Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Abortion doctor killer arrested...

By CosmicConservative
Of course I don't condone murder of abortion doctors. However, the below statement:
Details Emerge About Suspect in Abortion Doctor's Killing - Local News | News Articles | National News | US News - FOXNews.com The slaying quickly brought condemnation from both anti-abortion and pro-choice groups, as well as President Barack Obama. "However profound our differences as Americans over difficult issues such as abortion, they cannot be resolved by heinous acts of violence," Obama said in a statement.
.... completely ignores the "profound" reality that to those of us who view abortion as murder, EVERY abortion is a "heinous act of violence." And in PARTICULAR these late term abortions are indistinguishable from infanticide. But that's the problem with this debate. The Left simply refuses to acknowledge this fact. Obama's statement is breathtakingly condescending and completely rejects the FUNDAMENTAL argument of those of us who view the unborn as human beings. So when Obama says we have to have a dialog, he clearly means WE have to be CONVINCED that HE is right.

Comments (8)

reggie
The pro death left controls the language of this issue...pro abortion = pro choice, not pro infanticide the media is pro death, if you are not in the pro death camp you must be a knuckle dragging, bible thumping moron. When a pro death friend of mine was talking about how wonderful it was that the left was in charge ,I asked her what she thought about euthanasia. When she asked why, I said that killing the infirm and the aged was next, and I hope she didn't become a burden to her pro death children.
CosmicConservative
Well... when you view human beings as a scourge on earth, or a plague on the environment, it's not that hard to justify the culling of human beings to save the world. But the next step in this won't be euthenasia. It will be rationing of health services by government bureaucrats so that the government decides who gets organ transplants or expensive cancer treatments and, more importantly, who doesn't. It will use the declining population of doctors as a rationale for cutting back on such treatments for the unwashed masses while the government and "intellectual" elites will get whatever they need. This will be called "caring." Euthenasia won't be necessary for a long time.
Drax
If you could kill a mini-Hitler before he killed hundreds/thousands more people, would you? It seems that this is the question that the assassin answered. The law allows one to kill to prevent the murder of another. Abortion is, in the minds of many, murder. Do we have an obligation to take the law into our own hands to prevent murder? This is the logical outcome of the two competing values, the first -- the utterly reprehensible ruling in Roe where the Court refused to answer the question of "personhood" as it relates to an unborn human allowing for virtually unrestricted killing of human babies; the second -- the entirely reasonable belief that an unborn human is an actual human and that killing without cause is murder. What surprises me beyond all measure is that this doesn't happen more often. The lack of dead abortionists being found in back alleys every day speaks highly to the restraint of the "right" side of the political spectrum, both as to their willingness not to visit murder on murderers even to save the innocent when, even by most religious views, it would be entirely justified, and their willingness to bow to the rule of law, however misguided.
Andy
Drax, you make an excellent point, and one that I have often considered. It really is astounding that it is not a common event. I am sure that Christianity, and the teachings of Christ restrain many from doing what their flesh really, really, really wants to do. And not only to abortionists... But then, even those on the right side of this issue, without that Biblical restraint, tend to be rational, sane, and compassionate folks. Rational, sane, compassionate people know that even though they might just love to pull the trigger, there is a better way.
Dadman
I share Cosmic's frustration that the bloody carnage created by the abortion industry is rarely (really never) acknowledged by pro-abortionists. Until it is, this debate will never be an honest or productive one. Of course, pro-abortionists can't really acknowledge it, can they, because the truth is just too damned ugly and they know it deep down inside...
CosmicConservative
Andy and Drax: A couple of points. First, there are deeper reasons that pro-life individuals don't commit murder to stop murder. Among those are the realization that killing an abortionist does not stop abortions. There is a deeper societal issue that needs to be dealt with. Killing abortion doctors simply makes the anti-abortion effort seem as evil as the abortionists themselves, so it undercuts the larger societal goals. There will always be people willing to accept the risk of performing abortions if the money is attractive enough. Second, on the whole "would you kill Hitler as a youth if you had a time machine" question... This is a false choice. Given access to a time machine I would have many more options than "kill Hitler or have mass murder and world war." Among those choices would be "Go back and change the Treaty of Versailles so it was not such a crushing punishment of Germany that it bred an entire generation of resentment and hatred that led to Hitler's rise." Or even "Bring a young Hitler to the future to show him the impact of his actions." Or "give Hitler penicillin to stop the derangement associated with syphilis" etc. Given a chance I think I could find many better ways to deal with Hitler than simply shooting him in the head.
Andy
CosmicCurmudgeon: "...there are deeper reasons that pro-life individuals don’t commit murder to stop murder. Among those are the realization that killing an abortionist does not stop abortions. There is a deeper societal issue that needs to be dealt with. Killing abortion doctors simply makes the anti-abortion effort seem as evil as the abortionists themselves, so it undercuts the larger societal goals." That is exactly what I meant when I wrote about rational folks, and a better way.
Drax
Cosmic and Andy: Abortionists kill human babies for two reasons: 1) It is legal and can be done without material consequence, and 2) It is profitable. If more abortionists were found dead in back alleys, the first would no longer be true resulting in fewer people willing to become abortionists. Accordingly, yes...killing abortionists WOULD have the effect of reducing or even preventing abortions. As to the "false choice" of Hitler. You can make ANY choice a "false choice" because EVERY moment in history is built on every OTHER moment in history. We can go back to the causes of WWI and change THOSE rather than to the treaty of Versailles. We can travel back in time to any point and change that and have a different outcome. So, it doesn't make it a "false choice" simply by offering OTHER choices. So, there is no need for a "time machine" to pose and answer the "Hitler question." Better phrased, it is: "If you knew with utter certainty that a man will kill hundreds or thousands of people if not stopped, do you feel that you have a responsibility to stop him -- even if that means killing HIM? And, if you KNOW he will kill hundreds or thousands of innocent people if you don't stop him when you have the ability to stop him, are you complicit in the deaths of those hundreds/thousands of innocents?" The law allows me to kill you if I reasonably THINK that you are going to kill another. What if I do nothing and allow you to be killed rather than put myself at risk? Would I be called a coward? Would I BE a coward? (This puts in mind the rape in a subway system recently where two transit workers saw it but did nothing to prevent it -- instead simply "calling it in" to 911 rather than putting themselves at risk. They were roundly called "cowards.") I don't advocate killing abortionists either. However, if I were on a jury of one who did, I would likely acquit him.