Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Jesus, the cross and ultimate sacrifice

By CosmicConservative
I was recently in a discussion with a co-worker and friend about the nature of God and the purpose of heaven and lots of other high-falutin' stuff I really shouldn't get into. Remember I am a "Rational Conservative" not a "Religious Conservative" so I am pretty much agnostic when it comes to religion. Keep that in mind as you read this. We were discussing, among other things, the nature of truth, the importance of faith, and how one interacts with the other. It all started with a question about the recent revelations that the DNA analysis of Native Americans did not square completely with certain assertions some consider important to the Mormon faith. The individual I was talking with is a fundamentalist Christian who believes the Bible to be the literal word of God. When I asked her if the DNA analysis caused her to doubt some of the assertions of the Mormon faith she said "that seems reasonable." So of course I had to then ask why scientific support for the earth and universe being billions of years old was something she discounted, since she believes the earth was created in six literal days roughly 10,000 or so years ago. I asked why it was so easy to believe the science that challenged the faith of others while ignoring science that challenged her own faith. She dodged the question, instead saying that the literal six days of creation weren't the "central" aspects of her faith. The central aspect of her faith was the assertion that God had sacrificed his only son to atone for the sins of humanity. We went down a few side tracks on the subject of the veracity of the Bible, but that never gets anywhere, so instead I decided to pursue this fundamental assertion at face value. "Sacrifice?" I said. "Sacrifice!?" I repeated. "What do you mean 'sacrifice'? Where is Jesus now?" "Sitting at the right hand of God" she replied. "So what, exactly, did Jesus sacrifice if he is now and forever the second most powerful being in the universe and sitting forever at the right-hand of the most powerful being?" I asked. "His sacrifice was to die for our sins." she replied. "Die?" I asked? "So where is the body now?" "What do you mean?" She replied. "It seems to me that Jesus knew very well that he was not going to 'die.' He had absolute infallible knowledge that he was eternal, and would return to heaven where he would sit at the right hand of God. His period on earth looks more like a weekend getaway to me than a 'sacrifice.' Where is the sacrifice?" We went back and forth a few more times with me trying to understand how what Jesus went through was any sort of sacrifice at all for the supreme being of the universe, much less an "ultimate" sacrifice. When she was unable to convince me that even dragging a cross through the streets of Jerusalem and dying on a cross was much of a sacrifice for a God, she decided to focus on the "Oh my Father, why have you forsaken me?" quote and asserted that it was not the living on earth, the whips, crown of thorns, beatings and crucifixion itself that was the sacrifice, it was that moment when God separated himself from Jesus, that alone was the sacrifice she was talking about. Of course, being the curmudgeonly agnostic that I am, I can't help but wonder if that separation was all it took, what was all the hoopla around the crucifixion? Was it simply high theater? Does God simply have a flair for performance art? But still, I had to give her credit for making a point. Forget about the high drama surrounding Jesus's supposed last days, focus on this one issue. Separation from God is the supreme sacrifice for Jesus to make. But isn't that how all humans live every day? And we don't even have divinity, omnipotence or omniscience to fall back on. Yet Jesus, who has ALL these advantages, endured this as suffering beyond anything man can fathom. I'm still working on the philosophical and religious implications of this. My initial reaction is to wonder what being in God's presence is all about, if being separated creates such suffering. I'm not sure that's a good thing if I think about it. It implies that even if I go to heaven (not very likely I'm afraid) I trade self-reliance for an infinite dependency on God's presence. OK, I do know. I don't like the sound of that at all. What do you think?

Comments (10)

Dadman
People like your fundamentalist friend doubt the assertions of any religion other than their own. Before DNA analysis was available, Mormon detractors found countless other 'reasonable' justifications to either doubt or openly attack the Mormon faith. Evangelical Christians are particularly bigoted toward other faiths and seem to spend as much time and energy criticizing other religions as they do living their own. Ironically, the central aspect of a Mormon's faith is essentially the same as the one your friend articulated: that God had sacrificed his only son to atone for the sins of humanity. It is true that recent DNA analysis of Native American ancestry casts some doubt on the claims of the Book of Mormon that American Indians are descendants of the House of Israel. Of course, the Book of Mormon does not claim to be the story of ALL Native Americans. It is also true that recent 'scholarship' is casting some doubt on the historic accuracy of the New Testment gospels and the existence of Jesus himself. Religion will never cease to be a fascinating subject of research and discussion.
Dadman
By the way, I my view the 'sacrifice' of Jesus is best defined by the excruciating physical agony he endured in the Garden of Gethsemane that caused him to bleed from every pore and his physical death on the cross. Christ may have been aware of his fate after the crucifixion, but that knowledge did little to mitigate the pain he endured prior to his death.
mtnlurker
Being an aspect of God makes Jesus immortal. So, given eternity, even a lot of pain would not be unbearable. Sounds like a nice change from an eternity of unchanging bliss.
Dadman
Interesting theory, Mr. Lurker. Jesus, in human form, was subject to human pain and it seems to me that only immense pain could cause one to bleed from every pore which is what the scriptures tell us occurred in the Garden of Gethsemane. If Jesus considered it a nice change of pace as you propose I guess all the blood and agony were simply the product of clever special effects and fine acting. This discussion, of course, is futile. Each of us will believe what we wish. To each his own...
CosmicConservative
Heh... True enough Dadman. But I still don't see how any finite amount of suffering is significant to an infinite and infinitely powerful being.
Dadman
I will only say that we don't know much about the quality of the suffering except that it was sufficient to atone for the sins of humanity and therefore beyond normal human experience. If you believe all that stuff...
CosmicConservative
See, that's part of the deal. Why does it take so much suffering to atone for human sins? Yes I know that humans have a dark side, but they have a light side too. One of the things that really bugs me about Theism is that it almost always gives humans all the blame for evil, while giving all the credit for good to the Deity in question. One of the most irritating and insulting things I have ever seen is the poem "Footsteps" which talks about some poor fellow trudging through the sand who looks back and says "Oh God, how you have abandoned me, I look back in my life and see one set of footprints through the bad times, and two sets through the good times, where were you when I needed you?" And God replies "Oh my son, those single footprints were from the times I carried you." What utter rot. I was there and remember every freaking step. I'll take the blame for my screw ups, I don't need no freakin' megalomaniac deity taking credit for what little I do right.
Dadman
Your view of Theism and mine are quite different. I believe humans are free agents in this universe with enormous potential. Indeed, the concept of humanity's free agency is one of the most critical components of my personal cosmology. I believe humans often succumb to evil influences, but they are hardly responsible for the existence of evil itself. I believe true faith in a higher power can lighten burdens, but, as free agents, we will be individually rewarded for the things we do right. I believe sin leads to pain and anguish. Atoning for all humanity's sin - if that is truly what Christ did - would logically require pain and suffering beyond anything we can imagine. Your view of God as a 'freakin' megalomaniac' is utter rot. Perhaps you need a change of perspective.
CosmicConservative
That's not MY "view of God." That's my OPINION of how God is described by many Deists. My personal opinion is that God, if such an entity exists, is nothing like that. It is the idea that I am responsible for all my mistakes, but God is responsible for all my good decisions that is utter rot. As well as the idea that when I made my way through suffering that God allowed to happen, it's only because God reached down and propped me up. I find such a worldview not only fatalistic, but personally dis-empowering. And deeply, deeply offensive. IMHO
Dadman
Then we are in agreement. I believe we are accountable for all of our decisions - both good and bad.