Gay marriage...
By CosmicConservativeIn part because of the Carrie Prejean comments in the Miss USA contest (which I think I've been inaccurately calling the "Miss America" contest up 'til now...) and in part because of the constant hammering of the issue in the press, I've been trying to come up with a rational position on gay marriage.
What is marriage? It is both a religious and a legal designation. This, of course, is part of the difficulty of the debate. It's virtually impossible to discuss the legal ramifications without pulling in the religious ones, and vice versa.
So my first "position" on marriage is to separate the religious perspective from the legal one. I don't care if marriage ceremonies include the two, but call them different things. Call the religious one "marriage" and call the legal one "cohabitation". I don't care. Allow people to do one without the other if they like, I see no reason the two should be viewed as one thing.
Now, because I'm not a religious person, I really have no skin in the religious marriage thing. If your religion says you can only marry the opposite sex, that's fine with me, as is the reverse.
On the LEGAL side, the question of whether our society should allow same-sex and opposite-sex cohabitation contracts is simpler without the religious overtones. However, there is still the question of procreation. While in some cases marriage is simply a cohabitation, in the vast majority of cases the question of procreation comes in. Then the question is whether we should allow same sex couples to raise children. This is a more difficult question, and has to be answered on technical and ethical grounds.
I have heard many opponents of same-sex marriage use the argument that same-sex couples cannot procreate, and therefore should not marry. This argument is usually met with "well, they can adopt, or use surrogates". I'll go one step further. It is fairly easy for me to envision medical techniques which allow same sex couples to procreate with their own genetic material, producing genetically unique children containing the DNA of the same sex couple in genetically identical ways as opposite sex couples. Simply taking a donor egg and sperm cell and injecting the couple's DNA into them would work. For women, the resulting fertilized egg can be implanted into the womb. For men an artificial womb will someday (soon) be developed to perform the same function. In fact I suspect in a hundred years most babies will be carried to term in artificial wombs.
So the whole "procreation" thing doesn't fly for me, so I can't oppose same-sex marriage on technical grounds.
The ethical argument boils down to "children grow up more secure and happier in houses with a father and mother." This may be true, but it is not truly compelling because of the many examples of children growing up with one or both parents missing. This argument would seem to imply that children of divorced parents should be given up to the state or given to a secure opposite sex couple to raise. Since nobody would argue such a thing, I have to say that this argument also falls short.
I am open to more discussion on this. But based on this analysis so far, I can't say I have any opposition to redefining the terms and allowing legal cohabitation of couples of either sex, even to raise children.
Now, what does this mean for polygamy or incest? Well, make those illegal then. I'm good with that too.
Comments (43)