Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

How many times were they waterboarded?

By CosmicConservative
WASHINGTON (CNN) -- CIA interrogators used waterboarding at least 266 times on two top al Qaeda suspects, according to a Bush-era Justice Department memo released by the Obama administration. The controversial technique that simulates drowning -- and which President Obama calls torture -- was used at least 83 times in August 2002 on suspected al Qaeda leader Abu Zubaydah, according to the memo. Interrogators also waterboarded Khalid Sheikh Mohammed 183 times in March 2003. Mohammed is believed to be the mastermind behind the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks on the United States.
OK, I think the criticisms of the Bush administration for not being straight about waterboarding are fair criticisms. What I have seen from Bush spokespeople in the past is that waterboarding had been used "a few times" on no more than three individuals, and that it had immediately led to valuable intelligence. This is misinformation that can perhaps fairly be called lying to the American public. At least I feel like I have been misled. But as far as the revelation itself, I think it can be interpreted two ways quite legitimately. The first way is the emotional, visceral way, where you say "Waterboarding someone once or twice probably isn't torture, but 183 times in a month! WHAT? What is that, six times a day!?" Smacking someone on the face with an open palm once may not be torture, but doing it a hundred times in a row certainly qualifies. However, there is also the nearly opposite interpretation. If someone can put up with waterboarding six times a day for a month before they talk, it certainly does not seem to be a debilitating experience that leads to permanent injury. I mean the guy went through this for a month and the photos I saw of him around that time didnt' show a person with permanent physical or mental injury. I actually see the fact that the Bush administration intentionally misled the American people on this as a separate issue than the waterboarding itself. I am severely disappointed in Bush and his team, even if all they did was ALLOW the misrepresentation to stand. All that does is feed the perception that Bush and his administration mislead or lie on a regular basis. Shame on them. As far as the torture question? I can't really say this has changed my mind one way or the other. I mean six times a day for a month? No doubt it was a traumatic and horrific month, but was it torture? I'm still not convinced.

Comments (21)

Drax
Of course it was "torture." Being deprived of your freedom is "torture." Being told what to eat, when to eat it is "torture." Being told when to sleep, when to exercise, when to be in the "day room" and when to be in your small cell is "torture." ANY restriction on your freedom is "torutre." Being deprived of sleep is "torture." Having loud music slammed into your ear drums is "torture." Having bright lights shone into your eyes and being asked the same questions over and over and over and over is "torture." ANY inconvenience, however mild, which you cannot escape or mitigate is "torture." I could do this all day. Slapping. Hitting. Pulling fingernails. Waterboarding. It's all just DEGREES on the "torture" scale. The question isn't whether it's "torture," it's whether it's ACCEPTABLE torture. It's ACCEPTABLE torture, in my opinion, under two circumstances: 1) The person upon which it is being visited is a bad actor who is attempting or has attempted to take American/Allied lives. 2) The torture might lead to accurate and useful information which could prevent other bad actors from carrying out similar plans. I don't know why people get so twisted up over the term, "torture." Some throw it around like it is the worst thing in the world and others duck it like it's the worst thing in the world. It is a TOOL to gather information. If it is being used against a person who is deserving of its use AND it might lead to accurate and useful information....stop quibbling over definitions and get to work..
CosmicConservative
Drax: I would not agree with your definition of "torture." Your description of torture is logically equivalent to calling hunger just a degree of famine. Yes the "suffering" inflicted is on a scale, but at some point there is a line where "inconvenience" becomes "coercion" which becomes "punishment" which becomes "brutality" which becomes "torture" more or less in that order along the scale. The problem is that people draw the lines in different places. "Johnny, if you don't eat your peas, you can go to bed hungry" is not "torture" if the word "torture" is to have any actual rhetorical meaning. The reason people are at such odds over the word "torture" is because two people can agree exactly on the definition of the word as "punishment which has crossed the line" but one person can see the line to the LEFT of waterboarding while another sees the line to the RIGHT of waterboarding. In their own minds both are exactly right. So the question is what is the CONSENSUS on "torture." And that, of course, changes over time. What we now call "torture" would once have been considered completely just and fair punishment. 40 lashes for example. There are few people today in this country who would not call that torture. But 200 years ago, not so much. It is very hard to have meaningful discussions around terms which are so malleable, but that is the very nature of culture, for such definitions to change over time. As for me, I draw the line to the right of "waterboarding" with the caveat that it is conceivable that if you do ENOUGH waterboarding, the sheer quantity of waterboarding crosses that line, just as 100 slaps crosses the line that one slap does not.
Drax
CC: I really don't care if you agree with my definition of torture if you agree that the definition of torture isn't one which the world agrees upon. You may not agree that having your ears blasted with loud music is "torture," but I ASSURE you that some of those who are having their ears so blasted DO. Etc. etc. etc. And, your notion of "quantity" just befuddles me. Maybe it TAKES "100 slaps" to get someone to reveal information. 99 ain't enough. 1 sure isn't. Would being slapped once cause you to give up your friends/family/comrads? Maybe twice? Three times? At WHAT POINT is it "too many" slaps for you? And, that's MY point. Your "line" is utterly arbitrary and self-defined. Your point about "hunger" is without merit. It is punishment (in your "eat your peas" example). Do it every night...do it for no reason...keep your kid hungry...and it becomes "torture." THAT is the situation a PRISONER is in -- one in the complete control of another. He eats (or not) as his captor wishes. He sleeps (or not) as his captor wishes. And, in the kid's mind...yeah...it's "torture.."
CosmicConservative
Drax: Here's the deal on quantity: 1 slap per day for 100 days does not equal 100 slaps per day for 1 day. In fact 100 slaps in one day could quite conceivably kill someone. In the same way 1 waterboarding experience in a month would not cross the line to torture. In fact it is well known by people who care to examine the truth that our military special forces use waterboarding as a training technique to demonstrate what a captured member of the US military might endure. I haven't heard any of these "waterboarding is torture" people saying Navy Seals torture themselves. But 183 times in one month? Does that cross the line? 1 slap per day gives the face time to heal. 100 slaps in a day does not, so the damage is cumulative and potentially life threatening. Tissue damage from 100 consecutive slaps is not the same in type or scale to tissue damage from one slap per day for 100 days. Is there similar physical or mental damage from waterboarding that would mean 183 times in a month crossed that nearly impossible to see line? I dunno. But I do think 183 times in a month is a significant escalation in the technique that merits examination separate from the simple question of whether ONE application of waterboarding qualifies as torture. And as I said, I am disappointed in Bush for letting the reality be misrepresented so thoroughly.
CosmicConservative
Oh, also Drax. I am not going to dumb down the definition of the word "torture" to mean "anything that a person endures from another human being that they don't like." I'm sorry but there are already words to describe different degrees of human to human interaction, and I listed several of them in this thread already. Words need to have meaning. "Torture" needs to mean something DIFFERENT from "coercion" or "interrogation" or "inconvenience" or "punishment." Those words already describe different portions of the scale of human to human conduct. It does no rhetorical, philosophical or practical good to say ALL of them are simply "forms of torture." They aren't. Torture is distinguished in more than one way. Not only by degree and by context, but by INTENT of the perpetrator.
Drax
CC: I don't get it. You think that INTENT has something to do with whether or not something is defined as torture? So... A person who takes pliers to fingernails for his perverse sexual pleasure IS torturing someone while someone who takes pliers to fingernails in an effort to extract information isn't? What about someone who is doing it simply as an object lesson to another? How about I flog someone 10 times in a quest for answers as opposed to punishing them for talking to a male non-family member? I really think you have to reconsider your notion that the INTENT of the "torturer" has ANYTHING to do with whether or not the ACT actually IS "torture." Put someone is a tiger cage for a day? Discomfort. A week? A month? At what point is it "torture?" Is it "torture" for each person who endures it? At the SAME point? I can slap someone 99 times a day, but not 100? How about, instead, I get to slap him UNTIL HE TALKS? Or just give up on the notion of EXTRACTING information altogether rather than taking the chance that my actions will arbitrarily be defined as "torture" AT MY TRIAL -- by someone who self-defines the term according to his whim? Apparently, the only SAFE definition for "torture" which our interrogators can rely upon is "any action which DOESN'T extract information, since any action which DOES -- MUST have been torture." Some words have NO INDEPENDENT MEANING. They are inherently RELATIVE TERMS. We waterboard our OWN troops. Are we "torturing" them or "training" them? (Your notion that "intent" is part of the definiton means that the word ITSELF means NOTHING since the ACT ITSELF is defined differently based on the INTENT of the actor...) And...183 times... Sigh. Do we know how many times he was waterboarded in EACH SESSION? Once? Five? Twenty? More? Was he "waterboarded" (as a SESSION) a "few" times or 183 DIFFERENT TIMES? (Well, since it was over the course of approximately 30 days...one can ASSUME that each session consisted of multiple "waterboardings....") Regardless... We have a guy who was talking. At some point. Do we STOP waterboarding him because he BROKE? Or do we KEEP DOING IT until we NO LONGER GET USEFUL INFORMATION? I don't think that I can safely define the term "torture" in a fashion which will withstand examination -- especially if that examination is done by some weak sisters who think that ANY action taken to extract information from someone who is UNWILLING to give it without having been placed in a position of pain or fear (or both) is "torture." Yet, we HAVE to so define the term or have our interrogators be tried and convicted of "torture" for DOING THEIR DUTY, for doing that which we REQUIRE of them, i.e., to extract information from those unwilling to give it. Or, as I said....simply give up on attempting to extract that information altogether. Personally, I think it's a BAD IDEA to forego extracting that information, but if we don't SUPPORT those we ask to do it --- then we need to simply warehouse those murdererous bastards and accept that they have information which could have saved our wives, husbands, mothers, fathers, and children -- and we don't have the stomach to extract it.
Drax
I just can't let up on this "intent" thing. So...since EVERY action in an attempt to extract information from a prisoner IS intended to do that very thing...EVERY ACTION is "torture" since the "intent" of the FIRST slap is IDENTICAL to the "intent" of the 100th? Really?
CosmicConservative
Apparently, the only SAFE definition for “torture” which our interrogators can rely upon is “any action which DOESN’T extract information, since any action which DOES — MUST have been "torture.”
Heh, there's a lot of truth there. FWIW, I would allow "sexual perversion" and "interrogation" to BOTH be "intents" which would define breaking a finger as "torture." A doctor breaking a finger to reset it would NOT be torture, even though it might appear to be exactly the same thing in terms of the ACTUAL EVENT. (Let's say a doctor is resetting a broken finger after being stranded on a desert island and has no anasthesia). So, yes, I do think "intent" is a part of the definition of "torture." But, that still leaves open the question of if it is RIGHT or WRONG. That's a much grayer area. If you knew that breaking a finger would cause someone to give up the location of a hidden ticking nuclear bomb, would it be "right" or "wrong" to break that finger? Either way, it's still TORTURE. OK, so one slap isn't torture, 100 slaps in a row probably is. Is 99? 98? 55? In some sense that depends on circumstances, including both the resilience of the victim and the effort behind the slap itself. (By the way, 100 slaps would probably hurt the SLAPPER significantly too, so we'll assume the slaps are done with something to protect the slapper's hand.) Trying to nail down a single number of slaps as the definition of torture is as likely to be successful as identifying the single straw which finally breaks the camel's back. We all KNOW that enough straw will do it, even if we never know exactly which individual stalk of straw will be the final straw. My issue with your comments above are when you asserted that anything a person doesn't like and has to endure is "torture." I don't agree with that. It is redefining the word to mean everything from "irritation" to "brutality". Defining torture may be hard, it may be impossible to get everyone to agree. But if you are going to make POLICY around it, then you HAVE to define it. And since both the UN and the United States Government have DEFINED POLICY around it, then I think it is incumbent upon us to define it as best we can. And calling detention in a drunk tank torture does not pass the smell test. So to speak.
Drax
I agree that my attempt at showing that it is utterly impossible to define "torture" (and thus show that the word itself is without meaning mandates absurd results. That's the point. One CAN'T, as policy, define "torture" in a manner which provides GUIDANCE to those charged with extracting information from those unwilling to freely give it. One just can't. Because no matter HOW it is defined, SOME will find the definition to be too "brutal." So, I don't attempt to impose MY comprehension of what is "torture" upon those who use it to extract information from people who are attempting to kill me. Either we use coercive techniques to extract information from those unwilling to freely give it...or we don't. We don't quibble over which acts are and are not "torture" because ANY of the "techniques" which are used which might reasonably be calculated to extract information from one not willing to freely give it can be -- by someone -- defined as "torture."
CosmicConservative
My own opinion on this subject is probably close to yours. The only reason I am insisting that we use a defined form of "torture" is because it is embedded in POLICY statements. Since we say we don't "torture" as a matter of POLICY, the fact that we DON'T have a legal definition of the term is what leaves this sort of embarrassing international debate open. It is incumbent upon us (and the UN) to define explicitly what constitutes torture if we are going to publicly write laws saying that we DON'T DO IT. And when the word is left to describe anything the arguer doesn't like, all that does is make it possible to CRIMINALIZE policy differences. Which is exactly what the Democrats are trying to do.
Drax
I don't see how: 1) Any definition of "torture" which actually would result in techniques which would actually extract information from people unwilling to freely give it could be formulated; and 2) How on earth such would benefit us since we would be CONSTRAINED to performing those (and ONLY those) actions in our efforts to extract information since performing any OTHER actions would be, by definition, "torture." We see this in the UN Convention on Torture: "Article 1 1. For the purposes of this Convention, the term "torture" means any act by which severe pain or suffering, whether physical or mental, is intentionally inflicted on a person for such purposes as obtaining from him or a third person information or a confession, punishing him for an act he or a third person has committed or is suspected of having committed, or intimidating or coercing him or a third person, or for any reason based on discrimination of any kind, when such pain or suffering is inflicted by or at the instigation of or with the consent or acquiescence of a public official or other person acting in an official capacity." This is a HORRID definition. 1) What is "severe" pain or suffering? 2) The intent of the giver of the pain (to obtain information or a confession) is at issue. What if we just inflict pain for no purpose -- as did the Viet Cong and as do some of the terrorists? 3) The "torture" must be officially sanctioned. A slap can surely cause "severe" pain. Blaring music for extended periods can certainly cause "severe" MENTAL suffering. As can sleep deprivation or tossing a religious artifact down a toilet. In fact -- NO act which could be reasonably calcualted to actually be EFFECTIVE in extracting information from one unwilling to freely give it would survive examination under this definition. The Geneva Convention handles it differently, barring essentially everything: "No physical or mental torture, nor any other form of coercion, may be inflicted on prisoners of war to secure from them information of any kind whatever. Prisoners of war who refuse to answer may not be threatened, insulted or exposed to unpleasant or disadvantageous treatment of any kind." I guess that "intent" in this case is all important as it doesn't preclude just smacking around POW's for the heck of it...just prohibits it as a method to extract information. The ultimate question is whether we wish to engage in coercive techniques to extract information from those we've captured when they aren't willing to freely give it. We, as a nation, have agreed that we won't do that in a "war" against captured prisoners. We agreed to this in hopes that OUR captured prisoners won't be subjected to similar techniques. But, since we are in a "war" against people who don't follow those rules to begin with, are we bound by the terms of contracts which do not likewise bind our enemies -- or should we use ANY coercive techniques now that the rationale for not doing so doesn't exist? I'm generally in favor of taking all necessary steps to gather information to protect American lives when those steps are directed at the sorry bastards trying to kill us.
CosmicConservative
That isn't a definition. It's a rhetorical exercise in NOT defining. In fact I think it is deliberately non-defining to create exactly the effect it has had of stifling ANY activities that MIGHT run afoul of ANY interpretation of that "definition." It's all well and good to debate analytically about whether it is right to slap a prisoner to get information from them. It's a whole lot different when that prisoner has YOUR daughter buried alive in a wooden coffin and he is the only one who can tell you how to save her. The difference between me and most liberals is not that I WOULD slap the crap out of him, but more to the point, that I ADMIT that I would do it. I'll go one step further and say I have no use for any Dad who would NOT.
Drax
I agree that the UN Convention is a useless definition. Any attempt to define "torture" will result in a useless definition. And, I agree with you. And, most parents would when asked the question in that manner, i.e., would YOU visit pain and suffering on someone if it might lead to information which would save your daughter's life?" Frankly, most wouldn't even bother to ask if the person being "tortured" was innocent or not -- just whether he had information which might save his daughter's life. Anyone who would put a theoretical notion of "not sinking to their level" before the life of their own daughter is not a serious person -- or, if a serious person ... say a religious person who was more concerned with the after-life than his daughter's temporal life ... then he ain't someone I want in charge of getting information which might save MY daughter's life.
Drax
Heh...as I was sayin'... http://justoneminute.typepad.com/main/2009/04/not-a-lawyer-or-even-a-clear-thinker.html
CosmicConservative
Drax: I saw that too. Linked off of Instapundit I think. Sort of funny how close that is to your own words.
wayne fazio
Isn't the issue, "we tortue before proving guilty?"
wayne fazio
I think that the government can torture anyone before they are proven guilty, is the issue. I grew up in a John Wayne country where we didn't shoot people in the back or fight dirty. We took the high road even if it cost us. I want those days back.
CosmicConservative
Wayne: No the issue is not that "we torture before proving guilty." First of all it is not universally acknowledged that waterboarding is torture. So your fundamental assumption is an IDEOLOGICAL one, not a FACTUAL one. I do NOT consider waterboarding "torture" not by any reasonable definition of the term which cannot be stretched to include withholding TV viewing rights from schoolchildren. The Left's attempt to redefine the term "torture" to damage a sitting President is one of the most despicable political hack jobs I've seen in my lifetime. The individuals who were waterboarded were captured in the act of plotting or committing acts of terrorism against U.S. soldiers or civilians. The MAIN individual involved BRAGGED about having personally beheaded Daniel Pearl. Guilt or innocence was not debatable, these were evil terrorists who coordinated terrorist activities which killed hundreds or thousands of innocent lives and they were OPENLY PROUD of it. Finally, your whole point seems to suggest that ACTUAL torture would be OK if the person were PROVEN "guilty" of something. ACTUAL torture, as opposed to politically convenient definition changing, would be as wrong after conviction as before, and quite frankly, if the purpose of torture in general is to extract a confession, then there isn't much point in torturing AFTER conviction is there? Your second comment just extends this moral confusion. "we didn't shoot people in the back or fight dirty. We took the high road even if it cost us." With that sort of attitude, you would be the LAST person I would want in charge of any wartime military operation. War is hell. To win a war you do what you have to do. If you hold back in fear of getting your hands dirty, you will lose. Shooting in the back and fighting dirty are an integral part of warfare. There are some who think that in a bar fight they would fight cleanly. If so they are idiots. When your opponent picks up a stick, if you don't pick one up too, you are simply an example of Darwinian Natural Selection in action. As Sean Connery's "Untouchables" character said: "When they draw a knife, you draw a gun. When they put one of yours in the hospital, you put one of theirs in the morgue." People can contemplate their moral niceties in the comfort of their own protected homes while hard men make difficult choices to protect them. But don't expect me, or people like me, to admire their moral ambiguity or their self-righteousness. This is a dangerous world, it requires hard choices sometimes.
Drax
Wayne: There is an undercurrent of "morality" a view of "right/wrong" in your posts which, frankly, is counterproductive in the prosecution of a war. First: Let me make this as clear as I possibly can. We didn't sign the Geneva Convention because we wanted to take the "high road." We signed it so that all countries who were at war would not attempt to extract information from those they have captured. Us, them, all the rest of 'em. We signed it so that THEY couldn't do it to US, and, in order to get THEM to agree not to do it to US, WE had to agree not to do it to THEM. Accordingly, our agreement not to use coercive methods to extract information from prisoners of war wasn't some act of "morality," a choice between "right" and "wrong," but a PRACTICAL choice made for PRACTICAL reasons. Second: The use of the word "torture" is DESIGNED to inflame. It is DESIGNED to cause people to view the coercive methods we used to extract information in the very light you have, i.e., a negative one based on qualms any decent person would have when considering the ramifications of the word "torture." (It's the same reason the left now uses "Overseas Contingency Operation" rather that "War on Terror" for example.) Third: It is impossible to define torture. Impossible. No definition which is applied to that word would satisfy everyone which is the fundamental meaning of the word "define." Look at it this way: Try to define it yourself. Go ahead. I'll wait. Write your definition down. Go to a dictionary. Whatever. I'll give you as much time as you need.
Drax
Got your definition? Good. I pulled this one up on dictionary.com torture: –noun 1. the act of inflicting excruciating pain, as punishment or revenge, as a means of getting a confession or information, or for sheer cruelty. 2. a method of inflicting such pain. 3. Often, tortures. the pain or suffering caused or undergone. 4. extreme anguish of body or mind; agony. 5. a cause of severe pain or anguish. –verb (used with object) 6. to subject to torture. 7. to afflict with severe pain of body or mind: 8. to force or extort by torture: We'll torture the truth from his lips! 9. to twist, force, or bring into some unnatural position or form: trees tortured by storms. 10. to distort or pervert (language, meaning, etc.). " See the problem? The use of such words as "severe" "excruciating" or even "pain" are subjective words without quantative value. (And, there is no "mental" component of this defintion. Certainly if "torture" exists, there is "mental torture" as well as physical. So, let's break it down. Is torture an ACT? An INTENT? A RESULT? If torture is an ACT, the every time that ACT is committed, then it is torture. (So, when we waterboard OUR troops, it's torture, if waterboarding is torture. If a slap on a prisoner is torture, so is a slap on any other person. So, defining torture by the act itself is an extraordinarily silly method of definition.) If torture is an INTENT, then we can waterboard our troops with impunity, since we're "training" our troops, but use of waterboarding on someone else TO EXTRACT INFORMATION ("intent") would be torture. But, then, ANY act which has the INTENT "to extract information" becomes torture, and any act which does not have that intent is NOT torture. (So, the sadist who pulls fingernails is not torturing anyone while the interrogator who simply asks for information IS. Another unuseful criteria. What about RESULT? If "torture" is defined by its RESULT (DID the act extract information?), then ANY act which results in extracting information becomes torture and any act which does NOT isn't. So, yelling and pounding on a table, threatening with jail time which might be sufficient for one weak prisoner "rolling over" BECOMES "torture" while the strong prisoner who resists waterboarding defines waterboarding as NOT torture. Sigh. Not very useful criteria for defining the term. Do you see the problem?
Drax
Now that you have the problem firmly in mind, let's fully dispense with the "we're the good guys, so let's not descend to their levels by "torturing" the bad guys" mindset. In war, we do what we must to win. Our survival depends on it. If not survival, then, at least, American lives depend on it. That's why we leveled entire cities (men, women, and children...civilian and soldiers...homes as well as factories of war) in WWII (Dresden -- Berlin spring to mind.) That's why we dropped the nukes on Japan. That's why we lay seige to cities, starving those inside. We didn't do these things because we're "good" as, by just about any definition, it isn't a "good" act to INTENTIONALLY target population centers and drop bombs on them day after day after day with CERTAIN harm to "innocents" the inevitable result. But, it was NECESSARY. We do what is NECESSARY. Or we lose. So, the question isn't "what is torture," but "Is it NECESSARY to extract information from THIS prisoner?" A simple question. Does THIS prisoner have information which might save American lives? If the answer is "yes," is it NECESSARY to extract it from him? If you believe (as I do) that the value of American lives is GREATER than the value of a captured terrorist who has (and will, if given the future chance) take or cause to be taken American lives...then, the answer to that question is an unqualified "yes." So, the quandry that the President found himself in. He had in his possession terrorists who almost certainly had information which, if extracted, would almost certainly save American lives, possibly thousands of American lives. So, he did what we pay him to do...make a decision. He did what we hope that all Presidents do when asked such a difficult question, he sought the advice of EXPERTS. Lawyers. Lawyers to read the pertinent treaties, interpret words, provide guidance on just where the dividing line between "aggressive questioning" and "torture" lay. They ran into the same trouble I noted above, i.e., "torture" is impossible to define. But, they were asked to give their opinions. They took the "act" route, setting out which ACTS were and were not "torture" (waterboarding for THIS long THIS many times is not...more is; putting a bug in a box with a person without telling him it didn't bite WAS -- telling him it wouldn't bite WASN'T; a "slap" wasn't. Etc.) Can't blame them. There really isn't a good choice. They couldn't take RESULT because then ANYTHING which resulted in information would be "torture," and the President WANTED information. They couldn't take INTENT because the INTENT was integral to the questioning, i.e., the President wanted INFORMATION. So, they were pretty well limited to listing ACTS which were and were not "torture." So limited, they did a pretty good job. Because, remember... The people we had in our possession had information we wanted. That information was future attacks on Americans. Those who had that information would not willingly give it away. (They were the "good guys" in their minds. They were following "God's plan." WE were the "evil Satan." Any information they gave up would foil "God's plan," and cause the deaths of their friends, comrades, and possibly families.) So, the information had to be FORCED from them. The methods used were ones which we visit upon our own troops, only, when we do it to our own, we call it "training." And, since we have been doing it to our own troops for "training," studies have been conducted to determine whether these methods caused any permanant or lasting damage (to our troops) and those studies have determined that they DO NOT. So, those lawyers (the ones the partisan Democrats who NOW want their heads...) did a FINE job setting forth what our interrogators could do to extract this information from those terrorists who would not give it willingly. I'm glad that we had a President who was willing to do what was NECESSARY and who, as a result of his GUTS to make the hard decisions, his willingness to accept RESPONSIBILITY for those decisions, KEPT US SAFE FOR EIGHT YEARS. Okay. Done now.