Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Messages...

By CosmicConservative
Part of our DC vacation was spent in various museums, many of which had various incarnations of the march of human history. What struck me in all of them though, is how they politicized industrialization. In the National Museum of the American Indian, the stone-age existence of the indigenous natives was celebrated, while the introduction of European technology was depicted as the herald of doom. In the National Museum of American History the exhibits start to have a dark edge with the introduction of petroleum based technologies and reach a doomsday peak with the advent of the nuclear reactor. Even in the National Museum of Natural History the exhibits are infused with a palpable sense of doom whenever climate effects of "global warming" are mentioned. As a baby boomer who grew up in a period when Davey Crockett was a hero and schools unashamedly taught "manifest destiny" as a good thing, I am pretty well inoculated against this pervasive anti-technology bias, but I wonder about today's kids, and how well they are able to separate the wheat from the chaff, or the pig iron from the coke, so to speak. The unintentional irony of using complex computer systems and LCD displays to describe the evils of technology probably escapes most people, but it blares out at me like a neon sign. But what it makes me think is that today's world is caught in a massive cognitive dissonance where technology is loved and hated simultaneously by people who don't even recognize the conflict. One of the displays in the National Museum of American History was on the indigenous Alaskan people and their history. The display had obviously been done in part by modern politically correct automatons and in part by actual natives of the land. This became abundantly clear on the section devoted to the potential for drilling for oil in the Alaskan National Wildlife Refuge. The "proper" position was presented with compelling photos of choice parts of the refuge and the need to preserve them, but right next to that was a statement from the Inuit people saying they desperately wanted to develop those oil reserves to pull the region out of the abject poverty that was crushing their spirits and destroying their lives. In effect the indigenous people of the region were saying "We want the same benefits you have!" and the politically correct elites were saying "it is better for you to remain in abject poverty than to develop your resources and create jobs and an economy." I could not think of a more compelling example of how the elites in this country, and the world think. In fact it can fairly easily be boiled down to "We have our internet, our laptop computers, our cell phones, our jet airplanes, our supermarkets... but we feel guilty about them, so you can't have any of that. Trust us, it's all for the best. Let us be the ones to suffer from industrialization, while you live your authentic lives without the evils of Walmart and McDonalds."

Comments (6)

Foobarista
While living in Beijing, I ran into this attitude in spades among expats. They always were upset that crappy and unlivable shacks were being torn down for admittedly ugly modern skyscraper apartment buildings, while the locals (outside university types and other tut-tutters) loved the idea of central air and heating, hot water on tap, indoor plumbing, electricity that isn't a rats-nest of wires running through the building, and a shopping area at the bottom of the building (most of the newer buildings were in the Hong Kong style with apartments up top and shops of the sort you'd find in a neighborhood strip center below). Here, capitalism came to the rescue in various ways: in both Beijing and Shanghai, entrepreneurs bought up several blocks of these houses, fixed them up, and turned them into boutique malls. Houses that were bigger and had some historic significance were bought by other developers and turned into restaurants. Sure, Western tourists don't get the happy experience of seeing picturesque "living museums" in 500 year old buildings, but the people who lived there get to enjoy the life of modern people. Just like the Inuit. They're not so dumb that they buy the Rousseau "noble savage" nonsense; they want jobs, indoor plumbing, and a modern life too, instead of a picture-postcard existence where they live hard and usually die before 30.
Foobarista
One aside: here's a perfect song from 90 years ago that describes these ideas wonderfully... http://www.archive.org/details/ByronGHarlanwithAdaJones
Drax
Most of the people who yearn for those simple times amongst noble savages wouldn't survive a day amongst them, and, if they could, they would hate every day they did so.
CosmicConservative
Especially those noble savages who considered ripping your entrails out, tying them to a tree and making you walk around the tree until you died as good clean family entertainment.
Dadman
Heck...I think the British Empire was into similar clean family entertainment not too terribly long ago...
CosmicConservative
Well, perhaps. But the distinction I would make is that even though the British may have taken a few convicted criminals and drawn and quartered them publicly, they generally didn't pop over the Channel to bring a few innocent French folks back for their entertainment.