Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Disproportionate response

By CosmicConservative
Pirates have avoided attacking American ships before now. No longer. Any guess as to why?
Somali pirates hijack ship; 20 Americans aboard - Yahoo News NAIROBI, Kenya – Somali pirates on Wednesday hijacked a U.S.-flagged cargo ship with 20 American crew members onboard, hundreds of miles from the nearest American military vessel in some of the most dangerous waters in the world. The 17,000-ton Maersk Alabama was carrying emergency relief to Mombasa, Kenya, when it was hijacked, said Peter Beck-Bang, spokesman for the Copenhagen-based container shipping group A.P. Moller-Maersk. It was the sixth ship seized within a week, a rise that analysts attribute to a new strategy by Somali pirates who are operating far from the warships patrolling the Gulf of Aden.
Liberals are always complaining about using the military for "disproportionate responses." Meaning they decry any military response of overwhelming force against a weaker opponent. There's a reason you do that. It's to remind people like these pirates that if you attack American ships, hold Americans hostage and threaten American national security, you, your family, your friends and your associates are at severe risk to life, limb and liberty. This is a serious test of Obama's resolve. It won't get any media play because the media, being almost entirely Leftists, will simply view this as a bunch of rabble that should be scolded. Thomas Jefferson understood that piracy is more than that, it's a threat to our ability to freely sail the high seas. Jefferson's FIRST use of the Marines and Navy was to stop Barbary pirates from attacking American ships. This is no different. My guess is Obama will let these hostages suffer, then will pay a ransom, which will embolden the pirates to take MORE Americans hostage. After all, if that's how Obama responds, it's a profitable enterprise, and more people will want to play.

Comments (19)

Old Goat
Gotta spread the wealth around! Change we can believe in. At least Obama isn't bowing to some Kings of other countries. Oh, wait...
Drax
I don't know how one breeds a person who can formulate such an idiotic idea as "disproportionate response." It takes a special kind of blindness to reality to even conceive of such an idea as one which is desireable. The goal of war is singular: To win. Everything one does in prosecuting a war has to have that goal in mind. All other goals are secondary. The main secondary goal in prosecuting a war is to preserve yourself to the greatest extent possible. This secondary goal (obvious to anyone who has any registerable brain activity) dictates that any "response" be as disproportionate as possible so to limit the damage done to yourself. An overwhelming force has the potential (duh) of "overwhelming" the opposition -- limiting the potential of damage to ourselves. Purposely reducing our "response" to one which results in something equating in an equality of forces (what...are we going to hijack one of the hijacker's ships so to be proportionate???) is a purposeful pursuit of damage to ourselves. So, anyone who advocates "proportionate response" is advocating that we intentionally sacrifice our blood and treasure to the altar of their misguided conscience. As I said...how does one breed such mental defectives?
Drax
Heh. http://townhall.com/news/politics-elections/2009/04/08/officials_us_vessel_now_back_in_hands_of_crew That'll learn 'em.
Dadman
I like this quote from the article: "The crew reportedly has one pirate in custody. The status of others is unclear, they are believed to be in the water." Lunchtime for sharks...I hope.
CosmicConservative
Heh... Obama is saved from a difficult question by a heroic group of U.S. merchant sailors. I love it.
Dadman
Merchant sailors who have, evidently, not lost their American swagger. Nobama probably thinks they're arrogant. He'll probably have one of his teleprompters condemn them...
Old Goat
I guess they just want to kill the enemies a little in stead. Good on the Merchant sailors. Though don't expect to see them get any kind of heroes welcome at the WH.
Dadman
Apparently, the pirates fled with the ship's captain, so they have a hostage. Sigh. I wish it were possible to blast all the bad actors in this world with a fatal dose of...well, anything fatal...
mtnlurker
Latest: Ship captain tried to escape from the dingy in the night but was re-captured. Why didn't the navy vessel that was watching this help him. I wonder. Now the pirates want two million dollars or they kill the captain. They are muslim and not afraid to die. And they are not afraid to be captured as they know we will not torture them. What happened to the policy of not noegotiating with terrorists? An FBI negotiator is there. What is this person doing? I have little hope for this country any more.
Drax
Heh. It's always been the policy of the U.S. to SAY we don't negotiate with terrorists just as it has always been to policy of the U.S. to engage in negotiations with terrorists.
Dadman
They need to figure out a way to put all these pirates in the water. A SEAL with a spear-gun, maybe?
CosmicConservative
I say let Obama go all Chuck Norris on their butts.
Drax
One wonders if THIS is the "aspirin factory" fight that Obama wants to get public favor (which is slipping every day). It would seem a relatively easy fight, relatively inexpensive, and have almost no political downside while, at the same time, have a flair for the dramatic ("Obama To Pirate: Walk the Plank, Sir!") which the MSM could hawk to its mindless followers.
Dadman
Chuck Norris needs to go Chuck Norris on OBAMA's butt...
Left of center
Obama is the man....learn to live with it....he gave the order right away to do what was necessary to get that captain back. No if he can fix the economic mess and foreign policy disaster that Bush left....he may go down as one of the greats. Chew on that........
CosmicConservative
Left: He did not give the order "right away" but he did eventually give the right order. As I said in the other thread, at least he did not pull a complete Carter on us, and that's something. As far as how Obama goes down in history? Well at the moment it looks like he will go down in history as the President who bankrupted the nation. But we'll see.
Left of center
Yes Obama did.....and you can't take it.....as far as the Jimmy Carter comment it shows your ignorance. Carter's mission failed when the helicopters crashed in the desert. He did try. Carter probably would have been relected if not for that twist of fate. It was too bad because then the USA would not have been stuck with the buffoon Ron Reagan, who did nothing except put a bunch of marines on the low ground in Beirut Lebanon to get blown up.
Drax
(Way)Left of Center: Your posts have a grain of truth (See: Monkeys typing...Shakespere...) The RESULT (predictable and predicted) of Carter's "rescue attempt" was a failure. The RESULT (thanks to good shooting by sharpshooters) of Obama's rescue attempt was a success. The rest....comparing Carter's administration to Reagan's with Carter coming off looking good...well, see "Monkeys typing ... (not) Shakespere..."
CosmicConservative
I have to assume Left is just a leftist troll. I can't believe that anyone actually still believes the drivel he is pouring out.