Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

More idiocy in "reporting"

By CosmicConservative
Every now and then I see a story that is so egregiously factually inaccurate, or presents facts in such a monumentally brain-dead way that I have to comment on it. Like this one:
You worry a lot about the environment and do everything you can to reduce your carbon footprint -- the emissions of greenhouse gases that drive dangerous climate change. So you always prefer to take the train or the bus rather than a plane, and avoid using a car whenever you can, faithful to the belief that this inflicts less harm to the planet. Well, there could be a nasty surprise in store for you, for taking public transport may not be as green as you automatically think, says a new US study.
So far so good. After reading this far I was thinking "Wow, a relatively significant MSM source reporting that the environmental impact of something is more than a simple first-order approximation. Cool! Then I read this:
In some circumstances, for instance, it could be more eco-friendly to drive into a city -- even in an SUV, the bete noire of green groups -- rather than take a suburban train. It depends on seat occupancy and the underlying carbon cost of the mode of transport. "We are encouraging people to look at not the average ranking of modes, because there is a different basket of configurations that determine the outcome," Chester told AFP in a phone interview.
Waitaminute.... Did I read that right? Are they saying it is more eco-friendly to drive an SUV into town than take the train? Well, of course I have been one over the years to try to explain to people that mass-transit is not as green as people think it is. It is definitely true, as is made clear later in this article, that a C02/person-mile calculation between a couple of people in an SUV and a quarter-full train favors the SUV, which is what the study pointed out. But to say that it is more "eco-friendly" to drive your SUV than take the train ASSUMES THAT THE TRAIN WON'T RUN IF YOU DON"T TAKE IT! Of course in reality if you DON'T take the train, IT RUNS ANYWAY, which means that driving your SUV only adds CO2 to the atmosphere. In other words, the whole premise of this article is that INDIVIDUALS contribute LESS to global warming if they DRIVE THEIR SUV! Now, how many people who read this are going to say "Well, I guess it's OK to drive then" when they could take the train otherwise? Since the average person has the mental capability of an overripe kumquat, I would guess a LOT of people will come away from this article thinking that. The study was not a study intended to influence individual choices between driving or taking the train, the study was intended to influence public policy to determine if building a NEW RAIL LINE between two cities, for example, would actually be more harmful to the environment than just letting people drive. It's a good study, and one that should give people pause when they assume that a railway is always superior to individual cars. But the whole article here seems to be saying "don't take the train to work, it's better to drive your SUV!" Now, of course since I am a global warming denier, I don't really care that much one way or the other, but as a general efficiency aficionado I do like to see people pursue individual and societal efficiency, so I support mass transit when it makes sense. It's just this story is so idiotic....

Comments (8)

JSullins
In my decade spent at CSU, I cycled through many majors before settling on Computer Science. It is a little-known fact that I did a 1.5 year stint as a Professional Journalism major. The classes were packed with idiots. In fact, the classes were so packed with idiots that it helped motivate me to switch majors (again).
CosmicConservative
Oh... and on to the reporting thing... I've never taken a journalism class, but all I can go on is the people I read, hear or see in print, on radio and on TV. All I can say is that from what I can tell modern reporters spend more time on style and image than on facts and substance. I suppose there are some exceptions, but I see very few of them. As a profession I find it hard to respect journalism. In fact I rate journalists right down there with politicians in terms of integrity, honesty, intelligence and basic human decency. In fact, probably even below politicians. And't that's low indeed.
Drax
I studied Journalism in one of my first attempts at a college education. Other than Education, I found the classes to be stacked with mush headed idiots. But, the same is pretty much true of every class I ever took -- including those at law school -- including the professors.
CosmicConservative
Critical thinking is a skill. If you don't learn it, it rarely develops on its own. Schools simply don't teach critical thinking anymore. If they ever did. And parents don't do it either. We have raised two full generations of mush-headed idiots, and frankly they are now running this country. It doesn't seem to be getting any better.
Drax
Heh, the second sentence of my last post should read: "Other than Education, I found no classes to be more stacked with mush headed idiots." CC: I'm not certain that "critical thinking" was ever a major component of public education. Frankly, until recently (the last 40 years or so), the major components of non-memorized teachings were those values which were intended to make for a relatively homogenized work-force for an industrial society. Critical thinking is, generally, not a value which is completely consistent to a "homogenized work-force."
Andy
Cosmic: Check this one out. Read the headline, and tell me what a normal, half-interested person would think. Then read the article. Journalists... http://www.greenbaypressgazette.com/article/20090606/GPG0101/90606042/1261/GPG05/Weather++Record+temperature+set+in+Green+Bay+Saturday
CosmicConservative
Heh... Pretty clear to me anyway...