "smarter" humans may well have been more able to survive the event, resulting in the eventual extinction of humans without that genetic ability. That's how evolution works in situations like this. Humans didn't "get smarter" because of Toba, some small percentage of humans had been smarter for generations, but the Toba event selected them and as a result all humans collectively "got smarter." Make sense?
Drax
CC: As noted in an earlier thread, I can't wrap my mind around that scenario. Here it's posited that the human ability for "symbolic thought" just "happened" (that's what "randomness" is...something just "happens" for no reason) as some point many thousands of years before the Toba event and just sat there fallow for thousands of generations until it was "needed" and, when "needed" natural selection resulted in those with the (happily existing) needed trait rose to prominence, "replacing" those who did not possess it. Such a happy chain of coincidences! As I stated before, I can't imagine a time when the ability for "human thought" would NOT be of evolutionary advantage, so that WHENEVER it "randomly appeared" those who had it were evolutionary favored against those who did not. I believe that humans (and other living organisms) are capable of ADAPTING to their environments in a REACTIVE fashion (akin to the body forming antibodies in reaction to antigens) frequently resulting in, PRECISELY the "adaptation" to the environment which would be beneficial to the organism. I'm sorry, but for me, adaptation is more palatable that the happenstance of a "random" mutation many thousands of years in the past which has no effect UNTIL environmental stressors APPEAR which causes natural selection to favor those who just "happen" to possess that previously USELESS (or even DETRIMENTAL) mutation. (Or, likewise, that, when faced with environmental stressors, an organism just "happens" to randomly hit upon the precise evolutionary mutation which causes it to become favored in the "natural selection" lottery.) Just can't buy it.
CosmicConservative
Drax... I think my last attempt to explain how random mutations are expressed through natural selection to create a more survivable species variant was pretty good. I doubt I can top it. (That was the one about three-toed vs. one-toed grazers.) I think I mentioned last time that the concept of adaptation based on external stimuli is a restatement of Lamarkism. When you suggest that humans are capable AS A SPECIES of "adapting to their environments in a reactive fashion" you need to hypothesize some mechanism for this to occur. In other words, what is the PROCESS which allows for the reactive mutation? As far as I know there is no known or even proposed process which would govern this. Other than divine guidance, that is. In fact other than divine guidance, I don't know WHAT process you could postulate which provides for specific mutations in response to environmental stimuli. How do the amino acid pairs which make up the DNA strands KNOW how to organize themselves to produce the desired result? The advantage of the random mutation explanation is that it requires no agent, and the process is not only well understood, but it has been demonstrated in thousands of laboratory experiments and observations of natural phenomenae. As far as it being a "coincidence" that the mutation allowing for symbolic thought "just happened" to be in place when the Toba event occurred... Well, the only reason we are here talking about it is because it did. It only seems a "coincidence" in retrospect. Had it not existed, or if it only existed in neanderthals, humans might have been wiped out totally and two neanderthals might be blogging about it instead.
CosmicConservative
Hey Drax, let me ask you this... Is intelligence CURRENTLY an evolutionary advantage for the human species? Is a person MORE likely to reproduce and MORE likely to have their children reproduce if they are MORE intelligent than their peers? Factor in the statistical fact that high school dropouts have more children than high school graduates and high school graduates have more children than college graduates and that grad school graduates (including doctors and lawyers, etc.) have FEWER children than ANY OTHER educational category. Do you STILL think that intelligence is an evolutionary advantage TODAY. Much less 100,000 years ago? Is today's situation some sort of evolutionary anomaly, or is it more likely that intelligence is not as much a factor in the NORMAL survival of the species as one might think?
CosmicConservative
OK, I've been ruminating on the whole "when did language" appear concept for a day now. Here is how my brain works. (Heh, double meaning here...) When I "think" about something, I think in words. I have always assumed that I "think" the way other people "think" but I really have no way of knowing that. All I do know is how I think. And when I think, I use words. I gave a valiant effort last night to the attempt to "think" non-verbally. I didn't get very far. I found it virtually impossible to formulate "thoughts" that weren't expressed internally in words. With a smattering of French and Spanish I was able to "think" in those languages, but again, my thoughts were expressed non-verbally in words. So I then tried to think "symbolically" but wihtout words. In other words I tried to contemplate something while visualizing symbolic representations of things. Because I had just put together a three-person swing for our deck, I tried to visualize the process of constructing the swing without using words, but using abstracted mental visualizations of real-world things. I had more success with that approach. I was able to mentally visualize the components of the swing and non-verbally reconstruct the swingset in my head. Well mostly. Words were lurking all along the periphery of my awareness, and occasionally one would burst through my self-imposed language barrier and latch itself onto something in my head. But, I managed to convince myself that "thinking" is possible without a "language" made up of words. But for the life of me, I could not figure out how to COMMUNICATE those internal visions to another person. Then I tried to take that process and apply it to a stone-age task, such as making a stone tool. That meant I had to visualize an abstraction of a piece of stone that was suitable for making a tool. I decided that was doable too, in my mind I visualized stones of a particular color and consistency of a size and shape that would fit my hand. Then I visualized the process of flaking off pieces of it to shape it as desired. In fact I decided that I could use that approach to contemplate and even plan such things as hunting, cooking, carrying water, and even making fire. It occured to me that the only way to communicate this to another person would be to physically perform the actions while attempting to keep the other person's attention on the activity. In doing that though, it felt to me like any attempt to direct someone else to perform an action would almost certainly end up with the creation of rudimentary "words" to facilitate the process of teaching another person. In other words, if I found myself in a situation where I had to teach someone to do something with no shared language, I feel certain that a language would quickly develop. But what I DON'T know is if that is because my brain has been so trained to use words as representations of reality that it now automatically does so. But if I had NOT been trained that way, would it bo so automatic? I just don't know. I'm not sure how you could know.
Drax
Taking your posts in order: Why do I need to explain the mechanism which allows "reactive mutation" anymore than traditional evolutionists have to explain the mechanism through which "random mutation" occurs? I say that humans have the ability to "adapt" to their environment through an unknown mechanism. After this mutation, "natural selection" favors those individual humans who are able to adapt (like the "ice man" in our previous debate) resulting in those who are unable to adapt being replaced by those who are can. Traditional evolutionists say that all evolution is random, but don't say what the mechanism is which triggers the mutations. After that mutation, "natural selection" results in those who have had favorable mutations replacing those who did not. I fail to see how my notion requires any more "proof" than does the other theory. "How do the amino acid pairs which make up the DNA strands KNOW how to organize themselves to produce the desired result?" Well, how do anti-bodies "know" how to organize themselves to effectively fight antigens? It's coded in the body. How does the body "know" when to produce adreneline, or how to produce it in the first place? How does the body "know" that it's time to die -- to stop replicating cells it could replicate the day before? Why are some people able to train themselves in biofeedback so that they are able to control systems in their bodies which are deemed to be involuntary? How can some people train themselves to withstand temperatures which mean certain death for the rest of humanity. How do they train their bodies to send blood/oxygen to their extremities when the body would ordinarily shunt blood to the body's core? I dunno. I just find it reasonable that, since people are ABLE to adapt in the short term to their environment that the body has the MECHANISM to adapt and that MECHANISM which allows for short-term adaptation might allow for SPECIES adaptation, i.e., individuals adapting to their environment, passing those genes along allowing "natural selection" to favor those who adapt over those who cannot. As to the the assertion that evolution has "been demonstrated in thousands of laboratory experiments and observations of natural phenomenae," I dispute that without reservation on any SPECIES level. http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn14094-bacteria-make-major-evolutionary-shift-in-the-lab.html Those particular experiments (some 44,000 GENERATIONS) without any SPECIES mutation of any significant trait which then has ONE species mutation (the ability to metabolise citrate) does no more to convince me of "random evolution" than my assertion that, since citrate was in the environment and some E. Coli adapted to its presence and found a way to metabolise it would convince you that the E. Coli "adapted" rather than "randomly evolved." I like your question about intelligence being an "evolutionary advantage" currently. Heh. I watched the dreadful film "Idiocracy" a while back where it shows that the opposite is true, that the intelligent DON'T breed like cockroaches while the stupid do, resulting in a world of idiots. I'm of the opinion that evolutionary forces which caused (take your pick...evolution/adaptation) simply aren't in play with the human race at this point. At least in the "natural selection" sense that "natural selection" results in those best able to survive. For the human race, those environmental factors simply don't exist any longer. There is no individual penalty of any significance to being stupid, or lazy, or slow, or infirm. So, individuals who are stupid, lazy, slow, and infirm continue to have the essentially unfettered ability to reproduce. By the same token, there is no individual reward for the smart, hard-working, fast, or healthy to reproduce. All have food and shelter (in the greatest part). 100,000 years ago, the environment (both human "culture" and external factors) FAVORED those who could think over those who could not. Remember...at EACH stop of the evolutionary train, that which evolved/adapted was ALREADY a successful human or it would not have been able to survive to pass its genes along in the FIRST PLACE. So, those humans who gained the ability to "think" were ALREADY successful humans who had the ADDITIONAL ability to "think." (If they were otherwise, they would not have been afforded the opportunity to reproduce.)
Drax
I went through much of the same mental process you describe in your "thinking" exercise. Some things which jump out at me. Chimps are more "intelligent" than humans until both reach around the age of two years, the point where children are generally capable of utilizing language with some effectiveness. At that point, humans race ahead. One of the most effective teaching tools is, as you describe, keeping the other's attention on the taught subject. The pointed finger does that. It is the most effective, and uniquely human, teaching tool. "Look here." "See that." "Put your attention here." With the point of a finger. I haven't a clue as to when or how, or through what mechanism, the "light went off" and someone began trying to assign unique sounds to unique things/thoughts and try to teach another a "language" which is not yet a "language." What started all this for me is the notion that Man had existed for somewhere in the area of 250,000 years BEFORE that individual came along even though all "humans" existing prior to him/her had the identical brain and capacity to "discover language." I just think that "something happened" which resulted in a biological change in the brain which allowed for higher thought and that those previous "humans" simply weren't.
CosmicConservative
Molecular biologists have repeatedly described the mechanism which leads to mutations. I'm no expert but I know of three common ways it happens. The first is through molucular level events such as cosmic rays striking a DNA molecule, or ultraviolet radiation, or other intense radiation. The second is in the transcription process itself, when DNA replicates itself. Among the millions of genes along a single strand of DNA, it is relatively common for a gene or two to be corrupted as the new strand is made. In fact there are genes which control a checking process sort of like modern computer tapes have an "error checking" built into them. That's needed because transcription errors are common. Finally there are many viruses which corrupt DNA as part of their lifecycle. All three of these lead to mutations.
Drax
Oh, I don't disagree that mutations occur, or that they can be "random," whether caused by external forces or internal screw-ups. I just don't think that such fully explains evolution. Take the E. Coli example. Why didn't, in 44,000 generations, there occur some species wide detrimental mutations, resulting in extinction? This is clearly as easily occurring as the beneficial one of metabolising citrate. Where were, in those 44,000 generations, the dead-ends? The observable but innocuous random mutations? I don't DENY that "random mutations" occur or that they can exist prior to the time when they might prove beneficial and result in "natural selection" passing those mutations to subsequent generations. I simply assert that such doesn't fully satisfy me as an explanation of evolution.
CosmicConservative
I can't think of any article or any paper I've ever read on mutations which describe a mutation that would lead to species wide extinction. A mutation which led to certain death would almost certainly lead to the death of the individual and greatly reduce the chance for the mutation to be passed on. This is a sort of self-regulating control on negative mutations. You say this is "clearly as easily occuring as the beneficial one." I could not disagree more. To come up with a scenario where some gene would somehow come to be incorporated in the entire gene pool of a species without killing the individuals, but which suddenly killed the entire population would be a strange scenario indeed. The dead-ends you talk about, as I have said before, are virtually always aborted and do not even become viable organisms, much less pass their dead-end trait on. However, there are examples of mutations which are short-term beneficial and long-term negative, the best example of which is probably the tendency of some bird species to lose the abiltity to fly. I used this example before too. On an island with no predators, flight is an unnecessary and expensive luxury. However, once flightlessness has out-competed flight (which has happened many times in the world) the now flightless birds are at the mercy of any newly evolved or newly introduced predator which can outrun and overpower the birds. There are MANY examples of this in the fossil record.
CosmicConservative
Back to your key point here, the difficulty in accepting that humans "lacked language" for tens of thousands of years before suddenly "discovering" it and revolutionizing the culture... I have similar difficulties to your own in comprehending that. It doesn't make sense to me. Now, I CAN come up with hypotheses which could "explain" that scenario, but most, if not all, of those would be built around some brain activity that exists in modern humans but did not exist in pre-language humans. We know that the brain is a complex organ and that there are chemical triggers and transmitters in the brain that govern the brain's measurable activities. I could conceive of a situation where the ability to symbolically reason could be associated with some particular neuro-transmitter or some specific means of connecting neurons together. But if that is what happened, I would argue that such a mutation is significant enough to have identified a new species, and modern humans would not be the same species as the "humans" who lacked the ability.
Drax
Hmmm... I have to agree on the "species extinction" argument. As to the overall argument, I pretty much stay the same, i.e. "random mutation" isn't sufficient to explain things. Again turning to that E. Coli experiment. One of the notions to explain how the "evolved" E. Coli was able to metabolise citrate was that from the 20,000th generation to the 44,000th, there were a SERIES of mutations which allowed for that ability. A SERIES of "random mutations" all of which resulted in the final outcome of the E. Coli to metabolise that which was present in their environment? (It reminds me of the growth of wings...one useless structure at a time growing the ultimate overall structure of a "wing" including decreasing the density of bones, feathers instead of scales, eyes designed to see the long distances of an air-borne predator...all just "randomly" occurring one after another after another -- working unfailingly together -- until....woot! A Bird! I just have difficulty swallowing the complete "randomness" of such evolution.
Drax
"I could conceive of a situation where the ability to symbolically reason could be associated with some particular neuro-transmitter or some specific means of connecting neurons together. But if that is what happened, I would argue that such a mutation is significant enough to have identified a new species, and modern humans would not be the same species as the “humans” who lacked the ability" That's pretty much what I'm saying...
CosmicConservative
Wings... Do you have any idea how heated the debate over the evolution of wings has been in the past 150 years? My understanding of the evolution of wings is pretty simple, and perhaps even out of date, but here it is: Feathers pre-date wings. We find skin impressions of dinosaurs with scales that have developed a feather-like texture. This is thought to have been naturally selected because it is a more efficient means to maintain body temperature equilibrium to scales. The mutation which turns a scale into a feather may have been a single mutation. It is thought that small feathered dinosaurs moved into trees like squirrels, and that some of them with more pronounced feather-like structures likely learned that they could spread their arms and legs and "glide" from tree to tree much like a modern "flying" squirrel. Any further mutation of the modified scales to lengthen and strengthen them would increase the freedom of movement of the tree-dwelling dinosaurs. Eventually you would expect enough of these mutations led to a dinosaur with large feathers and a significant "wingspan" with other tree-dwelling adaptations such as branch-grasping claws. Which is exactly what the archaeopteryx fossil seems to be. Whether the archaeopteryx was a "flying" or "gliding" animal is still under debate. The main reason for the debate is that the archaeopteryx lacks a "breastbone" and also lacks evidence of significant musculature which is found in flying birds. However, the feathers of the archaeopteryx are very similar to modern birds, which suggests that there were many other transitional forms for which we have not been lucky enough to find fossil evidence. After archaeopteryx further mutations which resulted in the wishbone and other bird adaptations occurred. So the "bird wing" as we know it today is thought to be the result of several specific naturally selected mutations which began as mutations which provided a better way of regulating body warmth, and eventually led to the ability to fly. Every hypothesized mutation in the chain provided SOME naturally selected advantage, whether it was the ability to climb higher in trees (hollow bones) the ability to better regulate body temperature (feathers) the ability to glide from tree to tree (long feathered grasping arms).... Each individual mutation was random, but on occasion mutations provide a synergistic effect which provides a completely new ability.
CosmicConservative
Oh, by the way, there is a competing theory about the evolution of wings. The one I described above is known as the "tree down" explanation. The competing explanation is the "ground up" one, and it describes wings as being developed in species of ground-running dinosaurs who found the ability to leap long distances an advantage over competitors who could not leap as far. I find that less likely than the tree-down approach in large part because the advantage of lighter bones is clear in a tree-dwelling animal, but is actually a detriment to a ground-dwelling one (they break easier).
Drax
Again. While there is some rational explanation for just about anything, and other rational explanations which use the same facts to come to different conclusions, I just can't get over the happy circumstance that a land animal -- in a series of random mutations -- one on top of the other -- hundreds of them -- scales to feathers, the many different structures which make up the assembly of the wing, etc. -- just "happened." What precision those cosmic rays!
Drax
Man...need to edit my writings better... Should read...."I just can’t get over the happy circumstance that a land animal — in a series of random mutations — one on top of the other — hundreds of them — scales to feathers, the many different structures which make up the assembly of the wing, etc. — just “happened" to evolve into a flying animal." Sigh
CosmicConservative
"Random mutation" does not equate with "just happened." Not in the sense that I am inferring from your comment. Each individual mutation, once incorporated into the gene pool of the species, becomes part of the foundation for other mutations to occur. It is not necessary for wings to evolve from a land-based creature. It is only necessary for wings to evolve in a tree-dwelling creature that glides. How did you get a tree dwelling creature that glides? Well that only needs to be one step from a tree dwelling creature that jumps. Etc. etc... Had wings not evolved, and instead our skies were populated with balloon creatures who fill their membranes with methane, you could say the same thing.
Drax
But, wings did evolve. And "tree dwellers" didn't begin as "tree dwellers." And, if "random" doesn't mean "random," I'm not sure what it means.
CosmicConservative
I'm pretty well out of gas on this. You aren't the only one who has problems with the concept of random mutation and natural selection producing the vast diversity of earth-based lifeforms. However, I am not one of them. I think it is an incredibly beautiful and robust system. Whether it was put in place by some divine being or it "just happened" either way is fine with me. But I am fairly well certain that life did evolve in that manner, and that random selection is perfectly capable of explaining the world we see today.
Foobarista
Darn - do either of you guys have jobs :) A few asides, picked from a quick scroll down the 31 (!) comments... 1. From what I've read, evolution is "punctuated", with long periods of stability and short bursts of rapid change, typically in response to sudden environmental changes. Random mutations happen all the time, but environmental changes + "lucky" random mutations are what cause "big" evolutionary shifts. Catastrophes happen, and are the main driver of evolution. 2. In addition to the Toba event, we've had a brief period (about 2.5M years) of very short (in geological terms) and extreme ice ages, coupled with very short warming periods. This has stressed "generalists" over extreme specialization evolutionary strategies, particularly in animals and plants living in mid and upper latitudes. Note that an "evolutionary strategy" isn't a conscious effort; it's more similar to water flowing down a hill; it'll follow small gullies and avoid ridges, and eventually cut a channel. The gullies and channels of evolution are environmental pressures that favor some mutations and oppose others. 3. It's unclear whether intelligence is generally useful as an evolutionary strategy, but once it was developing, we could use it to be conscious generalists. Our brains are darn expensive, and nature is a tough accountant, so we had to use them for something that produced more energy than they consume. Personally, I don't like "god in the machine" arguments for humans appearing any more than I like "we don't know exactly how the pyramids were built, so it must be aliens" arguments. Occam's razor would have to cut through a whole lot of more reasonable arguments before we resort to external agents as explanations.
Drax
CC: I haven't a clue as to how we (or any other organism) "evolved" to where we are. I just don't think that anyone else does either. There are too many rational explanations as to how it came about which makes me conclude that old conclusion, i.e., "All can't be right, so either one is or all are wrong." Foobarista: I certainly can see how significant environmental challenges could prod a species to adapt. However, as the sole impetus for "evolution," it doesn't explain everything. (See, e.g., the E. Coli experiment.) Anyway, as CC said...I'm pretty well out of gas here as well. Simply put: I don't believe in a Supreme being -- or, more precisely, one who takes an active hand in temporal affairs, so, no "creationism" for me. However, I don't buy "random mutation" resulting in what I see when I view the world (or view the historical record as far as it can be viewed). I think there's something or somethings missing in the traditional understanding of "evolution." That's pretty much it.
CosmicConservative
Drax: Well, it may sound disingenuous, but the fact is that I DO have a clue of how we evolved to where we are. In fact I feel like I have a reasonably good understanding of several aspects of the process, from the Big Bang, to the formation of galaxies, to the formation of solar systems, to the formation of planets, to the formation of water oceans, to the saturation of those oceans with organic components including key amino acids, to the formation of self-replicating molecules, to the molecular processes involved in random mutation, to the crucible of natural selection, etc... In my mind evolution and natural selection is an integral part of the cosmology of the universe. Yes I know that we have not yet "PROVED" several key parts of that process, but we are getting closer and closer all the time. In fact there is a chance that we will see artificial life created in the laboratory based on theories of early earth conditions within a year or two. They are very close. The problem with "I don't think it's divine intervention, but I don't think it can be random either" is that pretty much describes your choices. What other choices do you have? If you postulate that earth's evolution was directed by non-divine aliens, that's fine, but where did THEY come from? Eventually it boils down to either it "just happened" or else that "God did it." If we are "missing something" other than those two options, I'd sure love to hear it. What could it be? Any agent that could possibly exist which takes the place of random mutations HAD to come from SOMEWHERE, and if that didn't come from a divine plan or from a previous evolutionary process, where DID it come from? So either we have an infinite stack of turtles explaining why we're here, or else we have to accept that it "just happened." I don't see a middle ground here. Can you give me some idea of where you see middle ground?
Dadman
I don't believe the universe, this world, and the diversity of life are PURELY a product of random, arbitrary events...and I find it more than just a little ironic that it requires the directed intelligence of the scientific community to come 'close' to creating 'artifical life' in a laboratory. If they happen to succeed it would seem to imply that intelligence is a necessary ingredient in, at the very least, the origin of life on this planet...
Drax
I haven't a clue. I can't get past "first cause" regardless of the notions of the "Big Bang" or the "Let there be light!" schools of thought (Or "Steady State" or any of the other minority views of the origin of the Universe, for that matter -- they ALL suffer from the same deficiency.) So, while you say that you "have a clue," all I can retort is: "Do not! You just THINK that you do! You have a rational explanation which fits your understanding of current scientific knowledge. That's all." One thing I've learned from observation and reading is that, when a scientific theory gains wide acceptance, contemporary scientists tend to find other theories to explain away (or "fit" the widespread theory) any evidence which might challenge that theory. Dark Matter? What's that? Oh! Well, HERE'S how THAT fits in. Dark energy? Well, now that I think about it... Why doesn't the universe have the same amount of anit-matter as matter? Well, I think that THIS would explain THAT. What do you mean that the Hubble constant ISN'T "constant?" Well, let me tell you about that... Where did the primordial matter come from in the first place? Well, have you ever heard of the "5th dimension?" It's a neat idea! Etc. I just get a kick out of the fundamental belief that the matter from which the universe sprang just "appeared." Disregard, please, the law of conservation of matter and energy. It doesn't fit the narrative. And, then, since the next question HAS to be..."Where did it come from?" we get treated to..."Such pursuits are pointless in an understanding of the Big Bang." Now, THAT'S helpful! And, then, since the next question HAS to be ... "But, if there was no "there" there as space and time didn't EXIST prior to the Big Bang, where did that primordial matter go TO?" we are treated to, "Nobody knows, so don't worry about it..." (How DOES one put something into "nothing" -- how does the primordial matter "appear" when there isn't anything in which TO "appear?") And, then, if asked "But, since space/time only exists within the confines of the universe (inside the expanding (unknown) shape of the universe), what would happen if I stood at the edge of the universe and took a step OUTWARD?" Hmmm. Could I? There is no "there" there into which to "step." No "space" in which to plant my foot. Doesn't matter. I'm sure there's one or more "theories" which explain what happens when I attempt to extend my foot beyond existence and into non-existence. All I'm saying is that "current scientific knowledge" is "current scientific knowledge," and, if history of "current scientific knowledge" tells us ANYTHING, not much of it survives unmolested the centuries which follow.
CosmicConservative
Drax, the fundamental existence of "anything" is not and cannot be resolved from our current understanding of this universe's laws. However, that inability to say where, for example, the "Big Bang" came from, does NOT preclude us from making scientific observations about what happened AFTER the Big Bang. It is not necessary for me to explain the origin of the Big Bang for me to say that I "have a clue" about how this universe has progressed since the Big Bang. I fully acknowledge that I can't explain the Big Bang, but I can explain a hell of a lot of what happened SINCE.
CosmicConservative
Oh, and by the way, there are multiple competing multi-dimensional theories which very simply explain where the "Big Bang" came from. The most developed of which is the "Brane" theory of multi-dimensional super string space. In that theory universes are created quite frequently, and the matter and energy in the universes is completely consistent with conservation of matter and energy because the energy of the colliding "branes" is sufficient to account for all the matter in our universe. Of course then you have to ask "where did the multi-dimenstional brane-space come from?" Answering the fundamental question of "why does ANYTHING exist!?!" is simply beyond us at this time. But I'm not going to let that stop me from understanding as much of what we can see as I can possibly understand.
CosmicConservative
Heh... can't let things go... This last assertion of yours that "not much of [scientific knowledge] survives unmolested the centuries that follow" is a pure solipsism. Science is a process, not a description. It may be TECHNICALLY accurate to say that Newton was "wrong" and that Einstein "corrected" Newton, but the fact remains that the science that Newton brought to us is JUST AS ACCURATE TODAY AS IT WAS 600 YEARS AGO. In fact it is NEWTON'S LAWS that physicists use to send probes to Saturn, Jupiter, Pluto and beyond. Einstein's "corrections" to Newton's laws are profound and critical to our modern understanding of the universe, but the did not REPLACE Newton's original laws, they have CLARIFIED them for situations that were, quite simply, beyond the technology of Newton's time to IDENTIFY, much less seek a solution to. I see this assertion frequently, that science is somehow "overturned" and "corrected" every generation or so. That is a complete misunderstanding both of science and of history. Telescopes work the same way today they did when Galileo built his first one. We have greatly expanded our understanding of electro-magnetic energy in the intervening 600 years, but THE ORIGINAL EQUATIONS STILL WORK. Einstein did not REPLACE Newton's Laws, he REFINED them. Newton did not REPLACE Keplers laws, he REFINED them. Now it is true that Newton did, in fact REPLACE Aristotle's "laws" and that was, in fact, a REPUDIATION of "bad science." But since then there has been VERY LITTLE actual "REPLACEMENT" of scientific understanding. What we see today is REFINEMENT of previous understandings. For example, the initial genetic findings of Gregor Mendel ARE STILL ACCURATE TODAY, even if we have completely revolutionized genetics in the 300 years since. His SCIENCE was still SCIENCE. His observations were still ACCURATE. His theories still SUPPORTED THE OBSERVATIONS. If you want to use "science is wrong all the time" you can use that argument on people who know a hell of a lot less about science and history than I do.
Drax
CC: I'm not saying that "full understanding" is necessary to have a "working knowledge" of many things. But, to say one "has a clue" how the universe came into being when one simply doesn't and has, at best, some explanations which "fit" what IS known (at this time -- subject to later revision as more complete understanding reveals itself) is unscientific. One THINKS that the universe began in a certain way. One cannot PROVE that thought. One can look at scientific data through the prism of current scientific technology and current scientific thought and THINK that one has "proof" that one's original thought is SUPPORTED by what one THINKS are the correct conclusions derived from that current scientific data as viewed through the prism of current scientific technology and thought. That's about it. It's "working knowledge," which is not NECESSARILY "knowledge." Agreed, it's the best we have, and, if we are to someday attain "full knowledge," then we MUST work with what we have. I just think it's a MISTAKE to confuse "working knowledge," with "knowledge" which, frankly, most do.
Drax
Oh, I agree completely with the statement that "science is a process." THAT, in fact, is my whole POINT.
CosmicConservative
I never said I had a clue about how the "universe came into being." In fact I very clearly said that I did NOT. What I said I had a clue about is how evolution has produced WINGS. If we want to get into a discussion about the scope and accuracy of any or all knowledge, well, that's the "science" of Epistemology. I love to discuss epistemology, but I have found in the long run that it boils down to "I think therefore I am" sorts of arguments. So they are lots of fun, but not very productive. You and everything else I see, touch, smell or taste could well be nothing but externally applied stimuli and I could be nothing but a brain in a tank. I can't prove otherwise. I just have to accept that you are real and that the universe is too.
CosmicConservative
Drax, your POINT seemed to me to be casting DOUBT on whether science could be used to determine ANYTHING because it could not explain EVERYTHING. MY point is that it most certainly can, and has been doing ever since the scientific method itself was introduced. I am a practical person, I don't have to know EVERYTHING before I allow myself to say I understand SOMETHING. I understand how electricity works at a practical level. No, I can't explian what an electric charge actually IS at a fundamental particle level. But I know how to make a light bulb.
Drax
No, my point was that, in the beginning, that, while current scientific thought has adopted "random mutation" as explanation for what is described as "evolution," that is not fully satisfying to me as, to me, it does not adequately explain how we got from there to here. This part of your discussion is what led me to the discussion of the Big Bang theory and the fundamental nature of the accumulation of "knowledge:" "Well, it may sound disingenuous, but the fact is that I DO have a clue of how we evolved to where we are. In fact I feel like I have a reasonably good understanding of several aspects of the process, from the Big Bang, to the formation of galaxies, to the formation of solar systems, to the formation of planets, to the formation of water oceans, to the saturation of those oceans with organic components including key amino acids, to the formation of self-replicating molecules, to the molecular processes involved in random mutation, to the crucible of natural selection, etc…" (Emphasis supplied) When one says "from the Big Bang," it is reasonable to assume that one believes that the Big Bang occurred and has accepted that as scientific KNOWLEDGE, rather than THEORY. And, that's where I got off that particular train...
CosmicConservative
Drax: Read it quite literally please. I said "from the Big Bang." I meant "from the Big Bang." What happened or existed BEFORE THE BIG BANG is not included in that. What happened AFTER the Big Bang is.
Drax
I understand. But, when you say "from the Big Bang," I think that it's reasonable to assume that you meant to imply that the Big Bang actually happened (else some other phrase for "the beginning of the Universe as we know it" would obtain.). Anyway, that's how I took it.
CosmicConservative
Drax, on the Big Bang "theory" itself, just a few comments. I am not one who uses "consensus" as a means of determining "fact" from "fiction." In the case of the Big Bang, I cannot think of another theory of such consequence that was accepted as universally and as quickly by the scientific community. I have quite literally never met an astronomer, cosmologist or physicist who doubts that our universe began with an immensely violent event which led to the galactic motions that we see today. There are many competing theories about the PROCESS of the Big Bang, and there have been many refinements of the fundamental theory itself ("Inflation" being the biggest one that I know of) but there is no current serious alternative theory about the origin of the universe which explains what we observe. Albert Einstein was himself an avowed "Steady State" adherent for most of his life. He was such a committed steady state believer that when he formulated his theory of Relativity, he fudged the formula to make it fit a steady state model. This is his famous "worst blunder in his career" where he introduced a "cosmological constant" to explain why the universe had not been destroyed by heat death due to the universal effect of gravitation. When Edwin Hubble's obsrvations of the red shift of virtually all galaxies was published, and when Hubble proposed that the only explanation for such a thing was that all galaxies were receding from an initial point of origin, Einstein IMMEDIATELY abandoned a lifetime belief in a steady state universe and GLEEFULLY erased his "cosmological constant" from his theory because the evidence was so compelling both observationally and theoretically. So, yes, put me in the "Big Bang really happened" camp.
CosmicConservative
However, not to turn this into a discussion of the "Big Bang", the process of evolution does not REQUIRE the Big Bang, it just FITS WELL into the overall cosmological model.
Drax
And, there we go. I don't have a problem with people who accept current scientific theory as fact. You have to have some step upon which to stand before you can ascend to the next step, and, quite frequently, current scientific theory turns out to be scientific fact. I view the progress of science as a myriad of staircases emerging from a single step. Each time one ascends the staircase, one is confronted with many different possible paths. Sometimes the scientific community ascends the wrong path and has to back track, but even in the ascension finds even more potential paths which lead from where he was to where he wants to go -- but sometimes just dead-end in error. I view evolution in this light. We have wound and wound this particular maze of potential paths and, through consensus (and, yes, that's how scientific theory becomes scientific fact...sometimes the evidence simply becomes too overwhelming for other theories to survive and "Einstein gleefully" abandons the one for the other) have decided that "random mutation" is dispositive of how evolution occurred. I think that consensus is premature. Again, I'm not saying it's WRONG, just that it's premature to say it's FACT. As this relates to the "Big Bang," I have to admit that I'm of the camp that, unless you can prove to me that it CAN happen, I'll reserve judgment as to whether it DID happen.
Drax
Oh, as an aside. Thank you. While we may disagree on many subjects (and frankly, it seems we disagree mostly as to absolutes) our discussions cause me to research many subjects which, ordinarily, I would ignore. Can't help but value that.
CosmicConservative
Any theory which replaces the Big Bang will still have to address what we FACTUALLY observe about the universe. That includes such obvious and verifiable things as the receding velocity of galaxies and how they recede faster the farther they are away from us. That includes such obvious and verifiable things as the Cosmic Background Radiation, which at 4 degrees K is ENTIRELY consistent with a universe which has cooled, and continues to cool, since it was born. It is possible that some refinement of the theory of the Big Bang could happen, but it is difficult to come up with a logical version of one which does not include the process of a violent birth and the subsequent expansion of space and time. I am certainly not aware of any such theories which are taken seriously at this time.
CosmicConservative
Thank you for the thank you. Of course it is reciprocal. I enjoy substantive discussion about important things. In fact I probably enjoy it too much.