Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Gay marriage...

By CosmicConservative
In part because of the Carrie Prejean comments in the Miss USA contest (which I think I've been inaccurately calling the "Miss America" contest up 'til now...) and in part because of the constant hammering of the issue in the press, I've been trying to come up with a rational position on gay marriage. What is marriage? It is both a religious and a legal designation. This, of course, is part of the difficulty of the debate. It's virtually impossible to discuss the legal ramifications without pulling in the religious ones, and vice versa. So my first "position" on marriage is to separate the religious perspective from the legal one. I don't care if marriage ceremonies include the two, but call them different things. Call the religious one "marriage" and call the legal one "cohabitation". I don't care. Allow people to do one without the other if they like, I see no reason the two should be viewed as one thing. Now, because I'm not a religious person, I really have no skin in the religious marriage thing. If your religion says you can only marry the opposite sex, that's fine with me, as is the reverse. On the LEGAL side, the question of whether our society should allow same-sex and opposite-sex cohabitation contracts is simpler without the religious overtones. However, there is still the question of procreation. While in some cases marriage is simply a cohabitation, in the vast majority of cases the question of procreation comes in. Then the question is whether we should allow same sex couples to raise children. This is a more difficult question, and has to be answered on technical and ethical grounds. I have heard many opponents of same-sex marriage use the argument that same-sex couples cannot procreate, and therefore should not marry. This argument is usually met with "well, they can adopt, or use surrogates". I'll go one step further. It is fairly easy for me to envision medical techniques which allow same sex couples to procreate with their own genetic material, producing genetically unique children containing the DNA of the same sex couple in genetically identical ways as opposite sex couples. Simply taking a donor egg and sperm cell and injecting the couple's DNA into them would work. For women, the resulting fertilized egg can be implanted into the womb. For men an artificial womb will someday (soon) be developed to perform the same function. In fact I suspect in a hundred years most babies will be carried to term in artificial wombs. So the whole "procreation" thing doesn't fly for me, so I can't oppose same-sex marriage on technical grounds. The ethical argument boils down to "children grow up more secure and happier in houses with a father and mother." This may be true, but it is not truly compelling because of the many examples of children growing up with one or both parents missing. This argument would seem to imply that children of divorced parents should be given up to the state or given to a secure opposite sex couple to raise. Since nobody would argue such a thing, I have to say that this argument also falls short. I am open to more discussion on this. But based on this analysis so far, I can't say I have any opposition to redefining the terms and allowing legal cohabitation of couples of either sex, even to raise children. Now, what does this mean for polygamy or incest? Well, make those illegal then. I'm good with that too.

Comments (43)

Drax
Homosexuality, like pedophilia, is abnormal, i.e., it is the drive to engage in the reproductive act with people with whom you cannot reproduce. Were such behavior "normal," the human race wouldn't exist. The fact that homosexuals have existed since the dawn of Man means nothing; so have pedophiles. All it establishes is that this particular brain abnormality has existed as long as Man has existed. The fact that some societies have tolerated, even encouraged, homosexuality also means nothing; societies have also tolerated and encouraged pedophiles. The fact that homosexuals were born that way means nothing; so were pedophiles. That fact simply highlights that, for true homosexuals, their sexual drives are organic rather than learned. So. Homosexuality is abnormal. Unlike pedophilia, however, most homosexuals engage in the sex act with other, consenting adults, and this is where the argument lies today. Regardless of WHY homosexuals have this abnormal sexual desire (to engage in a reproductive act with someone with whom they can't reproduce -- an act which, if the "norm," would mean the extinction of the Human Race) so long as it's consumation is confined to others of legal age, I have no problem. And, frankly, society as a whole doesn't have a problem with it. So, even though many people for religious reasons, or simply due to the "ugh" factor, do not believe that homosexuality is proper behavior, society has decided, after many years of forbidding such behavior, to tolerate it. But, marriage? The underlying purpose of marriage is to raise families. To have a small unit in which the values of society are passed down from the parents to the children. Now, common observation informs us that men and women are different -- different in ways which go far beyond differences in our plumbing. We think differently. We behave differently. Books have ever been written about this divide. Comics make good livings remarking on this divide. Some anthropologists have posited that the reason for the difference in how men and women think is derived from our essential differences in the earliest years...when men were hunters and women were gatherers (once we became somewhat agrarian). Men developed competitively as the best hunter frequently had the best rewards and standing in the community. They had to concentrate on a single task -- hunting/stalking their prey so they became very one-dimensional in their thinking, thinking about one thing to the exclusion of all else. Silence was valued in the hunt, so men valued silence. Women, in groups gathering, tended to engage others co-operatively, and, since they could, at any time, become prey, had to do their tasks while keeping an eye out for possible predators, resulting in the ability to multi-task to a greater degree than men. Working together required conversation and conversation did not interfere with the task, so women talked more than men. Women raised the children, so they became more nurturing. Of course, we all know these differences (and many more....) We're all aware of them if we have ever actually looked around (or read a book...) Many scientific studies have examined this difference: http://www.springerlink.com/content/7r97h874u616261m/ http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/extract/327/7405/57 Men and women are fundamentally different. As such, they offer fundamentally different examples to their children. Children who, in their most formative years are only exposed to one gender are deprived of the example of the missing gender, resulting in a world-view which is not fully formed. This had nothing to do with homosexuality, but with the natural outgrowth of normalization of same-sex marriage -- regardless of the sexual desires of the "parents." Children who are raised without the examples of a man and a woman are simply deprived of the example of the missing gender. While there have not been many scientific studies which have compared the effects of unregulated same-sex rearing of children from birth, I am utterly unwilling to simply experiment with the lives of thousands or millions of children. We have seen the results of that experiment with single parent families and it has been utterly disasterous.
CosmicConservative
Drax: What a rich ore to mine... "Abnormal" is not a scientific word. "Deviant" might be a scientific word, but I doubt you'll find anyone outside of the hardcore right willing to describe homosexuality as "deviant." If pursuing physical sexual acts without a reproductive goal is "abnormal" then so is masturbation. If that's true then 80% of all men are admittedly abnormal (and the other 20% are liars). And since the great majority of sex in this country is performed without the goal or possibility of producing offspring, your assertion that if such behavior were "normal" that would mean the end of the human race is simply demonstrably untrue. I'm not willing to describe pursuing sexual gratification without procreation as a goal as "abnormal" for many, many reasons, the most obvious of which is that the primary motivation for sexual behavior IS pure sexual gratification, with procreation a minor consideration in the vast majority of cases. That's why they call it a "sex drive" in the first place. Your defnition of abnormal would cover sex with a condom, sex after vasectomy or sex while on the pill as "abnormal." In other words your definition pretty much describes 95% of all sexual activity as "abnormal" which is a definition I find to be logically indefensible. Comparing homosexuality to pedophilia as equally deviant behavior is pretty bad Drax. I'm sure you could have found some other way to make your point with out implying that homosexuality is the moral equivalent of pedophilia. As a debate tactic I find it to be distasteful. Since you spent a paragraph on the subject of how marriage is primarily to raise children I have to wonder if you actually read my original post at all since I feel pretty confident that my argument of how technology will allow same sex couples to reproduce in a manner that is genetically identical to heterosexual sex pretty much dealt with that side of the argument. So we are really left with the question of whether a child "should" be raised in an environment where they are missing a male or female "role model." And as I said, the logical outcome of that argument is to remove children from the homes of divorced parents, or homes where one parent has died. Are you willing to call for that?
Drax
I'll go with "deviant." (Although, "to deviate" one must deviate from something. In this case, the "something" is the norm, resulting in a deviation from the norm, a.k.a. "abnormal.") Masturbation does not involve any other person as an object of sexual desire. Pedophiles have children as the object of their sexual desire. Homosexuals have members of the same sex as the object of their sexual desire. Hetrosexuals have members of the opposite sex as the object of their sexual desire. One could assume that each group masturbates with those objects in mind. So...I discard out of hand your "masturbation" objection. As to the "procreation" notion, i.e. that most sex is pursued without the object of reproduction, that has utterly nothing to do with the homosexual, pedophile, or hetrosexual becoming aroused by that which arouses them. Whether the actual act is intended to reproduce or not is immaterial. Each are driven to engage in sex with those who arouse them. This drive can be so strong that they risk imprisonment and death to consumate their desires. If pedophiles and homosexuals were "the norm," then the human race would not exist. The notion that my definiton of "abnormal" (being sexually attracted to a segment of the human population with whom it is impossible to procreate with is somehow akin to "sex with condoms" or the other silly examples is beneath you. The drive itself defines the abnormality, not whether or not, when consumating it, one practices safe sex. Hetrosexuality is "the norm." So... You think my comparison of homosexuality to pedophilia is "pretty bad?" Let's see. Is it your assertion that it is "the norm" for human beings to be homosexuals? Is it your assertion that "normal" human beings are born with the desire to have sex with people with whom it is impossible to reproduce? If so...how on earth do you support that argument? How would the human race exist if it were "the norm" for people to be attracted solely to people with whom they could not procreate? Comparisons between the two: 1) They are "born that way." 2) They are attracted to a portion of humanity with whom it is impossible to reproduce. 3) This drive is so strong that they will risk death and imprisonment. The ONLY thing which distinguishes homosexuals from pedophiles is the OBJECT of their sexual desire. In every other way, when viewed as sexual urge, they are IDENTICAL. As such, why do you find the comparison "distastful?" Is it somehow incorrect? If so, please point out the error. Absent your rebuttal illustrating my error (which seems to be missing in your post) the comparison is a rational one, one which MUST be made. EITHER homosexuality is learned OR it is organic. (It certainly CAN be learned...but that is a topic for a different discussion. But, either you're "born that way" or you're not. Homosexuals are almost universal in the "we're born this way" camp...) SCIENCE will answer this question. (Although I need no convincing. The "abnormality" seems pretty self-evident.) We WILL find out conclusively whether this drive is caused by a brain malfunction and HOW TO PREVENT/CURE IT. It's inevitable. It will happen soon. The same is true of pedophilia and other brain malfunctions. (And, WHERE did I even INTIMATE a "moral" comparison? To the extent that I drew any "moral" comparison, I stated that: Unlike pedophilia, however, most homosexuals engage in the sex act with other, consenting adults.... Regardless of WHY homosexuals have this abnormal sexual desire ... so long as its consumation is confined to others of legal age, I have no problem. And, frankly, society as a whole doesn’t have a problem with it. This would seem to be very close to the opposite of drawing a moral equivalency between the two. As to your final point (not your most absurd, but close...) that my argument calls for removing children from the homes of single parents. I didn't say that. I didn't mean that. One can't reasonably infer that. What one can reasonably infer is that which I said, i.e., that children in homes with a man and a woman overwhelmingly fare better than children in single parent homes. What I said was that the single parent experiment was a failure. What I said was that I was unwilling to undergo yet another "experiment" with the lives and futures of thousands or millions of other children just to assuage the feelings of a very small minority of the population or the feelings of those who, for whatever reason, support them in this effort. Once the state sanctions marriage between members of the same sex, then all fruits of that union will flow, including the right to adopt children (including surrogate parentage) from the moment that child leaves the hospital. Any "home study" (normally required in adoptions -- but not necessarily so -- and it is unknown what the "home study" requirements for surrogate parentage would be) would preclude by law even taking into consideration the same sex of the parents (that would be discrimination). So, marriage between members of the same sex would have as its inevitable outgrowth thousands upon thousands of children being raised in same sex households when we haven't a clue as to the long-term effects of such on those children and society as a whole. Are you willing to call for that?
CosmicConservative
Drax: I suppose we could debate "normal" and "abnormal" until we are blue in the face. You and I do not agree on what those terms mean. To me whether a behavior is "normal" is not the same thing as if it is the "predominant" behavior. You continue to assert that if homosexual behavior were "normal" then the human race would have died out long ago. This is simply not true. Humans, like most living organisms, are inclined to produce far more young than are needed to sustain the species, which is a primary reason the world is getting overpopulated today. Off the top of my head I would say that it is not even required for heterosexual behavior to be the MAJORITY behavior of the species for the species to reach self-sustaining levels. And it is entirely obvious to me that a constant level of homosexual tendencies in the 10% or so range would not significantly reduce the sustainability of the human species EVEN IF homosexuals NEVER ENGAGED IN HETEROSEXUAL PROCREATIVE SEX. I'm not sure if you realize that a large portion of the homosexual "community" DOES engage in heterosexual sex, in some cases STRICTLY FOR THE PURPOSE OF PROCREATION. There have been ENORMOUS numbers of scientific studies which have shown that homosexuality has no negative impact on population growth at the levels it has historically been practiced. It has also been shown that homosexual behavior has been fairly consistent throughout human history and human cultures. The most common figure published is somewhere around 6%. In other words, scientific study of the phenomenon tells us that it appears to be NORMAL for the human species to have around 6% of its members attracted to the same sex. And such a situation has NO NEGATIVE IMPACT on population growth or sustainability. So, is it accurate to call a person "abnormal" when they are behaving completely consistent with normal human behavior over the course of history? I suppose that conversation itself lends towards some philosophical considerations about language and human nature. I will just say that I do not consider homosexual behavior in the 6% or so range in a large sample of human population to be "abnormal" because it is absolutely NORMAL from every study of human history that has ever been done. But is it possible to call the INDIVIDUAL "abnormal" even while recognizing that the behavior is completely consistent with normal human cultural norms? Sure, I suppose it is possible, but only in the sense that a left-handed person could be called "abnormal" for exactly the same reasons. Part of my objection to the use of the term "abnormal" is that it is impossible to use that term without a pervasive negative connotation, either implied or inferred, and either intentional or inadvertent. But the negative connotation is still there. Just a few responses to your other comments: The ONLY thing which distinguishes heterosexuals from pedophiles is the OBJECT of their sexual desire. In every other way, when viewed as sexual urge, they are IDENTICAL. OK, so now we agree that sexual urges are more or less the same whether the object is a committed opposite sex mate, a White House intern, a same sex person, a child, an ostrich or a pair of latex pantyhose. Are you suggesting that ALL sexual urges are deviant? I doubt it. You are drawing lines and saying THESE sexual urges on THIS side of the line are the "normal" ones and THOSE sexual urges on the OTHER side of the line are the "abnormal ones." And my response is "You are ABSOLUTELY CORRECT! Except you put the line in the wrong place." Oral sex? Deviant behavior? Normal behavior? According to research something like 80% of heterosexual couples engage in oral sex (and probably 20% are liars). Yet oral sex has no procreative value. So is it abnormal? Which side of your line are you putting oral sex? Should we compile an exhaustive, comprehensive list of all sexual behaviors and vote on where they belong? Who gets to decide? You? Me? Dr. Laura? I mean how abnormal is the drive to engage one's genitals with another person's mouth? Well, if you go by actual behavior, it is PERFECTLY NORMAL. Let's do a little math. Currently in this country children born to single mothers is roughly the same as children born to married couples. In some subcultures children born to single mothers is HIGHER than children born to married couples. Let's do a little more math. Roughly 40% of married couples divorce. In the vast majority of those cases the mother is granted custody of the children who are the raised with the father having only visitation rights. By my count that puts the number of children raised in "normal" homes somewhere near the 35 - 40% mark. That means that in TODAY's SOCIETY, the MAJORITY of children lack that fundamental "need" for a male and female role model. Let's say that the 6% figure for homosexuality is pretty close and that ALL of them decide to pursue raising a family. Now instead of something like 60% of children growing up without a male and female role model, 66% of them will. Frankly I don't think that's a significant enough difference to worry about the long-term effects of society. In fact, if that is your TRUE bedrock concern about the "experiment" then you should be FAR MORE concerned about unmarried mothers and divorced parents, because that is an ORDER OF MAGNITUDE more impactful than the HIGHEST POTENTIAL of homosexual "family life." Frankly if I were pouring government money into the problem, I'd concentrate on single parents and divorce. There's a lot more bang for the buck there than in prohibiting homosexual couples from raising a kid here and there.
Drax
I'll start at the end. I AM far more concerned about unmarried motheres and divorced parents than I am same-sex marriage for the reasons you cite. But, THAT isn't the current discussion, is it? THOSE issues have already been "lost" for the greatest part as the causes for those (including abortion on demand, child support, welfare, food stamps (all reducing or eliminating the economic need for a "father") and no fault divorce) are almost certainly not going to be re-fought. Of course, we haven't "lost" the same-sex marriage argument yet, have we? THAT is a fight which can still be "won." Now, let's go to your comparison of homosexuals/hetrosexuals/pedophiles. You seem to (purposely?) ignore the unique identifier which is essential to identifying the sexual urge as "abnormal." I don't know how you missed it. I stated it several times. It is central to my posts. I'll state it again: "2) They are attracted to a portion of humanity with whom it is impossible to reproduce." I don't know how you missed/ignored this central point. I certainly highlighted it enough. As to your "numbers" about how many children are in "normal" homes. ("Normal" in this instance being YOUR definition -- not mine.) Even assuming that your numbers are accurate (which -- again -- they're derived from YOUR definition of "normal," a definition with which I do NOT agree...) making that number larger is what I'm against. Apparently, you aren't. And...again...(I guess I have to say it over and over and over and over and over and over and over...) It is the sexual drive which identifies the homosexual, the heterosexual, the pedophile -- not how or even whether they consumate it. The assertion from the homosexual community (and supported by many studies) is that they are "born this way." That means that, when they reach the age where they are cognizant of a sexual drive, they realize that the object of their sexual drive is the same sex rather than the opposite sex. It is at that point that "sexual orientation" is cemented. It doesn't matter if the homosexual ever actually consumates this desire -- it is the existence of the desire which identifies a homosexual. It doesn't matter if he uses a condom. Or engages in oral sex. Or does ANYTHING WHATSOEVER sexually with a member of the opposite sex. ALL THAT MATTERS is that the homosexual is attracted to members of the opposite sex and has been since awareness of his sexual identity. That is what DEFINES a homosexual. So, again. And, again. Masturbation doesn't matter. Condoms don't matter. Oral sex doesn't matter. Ostrichs don't matter. Closeted sex with members of the opposite sex doesn't matter. What IDENTIFIES a homosexual is their drive to engage in sex with members of the same sex. Because THEY'RE BORN THAT WAY. Can we move on from these silly examples now? Now..on to your discussion of my definition of "abnormal." Your rebuttal seems to consist of two prongs: 1) Homosexuality exists; therefore, it isn't abnormal. ("To me whether a behavior is “normal” is not the same thing as if it is the “predominant” behavior....I will just say that I do not consider homosexual behavior in the 6% or so range in a large sample of human population to be “abnormal” because it is absolutely NORMAL from every study of human history that has ever been done.") 2) Some sort of argument about humanity could still exist under some sort of circumstances which have certain underlying assumptions which are confused. As to the first. Huh? Your assertion is that, since homosexuals have always existed, it must be normal for them to exist? Really. Huh? The same is true for pedophiles, you know. (I think I said this in my first post...yah..sigh) The same is true for many other abberations from the norm. (Take your pick...schitzophrenia, sociopathy, whatever...) Mere existence of an abnormality doesn't result in the abnormality becoming normal. If that were the case, nothing would be "abnormal," and nothing would be "normal." Everything would be "normal" since...well it exists. As to your second, somewhat confused point: Flip your numbers. If 94% of the cave-man human population was homosexual (i.e., "the norm") then you're comfortable saying that the human race would exist? I'm not. I doubt that the human race would have gotten to the POINT where they could be called "cave men" when the normal sexual urge is sated by sex with same sex partners. I am much more comfortable with my conclusion than yours. Neither one is provable, but I think that humankind would have been an evolutionary dead-end if homosexuality was "the norm." Your other supporting information, such as homosexuals engage in reproductive behavior with members of the opposite sex doesn't address the central point whether homosexuality is abnormal, just that "homosexuals" sometimes engage in sex with members of the opposite sex. (How much of that was due to past discrimination against homosexuals...how much was due to societal pressures which shamed homosexuals into attempting to act as heterosexuals...how much was due to the no-longer-true fact that if you wanted children, that was essentially the only way to have them...) That doesn't address the CURRENT situation where homosexuals no longer suffer this discrimination...this societal shame...or are burdened with having sex with members of the opposite sex in order to have children... ---------------------- I didn't go into the other long term effects of same-sex marriage earlier. I touch on it now. I made the assertion that homosexuality as a lifestyle can be learned (as opposed to being "born this way".) We know this. (Any cursory reading of Plato, Plutarch or Greek history in general will reveal this.) We know that many of the ruling classes over the centuries were either openly homosexual or bi-sexual. (Chinese and Roman are the most widely documented.) The numbers you have cited (6%) have risen. It USED to be 3%. And, FAR MORE than 6% of the population engages in homosexual behavior. Exposure and acceptance (or being above reproach as in the case of nobility -- or expectations of tutulage as in the Greeks -- or close enforced quarters as with the Spartans) to behavior translates into people engaging in that behavior. If you have any question as to the truth of this, just turn on your television, read the internet, look at the billboards...maybe visit Vermont where the Legislature is considering legalizing "sexting" among TEENS. Homosexuality is now, at least arguably, not only accepted but in vogue. If same sex marriage becomes legal (as will almost certainly be the case), my child will almost certainly have the following conversation on the playground before she reaches puberty: "What do you want to do when you grow up?" "I want to get married!" "Great! Do you want to marry a man or a woman?" I think that this is a particularly bad idea. --------------------------------- Of course, assuming that the human race survives the next 100 years or so intact (an assumption I'm not currently willing to make) technology will ultimately moot much of this argument anyway. In the not-too-distant future, one's sexual identity will be malleable. One will be able to "become" a woman (fully, completely -- with a working womb and all) and live as such for so long as you (in your long, long life) wish. Then, once you have tired of birthing children, you will be able to "become" a man with all the appropriate working parts. Potentially, one could be both at once. So, sexual identity will become blurred at the very least -- if not obliterated altogether. Further, a (much) longer life will likely result in a different notion of "marriage" altogether. (A notion which, today, is far different from that which it was even 50 years ago, transforming from "until death do we part" to "until I get tired of you or find someone better.") That doesn't mean that, at this point in time, one doesn't argue for what one believes based on what is rather than what what might one day be.
CosmicConservative
Of course, assuming that the human race survives the next 100 years or so intact (an assumption I’m not currently willing to make) technology will ultimately moot much of this argument anyway.
Heh, you accuse me of missing or ignoring key points in your arguments, and you seem to have totally missed this key point in mine. You consistently say that the abnormality of homosexual desire is the “2) They are attracted to a portion of humanity with whom it is impossible to reproduce.” One of my first CENTRAL points in this debate is that this distinction is either ALREADY GONE, or will SOON BE gone. So if that's what defines the desire as "abnormal" then once technology solves that little procreation problem, I guess the behavior suddenly becomes normal from your point of view. Since you don't explain why it is "irrelevant" for us to discuss the VAST MAJORITY of sex which occurs between two people for whom procreation is not expected nor desired (condoms, vasectomies, the pill, oral sex, .... etc.) you MUST be suggesting something on a more general level, ergo "men and women GENERALLY are able to procreate, so sex between men and women who CANNOT procreate is STILL normal." OK, that's an understandable distinction, albeit one you have not made (you're welcome ;) ). I suppose we could even extend that rationale and say that sexual attraction between GENERAL CATEGORIES of human beings which require technical help to conceive is "abnormal" so that we can call homosexual desire "abnormal" well into the future. OK. I still think that we are using "normal" and "abnormal" differently. I still say that your definition means left-handed people are abnormal. As are blue-eyed people (brown eyes are the predominant eye color in the world). In fact I'm pretty sure that according to how you are defining "normal" and "abnormal" EVERYONE is abnormal in some way. (Blood type, hair color, allergies, etc.). I guess I'll paraphrase Dash from the Incredibles and say that a world where EVERYONE is abnormal is a world where NOBODY is. I suppose the only way to reconcile YOUR notion of "normal" vs. my notion of it is to say that it appears to be NORMAL in human society for some portion of the population to consistently and predictably be "abnormal" in a particular way. In that sense the INDIVIDUAL can be viewed as "abnormal" while the behavior itself is clearly "normal" in a more general, historic context. For example, looking at history it appears that war is "normal" behavior for humans. However, the individual actions taken in wartime by individual humans could be described as "aberrant behavior." People don't normally try to kill as many other human beings as possible. So while war is "normal", the actions taken by individuals in war are "abnormal." Is that a premise you are willing to accept? If so we COULD state that homosexuality ITSELF is "normal" in the human species, but that individual homosexual acts are "abnormal" behavior. Even if you are willing to accept that notion, it's one I'd have to think about for a while. By the way, do you have any actual statistics for the rates of crime, delinquent behavior, dropouts, drug use, etc. for children of homosexual couples? If not then I think you are making an ASSUMPTION that homosexual committed relationships have the same problems that broken homes or single-parent homes have. I simply have not seen that analysis and research done. Until I see that homosexual couples raise less prepared children than heterosexual couples, I'm simply not willing to accept your assertion that the mere lack of a male or female role model causes the problems we see in single or broken home families. I think there are a LOT more variables in that equation.
Drax
I'll make it short then: 1) Someone who is born with the desire to copulate with a member of the same sex is not the same as a person who is born with the desire to have sex with a member of the opposite sex -- but uses a condom. 2) Someone who is born with the desire to copulate with a member of the same sex is not the same as a person who is born with the desire to have sex with a member of the opposite sex -- but masturbates. 3) It is the drive which differentiates the homosexual from the heterosexual...not whether or how that drive is consumated. 4) If you continue to believe that a there is no difference between a homosexual who desires to have sex with members of the same sex and a heterosexual who desires to have sex with members of the opposite sex -- and, to the extent there is a difference, that difference is eliminated by masturbation, condoms, or your other "straw men" arguments, there is no possibility of rationally discussing this subject as rationality has deserted you. 5) We all have "abnormalities." Some of these abnormalities are of sufficient concern to be remarkable. Others are not. 6) The fact that I'm left-handed and my partner is right-handed is not remarkable. It does not affect the fabric of society. The fact that I have blue eyes and my partner has brown is not remarkable. It does not affect the fabric of society. The fact that I am a man and my partner is a man has the potential to affect the fabric of society. It is remarkable. Yet more straw-man arguments. 7) Just because something exists, just because something has existed from the beginning -- doesn't mean that that "something" is "normal." It just means that the condition exists. Nothing more. Whether it is "normal" or not is determined by comparing it to "the norm." That's how the comparative terms "normal" and "abnormal" are derived. Of course, something could be neither "normal" or "abnormal" if the condition didn't exist in the first place. Yet more straw man arguments. 8) There are no studies I could find which compares the effect upon children raised by opposite sex parents and same sex parents. I'm not sure such exist. That, of course, is my point. That, of course, is why I called it an "experiment." That, of course, is why I concluded that I'm unwilling to take a chance on this "experiment." You clearly don't have a problem risking the futures and fates of thousands/millions of children in this "experiment." 9) I'm not sure that, on the whole, there's anything which can be classified as a "committed homosexual relationship." Even by today's transient standards; even by today's fidelity standards -- homosexuals who have an average of 1 1/2 years in a committed relationship and average 8 "extramarital" relationships a year are transient and uncommitted. Again, why you would want to visit even more and to a greater degree failed experiment (single parent) on children with "I have two dads" tossed in for good measure eludes me. I'm not willing to add insult to injury in this regard.
Jack
If homosexuality has been with us since the dawn of man, I don't see how it has had much of an impact on the fabric of society. Mankind has (overall) continued to advance both culturally and technologically.
Dadman
I don't understand how any true conservative can be unmoved or impartial about legally redefining the institution of marriage. At the very least you'd think they would be concerned, as Drax is, about the adverse unintended consequences such social engineering could bring to society. I know I am. But my biggest beef with the legal recognition of 'gay marriage' is the impact it will INEVITABLY have on religious freedom and liberty. We all know that many gay marriage advocates hate religion about as much as they love the idea of 'gay marriage'. Consider this scenario: A member of a legally married gay couple, who identify themselves as 'Christian' apply for admission to one of the myriad faith-based liberal arts colleges that still teach that homosexuality is sinful and against God's will. They also apply to live in married student housing. They are denied admission (to both the school and the housing) based on their lifestyle and the religious teachings of the school's sponsoring church. It will take approximately one nanosecond for the lawsuits to hit the fan. Maybe less. In fact, I'm convinced gay activists are already planning test cases as we debate this on CC. The goal of these test cases will be, of course, to embarrass and disparage faith-based schools and ultimately force as many of them as possible to compromise their beliefs or shut down entirely. This outcome would, of course, diminish the religious liberties of tens of thousands of families who prefer to educate their children at church sponsored institutions. And the coming attack on faith-based schools is just one example of where this is all heading. Backed by an army of liberal and gay activists, legally sanctioned 'gay marriage' will clearly result in the further secularization of American society. I suppose if you're not a religious individual with no skin in the game that's not a big deal. But it is a big deal for millions of Americans who value their threatened constitutional right to worship God according to the dictates of their own consciences...
CosmicConservative
Drax: Well, obviously I don't believe I am submitting "straw man" arguments. I was not the one who said that desiring sex with someone with whom you could not procreate was "abnormal". That was your definition, I just said "Oh, OK, then LOGICALLY that would mean the following." How that is a "straw man" completely escapes me. If you have refined your point (or have accepted MY refinements) so that your point is no longer "abnormal desire is the desire to have non-procreative sex" then fine, but up until now I have seen no specific clarification of that position. In fact you have restated it forcefully. I'm fine with restating it the way I did so that we can get past this definitional, rhetorical impasse. Let me try to get this back on track. Drax, I think you have presented two fundamental problems that you have with gay marriage. Those two are: 1. Homosexual desire is abnormal and should not be treated as if it were normal. 2. Children raised without male and female role models are likely to become problem children. If you've stated any other fundamental problems and I've missed them, please post them as clearly as I have posted those two. In the meantime, let me deal with those two. (By the way, this is a classic "straw man" argument here. I am stating that this is your position and now I'm going to rebut it. If I have inaccurately stated your position then I am now attacking a "straw man" instead of your actual arguments. But I think these are your actual arguments, so I will proceed.) 1. You have not convinced me that homosexual desire is "abnormal." I am QUITE certain that your arguments will not convince anyone who has more skin in this game than I have. In fact if you took a poll today I would bet a substantial number of Americans would disagree with you. A majority? Maybe not. But close. You may think your argument is compelling, but so far I have not been compelled. Since I have not yet conceded the central premise of your argument, then I certainly won't concede the conclusion. 2. You have made an assertion which is not supported by actual empirical evidence. It MAY be true. It may not be true. There is some circumstantial evidence which supports your position, but it is also not compelling. Your position on this is that raising children in a same-sex marriage is fundamentally risky. I would say that raising children in ANY environment is risky. It may be true that raising children in a same sex marriage is MORE risky than in a traditional marriage, but riding a motorcycle is more risky than driving a car, yet we let people do it all the time. Raising children in a trailer park in tornado alley is more risky than raising children in a brick home in calmer climates, and we do that too. The question isn't even "is it riskier" the question is "Who is responsible for that risk?" Telling people they can't marry and have children because there is a higher risk of having problem children seems a bit Orwellian to me, doesn't it to you? Dadman, the way I am reading your point is that there is more to this than just gay marriage. In your mind you seem to view gay marriage as part of a larger agenda to promote non-traditional values and to actively attack the traditional values. I think you're right. In fact I find the tactics of the Left to be reprehensible in this and other areas. There is no doubt that the overriding agenda of the Left is anti-Christian, and could even be called anti-family. But I'm not making a statement here about the full agenda of the Left. I am simply evaluating this ONE issue and formulating an opinion based on nothing but that issue alone. It is certainly worth considering that this is yet another part of a slippery slope that is taking the Christian family into oblivion. That is a much more compelling argument to me than the "they are aberrations!" argument. That gives me pause anyway. But I also don't want to let my position on individual issues be clouded by political movements and agendas. I would rather address the motivations and goals of the Left directly and resolve individual issues on their own merits.
Dadman
The overriding issue in my mind is the Left's relentless quest to LEGALLY RE-DEFINE one of society's most basic institutions and the INEVITABLE consequences, both predictable and unforseen, such changes will have on our way of life. I think one thing (among many) that separates conservative ideology from liberal ideology is the conservative's willingness to define the ideal (in this case the fact - as I see it - that children are better off when raised in traditional nuclear families with a dedicated mother and a father) and then advocating public policy that encourages, supports, and enables the ideal. Liberal ideology seems to argue that all conditions are created equal and equally worthy of acknowledgment and support. I call it the 'Anything Goes' ideology and I think arguments for 'gay marriage' fall into this category. Ironically, some of the most significant people in my life are gay and when I look at them on an individual basis I find myself very sympathetic toward the idea of 'gay marriage'. It's only when I ponder the issue from a macro level, and the likely impact the legal restructuring of marriage will have on religious freedom at some point down the road, that I ultimately decide such a change is not best for society as a whole.
Drax
If a minority of 3% doesn't establish a deviation from the norm, or "abnormal," I really don't know what percentage will. If a scientist can't admit that a person who is born with the biological urge to mate with a member of the human race with whom he cannot reproduce is "abnormal" in regards to this biological urge, I don't know what he'll admit to. If all it takes for someone to consider a biological "oddity" to be "normal" is its very existence, I don't know what if there is anything which that person would consider to be "abnormal." I consider a very small minority of humans who are born with a biological urge to only have sex (the reproductive act) with people with whom they cannot reproduce to be "abnormal" in that biological sense. You apparently consider any deviation from the norm to be "normal" simply because the deviation itself exists -- giving new meaning to the words "normal," "abnormal," and "deviation" all of which have no meaning without both the normal majority and the deviating minority, i.e., if everyone were heterosexual, that wouldn't be "the norm," it would be uniformity. It is only when someone deviates from the uniformity that the majority becomes "the norm" and the deviation becomes "abnormal." I can't get past that wall of straw men you have constructed. Straw men: You take the part of my argument "to engage in the reproductive act with members of the human race with whom it's impossible to reproduce" and speak of masturbation, vascetomies, and whatnot and offer that as refutation of my whole argument, i.e., it is "being born with the drive to engage in the reproductive act with members of the human race with whom it's impossible to reproduce." Without being born with this drive, one isn't a homosexual. Being so born with this drive it doesn't matter if you never act on it. It doesn't matter if you sleep with members of the opposite sex. What matters is being born with that drive. You presented part of my definition of "abnormal" (in regards to this particular biological urge) -- a position I did not take --then proceeded to attack it. Thus "straw man." In a debate about same-sex marriage, you bring up left-handedness and the color of eyes in rebuttal to my argument that being born with the drive to have sex with members of the same sex is "abnormal" demanding that I equate the abnormality of being left-handed to the the abnormality of being born homosexual. While ALL deviations from the norm are "abnormal," THIS discussion is about same-sex marriage. This is an attempt to redefine "abnormal" -- to minimize it by equating the color of one's eyes to one's sexual orientation -- an argument I did not propose -- then refute it, thus "straw man." As to your notion that I have altered my argument -- rest assured that I haven't. I think that being born with the desire to engage in the reproductive act with members of the human race with whom you can't reproduce is "abnormal." I think that I've said it often enough that it simply amazes me that you even intimate that I may have changed my position -- or have altered it so to more agree with YOUR position. Let's take your summary of "my position." You summarize as follows: 1. Homosexual desire is abnormal and should not be treated as if it were normal. 2. Children raised without male and female role models are likely to become problem children. As to the first, I stated homosexuality was abnormal. I don't care how it's treated. This argument is about SAME SEX MARRIAGE. As to the second, studies have established quite convincingly that children raised by a single parent generally fare much less well than children raised by two parents of the opposite sex. My argument...stated several times...is that it is not a good idea to experiment with same-sex marriage and the inevitable result of it, i.e., households with homosexuals, people of the same sex, raising children. As to your notion of "polling" to determine whether or not the biological abnormality of homosexuality...that's laughable. Apparently, you think that societal notions of acceptable behavior trumps a determination of whether a biological deviation is "abnormal" or not. (Make sure that you poll the Muslim community throughout the world as well as the Christian communities not polluted by Western thinking. The "scientific results" of the poll wouldn't be valid without a valid sample now, would it?) Let's poll as to the reality of global warming next. How about we turn over all scientific questions to the population at large to settle the question. That sounds like a good idea. Nah. I'm comfortable concluding that a 3% minority possessing a biological urge to copulate with members of the human race with whom they can't reproduce is an "abnormal" biological urge. Since it's a biological question, why not, instead, settle it in a biological fashion? Since the purpose of the urge is to procreate (unless you're going to argue THAT -- and I suspect that you will), let's just put some couples on some islands and find out which of those couples are able to have the intended biological effect. Separate the gays on one island, the lesbians on another, and the heterosexuals on the last. Come back in a couple of years and see which have produced offspring. Let's call those who, when they engage in the reproductive act with the members of the human race they're driven to copulate with, produce offspring "normal." The others, if their biological urge is incapable of producing the intended biological results...let's call them "abnormal." Or, we can just accept that when there is a very small percentage of people who deviate from the biological norm -- that they are "abnormal." So, you're right. You can't convince me that it's "normal" to be born with a biological urge to copulate with members of the human race with whom you can't reproduce. I can't convince you that it's abnormal. Impasse. As to the "experiment" thing. More straw men. Motorcycles? Trailer Parks? Comparing these risks to the potential of a complete reformation of the fundaments of civilization, i.e., the family unit? You're kidding, right? No...you're not. You think that it's a valid argument...to compare allowing people to risk their lives by riding motorcycles and living in trailer parks to the potential of completely reshaping the family unit, sexual mores, and the roles of men and women in society along with the minor side-effect of the state's rejection of a foundational element of every major religion. Yah. I guess we're at an impasse here.
Drax
Dadman: There are many inevitable outgrowths to normalizing same-sex marriage including, of course, the attack on traditional religious beliefs. 1) Will clerics who apply for state's licenses to perform state-sanctioned marriage be required to perform same-sex marriages? Certainly, as you say, lawsuits will be filed with appropriately sympathetic judges. 2) Will foster homes of same-sex married couples be given children who are opposed to same-sex marriages on religous grounds? 3) Since homosexuality itself has already been "normalized," i.e., "accepted" by the majority of americans regardless of their religious beliefs, same-sex marriages with children continues and accellerates this acceptance so that we (like the ancient Greeks to some degree) become a society OF "homosexuals." (Just look around to see just how far we have ALREADY gone in "accepting the unacceptable.") 4) Will home owners who oppose same-sex marriage be able to deny renting to same-sex married couples when, today, they can refuse to rent to non-married adults living together if they so choose. 5) Since homosexual relationships are significantly shorter and the partners significantly less faithful and their children will be raised in this atmosphere, even less value will be given to both invaluable elements of the family unit. The ways that same-sex marriage will impact society are incalculable. ----------------------- As an avid science fiction reader from my earliest years, these "problems" have been on my mind for decades. I don't KNOW whether or not an utter reformation of what is a family, how we define or sexual mores, who and how long we take life partners ... is a bad thing. I DO know, however, that it will re-shape our society in completely unpredictable ways. My objection to same-sex marriage is NOT as CC implies, a cry of "abberration." It's a "bit" more sophisticated than that. Based on his replies to my posts, however, it is clear that "abberration" is how he interprets my arguments. -------------------------
Drax
A precursor of things to come: http://www.latimes.com/news/opinion/commentary/la-oe-wilson3-2009may03,0,248550.story
Dadman
Good find, Drax. The article hits on many of the religious conscience issues that concern me. However, at some point 'gay marriage' will become federally protected/sanctioned, a development that could jeopardize any religious protection clauses states manage to build into their 'gay marriage' laws. But you're the lawyer not me...
Drax
Dadman: The equal protection clause allows for discrimination when there's a "compelling state's interest." How that is defined is based on the make-up of the Court. Ask me in 8 years how these questions will be answered...
CosmicConservative
Drax: ALL of my argument is predicated from the notion that "marriage" be used to describe the RELIGIOUS ritual, and "cohabitation" be used to describe the LEGAL contract. Thus in my view "same sex marriage" would not be the result of my approach, but "same sex cohabitation" would be. In MY solution no religion would be forced to do ANYTHING that was against their religious beliefs because the state would have no NEED to do so since the LEGAL purpose would be solved by defining BOTH heterosexual and homosexual unions as "cohabitation" and not "marriage." You made a statement. I made a logical extrapolation of that statement. Your statement was "it is abnormal for a person to have sexual desire for someone with whom they cannot procreate". To point out that LOGICALLY means it is abnormal to have sex with a condom is not a "straw man" Drax. It is an EXTRAPOLATION of your argument. If you want to REDEFINE your statement so that it does not LOGICALLY apply to sex with a condom then FINE, but your first (and subsequent) statements DID NOT. So to use that extrapolation to rebut your argument is not only rational and logical, but it is a "reductio ad absurdum" argument, not a "straw man". Such an argument refutes an assertion by taking it to a logical extreme to demonstrate the contradictions it creates. Heh, now we're arguing about how we're arguing. :) As I said, you and I simply do not agree on what the word "abnormal" means. You are using what I consider to be a casual definition meaning "not normal." Well, OK, then what does "normal" mean? Here are two definitions: 1. Conforming with, adhering to, or constituting a norm, standard, pattern, level, or type; typical. 2. Biology: Functioning or occurring in a natural way; lacking observable abnormalities or deficiencies. You are using definition 1. I am using definition 2. I am using definition 2 because definition 2 is the SCIENTIFIC one, not the casual one. It is my contention that homosexuality fits the second definition. The FIRST definition is useless in my opinion because it defines "normal" according to CURRENT CONVENTION, which changes over time. We will never be able to have a reasonable debate so long as we are using different definitions of the word. That's why I wanted to go straight to your core contentions. Let me ask you a few questions.... Do you think your body "knows" that sex leads to reproduction? Your brain knows, for sure, but does your body know that? Does the body of a dog know that? If so, how does the body know that? Because if the body DOESN'T "know" that sex leads to reproduction, how can it possibly "know" that sex with the same sex does NOT lead to reproduction? Sexual desire is aligned with the reproductive act for complex evolutionary reasons (or because God made it that way) not because the body is pursuing reproduction. Sexual desire results in reproduction for those reasons alone. From an evolutionary perspective sexual desire leads to reproduction because some long ago mutation began that process and it proved to be very effective in driving individuals to have sex, and therefore those individual out competed individuals who had no sexual desire. From a theological perspective, God made it that way because that's the way God wanted it to be. But sexual desire in and of itself is NOT ABOUT REPRODUCTION. It is about stimulating the proper nerve cells in the brain in the right way to reinforce a certain behavior. It could be argued that in homosexuals this alignment between sexual desire and reproductive results has been broken or redirected. In fact I've seen exactly that sort of argument made by researchers. It can also be argued that such a break in the connection is a desirable population control mechanism, much like frogs spontaneously change sex when they overpopulate their environment. That argument maintains that homosexuality is a NATURAL CONTROL MECHANISM to combat overpopulation. If the second explanation is correct, then there is nothing abnormal about homosexuality. If the first explanation is correct, then homosexuality is abnormal. Regardless, our technology has made much of this argument moot since we have ourselves short-circuited the reproductive process in many ways. As separate as sexual desire and reproduction were originally, today the relationship is far less certain and every year it becomes even less so. Eventually sexual desire and reproduction will be TOTALLY SEPARATE THINGS. In fact in my opinion we're almost there already. For that reason I consider it to be almost a biological curiosity that the two are so closely related. It may have once been critical to humanity's future for sexual desire to drive reproduction, but that is simply no longer the case. Of course if the theological argument is correct, then I'm not only wrong, I'm probably going to hell, but that's a whole 'nother discussion. But if the evolutionary argument is correct then I simply don't care a whole lot if sexual drive is not always aligned with procreation. And since homosexuality has been so prevalent throughout human history, I am quite content to call it "natural" behavior and therefore biologically "normal." Whether it is CULTURALLY "normal" or not is not something I care a whole lot about, especially since I consider this debate to be one of the many contentious debates that technology will render historical curiosities in the next hundred years.
Dadman
Sexual desire aligned with procreation a biological curiosity? I think you are too far down that singularity path. Technology may make many things possible over the next few decades, but I don't believe it is going to change human nature. Sex and procreation, in my humble opinion, will never be a 'biological curiosity', but if you are correct and I am wrong I'll be pleased to be taking a dirt nap when that day arrives. BTW, I tend to agree with Drax in this argument. Homosexuality may be common and persistent throughout recorded history, but as a behavior I think it is fair to say it is 'deviant' by definition...
Drax
If you can't distinguish the fundamental difference between a person who is born with the desire to copulate with a person with whom he can't reproduce and a heterosexual who uses a condom...I can't explain it clearly or often enough to make you understand that it is a "straw man." While you now seem to want to divide the debate about "same-sex marriage" into some convoluted religous/state divide, that simply isn't the debate. It never was the debate. It never will be the debate. The debate is whether to allow members of the same sex to become married, state sanctioned marriage -- since state sanctioned marriage is the only one which receives legal recognition. -- Your "scientfific" definition: "lacking observable abnormalities or deficiencies." Somehow I see a biological drive to copulate with members of the race with whom you can't reproduce as a "biological abnormality or deficiency." (Crappy definition, by the way as it uses the term "abnormal" which requires the definition of "normal" to be understood as an essential part of the defined term.) -- Responding to your questions: Fundamentally, from a biological perspective, we have only one function -- to reproduce. Period. Once we have have reached the age where we can do this, we begin to die. Biology no longer has a use for us. We have no control (or little control) over the urge that our biology forces upon us...it just exists and compels us to attempt to reproduce. We are no different from the lowest animal in this regard. So, no. Our "bodies" don't know that sex leads to reproduction. But NOT being animals, our minds do. Our MINDS allow us the enjoyment of sex without the potential of inconvenient reproduction. But, our "bodies" are unaware, being...you know ... "bodies" and not "minds." Our bodies compel us to engage in reproductive activity. (Our MINDS can overule or not...) Certain stimuli causes certain response. We act on that and the human race goes on. We have no more conscious control over what stimuli causes certain responses than we do over any other of our primal urges. Our MINDS can control our RESPONSE to that stimuli, but our BODIES dictate that which we respond to. A homosexual can no more control the fact that he becomes aroused by members of the same sex than a heterosexual can control the fact the he becomes aroused by members of the opposite sex. All either can do is use their MINDS to determine how they respond to that stimuli. Unless, of course, you're arguing that one can WILL one's self to become aroused by stimuli which one ordinarily finds repugnant. Your babble about "complex evolutionary reasons" and "mutations" resulting in behavior which was "effective in driving people to have sex" is just another way of saying what I've said...i.e., "biology is determinative." And, just for the record, to the extent that your notion here has any validity, its validity extends solely to those "complex evolutionary reasons" causing "mutations" which were "effective in driving people to have..." HETEROSEXUAL sex as such a convoluted evolutionary process which led to HOMOSEXUAL sex would have been an evolutionary dead-end. As I noted earlier. I do get a kick out of this: "But sexual desire in and of itself is NOT ABOUT REPRODUCTION. It is about stimulating the proper nerve cells in the brain in the right way to reinforce a certain behavior." Did you not READ WHAT YOU WROTE just above that? The REASON for those "complex evolutionary...mutations" was to PROMOTE REPRODUCTION, and the reason the human race continues to exist is that those "mutations" were EFFECTIVE in doing so. All organisms must reproduce to survive. (This would SEEM self-evident.) Since you're invoking "evolution" then humans (who didn't BEGIN as humans) had many millenia to perfect the biological "mutations" which promoted that which promoted their survival...and that REQUIRED biological imperatives which result in REPRODUCTION. Then this: "It could be argued that in homosexuals this alignment between sexual desire and reproductive results has been broken or redirected. In fact I’ve seen exactly that sort of argument made by researchers." How, exactly, is this different from "homosexuality is abnormal?" The NATURAL alignment is broken or redirected...thus the resulting alignment is UNNATURAL...or...abnormal. You follow with this yet further attenuated postulate: "It can also be argued that such a break in the connection is a desirable population control mechanism, much like frogs spontaneously change sex when they overpopulate their environment. That argument maintains that homosexuality is a NATURAL CONTROL MECHANISM to combat overpopulation." Nice thought. Of course, it seems a bit lacking in the proof department. IF this were the case, we would likely see larger numbers of homosexuality (if "evolution" is happening before our eyes, that is...) in the most populated areas, or in the areas where the population outstrips resources. And, of course, it doesn't explain the relatively constant percentage of homosexuals throughout history even in times of no over-population. (And, lest we forget...War has been touted as a "Control Mechanism" for overpopulation as well. As has AIDS. As has crime. And many other utterly unproven "control mechanisms.") And, I guess, since from a biological perspective, pedophilia serves the same function as does homosexuality, it, too, is a "control mechanism." ---------------------------- I agree that soon this argument may be rendered moot by technology. However, it is not moot NOW. While we may soon be ABLE to transform ourselves back and forth between male and female forms ... that doesn't mean that it's a GOOD IDEA. How our society looks in the future is highly dependent on the decisions we make NOW. ----------------------------- And, finally. Finally. Finally. Just because a biological condition EXISTS doesn't make it "normal." It is just one which has survived. Accepting THIS biological abnormality as "normal" because it's been so "prevalent throughout human history" (It hasn't. There are POCKETS of acceptance of homosexuality throughout history. The vast, vast, vast majority of civilizations have repudiated homosexuality as has every major religion for thousands of years. The percentage of homosexuals has been relatively even over the centuries, i.e. 3-6%) -- accepting THIS due to its VERY EXISTENCE forces you to accept other abnormal sexual drives since, other than the object of the sexual desire, they are identical.
CosmicConservative
Heh, I guess we're going to have to leave this where it is, none of us is making much headway with the other, although I do try to rebut Drax's arguments without quite as much provocative rhetoric as he uses. ;) I will make one final point, with absolutely no hope that Drax or Dadman will accept it. This is something I've argued with both sides of the evolutionary debate. It's a fundamental misconception about evolution and how it works. When Drax says "The REASON for those “complex evolutionary…mutations” was to PROMOTE REPRODUCTION" he demonstrates what I believe to be the most common and most subtle misunderstanding of evolution that there is. And it is a profoundly important misunderstanding. There is no "reason" in evolution. None. The mutation which led to sexual desire had NO REASON behind it. It JUST HAPPENED. That's how evolution works in the accepted scientific definition of evolution. Similarly the fact that sexual desire PROMOTES REPRODUCTION is PURE CHANCE. The only reason it is prevalent today is because it was a mutation which out competed its peers. Certain nerve stimulation reinforces certain behaviors. Some of those mutations provide a competitive advantage and are carried forward in the species. Some provide no advantage nor detriment and are carried forward or not based on pure random chance. Some provide a detriment and are quickly weeded out. If homosexuality were truly a detrimental behavior, natural selection would have weeded it out a long time ago. At worst it is a behavior that provides no advantage and no detriment and so is carried forward much as eye color is carried forward when it provides no advantage or detriment. And that's a key reason I don't consider it "deviant" nor "abnormal". It is merely irrelevant behavior. One final point. My original post was NOT intended to reproduce the "current debate" on same sex marriage. I very clearly stated that I was exploring MY OWN OPINION on the subject. And the very first thing I said is that MY APPROACH is to split the religious and legal definitions of the word "marriage." So THIS debate, as framed by my original post, is NOT what Drax has described. He may have done his level best to MAKE it that debate, but I have not followed suit. Anyway, I think we've kicked this dead horse enough. I do appreciate the discussion but I am sad to say that my original intent was to see if this discussion would bring in new posters, and it has done no such thing. So in that sense it was a failed experiment. But I did enjoy it anyway.
CosmicConservative
Drax: I just have to clear this up since you keep going back to it. I can absolutely distinguish between homosexual sex and sex with a condom. The problem here is that YOUR ORIGINAL ARGUMENT DID NOT. I simply pointed that out in order to show your original argument was logically deficient.
Dadman
I am well aware that evolution, as science presently describes it, is based purely on randomness and chance. Evolution is not purposeful. Homosexuality may not be detrimental to a species (at its current levels of expression), but that is a different question than is legally sanctioned 'gay marriage' good for a human society. I think not... BTW, I agree that secular and religious unions or marriages should be split out from each other. The state could then sanction gay unions without impeding expressions of religious liberty with respect to marriage.
Drax
CC: My "original argument," as it related to abnormality is as follows: "[I]t is the drive to engage in the reproductive act with people with whom you cannot reproduce ... and ... were born that way..." (emphasis added) My original argument hasn't changed. You read into that argument something which was not there (a moral judgment) and ignored something which was (that they be born that way). You then began a comparison of that (implied) definition to masturbation, further compounding the error by ignoring the requirement that the (ignored) drive be directed towards having sex with someone... And, the thread continued in this manner. No matter how many times I stated it, you continued to ignore the two fundamental requirements I listed over and over...that they are born that way and that what they were born with was a drive to engage in the reproductive act with persons with whom they could not reproduce. Without being "born that way," homosexuality is learned behavior. The "drive" exists regardless of whether it is acted upon or how it is acted upon...because they're born with it...can't escape it....can't cure it...any more than a heterosexual can cure HIS (or a pedophile his). It's how they are born. So...again... The drive is unchanged (for homosexuals, heterosexuals, pedophiles) when each masturbate. It doesn't change if they get a vascetomy or wear a condom or take the pill. It doesn't change if they refrain from acting on the urge completely. It is the DRIVE (the one with which they are BORN) which defines the sexual orientation. -------------------- (Frankly...if I hadn't had to say the same things over and over and over...and have fundamental parts (bolded -- highlighted) of my arguments ignored or misrepresented, maybe my rhetoric wouldn't have been so provocative.) ---------------------- Evolution: Uh. I think I know the basic 5th grade notions of what is commonly promoted as "evolution." I used the word "reason" in a non-scientific sense, rather a backwards looking sense. We must reproduce in order for the species to survive. Therefore (assuming the validity of "evolution") evolution required a mechanism to promote that -- and did. Once created, the REASON it existed is self-evident. (As in....we need oxygen...we have lungs...the REASON we have lungs is because we need oxygen...) I didn't use "reason" in any "directed/intelligent" sense, more in a cause/effect, backwards looking sense. Your assertion that homosexuality, if truly detrimental, would have been "weeded out by now" via evolution is interesting. What other species has, once they've reached viability and has lasted many thousands of years, undergone "reverse engineering" and had evolution "clean up on previous errors?" I'm not aware of any. (And, isn't it simply AMAZING how "random evolution" seems to cease its randomness once an organizism has reached viability? We need "a" digestive tract...so we get one. Then...what? It couldn't be better? It couldn't be worse? Why the ceasing of randomness? Why two legs when 4 are better? Why don't we have better hearing or eyesight? One heart? Lungs but not gills? Evolution sure seems to cease being so danged RANDOM after the requirements for viability have been met.... And where is the historical record of all the RANDOM genetic failures? Since viability would seem to be HUGELY against the odds since we could as easily have grown a tail from our forehead as an eye -- it being all "random" and such -- so where is the historical record of the FAILURES? The FAILURES would seem to outnumber the successess by a HUGE MARGIN, it being all "random" and all...So where are the Mammoths which grew wings? Where are all the Dinosaurs which developed gills when they needed lungs? What? You mean that it's only "random" UNTIL viability? Gee...how does evolution "know" that further tinkering isn't required...? And, since it's all "random" and all...even the "successes" would seem to require further evolution, after all evolution would seem to favor a deer with fangs and claws over a deer without them...seems that evolution just stopped short of that. And Lions who could graze would seem a better end-product than one confined to meat. But...it seems that evolution just .... randomly .... stopped. Ah well...that's another discussion.)
CosmicConservative
Drax: I think you and I have presented our arguments as well as we're going to, so I leave it now up to the reader to decide which direction they personally want to go. As I said a few comments ago, I don't really have anything more to add to this debate, I think I've made my case as well as I'm going to. Your discussion about evolutionary randomness is interesting, but probably deserves a whole new thread. I'll make a quick stab at answering your questions about evolutionary processes though, even though I suspect your comments are more rhetorical than actually seeking explanation. Evolution as it is currently scientificially stated is completely non-directed. This is true even though biologists and paleontologists frequently speak and act as if this were not the case. I constantly see biologists discussing a biological attribute in ways that are completely at odds with true evolutionary theory. That's because it is very, very hard for human brains to contemplate true non-directed, pattern-less processes. Our brains are hard-wired to find patterns, and so patterns are found even where none exist. You ask "What other species has, once they’ve reached viability and has lasted many thousands of years, undergone 'reverse engineering' and had evolution 'clean up on previous errors?' " The whole concept of "viability" is the point here. Once a species is viable, there are few mutations which are beneficial, and those that do occur typically simply replace the previous model. An example of evolution "cleaning up a previous error" that is frequently cited in medical literature is the human appendix. (In other words, the human digestive system has in fact changed over time.) Another example is the horse's hoof. The evolutionary record shows that horses originally had multiple "toes" but that one toe became a dominant hoof. Once the other toes became redundant, subsequent fossil finds show a steady reduction in size of the other toes until they disappear completely from an external view and remain only as vestigal bones in the skeleton. Whale evolution is still in the process of "cleaning up" the leftover leg bones that are no longer used. In fact such "evolutionary house cleaning" is common according to the fossil record. Your question though also contains another subtle evolutionary concept which is frequently misunderstood. You ask why digestive systems don't "get better". Evolution isn't about "getting better." Evolution is about "randomly changing." If a random change does not prove detrimental, it MAY continue or it may disappear. If it proves detrimental, it is usually catastrophically so and the embryo spontaneously aborts. If it proves BENEFICIAL (an exceedingly rare result) then the resulting organism MAY pass that change on to more successful offspring until that mutation becomes the defacto "norm" in the species gene pool. There are examples of mutations which are "detrimental" yet which do not adversely affect viability and as such are propogated through the species. The best example of this are flightless birds. In an environment where birds have little threat from predators, wings become something of a liability because flying is a very high energy cost form of locomotion. If a bird species finds itself in an environment where flight is not necessary, a mutation which reduces the size of the wings is actually beneficial because wing muscle is high-energy tissue that requires more feeding to maintain. Losing flight ability saves energy and gives a slight edge in survivablity. That edge can (and has) result in an entire species losing the ability to fly. In fact there is a family of birds that is quite famous for it's rapid tendency to lose flight ability as soon as it finds an environment where flight is not required. The failures in evolution do vastly outnumber the successes. As I said above the vast majority of these failures are non-viable and are aborted as embryos. Those that survive birth with a "failed" mutation tend not to survive long enough to pass it on. Since our fossil record might contain a hundred examples of a species which numbered in the billions, it is highly unlikely that we would find the lone example of a mammoth born with wings, which did not survive to reproduce because the wings required so much additional caloric intake that the mammoth starved to death at eight months. Why don't we see deer with fangs and claws? There are a lot of reasons for that. The main reason has to do with how evolution is an incremental process. Arthropods are a great example of this. "Arthropod" means "jointed leg." Arthropods include crustaceans, insects, and arachnids. Arthropod evolution is distinguished by a steady specialization of "legs" to the point that arthropod mandibles are actually just legs that are reused to "chew" and swallow their food. The reason for this is because their genetic "toolbox" is heavily "jointed leg" specific. So mutations tend to affect the development and utilization of jointed legs. Claws and fangs are a similar specialization within the mammalian line. Teeth which are suitable for turning into fangs are the result of a long series of specific mutations which produced fangs. The same is true of claws. Deer teeth and hooves have a vastly different evolutionary history. For a deer to grow fangs would require a series of complementary mutations all of which would allow teeth normally utilized for chopping and crushing vegetable matter into teeth suitable for rending and tearing flesh. There is a great debate raging in evolutionary circles about the possiblity of these "grand" mutations as opposed to mutations being of necessity slow and gradual over time. The general "dogma" of evolution is that deer can't grow fangs because they would require thousands of individual mutations to produce all of the genetic and biological infrastructure necessary to grow fangs and claws, and the time required to do that would be so long that OTHER mutations would occur such that by the time a deer mutated to grow fangs, it would have gone through several intermediate species and the end result would most likely be an animal that much more resembled a modern wolf than any sort of deer with fangs and claws. Evolution of deer has not stopped. Lions of today cannot graze not only because they lack grazing teeth, but they lack all of the other infrastructure necessary to process pulped vegetable matter into usable energy. Giving a deer claws and fangs would not allow a deer to survive by eating meat. Giving a lion chopping, chewing teeth would not allow a lion to graze. The biological changes necessary for these mutations to exist are profound and would permeat the muscular, digestive and excretory systems. Since it is highly unlikely that a deer genome will spontaneously produce ten thousand simultaneous meat-eating supporting mutations, we don't see deer with fangs and claws, nor do we see lions which graze. That is not to say that a billion years from now the dominant predator might now have been spawned from a long, successive line of mutations starting from a modern deer. That is possible, but it will take a lot of time and a lot of changes to get there. I hope this is somewhat understandable.
Drax
I understand everything you said. I just don't think that it is comprehensible. As I comprehend it, a horse didn't begin as a horse. It began as a single-cell organism which "evolved" into a horse over many millenia. However, in order for the single-cell organism to survive to "evolve" IT must have been "viable," i.e., it must be able to survive and thrive both internally and externally -- it must be able to LIVE (do that which is required for survival "breathe, eat, reproduce, etc.) and must be able to SURVIVE (fight off, hide from, escape from predators) and it must do so in sufficient numbers so that the species doesn't "dead-end" due to insufficient biological material to sustain the species. So...it is "viable" in the earliest stages of "evolution" -- just as the current "horse" is viable now. Yet the single-celled organism CONTINUED to "evolve." It became something else...a "something" which was ALSO "viable" else it wouldn't have survived to become the "something else" it next became in order to evolve and evolve and evolve and evolve until it became a "horse." At each step along this evolutionary chain, the stages of "horse" were EACH "viable," else they wouldn't have survived to "evolve" to the NEXT rung on the ladder. Yet, the "horse" stopped "evolving." Surely there are MORE evolutionary changes in the "horse" which would be beneficial from the HORSE'S viewpoint. And, since the "evolutionary changes" are "random" why didn't one of the early stages of the horse's "evolution" result in a change which was DETRIMENTAL to the survival of the "horse" and wipe them out? So, when I speak of "where are the bodies" of the evolutional FAILURES -- I speak of this "horse" and the millions of OTHER species which reached a point of viability beneath that which they currently exist (but "viable" nonetheless) and make a "random wrong turn?" It would seem that, since evolution is "random" the historical, fossil record would be LITTERED with the remains of MILLIONS of species which had reached "viability" but an evolutionary wrong turn resulted in wholesale extinction. (Remember, any species must be of sufficient number to survive to remain "viable." This also implies that whatever CHANGE in the species must be of sufficient number to pass its genetic material down in sufficient number so that the CHANGE takes hold in sufficient numbers of the species so that the SPECIES changes...not just those originally affected by evolution's "randomness.") And, remember. The species was ALREADY "viable." So, any "change" must either be beneficial or neutral else it would lessen "viability." So, we see the changes in the species over the millenia -- BENEFICIAL changes which...for some reason....just STOP. (Your examples of the appendix, the hooves and the flippers, frankly, smack more of Lamark's theory of "use it or lose it" than of evolutionary theory...) Those changes just STOP even though there are unquestionably MORE changes which could be beneficial (and certainly many changes which, through "randomness" could be detrimental). So...why does the horse not evolve into something better? Why did it evolve into a horse when, at every step along the evolutionary chain, the form it HAD was "viable?" Why didn't evolution "stop" THERE (at ONE of the thousands/millions of quantum leaps along the evolutionary ladder) rather than HERE? Just call me "unconvinced" that science has fully explained "evolution."
CosmicConservative
Drax: I'm not sure where you have gotten the concept that horses are no longer evolving. Of course they are. So are humans. Evolution doesn't "stop" when an organism becomes viable. Mutations occur randomly all the time. I'm not suggesting that science has "fully explained" anything. But science has explained the specific questions you are asking. At least in theory. I had a huge comment put together detailing the history of life on earth as evolutionary theory explains it, but it got so huge and sounded so much like a biology lecture that I abandoned it. The shorter answer to your question about viability is that viability is always temporary. Evolution is a constant process, organisms are mutating at a steady rate. Even though the vast majority of mutations are detrimental, when there IS a beneficial one, the results are dramatic. There are two main reasons that a species goes extinct. The first and most dramatic reason is when the environment changes and the species is no longer viable. This can happen for a lot of reasons. An asteroid might hit the earth, hiding the sun and starving millions of species to extinction. A mutated virus may introduce a devastating new disease that wipes out an entire species. A plant that provides a particular enzyme or nutrient might go extinct because the animals grazing on it simply eat it into extinction. Etc... Environmental changes are frequent and dramatic and account for most of the species extinctions we see in the fossil record. The second most common reason for a species to go extinct is that a new species out-competes it. That new species could be the result of a mutation of the extinct species itself, or it could be the result of a mutation of another species which suddenly is in competition with the old species for the same resources. Here's an example of how that works. Let's say that we have an ecosystem with a variety of edible plants, a grazing herd animal and a dominant predator. This ecosystem is entirely self-sufficient, meaning that the plants aren't consumed to extinction because the predators keep the herd animals in check, and the herd animals when healthy can run fast enough to get away from the predators. Let's say that the climate is mild and wet, with the ground being soft. The herd animals have three toes, and the spread of those toes makes it easier to run across the soft ground. A completely self-sustaining, balanced ecosystem. But evolution does not stop. One day one of the herd animals is born with a recessive gene which causes the two outside toes to not grow fully, leaving the single remaining toe as the sole ground-contacting element. Because it is a recessive gene, it does not manifest in that first animal. He or she simply carries the gene. Let's say that particular animal is a successful one, and that it has twenty offspring. On average that meanst ten of its children will have that gene. Still, it is recessive, so it doesn't manifest. After a couple of generatations, that gene might be present in 5% of the population. By then there will be matings which cause a recessive-recessive combination, meaning the one-toed result will be expressed. That means baby herd beasts with one toe will be born. But since the ground is marshy, that turns out to be a poor adaptation and the animals with that adaptation get bogged down easier in the soft ground. So they get eaten. But it's a recessive trait, so only those with the gene from both parents suffer this fate. The gene stays in the gene pool, and the result is that every now and then a one-toed herd animal is born, but only a few reach adulthood and breeding age. Now the climate starts to change. It gets drier. Soon the ground is not quite so marshy and the single-toed foot is no longer as detrimental to the running speed of the herd animal. But it's not an advantage either, so soon the trait is expressed in large numbers in the herd, which now contains both three-toed and one-toed animals. But the climate continues to dry and eventually the ground becomes hard-packed soil, and the single-toe approach turns out to be more efficient, allowing those with one toe to run faster and make sharp turns better than the three-toed variety. Now the one-toed animal is actually faster and more able to escape the predators than the three toed variety. Now, imagine that the predator is also evolving. And one day, while the herds are a relatively equal mix of one and three toed grazers, a predator is born with an adaptation that makes it faster than its cousins. Fast enough that it can easily catch the three-toed grazers, but not fast enough to easily catch the one-toed grazers. This is a serious advantage for the predators, so soon ALL predators are the faster variety, and they are feasting on the slower grazers. Now remember, the three-toe gene is the dominat gene. That means every grazer with the gene will be born with three toes and be slower than the one-toed grazers. The one-toed grazers have no three-toed gene. And the predators are killing the three-toed grazers at a terrific pace. Eventually all of the three-toed grazers will be gone, leaving only the one-toed grazer. The gene for three toes will be gone entirely since it was a dominant gene, so there will be no resurrection of the three-toed variety, a new mutation would have to recreate a three-toed grazer. That's how evolution works.
CosmicConservative
By the way, it is interesting that you would pick the horse as an example becuase the fossil record of the horse is littered with species which became non-viable as faster and stronger versions of the horse became the dominant species. In fact the horse is a classic example of how evolution not only produces new forms, but weeds out obsolete forms at the same time.
Drax
See....this is what gets me: "I’m not sure where you have gotten the concept that horses are no longer evolving. Of course they are. So are humans. Evolution doesn’t “stop” when an organism becomes viable. Mutations occur randomly all the time." Where are they? Mutations being "random," one would think that in the thousands upon thousands of years we would have a fossil RECORD of these mutations -- MANY of which would be benign and, thus, widespread (since being "benign" there is no reason for the "mutation" NOT to spread. Where ARE all these "benign" mutations? Why don't we have more useless organs...tails...fur... sonar...infrared vision...etc. etc. etc.?) And, where ARE these "randomly created" TRANSITION species? (Since the mutations don't create a "wing" but the beginnings of a structure which, when DONE, i.e., a "completed structure", becomes a "wing" but, until THEN is utterly useless -- if not detrimental -- where are the TRANSITION species?) Further...IF the argument is that "evolution is occurring all the time" (or "mutations constantly happen") then where are THEY? I know...I know...it takes TIME. But, DOES IT? TIME would seem to be immaterial when looking for "random mutations." What would SEEM material is QUANTITY. "Time" SUBSTITUTES for "Quantity" because it took a lot of TIME for there to be sufficient "random mutations" that change might take place. But, there are CURRENTLY more people living than have EVER LIVED. (And, I'm certain that there are more people born EVERY YEAR than ever there existed the number of Neanderthal Man or any of the other off-shoots of our "common ancestor" (which we can't seem to find....)) Billions upon billions upon billions of opportunities to "randomly evolve" with beneficial effect...many MULTIPLES of the number of ANY of our "ancestors" who seem to have no problem "randomly evolving" into homo sapiens sapiens. But us? Nada. I just can't wrap my mind around it as I comprehend the current state of human evolution. Something's missing. (And, if anyone pipes in with stressors provided by the environment...then the evolution isn't "random" but a RESPONSE to STIMULI as the organism attempts to ADAPT to or SURVIVE the threatening environment. That ain't "random.")
CosmicConservative
Drax: Mutations are assumed to be random in Evolutionary theory. They happen all the time. Most are detrimental. Some are benign. Some are beneficial. Most that turn out to be "beneficial" in the long run are not actually beneficial at the time of the mutation. That's one thing I was trying to demonstrate in the example above. A mutation that is benign, or even detrimental, can BECOME beneficial if the environment changes. Mutations have been observed in bacteria and viruses. In fact the Swine Flu is a mutated influenza virus. Epidemiologists know precisely where that mutation occurred. Mutations and speciation in single celled and viral organisms has been observed and documented for decades. Mutations in highly complex differentiated organisms like deer and humans is much harder to spot. There are some examples of such mutations in less complex organisms such as amphibians, worms and insects. I mentioned in a previous post that there is a raging debate in evolutionary circles on the concept of "macro" vs. "micro" mutations. The "macro" camp says that mutations in highly complex organisms (like deer) can occur in dramatic observable ways. The "micro" camp says that such events are so unlikely that they can be considered to be non-existent for all intents and purposes. The one paper I read on this subject looked at a species of mussel, which is still far less complex than a deer, but is orders of magnitude more complex than a bacterium. The paper looked at two species of mussel which appeared at first glance to be dramatically different in morphology and behavior. One was a bottom-dwelling mussel. The other was actually a free-swimming mussel. The internal structure of the two was dramatically different, with one having a large swim bladder which was filled with air to provide buoyancy, which allowed the mussel to "swim". However, analysis of their DNA revealed that they were nearly identical. The "macro" proponents explain this in the following way. The "swim bladder" in the free swimming mussel is actually an enlarged organ that exists in the bottom dwelling mussel, but which is tiny and has no significant function. The difference in the morphology of the two mussels can be completely explained by a mutation which enlarged the swim bladder and filled it with air, forcing the other organs to move around to accomodate the enlarged swim bladder. So all it took for this mussel to become a new species, with dramatically different morphology and behavior, was a single mutation which caused this otherwise nondescript organ to enlarge and fill with air. Macro evolotionists have some dramatic support in medical cases of humans born with fully formed structures which are found from time to time. People are born on occasion with a sixth finger, or with a third breast, or with a fully formed and functioning third arm growing out of their shoulder. The explanation for this is that a mutation provides a map for a new breast, and the cells which become the new breast negotiate their own blood supply and nerve pathways as they grow. In general these are somatic mutations though, not genetic ones, meaning that they are mutations that occur in the embryo, not in the genetic structure of the individual. Frequently they are the result of some trauma. For example, a third breast can form if the cells which are forming a breast early in the embryo are split into two clumps at just the right time. The two subdivided cell groups will self-organize into fully functioning breasts, creating a three-breasted woman. This is the source of many "two headed cow" stories. In most cases these sorts of mutations are non-viable and spontaneously abort, but not always. The objection you are raising here is probably the most common objection raised by those who challenge evolutionary theory. "Where's homo superior then?" is the short-hand version of this. There are two answers to this. The first is that homo superior may well already be here. There is significant debate on whether homo sapiens is truly one species, or if early forms, such as cro-magnon, are genetically different enough that they are actually a different species. The second is a more difficult sell, but probably closer to the truth. That explanation is that the timescale of evolution is so long compared to human experience that it is highly unlikely that we would be lucky enough to spot a macro-evolution speciation event in historical timeframes, much less in the time since humans have been utilizing the scientific method and have had visibility into the worldwide genetic diversity that this planet has. In other words imagine a clock with a second hand, a minue hand, an hour hand, a year hand and a century hand. Now imagine telling a mayfly that the century hand is moving. The century hand would move so slow that many generations of mayflys would have to observe it before they could measure any movement at all, but it still moves in spite of the vast majority of mayflies who would swear on their ancestor's graves that such movement is impossible. The fossil record is misleading too. We really have very few examples of life forms that numbered in the billions. The chance of any one individual being perserved in a manner that it would survive a hundred million years of erosion, volcanoes, meteorites, storms, or even the activity of other living things is terribly small. The only reason we have any fossil record at all is because of the untold trillions of living things that have lived and died. To expect to find a "transitional form" preserved in the fossil record is something most experts consider to be like winning the intergalactic lottery. It just ain't gonna happen. Yet it has happened. Arheopteryx is such a compelling example of a transitional form between reptile and bird that it is routinely accused of being a hoax by evolutionary foes. I'm convinced that it is real. And it is a remarkable fossil. I'm not trying to convince you of anything. I'm a born skeptic myself. But I am well-versed enough in evolutionary theory that I can represent it fairly well.
Andy
Man...I'll bet y'alls' fingers are worn out! It has been very interesting to follow this discussion. Cosmic: Just to make you not feel like this was a failed effort... Hi! I'm not really Andy! I'm a new poster...let's call me Harold (because that is my real name) (don't laugh). "If I were the King of the Forest" this whole subject would be moot. In Harold's perfect world, Dadman's worries (which I share) would not exist. The pro-homo marriage crowd would not have any motivation to push for it because: 1) There would be no social security, thus no one to assign "survivor benefits" to. 2) Health insurers would devise their own plans (absent State regs) about who could be covered as a "spouse." The guy with the best plan would attract the most customers, and the better mousetrap would once again prove "better." 3) Anyone could assign anyone as "next of kin" for medical decisions, pull the plug...decide on burial arrangements, etc. Blood kin would have no say...just the assigned individual (regardless of gender, etc.). 3) Churches would not have tax-exempt status, and contributions to them would not be tax deductible. Problem solved! Churches could refuse to do ANYTHING that violates their tenets without fear of legal, or civil action. This would also allow them to choose to do ANYTHING politically. In fact, some churches opt to not go 501c just for that reason. side note: I'm a flat-tax, or fair-tax guy myself...too much "engineering" in the tax code...which much of this homo marriage stuff is really all about. 4) Pension funds would compete with each other for the trust of the current (and future pensioners). The pensioners would dictate whether benefits could be assigned from Adam to Steve, etc. And I'll tell you from a little bit of experience, most ALL would say "yea." It is a long story I won't bore you with. 5) There would be NO State sanctioned "marriage." Partnerships would be either rewarded, or discouraged by the private market. Let's face it, homos are gonna be homos, and straights are gonna be straight. How they choose to structure their finances, property ownership, family, etc. really should not be dictated by legislatures. But I am not the King of the Forest! So, since we are stuck with State and Federal legislators hell-bent on controlling every aspect of society...and with Social Security...and churches bent on hanging on to tax exempt status...and insurers at the mercy of The State House...and social engineers in power... My suggestion would be that if a State wants to grant "equal marriage" status to homos that they carefully craft legislation (judge-proof legislation...if there is such a thing) that legalizes a "lifetime partnership" (for lack of a better term) that has to be legally dissolved (with cause) between ANYBODY, straight or homo. It should be done right. In those laws, religious 501c Corps should be protected from civil/criminal/jerking their tax exempt status liability. Those laws should stipulate that ANY individual that objects to ANY partnership (i.e. not renting to Adam & Steve...I have been through that personally with Dad's apartments here) will not be subject to civil (or criminal) liability. I really believe that the fears over the whole subject would just go away. I am closer to Drax on his "born that gay way" views than I am to Dadman...but Dadman and I have gone down that road (Oh wait...that wasn't me...I am a new poster). Amazingly, I did not sway him. ;) Drax made some good points. Homosexuality is "out of the norm." But so are blue eyes, red hair, and 6 fingers (makes for one heckuva curve ball though). Just my two cents... Interesting discussion. I think I'll come back and visit this blog again! Love, Harold (new poster)
Drax
Yay! Harold! The purpose is served! Without pictures! (CC: You needed boobies, man. You needed boobies...) CC: I don't know enough about evolutionary theory, just some casual reading over the decades. (In fact, after I wrote my last post in which I posited the substitution of quantity for time, I realized that, while this may be true as it relates to the potential for mutation -- it takes GENERATIONS (not time but offspring) for any mutation to show...and, since the evolutionary mutations are most likely quantum leaps (say...the beginnings of a vestigal wing rather than the whole structure...) the number of generations required would likely be far beyond the number of generations homo sapiens sapiens has even experienced. However, one would think that, perhaps, there would be SIGNS...POCKETS of mutations...) All I conclude from what I've read is that there simply isn't enough information to convince me one way or another. If anything, I tend to believe that the body is an organism...one which, to the extent it is able, will ADAPT to circumstance for survival. The attempts to adapt are likely random to SOME DEGREE. However, I believe that the adaptation is conforms to the circumstance presented. In other words, I find it highly unlikely that an organism when faced with a fight for survival would have the organism's resources directed towards completely "random" mutation rather than directed towards something which might actually HELP. (As you say, the evolutionary progress of horses is instructive.) As "proof" I offer the following: If mutations are "random" then in surviving species we would find many unnecessary mutations, but we don't. For the greatest part (almost entirely) that which we and the other animals possess is something which WORKS to some end -- performs some function. (The "solution" may not be the "best" solution, but it IS "a" solution.) The Innuit, for example, have a core body temperature some three degrees less than "ordinary" humans. Other geographically separated sections of humankind have developed different biological responses to cold and heat which the rest of "ordinary" humans don't possess. Then, of course, there are the racial differences which seem to be in keeping with the geological differences in the areas those races arose. So, the Innuit have a lower core body temperature to survive the cold; they don't have an extra thumb, a tail, flippers or anything else...just a response to the cold. A higher UV rating in Africa translates into darker skin. Hotter climes tend to elongation of limbs for more effective dispersal of heat. Other distinctions (bone density, body fat, width of hips, brain size, amount of testosterone, etc.) likely served different purposes through the millenia. So, I can't simply buy into "random mutation." I tend to sign off to "mutation in response to circumstance," instead.
CosmicConservative
Drax: You said: "As “proof” I offer the following: If mutations are “random” then in surviving species we would find many unnecessary mutations, but we don’t. For the greatest part (almost entirely) that which we and the other animals possess is something which WORKS to some end — performs some function. (The “solution” may not be the “best” solution, but it IS “a” solution.)" Here is a list of "unnecessary human mutations" Eye color Hair color Appendix Skin color Facial characteristics Right/Left handedness A molecular bioligist could give you hundreds, probably thousands of examples of random human mutations that have accumulated in the genome over time. Most of them have to do with protiens or enzymes that are created but perform no known function at this time. In fact the human genome (and every other genome we've examined) is BRIMMING with unnecessary mutations. I have seen some estimates that as much as 30% of the human genome is wasted on such pointless non-functioning genes. In fact this is such a problem that our DNA (and that of other living things) has developed processes to TURN OFF the nonfunctional areas of our DNA, and some genetic diseases are the result of that function failing. I'm going to give this one last shot. Mutations are non-directed and random. That is a FUNDAMENTAL tenet of Evolutionary theory. More on that in a minute. Mutations which provide no benefit may or may not hang around in the genome. Many do (the 30% of our DNA which is redundant or non-functional). It is only when a mutation provides an environmental advantage that it becomes an important biological function. For example, a genetic mutation to function better in cold temperatures is NO MORE LIKELY in the Intuit than in the Arabs. However, such a mutation would likely get weeded out or suppressed in Arabs while in the Inuit it would be reinforced and expressed. So after millenia of random mutations, when you examine a biological individual, what you see is the collective result of environmental pressures SUPPRESSING some mutations and REINFORCING others. That's the whole "survival of the fittest" thing. You earlier accused ME of making a Lamarkian statement. Your last statement "mutation in response to circumstance" is the very DEFINITION of Lamarkism. Now, to get back to the "directedness" of mutations. If mutations are not random then there must be some mechanism which DIRECTS them. What is that mechanism? What tells the amino acids in the DNA molecule to arrange themselves in a particular way to achieve a particular effect? This opens up a whole new can of worms, and introduces the need to exercise Occam's Razor. I guess folks reading this will, as usual, have to reach their own conclusions on the subject.
Drax
Heh. I didn't say that they were "directed," but that they were in response to stimuli. The body undergoes physiological changes under stress. The changes are frequently different based on the kind of stress applied. Being cold produces one physiological response -- heat another. Long-term exposure to these stressors with the accompanying physiological changes "directs" the body to respond -- resulting in time to those differences indicated in my earlier post. Some of the mutations you list (hair color, eye color for example) are limited to the Caucasoid race. Others (facial characteristics, skin color) are also race-specific. What the appendix may have been for is a puzzle. I don't know if right-hand/left-hand distinctions are "mutations" or not. But, I agree, in general. There are a whole host of differences within the species and within the races of the species which are a puzzlement (blood type, for example). Did they have a purpose at one time -- and a hold over -- or are they simply a benign mutation? Dunno. But, I still can't but total randomness in mutation. These minor and, almost without exception -- meaningless in a functional sense -- deviations you list and refer to don't convince me of the TOTAL randomness (a minor variation in eye color which may or may not have had a purpose and exists in only one race -- a difference in skin color which supports my argument since it it helpful for those who have it (when they GOT it anyway...)). What I'd like to see is scales popping up...tails...gills...wings...fur -- SIGNIFICANT differences which would point to the "randomness" of the mutations, rather than what I see which are "mutations" which, in great part are BENEFICIAL. Going back to the Innuit. We know that people CAN "mutate" so that they have a lower core body temperature than the vast bulk of humanity. Ockham's Razor: Is it more likely that a group of humans who live in the cold: 1) Randomly "mutate" (from the nearly infinite possibilities allowed by "randomness") a defense from the cold (and are otherwise essentially the same as every other human being) or 2) The "mutation" is body's response over time to the presented stressor? When I apply Ockham's Razor, I'm compelled to go with #2.
CosmicConservative
Drax: The problem with your analysis of the choices and the application of Occam's Razor, from MY perspective is that you aren't asking the right questions. The way I ask it is: Is it more likely that (A) random mutations are selectively reinforced by environmental factors resulting in the eventual expression of specific favorable mutations, or is it more likely that (B) some unknown, undetected and untheorized process is at play which can manipulate individual amino acid base pairs in selective DNA molecules to derive a desired result? The answer to that is clearly "A". To pick "B" in that situation more or less requires some God-like force at play. Of course you can pick "B" if you believe that a God like force is in play. I just don't believe that.
Drax
How does "God" enter into it? Why is it not a possibility that over millenia the body can adapt in a fashion which is beneficial by employing defenses to the presented stressor? We KNOW that people can, through biofeedback, do things which are impossible for others. (I watched "Superhuman" the other night. Amazing what some people can do. One guy can sit in 30 degree water (SIT) for over an hour and not have his core temperature alter any significant degree when "normal" people would be dead in roughly 10 minutes.) Why not, over thousands of years, the possibility that those whose bodies are capable of such adaptation pass those genes to their children and result in such oddities as the Innuit? I don't have to have a "guiding hand" to support my notion. I just can't get my head around the following: A bunch of people are living in an area which is NOT cold. Over many centuries, it BECOMES cold. By HAPPENSTANCE, their bodies mutate in a manner which makes them less susceptible to the cold. Thankfully, (since it's getting cold) this happenstance proves beneficial. (Or those living in the heat grow longer limbs...which (again...thanks to the dice gods) is a happy coincidence...) I just can't wrap my mind around pure randomness resulting in such specific beneficial results.
CosmicConservative
Drax: I have no problem wrapping my brain around it. In fact it makes perfect sense to me. I'd like to see the guy who can sit in 30 degree water for over an hour. In fact I'd like to see 30 degree water. The general hypothesis of evolution is that mutations occur constantly and that they are random. That means your Inuit example involves lots of mutations over time, some beneficial, some benign, some harmful. The harmful ones usually don't even result in births, so are immediately forgotten. The benign ones provide no benefit and are completely overlooked. The beneficial ones provide some advantage and so are noticed. It's that simple. That Inuit population you point to and say "see, they've developed cold tolerance" has also most likely had mutations which provide heat tolerance too. Unfortunately those mutations provide no benefit so they either go unnoticed or they fail to reproduce and disappear. Here is an analogy. You pick pecans and want to package them. To package them you want very uniform sizes so you put a grid up that blocks the biggest pecans. You also don't want too small pecans, so you put another grid up that allows the smallest to pass through. The result is a collection of pecans that are all roughly the same size. What you are saying is effectively the same thing as someone coming along, seeing the pecans all the same size, seeing the two grids and saying "AMAZING! These two grids cause pecans to all grow the same size!"
Drax
Heh. I think it was actually 35 degrees. (They dumped ice on him up to his chest in a bathtub. This guy climbed Mt. Everest IN HIS SHORTS. http://armchairgm.wikia.com/%22Iceman%22_to_climb_Mount_Everest_in_shorts_and_no_shirt!) Funny analogy. Heard it before. No matter how you phrase it, the bottom line of randomness is randomness. Pure dumb luck that the VERY DEFENSE which is beneficial occurred AT ALL (out of the gajillions of potential mutations) -- with no significant detrimental mutations -- with no significant other benign mutations -- with no other significant variation from the vast bulk of humanity. Just -- need defense from cold -- roll evolutionary dice -- get defense from cold (skin doesn't turn blue, hair doesn't turn purple, a sixth finger doesn't grow) -- so.... YAY! I just have difficulty accepting that.
CosmicConservative
Drax: The mutations are happening all the time, in different individuals. The same day someone develops a cold resistance mutation another person may develop a heat resistance mutation. Only the cold one provides a benefit so it is retained, the rest are forgotten. Another analogy. You go walking in the woods. You like shiny rocks. You pick up shiny rocks. You come home and show the shiny rocks to your wife. She exclaims AMAZING! Those woods only have shiny rocks!!! That is the "SELECTION" part of "Natural Selection."
Drax
I understand the theory. I just have a difficult time accepting it as fact. Did you check out the link? That guy is frapping AMAZING.
CosmicConservative
When I went to the link all it had was a headline.
Drax
That's weird. Do the same search on Google and come up with the same page. Go to the page and it has text. Go from here and says "no text." Weird. Try this one: http://abcnews.go.com/Health/story?id=4393377&page=1