Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Latest "missing link" revealed

By CosmicConservative
Missing Link: Scientists In New York Unveil Fossil Of Lemur Monkey Hailed As Man's Earliest Ancestor | World News | Sky News The search for a direct connection between humans and the rest of the animal kingdom has taken 200 years - but it was presented to the world today at a special news conference in New York. The discovery of the 95%-complete 'lemur monkey' - dubbed Ida - is described by experts as the "eighth wonder of the world". They say its impact on the world of palaeontology will be "somewhat like an asteroid falling down to Earth".
To be accurate here, and to try to get a bit beyond the hype, what this fossil is, assuming it's not a hoax, is a link between primates and other mammals. It would demonstrate a transitional form which led to the primate branch of mammals, which, of course, includes humans.

Comments (11)

Dadman
Heh. I had just finished reading this article before visiting your blog. Interesting article, but the tone of it is so over-the-top self-aggrandizing that I am frankly skeptical of the claims it is making. Human evolutionary science, like climate science, is regrettably one of those fields of study that has been infected by ideology and dogma...imho.
CosmicConservative
I concur Dadman. When I went to the link and saw that they had created a full-blown media event around this, my initial strong reaction was "since when is science done by press release?" I guess that started about the same time it was done by consensus... Still, as skeptical as I am, my initial response is that this is probably a real fossil and has plenty of scientific value, but the hoopla is way, way over the top.
Drax
Too much science, like religion, is infected with "true believers" who have cemented world-views which are at least as much based on faith as they are reason. This has ever been the case. It is understandable in religion as faith is a fundamental aspect of "belief." It is incomprehensible in science where faith is as close to the opposite of the "scientific method" that it makes no discernable difference.
CosmicConservative
I don't think science and faith are nearly the polar opposites many on both sides think they are. When I say I have "faith" in the scientific method, I mean that in a very literal sense. As with many things, I think Einstein said it best when he said "The most incomprehensible thing about the universe is that it is comprehensible." All of science is predicated on this fundamental statement of faith that the universe is comprehensible. There is no Theory of Comprehensibility" which provides a context and framework for universes to be comprehensible. And yet that faith in the fundamental comprehensibility of things is what has driven science and technology to where we are today, and continues to drive us forward (into the maw of the singularity, no doubt...)
Drax
CC: I agree that the notion that science and faith are "polar opposites" is not entirely accurate. But, "faith" in the "scientific method" isn't the same thing as having "faith" in results which do not SURVIVE the "scientific method" (or haven't been or aren't capable of being examined through that lens).
Dadman
Speaking of singularities. I may have the privilege of hosting Ray Kurzweil for an Intel speaking engagement here in AZ. He is currently booked to speak at our Massachusetts and Santa Clara campuses and we (I am the co-lead on team that organizes these kinds of events for Intel employees) are seriously considering bring him to AZ later this year. I think it would be a very interesting event...
Drax
I almost picked up his book yesterday ("The Singularity is Near") at Barnes & Noble as it was on the 6.99 table. I flipped through it and it seemed to have a bit too much math in it for my easy comprehension (or I flipped to an amazing number of "random" pages with equations on them....) Is the math something I can dispense with and fully understand that writing?
Dadman
Cosmic actually read Kurzweil's book. Perhaps he can elaborate.
Dadman
I should probably read the book IF he accepts an invitation to come to AZ...
CosmicConservative
I will elaborate later today. Currently I am in a meeting getting my head handed to me over a botched migration attempt....
Andy
I missed this one before Cosmic. I'm glad you finally relented, and started posting more eye candy.