WASHINGTON (CNN) -- CIA interrogators used waterboarding at least 266 times on two top al Qaeda suspects, according to a Bush-era Justice Department memo released by the Obama administration.
The controversial technique that simulates drowning -- and which President Obama calls torture -- was used at least 83 times in August 2002 on suspected al Qaeda leader Abu Zubaydah, according to the memo.
Interrogators also waterboarded Khalid Sheikh Mohammed 183 times in March 2003. Mohammed is believed to be the mastermind behind the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks on the United States.
OK, I think the criticisms of the Bush administration for not being straight about waterboarding are fair criticisms. What I have seen from Bush spokespeople in the past is that waterboarding had been used "a few times" on no more than three individuals, and that it had immediately led to valuable intelligence. This is misinformation that can perhaps fairly be called lying to the American public. At least I feel like I have been misled.
But as far as the revelation itself, I think it can be interpreted two ways quite legitimately.
The first way is the emotional, visceral way, where you say "Waterboarding someone once or twice probably isn't torture, but 183 times in a month! WHAT? What is that, six times a day!?" Smacking someone on the face with an open palm once may not be torture, but doing it a hundred times in a row certainly qualifies.
However, there is also the nearly opposite interpretation. If someone can put up with waterboarding six times a day for a month before they talk, it certainly does not seem to be a debilitating experience that leads to permanent injury. I mean the guy went through this for a month and the photos I saw of him around that time didnt' show a person with permanent physical or mental injury.
I actually see the fact that the Bush administration intentionally misled the American people on this as a separate issue than the waterboarding itself. I am severely disappointed in Bush and his team, even if all they did was ALLOW the misrepresentation to stand. All that does is feed the perception that Bush and his administration mislead or lie on a regular basis.
Shame on them.
As far as the torture question? I can't really say this has changed my mind one way or the other. I mean six times a day for a month? No doubt it was a traumatic and horrific month, but was it torture?
I'm still not convinced.
Comments (21)